iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Randall Amster

Randall Amster

GET UPDATES FROM Randall Amster

Obama's Fake Progressive Birth Certificate

Posted: 04/27/11 03:01 PM ET

Okay, so now we finally know: Barack Obama is an American. (Well, he's a Hawaiian actually, but I suppose we can put any lingering sovereignty issues aside for the moment.) In a startling revelation sure to send chills up the virtual spines of rightwing operatives everywhere, the President delivered a speech from the White House asserting in persuasively proactive fashion that indeed, "people have seen [my] birth certificate."

Whew. Let's all take a deep breath at the majesty of the moment. He's one of us, after all...

Except not so much. Obama's national origins are less problematic than his plans for the nation's future. While the birthers and state-house hacks obsess over his convoluted neonatal underpinnings, far greater matters percolate at the President's behest. To his credit, Obama's speech referenced precisely this sense of distraction and obfuscation that serves to undermine genuine progress on more pressing concerns:

"We're not going to be able to do it if we are distracted. We're not going to be able to do it if we spend time vilifying each other. We're not going to be able to do it if we just make stuff up and pretend that facts are not facts. We're not going to be able to solve our problems if we get distracted by sideshows and carnival barkers."

Good words, but there's a fundamental problem lurking in the shadows. To wit: he doesn't really mean it.

I'd like to think he does, of course, but after the inevitable letdown from his campaign rhetoric to the realities of governance, it's hard to muster even a modicum of faith in the messenger at this point. Obama ran as a progressive on myriad issues, from war and the economy to healthcare and human rights. What we got instead is a Wall Street crony and war-machine acolyte who seems content to bail water with a thimble while the Titanic continues its inevitable submersion.

It's particularly telling that the major legislative achievement of his administration has been a sham healthcare bill that privatizes personal risks while socializing public profits into corporate hands. Did he end the war in Iraq? Sort of, unless you count all the private contractors and military bases still in operation there (not to mention the seamless shift of major fronts over to Afghanistan). Did he close Guantanamo? Only to the pursuit of transparency and justice. Did he save the economy with bailouts? Perhaps, but the economy he "saved" isn't the one we ever actually wanted.

With the reelection campaign ready to begin in earnest, it's worth asking to see President Obama's progressive credentials before the Democratic wagons begin circling around us. It seems quite likely that the biggest selling point for continuing with the present administration will be that the other side's version will be a lot worse. But the basic strategy of "I'm not the other guy" leaves a major question lingering in the air, namely: Who are you, then?

On some level, I think the President is aware of the ironies here. In his birth-defense speech, he talks about substantive issues including education, infrastructure, and the future that we're leaving for our children. This isn't the same sort of tin-ear lassitude we got from the previous administration. Obama's virtue is that he sees the crises and isn't above letting us know:

"We've got some enormous challenges out there. There are a lot of folks out there who are still looking for work. Everybody is still suffering under high gas prices. We're going to have to make a series of very difficult decisions about how we invest in our future but also get a hold of our deficit and our debt -- how do we do that in a balanced way."

But seeing and believing are two different things. The birthers can look at Obama's birth certificate forever and still not believe he's an American. By the same token, progressives may be tempted to believe he's on the side of justice and equality, yet will oftentimes reject the contravening evidence right before their eyes.

Now that we can rest easy about his innate Americanness, let's actually hold the President accountable to pursue the highest ideals that define the national enterprise.

 

Follow Randall Amster on Twitter: www.twitter.com/randallamster

Okay, so now we finally know: Barack Obama is an American. (Well, he's a Hawaiian actually, but I suppose we can put any lingering sovereignty issues aside for the moment.) In a startling revelation s...
Okay, so now we finally know: Barack Obama is an American. (Well, he's a Hawaiian actually, but I suppose we can put any lingering sovereignty issues aside for the moment.) In a startling revelation s...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 506
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:55 PM on 05/03/2011
It is clear Mr. Amster is unaware that President Obama must get reelected to bring about any meaningful change?

Or is it?
03:16 PM on 05/02/2011
i think that osama bin laden has know paid the deat of all the peoples families that he has hurt
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dannywanny
I think I'm diagonally parked in a parallel univer
05:03 AM on 05/02/2011
This is just more evidence that the birthers have a tenuous grasp on reality. No matter what the president does it will never be enough to satisfy the conspiracy theorists.
11:50 PM on 05/01/2011
How many porn-surfing SEC regulators did Obama demand the resignation of again?

