iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rev. Michael Dowd

GET UPDATES FROM Rev. Michael Dowd
 

TEDx: Why We Struggle

Posted: 06/22/2012 11:49 am

Faith traditions offer conflicting beliefs about our inner nature and challenges. Fortunately, a knowledge-based view is emerging that offers fresh and realistic hope for improving the quality of our lives and relationships.

Ignorance of our inherited drives has been one of the greatest causes of suffering throughout human history -- individually and collectively.

Every religion offers mythic beliefs about our inner workings. But until recently, we had no measurable knowledge about how our minds and emotions actually work -- what drives us, and why.

Now we know, through a wide range of evidence, that the powerful biological instincts we inherited are 'mismatched' for the supercharged environments we have created. Honoring this now indisputable fact can help us channel our deepest drives in ways that serve, rather than sabotage, our joy in life and the quality of our relationships and legacy. As well, we can appreciate how this inspiring, science-based perspective REALizes, or naturalizes, ancient mythic insights.

I delivered the following TEDx talk in Grand Rapids, Michigan, in May 2012. Beneath the video player is a brief description of some of the main points I covered.


Most of us, including evangelicals, know that our trials and temptations, our inner struggles, our troubling habits of thought and behavior, our personal and relational challenges, are not literally the result of our great-great-great-great... grandmother eating an apple.

Within each of us are instincts molded by millions of years of evolution to have us think and behave in ways that certainly benefitted our ancestors. Indeed, all of us alive today owe our existence to those very same instincts. But what have they done for us lately? To be blunt, they've made many of us fat, some addicted, and most of us in denial about how we are impacting the planet.

Our instincts can hardly be faulted. We are surrounded by 'supernormal allurements': processed foods, feel-good drugs and alcohol, Internet porn, and media sources that are no longer tethered to reality. Our ancestors faced none of these challenges.

Our ways of getting news, interacting with friends, and dealing with enemies have been altered beyond recognition by modern technologies. Our opportunities for indulging romantic or sexual urges, or wasting time and distracting ourselves, would be unrecognizable even to our great-grandparents.

The cultural contexts have changed enormously -- but our brains and bodies have not. We still have the same fears and desires as our ancestors, but now those instincts are out of sync with life conditions.

Compounding the problem is that we've all inherited exquisite skills for self-deception. The human brain not only distorts perception and memory; it then uses its extraordinary powers to rationalize or justify the distortion. In essence, our brain regularly tricks us -- and then masterfully hides the evidence!

Consider: Prior to microscopes, it wasn't just difficult to understand infection; it was impossible. Prior to telescopes, it was impossible to understand the Universe. The same is true of our inner world. Without an evolutionary grasp of why our instincts and emotions are the way they are, it isn't just difficult to wisely choose and live our priorities in this fast-paced, modern world. It's effectively impossible.

Our long history of living in primitive conditions and in small tribal groups did not give us instincts or equip us to deal with the supernormal allurements surrounding us today.

Especially for the young, trying to master one's animal urges (physical or social) without first learning why they evolved, and without appreciating the purposes they once served, is like trying to figure out why your car is running poorly when you've never been taught what's going on under the hood.

As Edward O. Wilson has written, "We exist in a bizarre combination of Stone Age emotions, medieval beliefs, and god-like technology."

We cannot, of course, change our instincts -- but we can change how we relate to them, how we manage them. Thanks to the evolutionary sciences, we now can understand our instincts and finally face our challenges with a measure of lightness and compassion and with practical tools that actually work.

The process begins with distinguishing fault from responsibility. We can thereby free ourselves of the burden of guilt, shame, and self-condemnation from choices we've made in the past, while stepping up to the responsibility of making amends for our wake and fashioning a better future.

When we honor our inherited drives (which is nearly impossible when referring to them as "inner demons," or our "shadow" or "ego") we can feel our heart expanding in gratitude, generosity, and compassion for self and others -- and our inner state will not only match but strengthen the ways in which we already are serving our community and the world.

