iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rev. Jennifer Butler

GET UPDATES FROM Rev. Jennifer Butler
 

Confronting an Immoral Budget

Posted: 06/07/11 12:32 PM ET

Below are the remarks I gave at a press briefing on June 3 responding to the Faith and Freedom Coalition's conference in Washington, DC, at which conservative operatives worked not only to promote their usual social agenda, but also to portray their radical economic policies as moral.

Thanks everyone for coming today, I know you're all very busy.

We're here to make some very important points about what's happening in faith and politics at this crucial moment.

Religious right operatives are not speaking for the mainstream faith community as they try to mobilize Christians behind a radical economic agenda. Their agenda of punishing hard-hit families with drastic, irresponsible budget cuts while giving trillions in tax cuts to millionaires is immoral, and people recognize that.

Some conservative religious operatives like Ralph Reed have been hard at work portraying their extreme agenda as mainstream.

They embrace greed: They want trillions in tax cuts for millionaires and powerful corporations -- even though these policies exploded our debt, and the wealthiest one percent of Americans already control 40% of the wealth.

They reject compassion and fairness for families: They want to make drastic budget cuts that will cause concrete hardship for struggling families, seniors, and the most vulnerable -- even as people struggle to find work and poverty is at staggering levels.

This is an immoral agenda, and people of faith are rejecting it.

A recent poll by Public Religion Research Institute showed that large majorities of America's largest religious groups -- including Catholics and white evangelicals -- find the concentration of wealth to be a major problem.

The same poll found that large majorities of Catholics and protestants support the wealthiest Americans paying higher taxes, and white evangelicals are evenly split on this issue.

And numerous polls show Americans across the spectrum reject Paul Ryan's plan to privatize Medicare, slash programs that protect families, and give millionaires tax cuts they don't need.
The radical economic agenda that religious right political operatives are pushing resembles the teachings of Ayn Rand more than the teachings of Jesus Christ. Politicians like Paul Ryan cite Rand as an inspiration, and religious right operatives are lining up to support Ryan's budget priorities.

Rand believed in selfishness and greed. Religious right operatives support giving trillions of dollars to the very richest Americans.

Rand held compassion and love for the weak in contempt. Religious right operatives seek to slash programs that protect the poor, struggling families, and the least among us.

On question after question, Ayn Rand and Christian moral principles are directly at odds. Yet religious right operatives are mobilizing en masse to support a budget that reflects Rand's teachings.

Prominent mainstream faith leaders across the country who are more interested in upholding the church's teachings about justice and the common good are standing together in overwhelming opposition to these extreme, immoral budget priorities.

Earlier this year, some in Congress advanced a budget that threatened to decimate programs that save thousands of lives every year and help vulnerable families put food on the table and get the healthcare they need.

Confronted with this injustice, a remarkably diverse group of nationally prominent clergy, from the head of the National Association of Evangelicals to African-American denominational leaders to leading Catholic bishops formed a "Circle of Protection" to stand up for these desperately necessary protections.

As Congress pushed through Congressman Ryan's budget, 30 Protestant bishops called the plan "morally indefensible," and 70 Catholic scholars issued a letter to John Boehner calling on him to turn away from his economic policies, which fly in the face of Catholic social teaching.

And Faithful America gathered thousands of petition signatures calling on Paul Ryan and John Boehner to support economic policies that protect the poor and honor their faith's teachings.

The message from the mainstream faith community is clear -- the economic agenda pushed by religious right political operatives is extreme, and it contradicts Christian moral values.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pembrokelib
11:06 AM on 06/08/2011
Ayn Rand, mostly ignored for years, has been embraced by the far right recently. Her code of complete selfishness fits in perfectly with their ideas.The author of this piece is right although I personally prefer to leave out the Christian part and speak of universal moral values. I applaud the clergy mentioned here and deplore the lack of basic morality of the so called Christian right. They are complete hypocrites and should be embarrassed to say that they are religious. They are selfish and greedy as well as uncaring of the less fortunate.
A-Superstitionist
Keep thy superstitions to thyself and out of laws
01:22 AM on 06/08/2011
Morality is deeply embedded in our evolutionary past and is currently known as the golden rules: treat others they way you want to be treated and don't treat others the way you don't want to be treated. They balance individual initiative with individual well-being for the benefit of society.

