More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
Rev. Tom Davis

GET UPDATES FROM Rev. Tom Davis
 

Santorum's Attack on My Church: A Clergy Response From the 'Shambles'

Posted: 02/24/2012 12:50 pm

It's hard to imagine what goes through a campaign manager's head when his candidate says to him, "Harry, tomorrow, I'm going to tell the Methodists, the Presbyterians, the Lutherans, the Disciples of Christ, the United Church of Christ, the Episcopalians, and the American Baptists that they aren't real Christians -- about 25 million people." Does the manager reach for the Tylenol or the Jim Beam? That is essentially what the Senator said in 2008 when he was campaigning at Ave Maria University in Florida. Here are his words.

"We look at the shape of mainline Protestantism in this country and it is in shambles, it is gone from the world of Christianity as I see it."

It sounds politically suicidal, but I guess it makes perfect sense from a certain strategic point of view. What he was doing was making an exclusive claim of the sacred. He was implying that only the Roman Catholic Church and evangelical churches like the Southern Baptists can claim the sacred. The enemy of these groups has to be the secularists. In America any conflict between the side with all the sacred symbols vs. people with only secular ideals will favor the former.

But if mainstream Protestants also represent the sacred and they are on the side of gay rights, marriage equality and pro-choice positions, then they must be discredited. President Obama's church, my church, the United Church of Christ, cannot be a "real" church. It has to be "gone from the world of Christianity." Their most important concern is to keep any vestige of sacredness from President Obama. They refuse to see him as a Christian in a traditional Protestant Church, a person who is no more Christian than other people, but no less Christian either.

At the risk of sounding as judgmental as the Senator, it might be he who has gone astray. He has a theology of purity, a concern never to be involved with anything that is condemned as impure by his religion, things like homosexuality and birth control. But the central value of biblical Christianity is not purity. Nor is it things like a literal six-day creation, or being born again. It is love and justice. Focus on that those values and you find yourself not worrying about purity, but actually trying to make society better. It is the dreaded affliction of us mainline Protestants: social justice.

But maybe the Senator is right about us. We don't seem to have the important qualities of a real religion. We are too soft. We don't ex-communicate people. We don't deny them communion. And there is another of our bad qualities: We try to be tolerant. We don't think we have a corner on the truth. And finally, we have yet another drawback. We don't listen. We don't listen to Glenn Beck, to Rush Limbaugh, to Sean Hannity, or any of the flood of conservatives who think social justice is for the birds. We ordain women to the ministry, we ordain gays to the ministry. We -- many of us, at least -- support the work of Planned Parenthood and think it that when it furnishes compassionate care for poor women and other women, it is in accord with that commandment to love the neighbor.

So, from Senator Santorum' s standpoint, I guess we are lost. We are so far gone that we are actually not ashamed of who we are.

But thanks for trying to save us, Senator. We won't forget it.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 228
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
photo
Gunfighter
Husband, father, follower of Christ, lawman.
07:36 PM on 02/28/2012
Oh, we won't forget is right!, although I suspect some of my fellow Lutherans might still actually vote for that guy.
11:01 PM on 02/27/2012
I have a question:

When Jesus returns, as prophesied, “to rule all nationsâ€, will He also rule over the Christian priests?

That is to say, when Christ returns “in the glory of his Fatherâ€, “in his own glory and in his Father’sâ€â€“when the Father and Son appear together, as Baha’u’llah and His glorious Son Abdu’l-Baha have appeared–will the Christian leaders humbly lay down their power, their authority, their fame, their scriptural interpretations, and their own knowledge of things, and accept Baha’u’llah as the return of their Lord, and follow Him, and do His bidding, though it may not be in accord with their wishes or desires or expectations; or will they instead “act as former generations have acted†in the ancient times, and devise fantastic notions, and dispute with Him, and cling to outmoded traditions and shibboleths, and continue to reject their Lord–in spite of compelling, incontrovertible and infallible proofs offered by Baha’u’llah and Abdu’l-Baha that show unequivocally not only their right to claim to be God’s Messenger for today, but also where the commentators have gone wrong–and vainly cite as a prerequisite the literal fulfillment of certain prophecies which they themselves have determined must occur, in the manner they prescribe, before they would deign to lower themselves to accept the appearance of their Lord?
10:21 AM on 04/14/2012
Good question. Are any of the priests willing to answer it?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John Camp
Pastor, teacher, former techie
10:07 PM on 02/27/2012
I have been struck by the concerted effort by mainline protestants to drop the mainline label in favor of main stream, even though they no longer represent the majority of weekly church attenders. And for the record as a trained theologian (ThD) I fail to see how a denomination (Like the UCC) that denies the exclusivity of Christ can claim to be Christian or why they would want to.
04:37 PM on 02/28/2012
Pick and choose, the hallmark of denominations like the UCC. Christ is viewed as a great teacher, the provider of love and social justice, a really great guy... rather than the Lord of All that he is. I mean, we'd certainly hate to have to live up to the standard now wouldn't we. Besides, then there's no reason for salvation or an actual relationship with Christ. Just love your neighbor, BAH-DING, all good. And I couldn't agree more, why does a denomination that denies the exclusivity of Christ claim to be Christian.
10:26 AM on 04/14/2012
I feel that Christ would neither be protestant nor mainline nor nor mainstream. That's why all of these academic titles must be dropped before we humble ourselves to realizing the Messenger Who came as Christ said, like a "thief in the night." And that is none other than Baha'u'llah, Whose son, 'Abdu'l-Baha, visited the America one hundred years ago. He did not go on the Titanic - as he was expected to. He sailed on the less acclaimed SS Cedric. Makes you think, doesn't it?
06:43 AM on 02/27/2012
He has an Old Testament faith, a fierce Moloch type of faith, which demands the the sacrifice of all other beliefs to propitiate it.
01:28 PM on 02/27/2012
You have it exactly wrong.

