iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Raul A. Reyes

GET UPDATES FROM Raul A. Reyes
 

"America's Toughest Sheriff" Is Not Above the Law

Posted: 01/17/12 05:23 PM ET

2012-01-17-arpaio.jpg
On January 5, Arizona Sheriff Joe Arpaio revealed his re-election plans with typical bluster. The man who calls himself "America's Toughest Sheriff" said,
For all those critics that demonstrate in front of my office for three years, calling me every name in the book, I'm going to announce right now... that I'm running again for sheriff, for my sixth four-year term. So maybe they're going to have a bad day, all these critics against me.

As Sheriff of Maricopa County, Arpaio embodies the anti-illegal immigration movement. He has made inmates wear pink underwear, paraded them in public in shackles, and housed them in tent cities. Now a scathing report from the Department of Justice (DOJ) documents Arpaio's unlawful discrimination against Latinos. Yet besides trampling on constitutional, human, and civil rights, Arpaio has neglected other duties of his office and failed to make his community safer. In short, his tenure has not only been bad for undocumented immigrants, it's been bad for Latinos and Arizona as well.

Last month, the DOJ found that Arpaio's office had illegally targeted Latinos for arrest and detention, and mistreated Spanish-speaking inmates. The DOJ backed their findings with thousands of pages of interviews and evidence. Their report cited a "pervasive culture of bias against Latinos." One expert termed it "the most egregious case of racial profiling in the U.S."

In Maricopa County, according to the DOJ, Latino drivers were four to nine times more likely to be pulled over while driving than white drivers. One Latino resident was incarcerated for thirteen days for failing to use a turn signal. In Arpaio's jails, prisoners who did not speak English were denied access to clean clothing and medical attention. In 2009, Arpaio forced a pregnant woman to give birth while shackled to her bed.

Meanwhile, in his focus on immigration enforcement, Arpaio has neglected critical duties of his office. Last year, an Arizona TV station reported that his office failed to investigate over 400 sex crime cases. Even the conservative Goldwater Institute has criticized the sheriff for not acting on more than 40,000 outstanding felony warrants. Arpaio apparently thinks that chasing undocumented dishwashers is more important than arresting violent criminals.

Defending Arpaio, Jessica Vaughan of the Center for Immigration Studies told the Washington Post that "his actions on immigration enforcement make everybody in this country safer." Really? Consider that violent crime has fallen everywhere in Arizona except in Sheriff Joe's jurisdiction. Between 2002 and 2009, violent crime dropped 12% in Arizona -- while increasing 58% in Maricopa County. So much for effective crime fighting.

Even worse, Arpaio's policies have negatively impacted relations between local law enforcement and the community. In 2008, then-Mesa Police Chief George Gascon complained about a "wedge being drawn between police and immigrant groups." The DOJ found that a "wall of distrust" had been created with Hispanics, which is a hindrance to police officers who must deal with crime victims and potential witnesses. Then there is the damage that Sheriff Joe's highly visible campaigns have done to Arizona's image. Once proudly known as the Grand Canyon State, today it is also widely seen as intolerant of Latinos.

Thankfully, the people of Arizona may have had enough. One of Arpaio's allies, State Sen. Russell Pearce, architect of the state's infamous "papers, please" law, was recalled in a special election last year. Sens. John McCain and Jon Kyl, both Republicans, have expressed concern about Maricopa County's botched sex crime investigations.

Arpaio maintains he is being used as "a whipping boy for a national and international problem." Still, that doesn't excuse his flouting of the law. It's ironic that someone who is so obsessed with who is "legal" would be willing to commit so many illegal acts himself. Arpaio is a perfect example of why local law enforcement officials should not be immigration agents. He has run amuck, harassing Latinos while generating lawsuits, investigations, and the ire of the Hispanic community. If he manages to get re-elected, he needs to understand that no one is above the law -- not even "America's Toughest Sheriff."

