iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rabbi Shmuley Boteach

GET UPDATES FROM Rabbi Shmuley Boteach

The Demonization of Eric Cantor

Posted: 07/19/11 06:38 PM ET

Attacks on Eric Cantor are gaining steam. Harry Reid called him childish. Many in the media have portrayed him as the obstinate Republican who will destroy American credit by blocking a deal on raising the debt ceiling. But for those of us who feel constantly ripped off by a government addicted to irresponsible spending, he is a hero.

I know Eric personally. He is a modest, focused, and unassuming man who speaks up with something important and wise to contribute. But beneath the calm exterior is a steely core which President Obama is now brushing up against firsthand. This is not a man whom you can intimidate. He is not flashy and is not desperate to be loved. He pursues principles rather than popularity contests. A man of faith and conviction, his salt-of-the-earth values stem from his upbringing in Richmond to a family with deep communal involvement. They are committed Jews who till today serve in leadership positions in Synagogues and educational establishments. Eric's mother is a warm Southern matron with a caring smile who converses freely and kindly. You could never guess that she has a son in high position of power.

But what is most responsible for Eric's meteoric rise to House Majority Leader is that he is a people person. When you write to him, no matter how busy, he writes back. When you speak to him in his office, he listens attentively and he seeks to learn from all whom he meets. I remember feeling, the first time we met, that I was in the presence of the consummate Southern gentleman.

And because he's a people person, he knows that people are plain fed up. We work hard to support our families and raise good kids. We feel let down by undisciplined politicians who think the American tax-payer is a piggy bank. We're drained from bloated government waste. Yes, we want America to be a compassionate country that takes care of the needy at home and fights bad guys overseas. But we're tired of being pawns in a game of vote-buying by political figures appealing to special interests. We feel no guilt at protecting that which we have legitimately earned and we want our generous charitable giving to be at our own, rather than the government's discretion.

Those who criticize Eric for refusing to raise taxes accuse him of harming America over a financial issue. They forget that the American revolution was a call to resistance against unfair taxation. And while the circumstances were, of course, different, and the British levied taxes without giving us elected members of Parliament, the principle remains the same: fair taxation, by the will of the people, that inspires citizens to live by the sweat of their brow.

The national debt has increased by a third in the two-and-a-half years since Barack Obama became President. Is the solution to closing this gap really to tax us more rather than to finally reign in spending?

We Americans are taxed up the wazoo. We are taxed when we wake up and we are taxed when we sleep. We are taxed when we breathe and we are taxed, ironically, when we stop breathing. We are taxed when we work and we are taxed when we rest. Yet still, our governments is bankrupt.

Aside from federal, state (in New Jersey it's nearly 10%), and local tax, owning a home requires me to pay exorbitant property taxes of which not a single dollar can go to my children's education because they are in a private Jewish day school. You'd think that some of my tax money could go to their school's mathematics or social studies departments, which are not religious. But I and other religious parents across the nation are being bankrupted by high property taxes and high tuition rates that are becoming unaffordable. So were we to feel when we read in the New York Times in early 2009 that President Obama's trillion dollar stimulus package forced public schools who did not request nor require stimulus funds to accept the money and spend it? We middle-class Americans are paying about half all we earn to the government. On top of that we want to give charity. Is it reasonable to ask for more?

Yes, we're fed up. President Obama can storm out of all the meetings he wants with Cantor. But he cannot break the man because Cantor is backed by people who are already broken and who have had enough.

Amid a flawed nature and an imperfect character, I try to live by the values of justice and compassion. I believe in helping all those who are in need, and Lord knows, I have been in need at times of my life as well. But I also know that greater even than the necessities of food, clothing, and shelter is that of human dignity, which derives from self-sufficiency. Dignity accrues to the man or woman who, with G-d's blessings, provides for their family's daily bread. The role of government is to facilitate the acquisition of human dignity by giving men and women the opportunities to be self-sufficient. In life we all seek redemption. But we wish for it to come through our own devices.

A bloated, nanny-state government is an impediment to that self-sufficiency. We want teachers who are effective rather than teachers who are guaranteed jobs which stunts student development and undermines the dignity of faculty. We want unions who understand that collective bargaining that drains a government's coffers is bad for workers as well as for business.

