iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Richard (RJ) Eskow

GET UPDATES FROM Richard (RJ) Eskow
 

Will a Young Generation's Dreams Be Rescued -- Or Bundled and Sold on Wall Street?

Posted: 04/25/2012 9:39 pm

Interest rates for student loans will double on July 1 unless Congress acts. That's outrageous -- but the fiscal abuse of our nation's young people runs far deeper than that. An entire generation has been trapped into debt servitude and joblessness by the implacable machinery of Wall Street greed. Bank-servile scolds insult the young people of America while the bankers' economic engines strip-mine their financial future.

Jobless or overextended college graduates aren't even allowed to declare bankruptcy -- a privilege that's extended to every reckless investor and mismanaged corporation in the nation. Once they finally find work, college graduates face years of garnished wages to repay the loans that funded their often-overpriced educations. If they haven't repaid that debt by the time they grow old -- a very real possibility at the cost of a college education today -- they'll even be forced to surrender part of their Social Security benefits.

That's indentured servitude.

Meanwhile banks have been slicing and dicing student loans into derivative financial instruments called "SLABS" -- student-loan asset backed securities. We've seen this movie before -- the one where big banks mass-market loans to a population with stagnated wages and dwindling economic prospects, then bundle them and sell them to investors who haven't reviewed the way they were underwritten and sold.

Hey, what could go wrong?

It's true that many of these packaged debts are backed by the U.S. government -- but not all of them.

Why are these graduates facing such a bleak job market? Because Wall Street's gambling on other financial bets crashed the economy, leaving an entire generation without much of a future to give them optimism and hope. Their parents can't help them much, because most of their assets were taken by Wall Street, too. So as an entire generation of college students graduates with unprecedented debt -- and joblessness that's unprecedented in modern memory -- they're looking forward to a lifetime of reduced expectations.

And just like their parents, these young people are being told the the banks aren't the problem: They are.

Half of today's college graduates are un- or under-employed. The total amount owed on student loans is greater than our country's entire credit card debt. The banks were rescued in a multi-billion dollar bailout (that did not turn a profit), but If anybody talks about a WPA-like program to rescue young people the bank-funded political crowd gasps in horror.

Instead of help, young people get comments like this now-notorious one from perenially ignorant GOP representative Virginia (Ginny) Foxx: " I have very little tolerance for people who tell me that they graduate with $200,000 of debt or even $80,000 of debt because there's no reason for that."

Ginny Foxx is acting out the last in a four-step process to crush the soul and spirit of a generation:

First, cut funding for colleges and universities throughout the country, driving the cost of a college education out of reach of most Americans. And while you're at it, play footsie with the for-profit college industry, giving out student loans for paper mills that churn out worthless diplomas at inflated prices -- but whatever you do, don't tell the students that!

Second, lobby to "privatize" much of the student loan industry. Turn Sallie Mae, the agency created to help students, into a greed-driven get-rich-quick scheme for greedy executives (See "Sallie Mae's Jets") who used government money to lobby for their own get-rich-quick schemes and turned the student loan program into a taxpayer-funded money tree for already-rich bankers. (To their great credit, the Obama Administration and Democrats on the Hill did a great deal to roll back this part of the greed machine with last year's student reform law.)

Third, deregulate Wall Street and allow them to wreck the economy, forcing an entire generation to face the bleakest job future in modern memory.

Fourth, condemn them for their own situation. That distracts some people from the real cause of this generational misery.

Blame the victim: It's the oldest game in the world. In fact, it's exactly what was done to many of their parents when they bought their homes. They convinced them that homes would rise in value forever, sometimes hired crooked appraisers to inflate their homes' value, encouraged them to take out loans on that inflated value -- and then, when the bubble burst, convinced a lot of people that the real problem in this country is 'greedy homeowners.'

But this time it may not work. There are too many young people, and too many parents, who have learned how the game works. They may not stand for it a second time.

There's another reason why it won't work -- and why Mitt Romney is suddenly the voice of reason, urging his fellow Republicans not to let these interest rates double. If they do rise after July 1, a lot of students will be unable to pay their debts. Not all of those loans are backed by the government, so a lot of banks will be hurt.

Republicans don't want that to happen -- so expect a lot of conversions to "reasonableness" in the coming weeks. The delinquency rates for these loans may be higher than originally believed, and there's reason to believe it could go much higher as more students graduate into a bleak job market. The financial industry is beginning to worry.

It should worry. So should all of the investors who have bought those "SLABS." Between the politics and the economics, Republicans would be crazy to let these interest rates soar. But then, they've done lots of crazy things lately ...