 

Follow Raul A. Reyes on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RaulAReyes

 
 
  • Comments
  • 103
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:33 AM on 02/29/2012
http://cis.org/Minority-Views-Immigration
Mexican-Americans want the border controlled.
12:34 AM on 01/21/2012
I don't see the problem since Arpaio is simply following the laws and picks and chooses which laws he enforces. He is simply doing what San Francisco, LA, Chicago, New York are doing in violation of Federal laws on immigration. At least he goes after people who have NO right to be here at all and who violate dozens of US and state laws. So by going after illegals who live and work here, he goes after those who are committing multiple crimes such as smuggling people into the US, harboring them, driving without a license which is a crime, not registering for the draft, tax fraud, SS fraud, forgery, perjury, etc. Instead, the critics want him to just go after those who commit ONE crime instead of on going criminal enterprises.

A SF Sheriff deputy was arrested in Houston, while on official duty smuggline an illegal minor out of the country. SF did that so that the kid would not have a Federal criminal record which is a major violation of our laws. At least Arpaio has not been charged with any crime. So while Arpaio has done things that some don't like, he so far has done nothing criminal as most of his detractors have done.

By the way, shackling a woman prisoner who is giving birth is the most common thing in most states It is NOT a violation of any law.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
laundrybrick
09:04 AM on 01/20/2012
Joe Arpaio is a HERO!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bldr1bob
07:13 PM on 01/19/2012
I'll clean this up so maybe it won't be deleted by HP or the author.........
The article is full of false informatio­n. Written by a lawyer who lives in NYC and has probably never been to AZ.
Crime in Miracopa County is down across the board.

http://www­­.azfamily­.­com/news­/l­ocal/Ne­w-n­umbers­-ind­icate­-crim­e-ra­te-is-­fal­ling-12­55­37383.ht­m­l

The DOJ has been chasing the sheriff since BO got into office and have never found him guilty of anything. The allegations listed in the article have not been proven to be true.
03:30 PM on 01/18/2012
An illegal Mexican in the United States has already committed a felony by invading a soveriegn nation so I believe Joe is defending America by ridding us of these parasites and putting them back where they came from. Unlike Raul Reyes and politicians in Washinton D.C. who are traitors to the United States of America by supporing a foriegn invasion.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
greeneyes51654m
Retired, finally...
06:02 PM on 01/19/2012
Fanned and Faved!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Napoleon3
02:12 PM on 01/18/2012
I live in AZ. We are glad to have him. It is a very safe city. Sure he is tough but equally. I talked to him once and he gave good advice on not being in tent camp. Don't do a crime.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ugly american
"I drank what?"- Last words of Socrates
01:59 PM on 01/18/2012
""America's Toughest Sheriff" Is Not Above the Law"
Neither are Latin foreign nationals but somehow they and their sending countries seem to think they are.
Arpaio is just doing his job. That's good enough for Americans, including most in Maricopa County.
The Latin countries are just trying to colonize and conquer the US and Obama is just trying to allow it. That doesn't sit well with most Americans.
02:13 PM on 01/18/2012
You don't read very well, do you. One of the problems is that he ISN'T doing his job.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pete Wood
sarcasm free..stay on point
03:49 PM on 01/18/2012
because he spends too much time doing the feds job(catching ILLEGALS) so get over it. NEED MORE SHERRIFS LIKE HIN AND LESS PRIVATE FOR PROFIT PRISONS
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ugly american
"I drank what?"- Last words of Socrates
04:29 PM on 01/18/2012
No, he is doing his job. The MCSO still arrests people for all sorts of other crimes and there has been no rise in the crime rate because of actions to detain unauthorized foreign nationals.
It would be more properly said that he is doing more than his job, because the Federal government under Obama is refusing to do theirs. The real problem is being created by the fact that the DOJ, Mexico and their illegal citizens and advocates don't like that he is picking up the slack they are trying to get ICE to leave.
I read just fine thank you. And I am probably better versed on the subject than you are.
The DOJ, despite years of trying to catch Arpaio doing something illegal, has found NOTHING they can successfully prosecute him for.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ugly american
"I drank what?"- Last words of Socrates
01:07 PM on 01/18/2012
It's funny that illegal aliens are only interested in our laws if it comes to trying to enforce them against someone else. Arpaio is just doing his job and if the citizens of his county really disagreed with him about the way he is doing it, he would not be the Sheriff.
The people who disagree with him are Mexico, the Latin countries that have formed a coalition with them and their citizens who flagrantly violate American laws, immigration and otherwise.
If the Federal government had indeed found wrong-doing in all the time they have been investigating him they would already be dragging him into court for prosecution.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:23 AM on 01/18/2012
This guy is not going to change unless somebody does something about him. Ok so the justice department has all this evidence of lawbreaking on behalf of this lousy sheriff. Now go get him. Put him on trial. Send a message. There should be no need for people to demonstrate outside his office. Feds need to put this creep out of a job.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sibyl9
Cloaking Device Engaged
03:49 PM on 01/18/2012
If they had any real evidence, they would have already charged him with a crime. What they have is anecdoctal evidence from LaRaza supporters that lacks sufficient credibility.
photo
special38x2
Live, Love, & Laugh
12:36 AM on 01/19/2012
It seems to his community, that he is doing what they need him to & not charges have been levied. Sometimes being tough in a bad situation ruffles a few feathers.
photo
intolleft
ObamaTAX...getting you shovel ready
11:10 AM on 01/18/2012
"Now a scathing report from the Department of Justice (DOJ) documents Arpaio's unlawful discrimination against Latinos."

