As we rush headlong toward the July 29th implementation date for Arizona's immigration law, SB 1070, all signs are pointing toward a truly epic clash in the offing. Positions have been staked out, legal challenges have been joined, legislative claims have been debunked, and activists are massing in the wings. This is a moment of historical import -- our generation's Selma and Montgomery -- and what transpires in the desert over the coming weeks will add a crucial chapter to the story of who we are as a people.
This is, in all likelihood, the sort of socio-political turning point that will spawn myriad future conversations devolving upon "where were you when it happened?" and "which side were you on?"
I am unequivocally, and unsurprisingly, on the side that says "Ya Basta!" to anti-immigrant policies and practices in Arizona and elsewhere. SB 1070 (which really should have been named "BS 1070" if they cared about truth in advertising) is thinly-veiled legislated racism and cynically misguided politics at its worst. Every justification given for why we need this law -- from alleged border violence and drug-related beheadings to upholding federal law and cleaning up social service programs -- has proven to be patently false and empirically untenable.
The bill's crafters, sponsors, and some of its supporters have open connections to hate-based supremacist groups. A number of law enforcement officials, including the Phoenix police chief, have spoken out against the law and a few are even part of the lawsuits challenging it. One officer bluntly said that enforcing it would make him "like a Nazi," calling the law "racist" and observing that under its provisions he could basically stop anyone he wanted to at any time with or without a concocted "reasonable suspicion" that is part and parcel of this "horrifying" law.
As has been pointed out by myself and many other commentators, SB 1070 focuses on effects rather than root causes, and punishes the victims rather than the perpetrators. Forced migration due to NAFTA, corporate malfeasance, governmental corruption, and simple human desperation cannot be eliminated or even mitigated by a legislative fiat that turns marginalized people into criminals based merely on their status. People fleeing toxification of their communities and immiseration in their jobs will still seek to cross the nation's most lethal border regardless of what legal chicanery awaits them on the other side.
One cannot be deterred from the desire for a better life for oneself and one's children that drives so much of the immigration we see here in the southwest. All that laws like SB 1070 and its ilk accomplish is to render imperiled people even more vulnerable to exploitation, fragmented families, and a host of other outcomes that are violative of the basic human rights guarantees enshrined in numerous treaties and agreements that are supposed to be "the law of the land" under our republican political framework.
Legally, economically, and morally, SB 1070 is inherently bankrupt. Arizona is teetering on the edge of becoming a "failed state" due to its race-to-the-bottom educational system, lack of public infrastructure, corporate giveaways, and de facto rightwing coup d'etat in the halls of legislative power. Immigrants actually return more to the state's economy than they draw out, crime rates are equivalent or lower among migrants than other sectors, and the ethnic diversity they bring here is part and parcel of the cultural underpinnings that reflect the rich history of the region.
By dehumanizing immigrants and creating an entire category of instantly-arrestable "illegals," Arizona is seeking to undo the modest gains achieved by generations of civil rights struggle, and in the process could spark a racialized pogrom that portends even greater levels of conflict and crisis in the days ahead.
And indeed, in a nod to the "ethnic cleansing" implications of the impending law, it has been reported that "thousands of families are already leaving Arizona." This matches the expressed intentions of the bill's senatorial sponsor, who recently trumpeted:
"Our law is already working. One can just scan the newspapers and see dozens of headlines like 'Illegal Immigrants Leaving Arizona Over New Law: Tough, Controversial New Legislation Scares Many in Underground Workforce Out of State.'"
It is this burgeoning recognition that SB 1070 is simply the opening salvo in a wider "race war" in America that has served to motivate a new generation of civil rights advocates and activists. In one of the most poignant and powerful signs, marginalized people themselves have been on the front lines of social protest under the mantra of "undocumented and unafraid," in some cases openly courting arrest and even deportation in the process.
Numerous ally organizations and individuals are ramping up their calls for widespread noncooperation with the law in an expression of solidarity and defiance. "We are urging all Arizonans of conscience not to comply with SB 1070 because it is an immoral law that will practically mandate racial profiling," said Joel Olson of the Repeal Coalition, which advocates the rescission of all anti-immigrant laws. "We believe that public and willful disobedience of this law is going to make it unenforceable, and that's our goal," Olson told the Arizona Daily Sun.
