More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert J. Elisberg

Robert J. Elisberg

Posted: November 16, 2010 11:17 AM

Aaron Sorkin Was Right

What's Your Reaction:

A friend was explaining to me the easy thing Republicans in Congress had to do to guarantee they'd win the 2012 elections. "If they simply focus on jobs," he said, "if they just pass a jobs bill, then Democrats will be in a lot of trouble."

It was an excellent point. Except for one huge flaw with his scenario:

Republicans in Congress don't care about jobs. They not only don't care, they don't want to see the job situation improve. After all, if unemployment drops, credit rises to the president, Barack Obama. Not only don't Republicans in Congress want to see jobs improve, it's the very last thing they want.

This isn't some random theory, but an observation of reality. If Republicans in Congress actually cared about jobs, they wouldn't have spent the past two years campaigning against the jobs stimulus bill. If they actually cared about creating jobs, they wouldn't have blocked the president's proposal to unfreeze credit to struggling small businesses. They wouldn't have voted near-unanimously against the president's aid bill to the states, designed to save 140,000 teaching jobs. If Republicans in Congress actually cared about unemployment, they wouldn't have voted against extending unemployment benefits.

To be clear, many people can articulately defend these Republican actions. The one thing they can't do, though, is defend them and also claim that they care about creating jobs.

Further, it's not that Republicans in Congress don't care about jobs -- it's that they only care about accomplishing three things: lowering taxes for the wealthiest 2% of the country, getting rid of Social Security and Medicare, and gutting health care and Wall Street banking reform.

When I explained this to my friend, something ruminated in the back of my mind. I'll get to that in a moment.

In the meantime, though, I got into another conversation with a different friend, this one on Saturday. I had been describing an email exchange with someone whose fury at All Things Liberal is so over-the-top outraged that even he describes it as "insane and irrational." He periodically passes along vitriolic articles he receives from his far-right circle that stir up red-hot, sputtering wrath at the White House.

After describing these emails, my friend commented, "I am truly shocked by the visceral hatred of President Obama." (This wasn't a reaction to there being hatred, that's politics, but rather the convulsive, feverish depth of it.)

I'm sure that psychologists are having a field day explaining the reasons. Honestly, I don't believe for a second that the far-right hatred of President Obama is actually a hatred of President Obama. The intensity doesn't match the facts. It's so many other things all ratcheted up by a long-existent, right-wing, hate-and-fear-building machine that churns out an end-product, "Must HATE Obama." A hate-and-fear-building machine that dates back to painting Bill Clinton as a murderer, his wife a lesbian, through creating a "Terror Alert" to keep Americans petrified, to warning that the next smoking gun could be a "mushroom cloud," onto portraying the Democratic presidential candidate as a foreign-born black Muslim who pals around with terrorists while making terrorist fist-bumps with his wife who hates America.

After a decade of this, and more, how could fear and hatred not finally ooze out of the pores of those anxious to be frightened, looking for an excuse to blame for troubles in their own lives? Shaken at losing power at the White House. Disoriented at having a White House that for the first time wasn't white.

And after explaining this to my friend, that same something as before once again ruminated in my mind.

It is something that has, in fact, been there for several years.

What keeps returning is a memorable speech written by Aaron Sorkin in his movie, The American President. It comes when President Andrew Shepard has finally heard enough hate-filled demagoguery from his opponent and finally breaks his silence. The long speech is eloquent, but what stands out is one passage, words that today have become eerily recognizable.

"And whatever your particular problem is, I promise you, Bob Rumson is not the least bit interested in solving it. He is interested in two things and two things only: making you afraid of it, and telling you who's to blame for it. That, ladies and gentlemen, is how you win elections."

The Republican Party of many years, dating back to Joseph McCarthy, but turned into high gear the last decade, has been Bob Rumson.

They don't care about your problems. They don't care about jobs. They care only about terrifying you and pointing fingers of blame at the scary liberals and frightening black man.