Our financial system can't afford another shock. That's another reason why the Administration's additional proposals for easing student loan debt should be passed immediately, especially the "pay as you earn" and "forgiveness in 20 years" (or less) provisions.

But that isn't enough. We owe the next generation a lot more than what's being offered. We owe them nothing less than a national program of jobs -- a program that will give them experience, income and a sense of restored optimism about the future.

Students also deserve the chance to pay off their loans altogether by taking on tough jobs (with salaries) that help society, as well as themselves. (There's some reduction in the length of the loan under the current system, but it should be improved.)

And yes, we should be talking about forgiveness.

It's surprising that we haven't seen more student protests like those that have gripped Quebec. The Occupy Student Debt Campaign may be the first step in that direction.

Think about it: One trillion dollars in loans -- loans that look increasingly risky with every month that passes. A generation that was tricked into borrowing for their educations -- in many cases for an overpriced or useless diploma, and in many other cases at costs that were driven sky-high by the selfishness and false economy of their elders.

And now, instead of helping our kids, we're letting people like Ginny Foxx demonize them. Or we're letting candidates like Mitt Romney say all the right things, then push for only the bare minimum needed to placate the public -- and protect the banks, which is their real agenda.

The choice is simple, really: We can do the right thing by the nation's young people -- or we can let the banks slice and dice their futures and sell them to unwary buyers. We can give our kids the chance for a decent life, or let their hopes be run through the Wall Street meat grinder.

We welcomed them into this world with promises. Will we sell their dreams to Wall Street to be carted away on SLABs?

Richard (RJ) Eskow, a consultant and writer (and former insurance/finance executive), is a Senior Fellow with the Campaign for America's Future and the host of The Breakdown, broadcast Saturdays nights from 7-9 pm on WeAct Radio, AM 1480 in Washington DC.

 

Follow Richard (RJ) Eskow on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rjeskow

FOLLOW COLLEGE
Interest rates for student loans will double on July 1 unless Congress acts. That's outrageous -- but the fiscal abuse of our nation's young people runs far deeper than that. An entire generation ha...
Interest rates for student loans will double on July 1 unless Congress acts. That's outrageous -- but the fiscal abuse of our nation's young people runs far deeper than that. An entire generation ha...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 37
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
06:02 AM on 06/07/2012
The blame game falls on both the Democrats and Republicans. They are both worthless to America. The parents of the collage kids today bought their homes more than a decade ago, and have been paying their mortgages on time, every month, until they got laid off recently, and the banks refuse to work with most every homeowner facing job loss no matter how responsible they have always been. Parents have to figure out how to feed their families and keep a roof over their heads because of this. The student loans are not a priority when trying to survive. Washington has also added a national debt that the next generation and beyond will now have to deal with, that just keeps getting bigger and added onto daily. Both parties are a fail and a cancer that that can no longer see past next week, and they are a product of Ivy League Universities. They are all just embarrassing!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TeamSanity
strong emotions don't equate strong arguments
03:57 AM on 06/07/2012
The thing that kills me is I've already done the equivalent of "Teach for America": I worked for years as a graduate teaching fellow - english departments require all incoming freshmen to take writing courses, and these classes produce income. I taught 2 - 4 classes every semester. I designed pedagogy still used by five different schools (public and private) and was never paid a dime for it.

I taught for years as an adjunct. Now I have a "lecture" job which is LOW LOW LOW in job respect and very high in work output. I earn the same amount I earned twelve years ago teaching high school.

Why isn't all the almost-for-free work taken into account as I face down a student loan for my Ph.D. that is almost more than the mortgage payment we pay monthly for a house we cannot sell as we pay rent in another state so we can work?
03:15 AM on 05/04/2012
I found bankruptcylive.com through a Google search and was quite impressed of services for consumers at reduced prices, further amazingly within same amount of turnover time. I did receive my bankruptcy public records within 35 minutes of placing my order. I wish great success to team and highly recommend this site goo.gl/HbTpq and service.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jerry Bourbon
02:18 PM on 05/01/2012
If you live at home and go to a college you can afford, you won't need to worry about student loan interest rates...Because you won't have any.
photo
Estreet1964
Gimmie the beat boys and free my soul....
02:59 PM on 04/26/2012
Why can't these financial genius' see how, by funnelling the lion's share of the nations wealth to the top -- to themselves!! --, they are starving the middle class of the wealth that needs to be circulated to maintain a growing and vibrant economy? You can't stand a pyramid on it's tip, it falls over. That's how our economy is now, very, very top heavy with cash and everyone else struggling to make ends meet.