Is this the same DOJ, along with POTUS that sent thousands of guns to Mexican drug dealers resulting in hundreds killed included two border agents, all so they could manufacture evidence for undermining the Constitutions 2nd Amendment?

I would hardly call that DOJ the arbitrator of the moral high ground on "discriminating against Latinos" when they are personally responsible for the deaths of hundreds and the terrorizing of thousands more.
01:11 PM on 01/18/2012
That was the U.S. Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms Dept, not the Justice Dept. And they were trying to uncover the patterns of gun distribution in Mexico, which is not covered by the 2nd Amendment. I agree that their actions were inexcusable, however, facts are facts, no matter who uncovers them. Ugly Joe must go.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FranklySpoken
I cannot believe you said that…
01:40 PM on 01/18/2012
Harvey: I think that you will find that the BATFE operates under the DoJ.
“The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) was established as a separate component within the Department of Justice pursuant to Title XI of the Homeland Security Act of 2002, Public Law 107-296, on January 17, 2003.” Link: http://www.justice.gov/jmd/mps/manual/atf.htm
10:31 AM on 01/18/2012
The good news is that by running again for sheriff he won't be running for governor or senator. Phew!

But, the problem is no one will challenge him because in the past he uses his office as a sort of praetorian guard to harass his politcal opponents.

Only an elected police official or sworn officer could challenge him so that there would be equal muscle on both sides.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
xenubarb
Nebulon V
04:59 PM on 01/18/2012
Not unlike beleaguered Los Angeles County sheriff Leroy Baca. He doesn't keep getting reelected because he's an adequate sheriff, he stomps the opposition.

And his deputies stomp the inmates in LA County Jail.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:05 PM on 02/27/2012
They wont charge him because there is nothing to charge him with. Illegals have NO right here in America. But I do. And he gets the job done that everybody else is to Chk sh!$ to do. You dont like then you go do his job lets see how long you last !
10:17 AM on 01/18/2012
Instead of acqusations brought by Obama's DOJ to coerce states into becoming sanctuaries so he can trade amnesty for votes, please list all the convictions and sanctions brought against sheriff arpio for his years of violating the law, trampling on constitutional protections and discrimination. Oh wait, there are none. FAIL
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:05 PM on 02/27/2012
BINGO !
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
normathumb
08:47 AM on 01/18/2012
The Bull Conner of his time.
12:43 AM on 01/21/2012
As an old civil rights activist, I can say you have NO idea of what you are talking about. Please show me any law that says that people can come to this country against our will and laws. Illegals have NO right to be here, much less be treated as an equal to a US citizen. THAT is why they do NOT get counsel when they are arrested and go to immigration court.