Moloch was the god of the Canaanites and other Semitic peoples of the ancient near east. His priests demanded child sacrifice. In the worship of this god, babies were burned alive by their own parents.

Mr. Davis supports the "work" of Planned Parenthood, which is the largest abortion "provider" in the nation. Estimates of the number of babies murdered by Planned Parenthood since 1973 is in the tens of millions - far far more than the number of babies possibly sacrificed to Moloch in a comparable period of time. If you are searching for someone with a "fierce Moloch type of faith" (whatever that is supposed to mean) Mr. Davis is your guy, not Rick Santorum.
06:21 PM on 02/27/2012
You, too?
04:12 AM on 02/27/2012
Glad you noticed that, Reverend D., I, too, find Mr. Santorum's assertion that the state of Protestentism is a shambles heretical. It is, and always has been a circus, forever,and ever. Amen.
10:36 AM on 02/27/2012
The genius of the Founding Fathers was to give all faiths equality, thus reducing them all to absurdity.
08:21 PM on 02/26/2012
Well, Reverend Davis, is this the dawn of the realisation that the political monster American Christians have created by voting "their conscience" is finally coming home to bite them?

Better late than never, I guess.
04:05 PM on 02/26/2012
Santorum was speaking to an orthodox Catholic audience that understands exactly why Mainline Protestantism is in a shambles and why it is important to safeguard the faith. Mr. Davis' own UCC is an indifferentist hodgepodge that encourages heterodoxy in the name of "tolerance" which it seems to think is virtue. If Mr. Davis is offended, tough beans.
06:32 PM on 02/26/2012
You hit the nail on the head. Having grown up in the UCC, I'm sad to say that it lost its way a very long time ago.
08:51 PM on 02/26/2012
United Methodist are the largest mainline church and the second largest Protestant church. Individual churches range from liberal to very Conservative, with most being in the middle or right of middle.

Last week a priest on Bill O'Reilly's show called. Santorum an extremist that will not be popular with most Catholics.

Mainline Protestants and Catholic have a similar voting and responses to polls. Research has also found both to be more intelligent and better educated than Evangelicals that are supporting Santorum. The following is the similarity between most Catholics and Mainline Protestants.

More than 75 Catholic college professors sent a publicly released letter to House Speaker John Boehner saying that the budget he supported will hurt the poor, elderly and vulnerable. Boehner, a Catholic Republican, gave the commencement address in 2011 at the Catholic University of America.

http://ncronline.org/blogs/distinctly-catholic/breaking-news-catholic-academics-challenge-boehner
07:44 AM on 02/27/2012
1. The priest was probably a Jesuit - an order that is barely Catholic any longer.
2. Yes, there are a great many nominal Catholics who are badly catechized. That is why the Holy Father has appointed orthodox Bishops to oversee a new evangelization both in Europe and the United States.
3. "Catholic College Professors" have no standing to speak for the Church or for anyone else.
4. Reasonable minds can differ as to whether conservative fiscal policy harms the "poor, elderly, and vulnerable." Personally, I think that confiscatory taxation and the totalitarian welfare state impoverishes everyone. In any event, such social policy is a prudential matter and not not doctrinal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ninotchka KS
Public ignorance is corporate bliss
03:23 PM on 02/26/2012
Santorum's rhetoric probably doesn't sound too much different than what was probably said at the beginning of the Crusades. And we all know what happened next; the Dark Ages...