I have had jobs and I have lost jobs. But the last thing I want is to be kept on in a job because I am pitied. If I have had to lean on others in difficult times -- and I have -- it has eroded by self-esteem and I have therefore endeavored to get back on my own feet rather than develop, G-d forbid, a stultifying and painful dependency. The sentiment is best captured in a beautiful Jewish prayer, recited on the graves of the righteous:

May my sustenance be conveyed to me by Your hand and may it be sweet. May it not be conveyed to me by the hands of mortals, for then it would be as bitter and tough as wormwood and shamefully degrading. Therefore may You, in Your abundant mercies, prepare my sustenance from Your good and full hand, and may it be complete.

Hence, my support for Eric Cantor. He, more than anyone else currently in government, is the dam holding back the torrent of spending that would deepen our national depth and increase the unhealthy dependency that government sometimes creates. His efforts may not be fully appreciated now, but in cutting government waste he will earn the gratitude of the American people for saving our country from financial calamity and saving the rest of us from the plundering of private pockets to facilitate that oblivion.

 
 
 

Follow Rabbi Shmuley Boteach on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RabbiShmuley

 
 
  • Comments
  • 729
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (17 total)
08:16 PM on 08/04/2011
Sure, federal spending is a concern. But people like Eric Cantor have no credibility because

1) Bush racked up huge deficits and you didn't hear a peep from the GOP
2) They won't touch the defense budget even though it's rife with waste, fraud and abuse
3) They didn't utter a peep about the tremendous cost of engaging in 2 offensive wars
4) They refuse to consider ANY tax increases, even for the very wealthy. The WSJ reports today
that sales of luxury items are skyrocketing, so the argument that rich people
are to be pitied rings pretty hollow.
5) They won't penalize corporations even when they use their tax breaks to send or create jobs
overseas instead of being required to create American jobs.
6) Americans who are flipping burgers just to make ends meet can't relate to people like
Cantor and Rev. Boteach whining about the privations of paying for private schools.
04:13 PM on 07/29/2011
We need your help to defeat ERIC CANTOR!

E. Wayne Powell is the Democrat Candidate 2012. National Dems give him nothing. Please help get the word out! Lets take back the 7th!

http://www­.ewaynepow­ell.com/

Sign up to volunteer and donate today!!
"Like" Wayne on FB!
https://www.facebook.com/home.php?ref=hpskip#!/pages/E-Wayne-Powell/196474383721545
09:39 AM on 07/26/2011
Eric Cantor is the best that the Wall St and the big real estate Firms can buy. Last year his fund raising firms took in nearly $2M from security, investment, and real estate firms. More than double what Boehner took in. Is it no wonder that he walks out of talks when they begin to talk about closing the tax loop holes and dismantling subsidies for the big corporations.
02:35 AM on 07/22/2011
Cantor must be a fan of Ayn Rand, where greed is king and social responsibility is anathema. You cannot drastically reduce the means and then complain that we are not living within our means. You cannot take just about all of the increase in wealth for the last 30 years and then shift the tax burden to the middle class. You cannot refuse to pay living wages and decent benefits and then wonder why many of the working class need assistance programs.

After running up the debt while lowering taxes to record levels, the GOP has succeeded in convincing people that we have a debt crisis instead of a jobs crisis. This is "disaster capitalism", a plan to slash revenues and run up the debt in order to get even more tax cuts for the rich, more deregulation, to decimate assistance programs at the same time that they are most needed, to get cuts to Medicare without fixing its prescription plan, and to attack Social Security, a program that is funded only by payroll taxes on incomes less than $106,800.

No new taxes? Then restore old ones. We are tired of the rich man's hand in the poor man's pocket.
photo
OMEGA MAN
A wise man learns from the mistakes of others.
10:44 AM on 07/21/2011
We should end the TAX FREE status enjoyed by religious organizations. They depend on the nanny state government to pay for their roads, bridges, police, fire dept., education, social services, air ports, courts, etc. etc. All this at no cost to them. I have to pay for it. Start paying your own way so that I can have another tax cut.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JFoxCPT
09:34 AM on 07/21/2011
"His efforts may not be fully appreciated now, but in cutting government waste he will earn the gratitude of the American people for saving our country from financial calamity and saving the rest of us from the plundering of private pockets to facilitate that oblivion."

This florid and gushing piece doesn't seem real to me. More than anyone else Eric Cantor is protecting America? This oozing of praise could be appropriate in Eric Cantor's high school year book but it's got nothing to do with the reality of what Republican politicians (Eric Cantor) are doing to ruin America.
07:57 AM on 07/21/2011
"President Obama can storm out of all the meetings he wants with Cantor. But he cannot break the man because Cantor is backed by people who are already broken and who have had enough."