We were fighting for the rights of ALL American citizens, and most especially those of black Americans whose rights were illegally being denied. Illegals have NO such claim or right. YOU and your kind are the Bull Conors of today by claiming YOU and the illegals are above the law and do not have to follow any law you don't like. Just like Bull Connor did.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:07 PM on 02/27/2012
I love your brain ! THX !
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MUDPUPPY
05:44 AM on 01/18/2012
Arpaio is simply enforcing federal laws, something the government is not doing. It does no good to deport. Those that are deported know how to sneak in and many do again. When the government brags bout how many they deport they fail to mention this.
09:10 AM on 01/18/2012
It's not his job to pick and choose which laws he will enforce. He chooses to enforce specific federal laws outside his scope of duties. Meanwhile he ignores his real job which is to enforce local and county laws and protect the citizens.
photo
intolleft
ObamaTAX...getting you shovel ready
11:12 AM on 01/18/2012
Then you should be just as outraged against the DoJ and POTUS picking and choosing. Nobody should be doing it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pete Wood
sarcasm free..stay on point
03:52 PM on 01/18/2012
HE IS PROTECTING the citizens from the ILLEGALS. BUH BYE
10:29 AM on 01/18/2012
Won't those caught and ultimately deported by Arpaio also sneak back in?

What special power does Arpaio have that the feds don't when it comes to sneaking back in.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ugly american
"I drank what?"- Last words of Socrates
04:42 PM on 01/18/2012
Two words : Pink underwear.
It's got to offend the Latin sense of "machismo".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:11 PM on 02/27/2012
So your going to blame Arpaio for the criminals coming back ? Well what happens then is Arpaio does his job AGAIN and gets rid of the illegals again. And does a great job at it !
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
LiberalDemIda
You can't spell "Conservative" without Con.
03:36 AM on 01/18/2012
Arpaio is a sad.is.t and a failure. Period. He's an embarrassment for everything he's done to - and yes, TO not for - his county, from egregious human rights violations, to fair and equitable treatment of prisoners, to doing just doing his job to fight crime. There's a 58% RISE in crime in his district when overall crime rates have DROPPED 12% in Arizona.

So it's a fair and factual statement when I say the simple.tons descending on this thread who support him support him for his r@c!sm NOT for his work as a taxpayer funded civil servant.

The man is going to go down hard, thanks to the DOJ, and may he end his days in prison for the atrocities he's committed, for the rest of his miserable life.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Scott Leland
11:00 AM on 01/18/2012
Dear LiberalDemida: There are those groups that are organised against the American system of laws that make it possible for Americans to carry-on their everyday lives secure in their property and civil rights. Sheriff Arpaio is merely carrying-out the desire of Arizona's citizens for the laws to be applied to all vistors to their state.

I received a press release from one of those groups bragging about it's victory over American citizens:


http://redwriteblue.blog.com/2011/11/12/nefarious-victory
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
LiberalDemIda
You can't spell "Conservative" without Con.
11:38 AM on 01/18/2012
You need to reread the findings against this Sheriff. There is NO excusing his tactics.

Incarcerating a Latino for thirteen days because he failed to use a turn signal? How's that supposed to "secure ... property and civil rights"?? And then he fails to investigate over FOUR HUNDREDS SEX CRIMES because he's out arresting brown-skinned people for not using their turn signal? Why are you defending him? If a black sheriff arrested you and locked you up for thirteen days, would you tell yourself he's just "securing other people's property and civil rights", or is he in violation of yours?

Arpaio is *not* above the law. And as for Pearce, SB 1070 was targeted against all people with brown skin and it's a cause for celebration that the arrogant rep was ousted and that egregious law was gutted.

Arpaio and Pearce are a disgrace to America and anyone who supports him is, too.
photo
special38x2
Live, Love, & Laugh
12:44 AM on 01/19/2012
Love the statement "we’ve shown we’re powerful,and we’re going to keep fighting for our ‘rights.’ In 2012 anti-immigration legislators will now have to think twice before pursuing anti-immigrant policies in our states.”ove the statement " Illegals don't have constitutional rights as non-American's so why are we allowing this kind of lobbying to occur?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bldr1bob
06:16 PM on 01/19/2012
You read in this hit piece a bunch of lies so therefore it's fact? Crime is down in Miracopa County

http://www­.azfamily.­com/news/l­ocal/New-n­umbers-ind­icate-crim­e-rate-is-­falling-12­5537383.ht­ml

The brown shirts in the DOJ have been chasing him since BO got into office. They have found no evidence. That's a fact.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
LiberalDemIda
You can't spell "Conservative" without Con.
07:03 PM on 01/19/2012
Another person who fits the description in the second paragraph of my comment. Congrats.

Your link is a dud, btw.

Try this one:http://washingtonindependent.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/AmericasVoiceCrimeGraph2.png