More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rabbi Yonah Bookstein

GET UPDATES FROM Rabbi Yonah Bookstein

Israeli Embassy Pogrom Is a Sign of What's to Come

Posted: 09/16/11 02:00 PM ET

2011-09-13-artegypt420x0.jpg
There was a pogrom in Egypt Friday night.

The intentions of the mob were obvious. According to eyewitness Rev. Giovanni Esti, a Catholic priest and missionary of the Comboni order, "We saw the group that attacked the Israeli embassy. It is hard to think that it was a spontaneous event. It was a planned event. This attack was carried out by recruited football fans. What is most disturbing is that the embassy was not adequately defended."

Had the Egyptians penetrated the Israeli Embassy's last security door, they would have set upon and likely killed anyone they found. The rioters smashed the offices, and tossed equipment and files to the streets. Although some of the details are unclear, the 85 members of the diplomatic core and security agents were evacuated by Egyptian commandos to the airport and flown to Israel on military jets.

The Israeli Embassy, a symbol of peace and normal diplomatic relations, lay trashed and occupied until the morning by the rioters.

They had tried before.

2011-09-13-4e6b190e30c58.preview300.jpg
On Saturday, Aug. 20, they attacked the building, and one Egyptian managed to scale the 20 stories to replace the Israeli flag with an Egyptian one.

The Egyptian military authorities then built a 12-foot-high security wall -- but that only seemed to have enraged them.

On Tuesday, Aug. 23, organizers of the attack called for a million-man march on the Embassy to call on Egyptian authorities to kick the "Zionists" out.

One week later, on Tuesday, Aug. 30, marking the first day of the Muslim feast Eid Al-Fitr, thousands of Egyptians held a massive protest in front of the Israeli Embassy. This time Egyptian security forces had been increased and no one managed to infiltrate the grounds of the embassy building.

However, on the night of Friday, Sept. 9, at the start of the Jewish Sabbath, the rioters came with enough people, battering rams, tools and weapons to actually succeed. There were no Egyptian security people there. They also attacked a nearby police station.

The attacks on the Israeli Embassy, according to many, were premeditated and planned, and the organizers were waiting for the right moment. With the death of three Egyptian soldiers on Aug. 19 during clashes between Israeli soldiers and terrorists on the Israeli-Egyptian border, they found the provocation they needed. Despite Israel's immediately issued apology of deep regret over the deaths and vowed to convene a joint Israeli/Egyptian investigation, the organizers had all they need to provoke angry mobs to do their bidding.

Up until then, those who had been calling for the removal of the Israelis relied on Egyptian anger over Israel's close relationship with Hosni Mubarak.

"I insisted on climbing on the roof and take down the flag of the Zionist entity," said Ahmad A-Shahat to Al-Jazeera, the one who scaled the Israeli Embassy on Aug. 20, "because that was one of the goals of the revolution -- to depose Mubarak and all his friends, among them the Zionist entity."

2011-09-13-web588534.jpg

The series of events that took place follow a predictable pattern common of pogroms, when emotional hatred against Jews can be physically acted out.

Those who perpetrate pogroms -- a Russian word to describe a form of violent riot against a particular minority group -- aim to not just murder, maim and defile, but also to destroy property, homes, institutions, sacred objects. Without the safety of a place to live or pray, the hated are unlikely to return.

Pogroms have been instigated by accidental deaths, but often don't require an actual victim. Rumors, prejudice and jealousy often suffice. With enough preparation, it doesn't take much to inflame the passions of those already predisposed to hate.

Pogroms are often orchestrated by governing authorities to divert attention from the cruel poverty, repression and unfulfilled promises of the government. Pogroms are also notoriously organized by opposition groups to destabilize governments. What transpired at the Embassy was not spontaneous and it will be interesting to see who the authorities eventually blame for the pogrom.

There are many questions that remain unanswered about this pogrom: Why was Egypt lax in protecting the Israel Embassy that night when a Facebook event announced the intentions of the mob? Did the Muslim Brotherhood have a hand in organizing the attacks and, if so, what are the repercussions? What is the fate that awaits Egypt's persecuted Coptic Christians? Who is to benefit from the re-imposition of martial law?

Not all Egyptians support the rioters and the pogrom. Egyptian opposition leader Wael Ghonim wrote "what we are witnessing now is contrary to what I dreamt of. We need to wake up quickly." He is joined by millions who do not want to see their new-found freedom undermined by undemocratic Islamic groups.

However, when it comes to bigotry, hate and prejudice, it is difficult to undo quickly what generations of propaganda has instilled. When it comes to anger over socioeconomic trouble, nothing is better than a scapegoat.

Thanks in part to televised dramas and other programs, many in the Arab world believe that Jews use blood in bizarre matzoh rituals, desire world domination, and use sorcery and witchcraft. The fall of dictators has destabilized local economies. Add to this poisonous mix the belief that Jews occupy Muslim land and holy sites, and there is fertile ground for greater and more pogroms, perhaps culminating in a new Arab-Israeli war.

Sadly, if history offers any lessons, the pogrom this past Friday night is a precursor for how Jews and Israel will be treated on the streets of "liberated countries" and in diplomatic hallways around the world for some time to come.

Unless stopped by internal forces, these attacks may continue until all vestiges of Israel are gone from Egypt and elsewhere in the Arab world.

For a detailed hour-by-hour account of the assault see Wikipedia.