* * *

NOTE: My 27-year-old son, Shane (an athletic trainer and life coach), and I are in the process of creating an online support structure for men who want to explore this subject more deeply, individually or collectively, titled, "Men Evolving Men." If you'd like to be notified when this is available, email me at Michael@TheGreatStory.org

Also see:

 
 
 

Follow Rev. Michael Dowd on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MBDowd

FOLLOW RELIGION
 
 
  • Comments
  • 40
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
ILoveTheUSofA
BREAKING NEWS: There is no God.
04:34 PM on 07/03/2012
This is the first essay masquerading as a "Rev. Michael Dowd" essay that didn't annoy me - so, I don't who you are, "Rev. Michael Dowd," or what you did with the REAL Rev. Michael Dowd - but you're not fooling me at all.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
12:59 PM on 07/04/2012
I took over his body/mind...but only temporarily. I suspect you'll soon be annoyed by me/him again soon. ;-)

Wishing you a wonderful and relaxing Independence Day holiday, ILoveTheUSofA.

Warmly,

~ Michael
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:52 AM on 06/25/2012
Great presentation Michael, your work is a valuable contribution to a more accessible understanding of who we are and where we come from, and your participation here is beyond impressive. Thanks also for including specific links in your responses - "giving heresy a bad name", LOL.

Psychologist Daniel Kahneman('Thinking: Fast and Slow' and a pioneer in the study of cognitive biases) said at a recent conference on science communication that in order to communicate effectively with people, "It almost necessarily involves stories." - pretty solid validation of the need for The Great Story, Big History, Epic of Evolution approach.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
05:40 PM on 06/25/2012
Thanks, my friend! I feel seen and heard by you. So nice!
researcher
researcher
03:35 PM on 06/24/2012
"In essence, our brain regularly tricks us -- and then masterfully hides the evidence!"

The human mind can be our greatest asset and our greatest enemy.

What better reality to evolve the soul than to live a physical life in a world of creature desires and those with political agenda's and their attempt to control and manipulate us and economic ideologies of greed and selfishness and the challenge of separating religious dogma from divine spiritual teachings.

The evolution of consciousness is the stuff of life, in religious terms the expression/s of God's divine potential; whereas the evolution of the physical is just appearances that both the religious and the materialists judge by appearances.



"The process begins with distinguishing fault from responsibility"

This sentence needs to be explained in much more detail. responsibility can mean personal responsibility and that usually means to most culpability and blameworthiness.
05:08 AM on 06/24/2012
It's not as if these "god-like technologies" which man has developed has played any role in his survival skills. In other words, man's brain has to trick or through ploys of self-deception keep these primordial tendencies at bay. And, by the same token we are allowed to "free" ourselves from the more base instincts because we simply don't understand "why" we have these urges. Therefore, we can ulitmately blame our ancestors instead of ourselves...even though, they too are innocent of the guilt which they inherited from some twist of the DNA. C'mon, that's stretching credibility and responsibility a little bit to far.
Plus, MBDowd and Son are going to teach us "how" to honor our inherited drives. I can just see it now..."Honey, did you just throw the dog out the window!??" the wife asks. "Yes, as a matter of fact I did, sweetheart, " the husband replies. "It all has to do with my primal instincts which I'm honoring today. And, it was either throw him out the window or eat him! By the way, do you know where my club is?" the husband retorts. "Are you looking for your nine iron?" the wife asks. "No, I mean my club the real one. I think that dog is sneaking back in!" the husband replies.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
08:48 AM on 06/24/2012
Nephew, you could hardly have a more INaccurate understanding of what it means to honor and harness (i.e., understand, appreciate, and respectfully manage) one's inherited drives or instincts.

Still, I appreciate your sense of humor in the last para. :-)
02:08 AM on 06/25/2012
Thanks, for not jumping down my throat for the humor. There's tons of things I actually agree with you about. Some of your opinions are a little reaching for me. I read an article the other day, and I can't remember who wrote it but it was about "how" the weaker of males became dominate in females selecting them for mates. If that is the case, by now we're so emasculated that we can't even recognize ourselves regardless of our inherited drives or instincts.