Alfredo Gutierrez, an organizer with Somos America, further observed that the coming protests will be "nonviolent and symbolic," and that they will serve as acts of "defiance and hope" for the state's growing Hispanic community.
Across the state, people are planning an overt "campaign of noncompliance" should the law survive pending legal challenges and take effect. As recently noted in an article in Waging Nonviolence, SB 1070 provides a "rare opportunity" for direct civil disobedience in the sense that people will be willfully violating the very law in question in itself, rather than the typical scenario where an ancillary law (e.g., trespassing, blocking traffic) is violated in protest of some larger policy. This has legal significance, and more importantly harks back to the Jim Crow era in which segregationist laws were openly violated through lunch counter sit-ins and the like.
As Martin Luther King, Jr. once said, borrowing from St. Augustine before him, "an unjust law is no law at all," and furthermore "one has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws." The fact that we are back again to invidious legislated bigotry is disconcerting to say the least, yet it also has served to mobilize a resurgence of critical engagement with issues that for too long have been swept under the rug of our archaic and draconian immigration policies.
As the implementation date for SB 1070 is now mere days away, here we arrive at the crossroads that is Arizona's, and the nation's, moment of truth. To the right is the ethical and spiritual dead end of racism and the historical baggage of slavery; to the left is the promise of an engaged populace imbued with a sense of social justice and steadfast solidarity.
My lot is cast with emancipation, and I hope yours is too.
Follow Randall Amster on Twitter: www.twitter.com/randallamster
Ben Daniel: Arizona Immigration Law Founded on Fear and Falsehood
I don't like the law because it encourages racial profiling; I don't like the law because I doubt it's constitutional; but most of all I don't like the law because it was passed in response to fears about immigration with little grounding in reality.
Marissa Moss: Zack de la Rocha, Tom Morello and Conor Oberst Rally to Fight Arizona's SB 1070
On Wednesday, Zack de la Rocha and Tom Morello, Conor Oberst and Dolores Huerta joined together in a press conference to discuss Soundstrike and their campaign against Arizona's SB 1070.
Rage Against The Machine To Rock Against 'Racist' Arizona Immigration Bill
Judge holds hearing on Arizona immigration lawsuit
Univision Provides Unparalleled Coverage of Arizona's Controversial SB1070 ...
Arpaio setting aside space at Tent City to enforce SB1070
KOLD News 13Prescott Valley considers code changes to comply with SB 1070
sheriff deputy sb 1070 training
Arizona immigration law already depicted in movie trailer...feature to come
I am also from Arizona and proud of it. Glad to see our state take a stand on a subject that very few people have the political will to tackle. It shows backbone in my opinion.
I would agree that there is a lot of racism around this subject. Hispanics are getting preferential treatment in the United States due to the fact that they are such a large voting block.
It is unfair to the multitude of people that are waiting in line to come here LEGALLY who have either valid qualifications or are legitimate refugees. I understand Hispanics come here looking for a better life, so do a lot of people, why do they get to jump to the front of the queue (Amnesty) or not even have to worry about immigration procedures to begin with (lax border enforcement). I find this ‘outright discrimination appalling’. And it makes me wonder about what kind of racists that are running these Hispanic groups that look to get their ‘people’ in first, as well as their racist supporters.
Put the shoe on the other foot, what if there were groups out their advocating amnesty for a predominantly white group of people. Yeah…that is what I thought…
Be careful before you start pulling the race card on this one.
Kai.
I wish I would have read this sooner but it was lost in all the other hoopla going on the last few days.
Yes this is a test for AZ but I doubt they will figure out the ramifications of their stupidity. I think these guys will have to learn the hard way and the state will have to suffer much more before they get it. Most people here were raised on Rush, Fox, Bill O’ and Beck who all teach hatred and their hero will always be McCain. I don’t think anything is going to change and it will be slow coming before the people actually vote in sensible leadership.
Anyway you are fanned from this comrade in Arizona.