That's pretty condescending, considering that Eric Cantor also walked out of negotiations.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Skepticat
Supporting skeptical felines everywhere
07:54 AM on 07/21/2011
Perhaps if the Rabbi spent less time in Mr Cantor's echo chamber he would realize that taxes are at an all time low - and most of this awful national debt was run up cheerfully by Mr Cantor's party in a policy called starve the beast over the past 30 years which included - tax cut, spend, borrow from China and raid the social security piggy bank with intent to destroy it. This is the same Mr Cantor quite eager to kick the poor, sick and elderly in the teeth by cutting social services they payed into while demanding the Bush tax cuts for the uber rich be extended as a condition for any assistance to people who need help - during the worst economy since the depression. You want this guy as a friend - you keep him.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blueinannarbor
My micro bio is now full
06:38 AM on 07/21/2011
I recall him attempting to subvert the legislative process with the some cockamamy idea about giving the Senate a deadline to pass legislation and if they didn't, the bill would be come law. No passage of this bill in the Senate, no signing of the bill into law by the President. If I accept your premise that he isn't childish, then I must say his understanding of how a bill becomes a law is child-like. Moreover, there is some dispute about the story of Obama 'storming' out of a meeting.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
reliant1
my bio is mine
04:21 AM on 07/21/2011
No dear author - the revolution was not fought over unfair taxation. It was fought over lack of representation in the English Parliament. Taxes went up immediately following the revolutions victory.
Ahhhh....but now it was taxation with representation and ok.

Except for those who didn't like the idea of paying any taxes for anything and they took the easy way out of that problem. They crossed over the 13 new states borders and went west...into no-mans land. Where they were no longer English or American citizens. The Pacific stopped them or they would have kept right on going...

Too bad we can't pack up the baggers and send them westward in their footsteps. Maybe we can float them away to the west and the freedom from any gov't and any taxes and any social responsibilites they so crave. I have a raft I'll gladly donate. Maybe some others have a spare boat they'd be willing to kick in...let them sail westward and out of the 21st century.
12:48 AM on 07/21/2011
What will deepen our national debt is more unemployed. When we cut spending, we will have more unemployed. That will deepen the national debt. We need to break the cycle and use this opportunity to rebuild the infrastructure, put people to work doing it. How do we pay for it? 50 cent gas tax with a rebate returning the taxes paid to people earning less than $100,000 per year.
Easy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eternalscorpio1
just your average workin' man
10:37 PM on 07/20/2011
People like Cantor deserve to be demonized, because they are corporate tools, who would throw every sick child in this nation into the ocean, inorder to protect their rich masters from one penny more in taxes........
03:33 PM on 07/21/2011
come on please. Leftist drivel does not make for valid criticism....
09:31 PM on 07/20/2011
Please, Rabbi, point out to me just ONE public school that had stimulus funds "forced" upon them which had no productive use for the money.
09:01 PM on 07/20/2011
Nice try, Rabbi Boteach. But caring for small children and puppy dogs does make anyone a statesman. The man whom you profess to be committed to working families had no difficulty supporting TARP in 2008, but has vociferously opposed any increase in the minimum wage. The man you find attentive and compassionate has publicly stated that federal disaster relief requests should not be honored without offsetting cuts elsewhere. This "dam" against the "torrent of spending" had all of his sluice gates open during the eight years of the Bush administration. Rep. Cantor may be quite pleasant to be around, but that does not mean that he is not mean-spirited, immature and opportunistic.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JFoxCPT
09:16 PM on 07/20/2011
Well said.
09:32 PM on 07/20/2011
you do remember that TARP was paid back - too bad the rest of the money poured out by this administration to supporters will never be and did little good.

and ya lets fight for that minimum wage while you guys defend 12 MILLION illegal aliens that not only don't get it for the most part but take American jobs to boot.

I get it......just keep spending - someone will pick up the tab some day right..........?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
michael westman
not stepping in right wing cowpies
08:04 PM on 07/20/2011
Cantor is a true and dedicated believer....but only for an entitled well to do part of our society. His vision does not include those who are left behind by corporate America
09:32 PM on 07/20/2011
so the massive debt does not hurt everyone? Are you kidding?
photo
budanatr
US Expat in EU
10:27 PM on 07/20/2011
You keep spewing out the same meme even though it has nothing to do with the comments.
Take a nap and stop with the vodka.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
michael westman
not stepping in right wing cowpies
07:38 AM on 07/21/2011
Yes it does....the poison pill the right offers is far more destructive in a fragile economy....but it does benefit the mighty few