 

Follow Rabbi Yonah Bookstein on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RabbiYonah

 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:55 AM on 09/20/2011
"The Israeli Embassy, a symbol of peace and normal diplomatic relations....."
LOL
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
11:30 AM on 09/19/2011
Israel is not suffering from pogroms, it is suffering, and the suffering is minor compared to what the Palestinians endure, from understandable anger at Israeli crimes against humanity. Sometimes, but not always the anger and resistance oversteps the boundaries of what is acceptable, but if Israel wants to not be hated it needs to stop behaving so hatefully.
photo
Bar Kokhba
I'd have a micro-bio if I knew how to make one
03:43 PM on 09/19/2011
"Crimes against humanity"? You demagogue and protest anything Israel, irrespective of facts or truths, rendering you little more than a barking dog; an annoyance indeed but rather insignificant.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
03:37 PM on 09/18/2011
Pogram doesnt mean what you think it means.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gracie fr
04:20 PM on 09/17/2011
Thinks "pogrom" in the article title is a nasty, pot-stirring, over-the-top reference This was a demonstration by "the football hooligan crowd" the ilk of which has been seen when the wrong team won in European matches, or British delinquants rioting in Great Britain.Perhaps the the good Rabbi is trying to scare people purposefully with his 19th century language....
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rabbi Yonah
Runs Jewlicious
12:38 AM on 09/18/2011
I am not trying to scare anyone. My studies of pogroms for years, which culminated in my MA on the subject, make me take this very seriously indeed - I don't use the term lightly.

Dear Grace, when they have tried for weeks to attack and destroy the Embassy and hurt or drive out at best the staff over the course of a month, and the attacks are organized — I am not sure how that qualifies for hooliganism like at a football match....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gracie fr
04:47 AM on 09/18/2011
So then, would you consider Israeli settler attacks on Palestinians as "pogroms"...?
....." The disclosure reveals growing unease among the security forces at their inability to contain increasingly militant settlers, seemingly bent on exacting revenge for every move against them through so-called "price tag" attacks – where Palestinian property is destroyed for every hostile move towards the settlers by the Israeli authorities..... "
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/israel-fears-settlers-in-west-bank-are-using-terror-tactics-2354321.html
04:41 PM on 09/18/2011
I have had an interest in comparative racism for some time yet I find authoritative information scarce.
Did your studies ascertain a commonality in pogroms against Africans, Hugenots, Hindus, Aztecs, American Indians, Aborigines, Dalits, Muslims, Jews, Christians, Bahai etc. ?
How many groups have suffered pogroms?
Which has the highest incidence in terms of (a) Victims, (b) occurrence?
Any links or references appreciated.
photo
SamSeven
You're either with Humanity or you're not.
11:28 AM on 09/17/2011
This a ripple of effect of Operation Cast Lead, Israeli treatment of the Palestininas for the past 62 years and supporting the dictator Mumbarak.
11:21 AM on 09/19/2011
You are the ripple effect of genetic disorder-away u go back ot Hamasistan
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles Queen
I am a disabled nam vet
06:53 PM on 09/16/2011
Egypt shouldn't have any issues with the Israeli's at all.I mean they havn't fought ina long long time.Having Turkey sticking it's nose into the fray and trying to cause even more trouble isn't helping matters any at all
04:21 PM on 09/16/2011
It would appear that a more appropriate term could have been used to describe the hooliganism in the rabbi's posting. While he gave an accurate definition of the word pogrom, nevertheless, the connotation of the word conjures up another time, when Jews were defenseless and without a homeland and thus ought to be restricted to 19th century Eastern Europe and the Pale. We aren't in that situation today. On the contrary: we are the masters of our own destiny, with a foreign policy defined by the needs of Israel and not those of Jews in the Diaspora.
06:38 PM on 09/16/2011
I agree it would have been more appropriate to use another word to describe the events in Egypt as hooliganis­m than pogrom. He knew exactly what he was trying to accomplish this using such of a word as pogrom.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BcemXAHA
Yerushalaim shel zahav
08:04 PM on 09/16/2011
Jews in Diaspora scream that Israel doesn't represent them, some even go as far as opposing Israel's existence. Those Jews don't get to be hypocrites by attempting to dictate Israel's policies if they don't want Israel to represent them.

Sadly, these are the very same Jews who'd be standing at the gates of Israel begging to be let in should there ever be a need. It is my sincere hope that Israel slowly and quietly shuts the gates leaving these Jews with those who's rear end they were busy licking all of their lives in Diaspora.
09:36 AM on 09/17/2011
I've often thought it but never verbalized it. Kol Hakavod!
04:04 PM on 09/16/2011
Israeli people can only blame their governments policies for all the hatred. Why not make peace now. Let the pals leave in dignity and have a future for their children and I can assure you the hatred will be gone as well.
photo
YafoDalet
a secular Jew
08:15 PM on 09/16/2011
It takes two for tango. Maintaining hatred towards Israel was instrumental for the Mubarak regime, and he was/is not alone in that.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:59 PM on 09/16/2011
"...I can assure you the hatred will be gone as well."

You can't assure anything. As for the "hatred," let the Arabs hate as much as they want. They just need to keep their hands to themselves and leave the Jews alone--basically what most of us learned in kindergarten.
02:55 PM on 09/16/2011
stop whining. Your Israeli government does the same to Palestinians every day. what, you didn't know? Let me clue you in... as long as you continue to settle in their land, build walls, deny them access to a standard of living beyond poverty - they will behave like any human or animal would: cornered and desperate - and they will rebel and terrorize. Here is the secret sauce... you know very well that their rebellion is what you want. There is your justification for further oppression, more settlements, more $$$s from the USA to protect you from these 'evil doers'. You know the drill. The day you make peace is the day you lose relevance and leverage for continuing your barbaric acts.
04:05 PM on 09/16/2011
fanned.
05:04 PM on 09/16/2011
Fanned & Faved