This is more valuable than mythical books of superstition that everyone selectively reads to discriminate against the poor, the elderly, the economically disadvantaged, homosexuals, stem cell research, women, freedom of choice, ...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
almostlyniceguy
Not young enough to know everything..
10:52 PM on 06/07/2011
Thank you, Reverend Butler. Although not religious myself, I have been struck by the disconnect between Christian teachings and the fiscal shenannigans going on in Washigton. I am happy that someone is speaking to this disconnect, and I hope that you gain ground and media attention.
NoRhymeOrReason
Teach your children well...
09:21 PM on 06/07/2011
I had planned a detailed explanation of what is going on. But, with only 250 words, I have opted for the short version.

It is the worship of money and greed. The Ryan Budget is not a product of Christian values. It is a direct worship of the Beast. Make no mistake. The worship of money and the worship of Greed is worship of the Beast.

I often wondered how the Beast, being so blatantly evil, would be able to entice so many people. Well, we are witnessing the answer to that question each day in the media.

I doubt that my opinions will sway any minds, but, for those of you who understand, do not give in.
05:42 PM on 06/08/2011
Mammon a.k.a. the beast.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edgraham
There is no magic
10:54 AM on 06/09/2011
I don't actually think there is a "Beast," but I totally agree with you.

Corporate Greed = The Beast (my version)
04:51 PM on 06/09/2011
Beast = Animal, instinctive drive to compete for limit resources
NoRhymeOrReason
Teach your children well...
11:33 AM on 06/14/2011
OPR8R has it exactly right. The "Beast" is not a person or a thing. It is the animal instinct that resides inside all of us.
researcher
researcher
08:35 PM on 06/07/2011
christian moral values??????

we are the most christian nation of all the industrialized world.

we have 50 million people without health care insurance.

we have a wall street that is nothing more than scams.

we have on going wars for corp profits.

we have a mega military I am sure jesus would approve of that. ie not.

our prisons are overflowing.

these christian moral values teach guilt, sin, evil to our young children. at easter a church I know had a mock torture of jesus nailed to the cross with blood running down his body as he was screaming in pain. ie youth pastor played jesus. yes there were children watching this. might have warped their minds for life.

this christian nation supports an economic system called capitalism of corp profits over peoples needs like food and medical care. our medical insurance companies find ways not to pay to enhance their profits and CEO bonuses.

we now have one out of seven americans on food stamps.

need I go on with your christian moral values. I think not.
05:50 PM on 06/07/2011
I agree mostly with this article, but the supposedly ultra-moral Dems have not yet pulled us out of the two wars. I don't think that conservatives and Republicans have a monopoly on "immorality."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
almostlyniceguy
Not young enough to know everything..
10:48 PM on 06/07/2011
Dems have their occasional instances of personal immorality, but they do not engage in it on the breathtaking scale of the republicans. As for the wars - you are right. But the old adage is true - it is easier to stay out than to get out.
05:45 PM on 06/08/2011
Correct now ask yourself which is the lesser of the evils and which if in power would be easier to convince they are being immoral? This is why I am voting democrat this time around.
03:57 PM on 06/07/2011
Perhaps, rather than demogogue the House GOP budget, the liberals should demand that the Democrats in the Senate do what they're supposed to do and present an alternative. Last year, the Dem-controlled Congress (both sides) failed to produce a budget at all. This year, only the GOP-led House has actually performed their duty and submitted a budget for consideration while the Senate Dems sit on their hands and can only cry about the House version. What is keeping the Democrats from laying out their fiscal ideas? Could it be that they don't want to have to campaign on them?
05:47 PM on 06/08/2011
It is easy writing a budget that benefits a few, try writing one that benefits everyone. Just because someone has a plan doesn't mean we have to help them achieve it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shifu
Train and be ready
01:51 PM on 06/07/2011
I still cannot understand why anyone would vote Republican. Eisenhower and Buckley must be turning over in their graves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edgraham
There is no magic
10:59 AM on 06/09/2011
I don't get it either. They control their voters by fear.

