More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rep. Mike Honda

Rep. Mike Honda

Posted: July 29, 2010 01:32 PM

What's Wrong With the War in Afghanistan

What's Your Reaction:

Today, Congressional Progressive Caucus co-chair Congresswoman Woolsey and I co-hosted a briefing to discuss the most pressing foreign policy issue facing our country today -- the war in Afghanistan.

As the Chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus's Afghanistan Taskforce, I am very interested in ensuring that the Progressive Caucus and the rest of my colleagues in Congress have sufficient information to make informed decisions about this war.

We are at a very dangerous and difficult time in this war.

We are funding the longest war in US history. This is our 105th month at war in Afghanistan, compared with 103 months in Vietnam.

We are funding the most expensive war in US history, in terms of cost-per-soldier, at $1 million per soldier per year. That's $100 billion a year -- and that's just for the troops. Keep in mind this is money we do not have. It is deficit-funded, putting our country further in debt.

We are funding pervasive corruption among all contractors, American, foreign, and Afghan. The skimming and pocketing of massive amounts of money is prevalent. All too common is the story of a $7 million project landing on the ground with only $700,000 left to build the intended road, school or hospital. Oversight Subcommittee Chairman Tierney's recent report highlights how rife corruption is throughout the contracting community.

We are funding an unprecedented and unaccountable privatized model for "clearing, holding and building" in Afghanistan. Seventy percent of all defense dollars are going to private contractors who remain outside the purview of strict auditing, accountability, and monitoring and evaluation measures. We witnessed tens of billions of lost dollars in Iraq; we are now witnessing the same in Afghanistan. State and USAID have largely become granting agencies, having lost much of their internal reconstruction and stabilization capacities.

Only ten percent of all US-funded development dollars stay in Afghanistan -- the rest return to contractor countries. Only thirty percent of all US-funded defense dollars remain in Afghanistan. Eighty percent of these monies circumvent the Afghan government entirely. This makes it near impossible for Afghans to provide state-based self-governance and security.

We are funding the wrong strategy. Rand Corporation notes that more than 84 percent of insurgent groups are dismantled by good intelligence, policing and negotiations. A combat-heavy approach will not work. It did not work in Marjah and it will not work in Kandahar. The threat is far more sophisticated and amorphous. The Counter Insurgency manual recommends an 80 percent focus on economic and political capacity building, with a 20% focus on military. In Afghanistan, the opposite is employed with 90 percent of funding focused on military, and only 10 percent on building sustainable political and economic structures.

Lastly, the Wikileaks report is just the latest indication that we are fumbling on all fronts in Afghanistan, from security to development to governance and reaffirms my call for effective and independent monitoring and evaluation of U.S. presence in Afghanistan.

I could go on and talk about mounting civilian casualties and misguided strategies in training and staffing Afghan security forces.

Those of you who share my concerns with this war must continue to voice our critique, intelligibly, tactfully and loudly.

Too few in Washington are questioning US strategy in Afghanistan, and I thank these panelists who examined thoughtfully and thoroughly our strategy for its effectiveness.

Rep Michael Honda is the Chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus's Afghanistan Taskforce.

 
Today, Congressional Progressive Caucus co-chair Congresswoman Woolsey and I co-hosted a briefing to discuss the most pressing foreign policy issue facing our country today -- the war in Afghanistan. ...
Today, Congressional Progressive Caucus co-chair Congresswoman Woolsey and I co-hosted a briefing to discuss the most pressing foreign policy issue facing our country today -- the war in Afghanistan. ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:13 PM on 08/01/2010
Joining, or remaining with, a group of known criminals, such as the U.S. Congress, has become part of the proceedings. You can't simply come here, admit the crimes of others in the same body, then return and address them as your 'trusted' or 'esteemed' colleague. If you believe what you are saying, and I would think that is just the start, then you have to more than come to the blog and whine like the rest of us.
03:49 PM on 07/30/2010
Until President Obama develops a fighting policy and makes these issues a priority and defines the Republicans definitively as the Party of No, explaining what difference it makes for America, there will be no progress. He just does not have the will to fight. He can't send the Republican leaders to a corner or to their rooms, his only way to combat bad behavior.

This country is suffering from his girly-man approach to partisan politics. Reagan? He is not at all like Reagan.
photo
George Hanshaw
There are none so blind as those who will not see.
02:30 PM on 07/30/2010
If we are going to be at war, the worthless damn Congress ought to DECLARE it, as is their responsibility under the Constitution. And if they do DECLARE IT, we ought to take the gloves off and win - whatever it takes.

But if it's not worth declaring or fighting to win, why are we in there?
02:15 PM on 08/01/2010
Win what? Is that what you think makes it worthwhile? Declaring victory so you and others can say we can have a parade?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Exiled Scot InThe USA
07:49 AM on 07/30/2010
"What's wrong with the war in Afghanastan."

Answer - America and Britain are involved in it. What the hell are our Governments thinking here? I have been and still am an admirer of President Obama and the man has done well so far in trying to clean up the mess he inherited from the Shrub, but Mr President, STOP throwing endless cash at this venture and get our troops out NOW. This is a situation we can't and WON'T get a final solution so it's time to get out. America is on it's knees back home and we continue to throw money at this 'war' which is nothing more than an organised money making machine for corrupt construction businesses, (you listening Cheney?) not to mention the daily threat to young soldiers lives in a conflict with no chance of an outcome.

Do what's best for America President Obama and start bringing our soldiers home and stop kow towing to the slimey corporate businessmen who are getting filthy rich at the expense of American and British lives.

What happens when this latest bundle of cash runs out? Do we throw another 100 Billion dollars at it? Then what? More money?

Let's get real and forget this venture and concentrate on rebuilding America and getting the men and women back to work, there is much work to be done with our crumbling infrastructure.

STOP worrying about keeping the fat cats happy and get America back where it belongs.
02:16 PM on 08/01/2010
What exactly has he done? From where I sit, he has done nothing. Not one single damn thing. If fact, he is, for me, worse than Bush and certainly a war criminal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carl Caroli
Give peace a chance
07:04 AM on 07/30/2010
The biggest support for the war comes from the profiteers that are getting wealthy from it.
02:18 PM on 08/01/2010
And those who are invested in the profiteers. This, these, wars are for nothing more than protecting this particular brand of rotten capitalism which literally steals from poor nations, or poor people, to benefit the ultra rich. Don't forget those who want war simply to feel good about crushing weak undeveloped nations.
02:02 PM on 07/29/2010
Thank you Rep. Honda, I will do my part to voice the same concerns with my officials here in Kansas.