However, it would still seem that, from reading this other article, that the instincts which you are speaking of are still the more pacifistic.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OtayPanky
You're welcome
01:16 AM on 06/24/2012
BLogger: NOTE: My 27-year-old son, Shane (an athletic trainer and life coach), and I are in the process of creating an online support structure for men who want to explore this subject more deeply, individually or collectively, titled, "Men Evolving Men." If you'd like to be notified when this is available, email me at Michael@TheGreatStory.org

---

How deeply are we talking about, in dollars and cents?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
08:43 AM on 06/24/2012
Good question; I don't honestly know yet. What I do know is that Shane and I are both committed to ensuring that no one is turned away due to lack of funds.

Currently, I'm thinking that we'll probably be doing 90-minute interactive conference calls once a week, creating a structure for online small groups and community interaction, and working closely with a small group of co-facilitators, and the cost being somewhere in the ballpark of $5-$10/week ($20-$40/month), depending on someone's income level and degree of participation.

Given what I said above, however, I suspect that we'll be doing some bartering and perhaps offering scholarships too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
02:05 PM on 07/14/2012
Here's our current thinking, as of mid-July:

Men Evolving Men:
Fitness for Life Online "Gym":
http://thegreatstory.org/men.pdf
photo
flinthfp
1John 5:11-12 Eternal Life in flesh
08:50 PM on 06/23/2012
****when we honor our inherited drives (which is nearly impossible when referring to them as "inner demons," or our "shadow" or "ego") we can feel our heart expanding in gratitude, generosity, and compassion for self and others***

I believe this concept is the complete opposite to any spirituality that honors EGO/SELF.
Christianity teaches that the WORD of GOD became flesh and blood, in order to bring it to its intended purpose. In the killing of sin, I.e. the animalistic desires Base natures, drives, and raising it to a new creation, mankind is enabled by this one act to enter into a co-crufication,( die to self, surrender) and co-resurrection, spiritually in Christ. This new life "Eternal Life" empowers mankind to overcome sin, base natures, temptations, and ultimately death.
Shalom
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
09:19 AM on 06/24/2012
Flinthfp, A couple of years ago I wrote two blog posts (on my Evolutionary Christianity blog site) specifically for those who think and feel and interpret the world and their faith as you do. I hope you find them helpful...

Why Evangelize Evolution?
http://evolutionarychristianity.com/blog/why-evangelize-evolution/

Evolution Isn't About Darwin -- It's About Salvation Before You Die
http://evolutionarychristianity.com/blog/evolution-isnt-about-darwin-its-about-salvation-before-you-die/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Weidner
Ask me about my narcissism!
03:43 PM on 06/23/2012
No, there are plenty of people that think that we should go to hell because Adam and Eve ate that magical fruit. They truly believe it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
07:14 PM on 06/23/2012
No doubt, David. But having pastored three churches over the course of a decade I can fairly confidently say that many people who would consider themselves theologically conservative know there's something else (something biological or cultural or *whatever* else) going on. But you're right, there are plenty who still have a very mythic / magical / unnatural view.

Here's a rap I've used pretty effectively to shock some literalists out of otherworldlyism...

Supernatural Is Unnatural Is Uninspiring (When You Think About It):
blogpost: http://thankgodforevolution.com/node/2024
podcast: http://evolutionaryevangelists.libsyn.com/29_supernatural_is_unnatural_is_uninspiring
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
12:03 PM on 06/24/2012
Yes, surely. But I think you'd be surprised at how many evangelicals (and other theologically moderate-to-conservative Christians, Muslims, and Jews) will admit to you, though perhaps only in private conversation, that they interpret that story in a metaphorical or symbolic way, not literally.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Weidner
Ask me about my narcissism!
12:21 PM on 06/24/2012
You respond to my comment but remove my response to your response (Maybe some other person moderated).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:55 PM on 06/23/2012
These ideas may be useful for someone who is unfamiliar with Nietzsche or Freud, if there is anyone like that. However, these days the more contentious issue has to do with how we are our bodies. That is to say, the old myth of "mind" (used in this article in its ancient Platonic sense of something to control the body) now increasingly has the status of a ghost. Most of us no longer believe in ghosts, either external or internal. I thought "naturalism" meant something such as Nietzsche's affirmation "Become what you already are."