But they got theirs by golly....they got theirs.

Trash heap of history here we come!
01:01 PM on 04/26/2012
We may not be able to look inside the cryptic bubble-forming mechanisms of the system as a whole, but we can still tell by the signals it sends whether it has changed its ways and learned to behave since the crash of 2008. The answer is obviously no, as the main players continue to use the same hide-the-risk mathematical tricks, financial instruments, and political manipulation to pump up the profit at the expense of large segments of the society. They sucked up the wealth from homeowners in their previous sting operation, and now it's the turn of the students. The always useful snake oil technique continues to bear fruit: pump'em, fleece'em, blame'em.
12:21 PM on 04/26/2012
Nobody is forcing anybody to go to college. Nor is anybody forced to finish within 4 years. Maybe it's past time to realize what we CAN do...not what we want to do because the 2 do not coincide...

Maybe it takes longer or maybe one just saves a bit on thier own...or (and here's a thought) one (OMG, here it comes) works thier way through it.

Forget about the "good 'ol days" because they're gone...just a fanciful memory that's been skewed by time.
06:15 PM on 04/27/2012
You say nobody is forcing anybody to go to college, but you ignore the fact that about 50% of jobs available in the next few years in the U.S. will require a college degree. The jobs you could get out of high school and support a family are gone. I was born into poverty and college was my only way out. I've been working since I was 16. I worked 3 jobs through two degrees, but it hardly made a dent! All these old people who used to have decent wages and lower tuition COULD pay their way through college because it was possible. It's next to impossible these days.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TeamSanity
strong emotions don't equate strong arguments
04:01 AM on 06/07/2012
I worked my way through school, formontoya, but in the early '80's, you could do that. I could take 18 credits and was charged around 650 - 700 for it, by the semester.

I teach college. My students are charged thousands every semester. They literally cannot work their way through school. Between tuition and the cost of living, it's not possible to pay as they go.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
binkyblue
10:38 AM on 04/26/2012
Banks have been abusing students for years by charging high interest rates for guaranteed(only the baks are guaranteed to get excessive profits no matter what) and by selling the loan so many times so opaquely that a student or former student has no idea who actually owns the loan. The school's financial aid office is often kept in the dark as well.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GHY1
10:07 AM on 04/26/2012
What would happen if students who have graduated get together and go on strike and not pay their student loans.
photo
Estreet1964
Gimmie the beat boys and free my soul....
03:00 PM on 04/26/2012
It'll happen.

What choice will they have?
10:00 AM on 04/26/2012
Of course! As long as there's a dollar to be made... The way I see it, things will turn out like Spaceballs where air is canned and sold. So why wouldn't Wall Street churn a profit from student loans?

Then combine this with the fact that we don't learn our lessons--for this, I cite the returning of subprime loans--and that there's always going to be people who think they can beat the game, even if it's at the cost of other people.
photo
teardownthiswallst
Only Truth will set us Free
09:55 AM on 04/26/2012
Everyone saw “The Matrix.” Did anyone grasp its’ symbol and metaphor?

Creating circumstances leaving people no realistic alternatives for advancing their meager lives outside of taking on massive levels of debt keeps them ‘plugged’ into the system for their entire lives.

Drawing unenlightened subjects into a lifetime of debt is the financial industries’ ‘profession.’ Few of us are crazy enough to gamble our lives away at the rigged Wall St casino, but nearly everyone is willing to gamble on themselves in an endless pursuit of the American Dream.

Endless consumption of life’s essentials; housing, food, clothing, cars, and fuel provide a steady baseline for profit. Toying with these commodities through speculation creates bubbles that suck us dry. Technology, toys, and games overstimulate human propensity for consumerism and inflate tech bubbles to popping.

These profit models are faulty. An impoverished citizenry can reduce their consumerism and even their essentials. Furthermore, bankruptcy provides an escape clause.

Perfecting the model required two modifications; eliminating the bankruptcy escape clause, and establishing an entity everyone needs to have any chance of succeeding. Free market health care nearly perfected the second point, but was still susceptible to bankruptcy. Creating an environment that established the absolute necessity of advanced education perfected the model.

The symbolism of Dickens, Hugo, and the Wachowski brothers was intended to provide us with cautionary tales. The banks and Wall St have perfected a grid of lifetime indentured servitude and brainwashed a zombie public that prefers the dream over unplugged reality.
photo
Estreet1964
Gimmie the beat boys and free my soul....
03:02 PM on 04/26/2012
You may have something there.