SACRAMENTO, Calif., July 23 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The Latino Policy Coalition, a national non-partisan, non-profit consortium of the country's leading Latino research organizations, issued the following statement today concerning the U.S. Justice Department's suit challenging the legality of the state of Arizona's recently enacted law – SB 1070.
"We are pleased and proud that the U.S. Department of Justice has asserted its right to challenge the constitutionality of Arizona's discriminatory SB 1070 law. SB 1070 in effect is a hate crime masquerading as an official act," said Latino Policy Coalition Chairman Jim Gonzalez. "
http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/latino-policy-coalition-statement-on-the-status-of-arizonas-sb-1070-law-and-the-federal-lawsuit-brought-by-the-us-department-of-justice-99126289.html
so much for the LIE Latin@s support SB 1070 or that they aren't FURIOUS.
"SB 1070 = A HATE CRIME masquarading as an official act."
I am thinking positive regardless, and my love will contrast their hate. Good luck to all in Arizona, the whole world has got our eyes on you. Act accordingly.
Melissa Etheridge & Joss Stone - Janis Joplin Tribute
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ef-f-l2Pbn8
"So in love" - k.d. lang
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D6Ye9G3HEsQ
Carlos santana with rob thomas - "smooth"
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x56im_carlos-santana-with-rob-thomas-smoo_music
AZ = THE DESERTED STATE
For the people that believe the Arizona law regarding illegal immigration is unfair or racially motived, below is a link to sponsor an immigrant.
http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/uscis/menuitem.5af9bb95919f35e66f614176543f6d1a/?vgnextoid=f987a4491c35f010VgnVCM1000000ecd190aRCRD&vgnextchannel=b328194d3e88d010VgnVCM10000048f3d6a1RCRD
If you are not a relative you will need to employ the person or family, be financially responsible for them and pay for their costs related to immigration. They will also need transportation to your state and a place to live, so you might need to spare bedroom. Remember be patient , it could take a couple of years.
It would really help us out in Arizona and demonstrate that you really care about people. it would elminate the for states passing laws when the federal goverment take responsibility for the borders.
Thank you on behalf of the citizens of Arizona.
http://www.ponderingpolitics.com
So much propaganda and misinformation, I am on the side of liberty and emancipation.
I am on the side of the United States of America, this big huge dysfunctional family of "we are the people". I do not care if it is popular or not, this law is already null and void. If people took time to read the constitution, instead of it being interpreted for them. They are writing their own rights away, which is funny.
The migration of illegal border crossers is causing a great amount of ecological damage, especially down here in the southern part of the state. Enough that guys like Gary Nabhan are saying we'll be living with the effects well into the next century. This is something that all liberals (like me) should care about.
And when are people ever, finally, going to realize that is not about race? There are many, many Hispanic Arizonans who fully support SB1070, and many more who may not like it, but understand that something has to be done. The small clinics and community resources in places like Douglas are being totally consumed by the illegals. The towns are going broke. The ranchers are losing their livestock and their livelihoods.
Not all of those coming here illegally are nice, good people simply trying to improve their lives. About 1/5th of them are criminals, and that's a lot of folks. We need enforcement of our country's immigration laws and if the Feds won't do it, the state has to step up.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2gD_NdIstbM
You will have "THE" longest hottest summer in your recordable history as a state.
si si puede
What I read was CA has a similar provision that restricts where day laborers can gather and be picked up, that was the reason I bellieved that provision might remain.
ALL the undocumented people in AZ is about 400,000.
You claim you are liberal, but you sure shovel the FAIR organization propoganda like a PRO.
You also try to pit enviromentalists against Brown people, which I've seen with others, they also try to pit Blacks against Brown, and pit Gay against Brown....it doesn't WORK.
http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2006-8/1210139/UOB.jpg
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/2010/07/23/2010-07-23_arizona_immigration_law_wont_be_completely_blocked_federal_judges_indicates_duri.html
http://www.ponderingpolitics.com
After angering Latin@s from coast to coast and continent to continent....you LOST BIGTIME.
see you in november
http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2006-8/1210139/weWillNotComply.jpg
http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2006-8/1210139/thenwevote.jpg
http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2006-8/1210139/thenwevoteSpanish.jpg