I am a whole who cannot understand or be understood as an assemblage of parts. Sure, if I need the help of a mechanic (e.g., a physician) I know he will operate by his blueprints. But I am no more the result of a blueprint than a work of art is the sum of its materials. As all of us, I need help. From religion I expect a holistic understanding.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
03:25 PM on 06/23/2012
Surely you are aware, January, that well over 80% of the American public (probably closer to 85-90%) have an extremely superficial understanding of Freud, and far fewer have any understanding or familiarity whatsoever with Nietzsche.

You need to get out more, my friend. You've been hanging around philosophy majors too long. (I'm speaking as a philosophy major, myself.) :-)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:38 AM on 06/24/2012
You may be right that I hang out in all the wrong places, but your response limits itself to just the first sentence of my comment. In a 2007 obituary for the late Richard Rorty, a colleague of his wrote that Rorty proposed ”we should see philosophy and science as forms of literature." That's where I hang out and where religion that is not doomed to cultism ought hang out.

I call religion that avoids the responsibility of rigorous investigation "greeting card religion:" lots of good advice and best wishes for a successful life. A probing and provocative theology is not absent from the current scene. But it is being written by philosophers, literary and comparative religion scholars, found in cultural and religious theory as well as in the curricula for religious studies at the university level.

Yes, those require an institutional commitment. If hanging out there has no appeal to a majority of people today, so much the worse for them.
08:06 AM on 06/23/2012
Within each of us are instincts molded by millions of years of evolution to have us think and behave in ways that certainly benefitted our ancestors.

This and other lines are delightful being heard in a religious context. Perhaps Fox Entertainment could use a nightly show? Their vewers don't seem to belive in evolution, the earth being over 6k years old, and think all instincts have to do with sex which started at the first taste of...apple.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
01:27 PM on 06/23/2012
Thanks, Cold in Michigan. (The last church I pastored was in Ann Arbor.)

I'd love to be invited to do a nightly show, though I'm pretty sure Fox News wouldn't see me as a good fit. :-)

Having said that, however, a few years ago I *was* invited onto the Sunday morning FOX & Friends, which was broadcast nationally, and had fun "evangelizing" evolution. Check it out...

http://michaeldowd.org/news/tv/tv.html
SelfAwarePatterns
seek truth; question everything
07:04 PM on 06/22/2012
Outstanding. I hope the message gets out. It's badly needed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
07:36 AM on 06/23/2012
Thanks! I do too, SelfAwarePatterns.

Follow the links at the end. They're each a portal to a lots of good online resources on this subject.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Steve McSwain
Author; speaker; spiritual teacher
03:36 PM on 06/22/2012
Beautiful Michael...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
07:36 AM on 06/23/2012
Thanks, Steve.
12:18 PM on 06/22/2012
"Most of us, including evangelicals, know that our trials and temptations, our inner struggles, our troubling habits of thought and behavior, our personal and relational challenges, are not literally the result of our great-great-great-great... grandmother eating an apple."

You haven't met many evangelicals... :(
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MBDowd
America's evolutionary evangelist
03:22 PM on 06/22/2012
Okay, so I'm a tad prone to wishful thinking. :-)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:43 AM on 06/25/2012
What do you make of Matthew 19:4-6? Seems Jesus believed in a literal Adam and Eve and the book of Genesis.

"4 He answered, “Have you not read that he who created them from the beginning made them male and female, 5 and said, ‘Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh’? 6 So they are no longer two but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, let not man separate.”