And how many folks at the MMS got fired after the gulf oil spill?
03:24 PM on 05/02/2011
that was not righ that they did that they should have been fired they are hurting the enviorment and all the animals that live their and their families .the animals are inporant to the ecosystem
08:32 PM on 05/01/2011
Neither Obama or Bush mean anything. The way to get rich, and I mean real rich, bet big, pocket the profits and when you lose push the losses off to someone else. Thats why the wealthy on The Street are so wealthy. A democratic Congress and a Republican President failed to show the guts to let the super rich take the hit they deserved. yes we would have seen a 15% decrease in GDP but we would be over this mess by now. We have been out of the recession for close to 2 years, and we are not getting any better. Until we allow failure, we will continue to see the best and the brigtest go into the money sector that does not create any real wealth except for those in it and not go into something productive like effective green energy or some other new technology. Remember when you were graduating computer guys by the thousands when the internet was new, not we graduate consultants for finacial companies.
03:26 PM on 05/02/2011
you are so right about every thing
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:50 PM on 05/03/2011
You too.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:49 PM on 05/03/2011
Craigslist. Talking point.
04:46 PM on 05/01/2011
Why is it President Obama's fault that Americans refuse to focus on the issues that actually make a difference to the survival of America? An enormous amount of energy and resources were poured, and will be poured, into discrediting Obama instead of sitting in committees doing the hard work of trying to figure out how to improve America. I have yet to see any real and sustained protests (except in Madison) about very big issues like the awful condition of the educational systems across the country (without a highly educated workforce we cannot compete in the global market. You cannot blame Obama for not being a Roosevelt style democrat when there is absolutely no real support for such a radical stance.
06:24 PM on 05/01/2011
Is he just clueless that when he and his pay czar approved the use of middle class taxpayer money to pay the failed CEO of the bankrupt AIG his undeserved $10M compensation, that we would just applaud, like nothing happened? Doesn't he understand that the middle class taxpayer has now lost patience?

I vote that we give honest hard working middle class taxpayers in Dockers or bib overalls millions of dollars, instead of Brooks Brother suit-wearing crooked, failed and irresponsible bankers millions of dollars for sitting around all day long making devastatingly bad decisions.


We will see the economy turn around as soon as we start seeing failed execs at TARP-funded money center banks walking out of their place of employment with a pink slip in one hand and a cardboard box filled with their personal effects in the other hand and a dazed look on their face, as they post the Space Available sign on their shuttered money center bank headquarters building. That is when things will turn around, and if Obama can't make that happen, we need to replace him with someone else that can make good decisions.
04:42 PM on 05/01/2011
Hang in there and don't vote until we get a genuinely progressive candidate. That's what we need and we're not going to get it until we withhold our votes. Chastising Obama or fretting that he isn't what we expected won't accomplish anything. Just don't vote until there is a candidate you want.
03:49 PM on 05/02/2011
Nice sentiment Trevor....But all progressives will get by withholding their votes is a republican in office who's views are even further from their's than the president's. I will vote for Obama again, and then hope he feels free to get his progressive groove on 2cnd term, because he won't have to worry about re-election.Even if he doesn't, and walks the middle...still far better than any in the crowd repubs are offering so far!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:51 PM on 05/03/2011
Great advice.

LOL
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dannywanny
I think I'm diagonally parked in a parallel univer
03:16 PM on 05/01/2011
Americans want quick, easy solutions, solutions that wont hurt them personally. The last time a crisis of this magnitude happened, in 1929, the aftermath lasted 11 years. The cause was the same as this one. So this one will be extended far into the decade, and possibly the next. It has nothing to do with who is in the White House. The damage has already been done. There will be no easy solutions this time either and people seem unable to understand the depth of the damage, while they whine about comparatively minor problems.

There's an old saying, "Divided we fall, united we stand." We're not getting anywhere when we bully, bicker and obfuscate. Do Americans have the courage to stand united to get through this crisis? It doesn't look good.
02:02 PM on 05/01/2011
How’s this recovery working for ya’

OK, let me get this straight, The Federal Government is bailing out car companies so that they can build more cars people can’t afford to buy, Sending trillions of our tax dollars to financial institutions. and bailing out banks who have all the money anyway while they continue to cry ‘poor mouth. Did I miss something?

We don’t produce anything anymore, we’ve given it all away to foreign companies. Over the years have laid off millions of our own workers. Just look around you at business closings, bankruptcies and foreclosures and illegal’s who have overrun our country. No one has the power to stop greed. The inept political process in this country has all but killed our economy. Our future is now in the hands of a ‘Clown Car’ government. This country was built on entrepreneurial sprit, mobility and self determination, not government interference and regulation. We have an embarrassing President who hasn’t accomplished anything since he’s been in office. He’s presented with a Nobel Peace Prize for doing what?

Folks, we are in dire straights and being led down the path to economic slaughter. The government is being set up to dictate your every move. If you voted for this socialistic regime, you are about to get what you voted for. The only way we can stop this personal encroachment on our freedoms is to stand up, get involved, vote and be counted. Don’t complain when it’s too late.
God help us!
04:00 PM on 05/01/2011
I think he did something right by pushing through a watered-down McCain health reform plan...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:53 PM on 05/03/2011
Talking points fest.

LOL
01:28 PM on 05/01/2011
Some people will simple never be satisfied. Would you have rather had John McCain in the Oval office Mr. Amster? Tell me, who do you recommend for the office of President who would actually have a chance at winning? The problem is not the politicians, the problem is us. We are to lazy as a people to inform ourselves and make good choices so we don't elect politicians who are willing to make the hard choices and take the heat. And we do, by some accident, we don't give them our full support when they try to do what is necessary even though it is unpopular.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hempy
12:54 PM on 05/01/2011
When it comes to the economy, Obama and Congress seem to be out of ideas.