And to return this full circle, it is because of that that Republicans stand on the precipice of being crushed in 2012. Because, once again, It's the Economy, Stupid. It's Jobs, Stupid. And Republicans in Congress won't do anything about any of that because if the economy improves, if unemployment lessens, it's bad for them. And they caused the problem in the first place. But more to the point, Republicans in Congress won't do anything about any of that because -- in the end -- They...Don't...Care.

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is how, in 2012, you lose elections.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 53
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:33 AM on 11/22/2010
Congress is away this week in their nice warm homes,but, they left the people who put them there in a homeless food line !! I hope people will start to vote,better yet,I hope people will start praying for a government gone big head full of selfish hot air and the people will stop being lazy in who is really running our country. Other countries are watching and taking notes on "A country divideded will fall" like, is this going to be the next reality show? Come on, look at the other countries without GOD, Its clear where," We the People" are headed,,fallen , like satan! OH wait a minute satan has a job! Congress does too, HUMMMM!
03:00 AM on 11/17/2010
I can't believe people think that Obama was going to fix everything that was messed up in just two years. That is why people voted against Dems in the most recent election.

But, I forgot, we are not allowed to blame anyone for what a president inherits. They all come in with a blank slate.
03:50 AM on 11/22/2010
Oh sweeti,please dont sue me for saying that!I'm poor and live in a rented trailer! teehee(true)! Life is hard,It should not be a clean slate ,,is'nt that why they run ,,,to clean the past clean!Obama is being used, Old white politician's get bored and the wrinkles on their butts show! In 40 years they see at least 3 generations and none of those generations even know who they are and by the time you do ,youve been hit by a bus,crazy ,but true! or slipped in the tub getting ready for church! and yes sweetie, ohpps! we are allowed, please don't forget ,as an American Don't forget,unless you have Alhimerzier's'and even then ,you are an American and that is why our guyand arls are fighting to keep our country free to make the changes to make us a better country, NOT to suppress the the people that make FAT CATS,but, house keepers and we the people are the house!So maid out ,your getting paid ,you got a job,,,,do it or you are out!
04:12 AM on 11/22/2010
CORRection to my comment TO the guys and gals fighting in our military to keep our country free, have my total respect and prayers of protection,my one an only son wants to join ,to give his family insurance and status if he dies,GO! I say, as a mother I would like to see our Politicians go as they are the one's that start the crap,,,Clean slate NO they know .what they are getting into,that is why they run,,,,death is on all their hands ,,and if my son goes in,,just to be able to take care of his family and dies,,,more blood for the the greedy,I have peace as a mother ,my son believes in JESUS Ihave HOPE in seeing him again and our politician ,Ihope they understand why they are sending our children in to maybe come home,while their chicken poopoo butts sit over here with the woman and children! HUMMM!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DarianSentient
Omnium Bonum Est
02:29 AM on 11/17/2010
...Look, I'm not a Dem, but I'm CERTAINLY not a GOP... while both parties are undeniably corrupt, at least the Dems give some kind of indication that they give a damn about their fellow man, even if they ARE hopelessly inept at finding ways to actually help him. The GOPs seem to believe manifest destiny works on a social scale, too... and the fact that they can legislate that kind of thing EFFECTIVELY is what worries me.

I'm hopeful that a viable not-Dem-or-GOP candidate for ANYTHING run for office somewhere I can vote for them... I may even attempt to do so myself in a few years. I think rationality, integrity and not-taking­-campaing-­contributi­ons-at-ALL would be interesting virtues upon which to run... and I think anyone who made a demonstrably honest attempt to do so would have my vote on general principle.

http://www­.wasabisof­t.net/2009­/02/18/int­egrity-cov­ers-rock/
09:40 AM on 11/17/2010
Agreed. But when presidential candidate Jerry Brown did exactly that a few terms ago he was roundly denigrated as 'being from Mars'. Maybe the times have changed for a viable second party candidate but...?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DarianSentient
Omnium Bonum Est
11:15 PM on 11/17/2010
Yeah, I could see that. Though "being from Mars" kinda reminds me of Stranger In A Strange Land, and I wouldn't say Valentine Michael Smith is a poor role model. :P

It's possible for a candidate running on... sanity, quite honestly... to get elected, but only if the American people come to the realization that the false decision between Dem and GOP with which they are being presented is, well... false. I think we're starting to see more of that sentiment amongst our populace, but it's motivated more by ANGER than by any kind of thought or reasoning... which tends to drive more of a "vote for the OTHER guy" mentality than a "don't vote for EITHER" mentality... and that's what would really be necessary for myself or anyone like me to have a chance.