Fear of God
Fear of other races
Fear of other countries

It's a long list, but racism seems to pop up a lot.
01:33 PM on 06/07/2011
Two points: For thity-plus years, the left has been insisting that religion and religious values be kept outside of government. And I've agreed with them. Now, all of a sudden, the left has discovered religion and insists it has to be a part of, indeed guide, our decisions on government policy. This is disingenuous of them. They have suddenly discovered religion merely to attempt to divide and one-up the right. Secondly, the immorality is in the growth of government to such an imprudent extent that we are now threatened with fiscal insolvency - in fact, we are already there, and would see it more clearly if the deficit were accounted for more honestly. The poor will do far worse under a bankrupt (or supersized) federal government than under a lean government without crazy regulations, and a thriving private sector. A bankrupt government is not compassionate. In short, the left needs to actually employ the thinking skills they pride themselves on presenting and abandon their failed policies of the past. A secular, minarchical government is the only way to assure America's future. Leave religious affectations out of it - and stop misrepresenting Ayn Rand.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:31 PM on 06/07/2011
you completely fail to see that there is contradiction the size of Texas between the purported values of the Christian Right and the conservative "drown the government in a bathtub" agenda.

To tolerate a contradiction means you tolerate crazy. It means you lose the basis for rational argument. You can start to discuss values only AFTER you removed contradictions from your agenda. Otherwise, all discourse is futile. This is NOT a matter of preferences. This is property of reason (and reasoned disagreement).
04:35 PM on 06/07/2011
And still, you ignore the left's OWN contradiction which the commenter pointed out which is that a group (liberals) who disavow any pairing of religion and government will turn to religion and use it to prop up an idea for government (as in this article) when it suits their needs. Are there hypocrites on both sides? Of course. But believing in compassion for your fellow man and wanting a smaller government are not opposing thoughts. Compassion begins at home, not in the halls of state or federal legislatures, and it certainly doesn't always demand unlimited taxpayer funding.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cindbird
Using my head for something other than a hat rack.
05:14 AM on 06/08/2011
No one is misrepresenting Ayn Rand. She made her views quite clear many times over. And the liberal "failed policies" were the ones to balance the budget under President Clinton. It was President George W. Bush's policies which directly led to the Great Recession. It began under President Reagan's administration with the "Trickle Down Economics" policies which failed to take into account GREED. The reason the government is broke is that President Bush decided to cut taxes (the government's income ie. paycheck) and then enact a drug benefit, and start 2 wars he didn't bother to pay for (ie. ran up the credit card since he didn't have to pay it). He forgot all about the budget when he went into Iraq on his modern day Crusade against Muslims (which he admitted to). But now Conservatives want to blame it on President Obama when all the Republicans have done for 2 1/2 years is say "No" to anything he suggested. That's the definition of a hypocrite. And No, I'm not a card-carrying Democrat or Liberal. I am an Independent who has been "employing the thinking skills I pride myself on presenting".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:25 PM on 06/07/2011
"Earlier this year, some in Congress advanced a budget that threatened to decimate programs that save thousands of lives every year and help vulnerable families put food on the table and get the healthcare they need."

Very much so. It's not a Sunday school issue. It's a life and death issue.
photo
Scholastica8
RINOS & Bull-Mooses UNITE! People Matter!
12:12 PM on 06/07/2011
The more mainstream religions push back with a "morality" view, the sooner the religious right will revive the old hot-button issues of abortion and gay marriage. The issue of abortion in particular is the wedge can be relied upon to split and weaken any mainstream Christian efforts. That becomes the black-and-white issue. You cannot preach morality if you support a candidate that favors a woman's rights over her own body. That makes you a supporter of a baby killer.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:36 AM on 06/08/2011
so you threaten that if all else fails, you can just randomly call those people you don't like "baby killers" and then magically the economic problems will be solved?

And how will that work in a situation where the main problem is gridlock in Washington? Will it help to randomly call people who have never thought of killing babies "baby killers"?

To me it seems like it's bad enough that this strategy has been tried for decades. Do you really feel that it has been a success?