Why not find other sources of revenue? Today’s (Sunday, May 1, 2011) New York Time’s article entitled “Geithner’s Loophole” reported that there’s a $4-trillion-a-day derivative market. Annually that’s about a $1.44 quadrillion a year.

If a proportional rate tax were in effect, and the buyer and seller each paid a 5% rate for their transaction (seller sells, buyer buys), that would generate about $144 trillion to the treasury.

So why isn’t Obama or Congress or both, proposing just such a tax? Adam Smith, the father of capitalism proposed a similar proportional tax. Alexander Hamilton proposed that the movement of money be taxed proportionally.

Is anybody in Washington going to stand up for American values? Or, aside from the birther issue, is Washington just going to wring its hands and continually harp about a “deficit”?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dannywanny
I think I'm diagonally parked in a parallel univer
03:24 PM on 05/01/2011
As I recall, the members of one party announced, repeatedly, that their principal goal was to oppose the president and to ensure that he's a lame duck. Jobs, the economy, values, everything else is secondary. Large numbers of people voted these people into office because they supported that idea. Now, the members of that party have linked arms to do exactly what they said they would do. Why the surprise?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
meoshi
A Member of We, the People
12:16 PM on 05/01/2011
Mr. Amster is right........We must "hold the president accountable to pursue the highest ideals that define the national enterprise." I believe, after the thumping President Obama gave Mr. Trump last night, that the president can't continue to follow the same path he has been following...A path defined by the process of "going along to get along.".....He has the guts and gumption to do what he has to do.......He showed it last night at the White House Correspondents Dinner........We, the People, will have to force the president to do what he has to do........
photo
TheNative
An American before American was in vogue
11:51 AM on 05/01/2011
It seems we all have opinions on whether Obama kept his promises he laid out during his election campaign, or whether he caved into the opposition. The real question that we should be asking is; would it had been better for america if he not compromised on any issue and remained true to his resolve. It would have given the perception of a strong leader, but aren't we really looking for solutions to the countries problems. Deep down inside, most of us understand that we won't be able to get all of what we want, so we compromise. Obama compromised to keep us moving forward maybe not in the directions most nay-sayers wanted but forward non the less.
01:02 PM on 05/01/2011
This is about taking $10M in middle class taxpayer money and giving it to the inept and failed AIG CEO for bankrupting his company. Why does the AIG CEO get more money in welfare than the irresponsible 20 year old mother of 4, all from different fathers? After all, the irresponsible mother of 4 didn't know any better.
photo
TheNative
An American before American was in vogue
04:26 PM on 05/01/2011
As you've replied to my comment, I assume you're blaming Obama for giving money to AIG. Note that the bail out actually happened during GWB's watch. Like anything else, it was a bet that the government took based on the belief that if these huge financial firms defaulted it would hurt the country. We will never know what might have happened if they were allowed to default. All we can do is speculate.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
disgustedwithall
USA not free/safer if citizen requires gun for it.
11:36 AM on 05/01/2011
Basically let's face reality, there is one party in this nation running things, the $$'s Party. When we should be shocked, instead are/were "educated to accept, business as usual for all elected", dirty, system is corrupted and money runs show. Once the elected/money/shadow government sold that to commoners, the flood gates of corruption opened wide. Phsy 101 Student will tell your "expectations" are powerful tools, well played by money/elected to take over nation.

Hard data,suggests USA a more dumbed down nation each years, where "finance, government, history, currency AKA well rounded educations are "just boring stuff I will never use". Result of years of "boring stuff we ignored", most do not only not care, but do not have a clue on how to do compound interests, much less understand basics of any money issue.

We are simply being feed headline by generally useless media, whom never took "Boring courses", a commoner appetite for sports/celebs as know more of them then reality. Education now openly under budget attack, as hypocrites "worry about debt for kids, but not world class competitive education. For years we have not vote FOR candidates, rather "AGAINST, since most lack backbone/ability to question well, listens better as might dissolve partisan smoke screen so popular now.

2012, will again be a "best vote against them, yet really do not want to vote for him, little choice. Yet, to the West, big Dragon China keeps feeding, growing bigger, USA dumber fatter tasty target
11:30 AM on 05/01/2011
How does a President change the course of a country in less than two years? Obama has done what he could with the mess he was left by the Bush years. He has made some mistakes and I believe that all administrations have made "mistakes". I think that we need to end these useless wars in other countries, save the money that they have cost us and apply it to the deficit. Our infrastructures are a mess, we need to clean them up, we need to feed our poor and put education and innovation back on the table. We also need to stop belly-aching about the lack of jobs and pony-up to being real Americans that have a "can-do" approach to problems including our own.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MikeLawson
Still to the Left, still Right for it
12:21 PM on 05/01/2011
Allow me to be your first fan, Elise and welcome to the HuffPo!
photo
TheNative
An American before American was in vogue
01:04 PM on 05/03/2011
Well stated, hopefully it won't fall to deaf ears. Fanned!