Maybe I'll have to wait until "being from Mars" becomes a point in my FAVOR.
photo
ewldest
I don't care "whose" war it is - end it now
12:39 AM on 11/17/2010
Let's one thing clear -the difference between government created jobs program and trickle-down private sector jobs creation is that government programs are ultimately accountable to the voters; private sector programs - hey, there are no private sector 'jobs' programs, they're not accountable to anybody.
So for the Repubs to argue they are 'for jobs created by the private sector' is as much as to say, they're in favor of a crap-shoot and hope their number comes up.
Only it won't this time - because the multinationals who financed their campaigns don't give a dam'.
07:16 PM on 11/16/2010
if the economy does improve you can be sure the conservatives will take all the credit and ratchet up the hate even more--their messaging willnever stop
06:54 PM on 11/16/2010
The Republicans have done alot for jobs. Their constituency is getting paid more than ever and they're earning bigger and bigger salaries. Their standard of living is skyrocketing and they're raking in record profits which is allowing them to buy more goods than ever.

You see, the Republicans have done alot for jobs for their constituency; the top 2% of wage earners in the population. Those people are now pulling down 24% of the money each year. They have the Republicans to thank for bringing them such a good pay day.

As far as keeping their power, well there's all those poor fools to scare to death out there. Sick Glen Beck, Sarah Palin, and Rush Limbaugh on them and they'll be back voting for the Republicans once again. You see, there's nothing to worry about...if you're in the top 2% that is.
photo
errol44
Just in town for the GOP circus
09:51 AM on 11/17/2010
Actually, your 24% is far lower than actual. In fact, as of 2,007, the top 1% had 34% of the income and controlled roughly 43% of the wealth.. That is the top 1% controlloing nearly half the wealth and taking over 1/3 of the income.

