Seth Myers had is exactly right. At the White House Correspondence Dinner on Saturday night, Myers said that given the paucity of viable candidates so far offered up by the Republicans for the coming election, Obama's only viable opponent was going to be Obama '08, the charismatic, exciting idealistic harbinger of hope who captured our hearts and minds.
Obama '12, on the other hand, Myers said, is tired, worn down, graying and hesitant. Although the campaign trail may energize him, bringing back some of the fire in the belly, the American electorate will be more wary this time around. The crowds will be smaller and the message darker. The problem is, however, once that voter gets into the booth, draws the curtain (where they still have curtains to draw), what will he or she finally do?
If the Republicans settle on Romney, the Tea drinkers will bolt and vote for Ron Paul, who will probably run a third-party campaign. If the Republicans are foolish enough to nominate a Tea drinker, the moderates will either sit it out or vote for the new Centrist Obama. As for the Progressives, they will swallow hard and stay with the incumbent, who, after all, is at least sane.
What Myers did Saturday Night (Live) was to do what the pundits have not done: tell it like it is and pose the right question. Basically he asked us what is the American voter to do? Both the Near and Far Right are crazy, and the Obama Administration appears to be adrift on its raft in a turbulent sea.
I have argued in this space recently that Obama's best shot is to bang away at the signature issues like health care and taxes for the rich and see if the voters are frightened enough of the Tea Party to throw them out. If that happens, the second term could supply that drifting raft with a rudder and even an engine (solar-powered, of course).
Follow Richard Geldard on Twitter: www.twitter.com/richgeldard
The thing is, even if he does, we know what his promises mean to progressives, we know whom he appoints and surrounds himself with, we know how he "negotiates" with the bullies on the right, we know his intentions regarding civil liberty issues, whistle blowers and anyone revealing his secrets--in short, Obama CAN'T be to us the guy he said he was in '08, because we know better.
And, in the end, we are reduced to voting for him because "at least he's sane"?! Holy Shite! This country is screwed.