All those guys on The Street do kind of look like an army of Agent Smiths.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TeamSanity
strong emotions don't equate strong arguments
04:05 AM on 06/07/2012
If I could declare bankruptcy I would. I'm rounding the corner to 50: I've taught for 15 years after an interesting but poorly paid career brought me to seek a Ph.D. I'm terrified about my financial future, as I work the teaching jobs to bring a lot of revenue to my employer, as I create classes that are used elsewhere but I am not remunerated for them, as I struggle to pay a loan whose interest has almost doubled the amount I originally borrowed. I wake up in the morning, my heart pounding with anxiety, as I think about a retirement I shall never enjoy, and worry that I might have to eke out my days as the equivalent of a Walmart greeter.
09:26 AM on 04/26/2012
A conservative is someone who walks into a restaurant only to learn his favorite chef is in the hospital suffering from a heart attack. "Why does this always happen to me?" he laments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BoshSpong
My micro-bio does not meet HP's guidelines
10:38 AM on 04/27/2012
Exactly, fanned -

by the way have you noticed the uncanny resemblance between Bat Boy and Governor Rick Scott of Florida?

Separated at birth?
"Inquiring minds want to know.... "
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TeamSanity
strong emotions don't equate strong arguments
04:07 AM on 06/07/2012
Oh my god, what a beautiful, hilarious and spot on analogy.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fearthebetenoire
Lying's like 95% of what I do. In your job? Sure.
08:32 AM on 04/26/2012
Any student or student's parent voting Republican is NOT voting out of self-interest.

And any student who believes that the GOP is on his or her side is NOT reading more than just "obsolete" newspapers.

Students and their families, like all Americans, should look behind the words of all politicians and apply the kind of critical thinking that higher education is meant to provide. Which is why education is as important for the common good as it might be to get a job.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Heroldness
from the frozen Northland
07:30 AM on 04/26/2012
If the bubble burst will American tax payers be expected to bail out the banks and Wall Street again? Will CEO's be getting their usual huge bonus again for another round of greed? How many more American workers will lose their jobs and how many more dollars will the ones that don't lose their jobs be expected to give up in their paychecks? Will Americans again lose more or maybe this time all of their retirement savings? I don't know about the rest of you, but I wonder if we aren't one more crisis away from completely destroying our economy this time around.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LiberalDem
11:22 AM on 04/26/2012
Yes, we will be expected to bail out the banksters and fraudsters when the next bubble bursts. As long as our political system is warped by the outsize influence of big money and corporations this cycle will continue.
photo
Estreet1964
Gimmie the beat boys and free my soul....
03:11 PM on 04/26/2012
Of course we'll have to bail them out again. That's the way the system is designed.

They're not only "Too Big Too Fail", they're bigger than they've ever been. Forget al Qaeda, "Too Big To Fail" is the greatest threat to our national security and the world economy. The failure of just one of the top ten banks would set off a domino effect and collapse the world economy. (I'm betting BofA is the first to tumble) Nothing has been done to stop the excesses of Casino Capitalism and nothing has been done to mitigate the need for a bailout when one of them fails. Privatize the profits and socialize the losses. Them bankers just love them some socialism.

Don't let the politicians tell you that they'll be no more bailouts. There'll be bailouts.

Oh, there'll be bailouts.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BoshSpong
My micro-bio does not meet HP's guidelines
10:45 AM on 04/27/2012
Of course, the frustrating thing is that our Democrat President is so deferential to the right and the Dems in congress shake in their loafers so that the so-called financial regulation enacted by this admin. is extremely weak, no much has changed.

Funny thing is that the GOP wants to get rid of that milk-toast legislation claiming it is "stifling" economic growth.

On an unrelated matter have you noticed how much resemblance there is between your avatar "Bat Boy" and Florida's Governor Rick Scott? Separated at birth?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
oldStory
Southern hippy man dreaming on
06:53 AM on 04/26/2012
Two guys walk into a bar. One has the four-letter word "Love" tattooed on his left fist, the other the word "Hate" tattooed on his right one. The leftie, who looks a little like our president, is high on pot and looking for an umbrella drink to slake his thirst. The rightie has molten sulphur leaking out of his ears from listening to talk radio and needs a couple shots to smooth out the meth he uses to drive cross country. How many student bartenders doe it take to pull the rightie off the leftie? That endless horizon of American opportunity that stretched from sea to shining sea is now littered with roadblocks and the drawbridge that leads to the promised land is being pulled up. You gotta' be born in the pot to get the gold these days.