http://sociology.ucsc.edu/whorulesamerica/power/wealth.html
photo
sandyinalabama
Prejudices are what fools use for reason.
03:11 PM on 11/16/2010
~ People don't drink the sand because they're thirsty. They drink the sand because they don't know the difference.~
President Andrew Shepherd
photo
sandyinalabama
Prejudices are what fools use for reason.
03:09 PM on 11/16/2010
Sydney Ellen Wade: How do you have patience for people who claim they love America, but clearly can't stand Americans?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DarianSentient
Omnium Bonum Est
02:09 AM on 11/17/2010
I suppose because the IDEA of America, the idea that anyone can become anything with the right combination of support and determination and luck, is so honorable that many of the Americans one meets in the course of one's life are simply unworthy of it. There are many people in this country I personally have reason to dislike, but that is no reflection whatsoever on what America has the potential to be... it is that potential that I love, and the people who would seek to deny others a shot at experiencing that potential are the ones I can't stand.
01:09 AM on 11/22/2010
EXACTLEY,,Our forefather's risked their lives, that" ALL" could enjoy the freedom to express ones potential, talk about tuning in the grave! To deny someone of their potential, is a true sign of weakness,it saddens me to belong to a great GOD built country, to appear to be so weak as to certian insecurities, that does not allow us as a great country to continue to be the melting pot that we were founded on,GOD have mercy on us all!
12:43 AM on 11/22/2010
well put!! People are watching americans ,,They call us PIGS! What we have in our trash cans in one day would feed a 3rd world village for a month!!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christopher Hull
Democratic Socialist
03:09 PM on 11/16/2010
Great article but the Dems don't seem to care too much about jobs either.
Obama could have rightly called for a WPA type jobs program the states affected by Katrina and the BP disaster. Using an argument that said, "Once and for all we will repair, rebuild and restore." It would even have made good TV. Only he didn't do that. He told us the oil spill wasn't that bad and to trust the banks to fix the economy.
Economics isn't magic. You can't just take your hands off the rudder and get surprised when your ship runs aground.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
onlinesavant
03:03 PM on 11/16/2010
I think that in the end, their "hatred" has a more insidious, yet understandable foundation to it. The reason that these people are "conservatives" (Nee, regressives who yearn for an idyllic time which never really existed, and most assuredly was not "idyllic" for minorites, or gays, or to a lesser extent, women.)is that essentially, they find 'change" abhorent. They see the writing on the wall, and in the back of their mind's they know that there is very little that they can do to hold back "change" or in actuality, progress.The racial element of this mindset is constituted as the erosion of white male hegemony over the institutional power structure(s) that run this country (Even though the President's election is the ultimate indicator of this occurence, the substance is not as rapidly revealing as they perceive it to be. The vast majority of corporate CEO's are still white males.). Additionaly, the burgeoning gay right's movement, and women's ascendancy into the aforementioned upper echelon's of institutional power, signal the very element that those of the regressive mindset have been literally fighting against since the Civil War. Sadly for them, the changes are inevitable, and instead of finding happiness in America actually moving toward fullfilling the ideals with which it is supposedly built upon, the revelatory angst that these people exhibit merely slows the inevitably. "Patriots" indeed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DarianSentient
Omnium Bonum Est
02:16 AM on 11/17/2010
This white male agrees with you wholeheartedly. I think many of the people afraid of change see life as a zero-sum game; that as opportunity becomes available to more people, somehow there is less opportunity available to themselves. I've found the opposite to be true: as more and more people are able to achieve success in this society, this society becomes a stronger, more optimistic place... which in turn enables more people to realize even greater successes, even the ones whom were pretty successful before. Most importantly, it is giving a damn about your fellow man that enables your fellow man to give a damn about you. I would think even ultraconservatives could see the personal profit in that sentiment.
06:41 AM on 11/18/2010
I'm also a white male who completely agrees with you. But you're being far too kind. It's not just that Righties have an uncomfortable, abstract fear of change. They also affirmatively hate all Blacks (except Republicans), women who aren't submissive (except Neo-Cons), and anyone who disagrees with them on anything (such as gays, as to homosexuality being morally neutral; Jews, Muslims and freethinkers, as to Christianity; foreigners, immigrants and folks who travel abroad, as to America's place in human history; and all scientists and everyone else who thinks independently, critically or [frankly] at all). They're motivated exclusively by greed (lower taxes for them is the only goal of every policy the espouse) and characterized by anger and willful ignorance (seeing anyone formally educated who disagrees with them as an elitist and an enemy).

Based on how I vote, I'm a twenty-something biracial lesbian immigrant union member. Few Neo-Cons and Tea Partiers seem to know anyone in any of those categories. You and I and DarianSentient agree: they live in a dream world. The Buddha taught that to reach nirvana, one must overcome greed, anger and ignorance--yet these are the very qualities that define today's Republican Party.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
noaxe397
02:26 PM on 11/16/2010
Translation:   We have a black president.
 
 
And, if the job situation improves the GOP WILL get the credit for it.   Clearly, sir, you are unable to think like a Republican, and until progressives start to think like Republicans they will never be able to defeat them (when I say "think like" I do not mean emulate, but understand.)
 
The GOP will take the credit by saying they blocked Obama's "socialist, marxist, .....ist, .....ist. ........ist   programs and that allowed the power of the free markets to work their magic.
 
 
And the GOP gets a two-fer because if the economy tanks further they can blame the Reid-Obama agenda.
 
sir, here is your first lesson in understand the conservative mind:   the conservative mind is perfectly comfortable holding two completely opposite  ideas at the same time and believe in both of them equally.
02:51 PM on 11/16/2010
Makes me glad to be a dirty commie hippie fascist marxist socialist liberal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DarianSentient
Omnium Bonum Est
02:21 AM on 11/17/2010
Indeed... it's almost like they've had a lifetime of training in believing in a fabricated, exclusive Truth that unerringly favors themselves, regardless of what reality may otherwise indicate... and yet they're still able to profit from (and take credit for) reality when events turn in their favor.