Obama Again - 2012!
04:02 PM on 02/26/2012
The "Dark Ages" (a misnomer in any event) began with the fall of Rome in the 5th century and continued until the 13th Century. The Crusades lasted from the 11th Century to the 13th. What happened after the Crusades were the Scholasticism of the High Middle Ages and the Renaissance. You should read more and write less.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ninotchka KS
Public ignorance is corporate bliss
04:21 PM on 02/26/2012
Fair enough. But I stand by what I said about Santorum.
01:49 PM on 02/27/2012
Ah yes, the Renaissance....the birth of reason; Although Mama church managed to delay the delivery for about 4,500 trimesters, and ironically seems intent on a post-natal abortion, the little imp is still growing, and may yet free us from the staggering amount of darkness that still clings to her.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
03:18 PM on 02/26/2012
Santorum has done much to re-earn his previous award as "The Dumbest Senator." There were ninety-nine others, and it wasn't close.
01:40 PM on 02/26/2012
These so-called conservative politicians and religious leaders are no different than those, in the old days, who criticized Jesus for not being Christian enough. "Look! He performs a miracle on a Sunday!" "Look! He is sitting with the sinners!" To consider these people as true believers of God would be like considering the tea partiers as true defenders of our constitutions.

I wish more "liberal" religious leaders would speak out against this hypocrisy. As Rev. Davis points out "We are too soft. We don't ex-communicate people. We don't deny them communion. And there is another of our bad qualities: We try to be tolerant." Such tolerance and silence have discouraged and turned away many people from church and God, spawning videos like "Why I Hate Religion, But Love Jesus || Spoken Word". Their frustrations towards organized religions were obviously caused by a small group of people who hold extreme views and love to pass judgments onto others. In reality, these people couldn't be further away from the Bible's teaching.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ninotchka KS
Public ignorance is corporate bliss
03:25 PM on 02/26/2012
F&F They were called the pharisees and Christ spoke negatively about them.
10:53 AM on 02/29/2012
Christ's frustration with the Pharisees was that they could not see their own sinfulness (as the more "conventional" sinners could easily see their own) so as to receive the pardon He came to provide.

Many on the religious right might still resent Jesus for hanging with the sinners...but the religious left would resent Him just as much for calling the sinners to repent. Such is our state when we don't continuously abide in Him, for despite the Rev.'s erroneous assertion that Christianity isn't about being born again, Jesus said quite emphatically that unless we are born again we can't even SEE the Kindgom of God.
photo
herkyc130
telling the truth and pulling the blinders off
12:06 PM on 02/26/2012
Maybe santorum has a log in his eye
photo
Gestas
Mountain Man
11:46 AM on 02/26/2012
Santorum needs to know that the box up front in some those churches where he is,, begging for votes has real live Rattle Snakes in there....
10:37 AM on 02/26/2012
The last time I looked NONE of us, no matter what religion, held the keys to the Kingdom. I believe it behooves mankind to remember we are ALL His children. If we concentrate on our own behavior and less on our neighbors we would all be better off. It is not up to us to decide or judge others. JUDGE NOT LEST YE BE JUDGED. in other words - mind your own business.
12:17 PM on 02/26/2012
...for we will be measured with the same meter stick we have used on others. Santorum and his ilk are setting themselves up for some pretty severe judgement.
pogo
My micro-bio is empty.
10:16 AM on 02/26/2012
And the Sunnis think the Shiites have fallen from the grace of God. The Shiites think the Sunnis have fallen from the grace of God. God must be smiling down on all of us, his beloved children...or whatever percentage of us are lucky enough to be correct in our beliefs.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
03:19 PM on 02/26/2012
If there is a god who looks down upon us, he/she/it must be laughing at us.
09:48 AM on 02/26/2012
I was raised a Catholic, went to a Catholic Prep School and married a Catholic woman in the Catholic Church. Since I married her, Pope John Paul II has died, there have been sex abuse scandals, 9/11, the evangelical rhetoric of Bush II, and now Rick Santorum. I more or less consider myself an Atheist now. Organized religion has disappointed me, to the point I no longer see the value of it. I have some personal beliefs, but I have come to question everything I grew up believing. I'll admit, I see no value in the Old Testament, whatsoever. It is full of myths, fairy tales, and outdated rules. I despise how many modern day Christians pick and choose which of these rules they wish to follow. I have thought that if Christians just followed the new testament and the core teachings of Jesus, the world actually could be a better place. Love your neighbor, turn the other cheek, peace on earth. Isn't that how he was trying to teach humans to behave? Whether you believe Jesus was divine or not, I think you can still see the value in his teachings. Anyway, that is where I currently am in my ever-evolving philosophy.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
03:21 PM on 02/26/2012
The Old Testament is the story of a really nasty God who just loves to kill humans and to receive the blood of animals. He is a bloodthirsty fellow - in both senses of the word.
10:49 AM on 02/27/2012
Amen phal4875. The murder of children and infants is the single most evil thing a man can do, yet time and again the "God" of the bible commands his holy warriors to murder them in cold blood in the most awful of ways: by cutting their throats, slashing them with swords, and bashing their heads against stones. Why in gods name would anyone want to follow such a God?