...And I apologise in advance for the extremely vague religion metaphor. But now that you know what I was going for... it makes a depressing sort of sense, doesn't it? :P
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
peteb91
02:26 PM on 11/16/2010
Democrats are frauds, more war, more torture, Gitmo, big bailouts, more domestic wire taping, same as the Republicans. I worked, donated and contributed to the super majority just to have the same business as usual. President Obama and the rest of the Democratic party have lost me for good, I'm voting Green or any independent running, the 2 party system is a failure.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Christopher Hull
Democratic Socialist
03:03 PM on 11/16/2010
Happy to be your first fan!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Randolph Greer
I am a Poet .
02:30 AM on 11/17/2010
Amen ! I'm happy to be your second . You may have beaten me here this time Christopher but I'm gonna beat you next time .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rick Scheuer
Techincal writer, architectural specifier
04:42 PM on 11/16/2010
THe false equivalency you parrot doesn't wash. If you sat on your vote this election with that nonsense, then shame on you.
You thought you saw a whole lotta gridlock before, wait till you get a load of the new congress.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DarianSentient
Omnium Bonum Est
02:28 AM on 11/17/2010
Yeah, kinda agreed... while both parties are undeniably corrupt, at least the Dems give some kind of indication that they give a damn about their fellow man, even if they ARE hopelessly inept at finding ways to actually help him. The GOPs seem to believe manifest destiny works on a social scale, too... and the fact that they can legislate that kind of thing EFFECTIVELY is what worries me.

I'm hopeful that a viable not-Dem-or-GOP candidate for ANYTHING run for office somewhere I can vote for them... I may even attempt to do so myself in a few years. I think rationality, integrity and not-taking-campaing-contributions-at-ALL would be interesting virtues upon which to run... and I think anyone who made a demonstrably honest attempt to do so would have my vote on general principle.

http://www.wasabisoft.net/2009/02/18/integrity-covers-rock/
02:17 PM on 11/16/2010
It seems to me that, for the moment at least, it is perceived that the Republicans, as a result of their "overwhelming" victory in the last election, are now running the show.

If they continue to not care about improving the employment outlook, it may be their turn in 2012 to take the "it's the economy, stupid" blame, and their two years of guaranteed gridlock starting next year will have been for nothing but the ongoing ruination of the nation.

Maybe deep down inside, they figure they're not hated enough yet.
01:36 PM on 11/16/2010
I suppose there's an argument that the pendulum swings both ways regarding the "sincerity" of either party. But as you've made clear in your writing, the time is "now" and the Republicans are already campaigning against jobs. They have Americans scared that increasing taxes on the top tier will cause these "missing in action for 10 years" job creators to take their toys and go home to the Summer Mansion and tuck away their record profits. No jobs for you "bad" Americans! You increased my tax bill by 3% on the marginal income above $250,000!!! How dare you, bad Americans!! I'm still waiting to hear one Republican explain why job growth was anemic during the Bush era and ultimately we declined in manufacturing and put millions of Americans out of work WITH those magical, job-creatin' tax cuts for the top 2%. I can understand how Middle Class tax cuts work, it's that "common sense" that the dollars are spent and that keeps people employed. But in all my years, I have never seen tax cuts create a single job, pay for a single war or build a single school or highway..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Appleblossom
05:24 PM on 11/16/2010
Their excuse is that things were just fine before the Democrats took over Congress.
03:24 AM on 11/22/2010
YEAH Brother! It's nice to air our opinion, I would say feelings or bare my emotions, but, that would make me a humunitarian or maybe someone who cares about this beautiful country we all live in,the only reason there is no jobs; someone is making their fortune and it is not down here in, RealLand,Back in the early 60's the government had the blacks killing the blacks,turning the country against each other,hippies were trash and christians were used to beat that freedom down!
Our government always finds a way to turn us on each other,while they devour our pathetic lives! Keep-Up It's amazing ,if more americans would do that ,there would'nt be so many absorbed ,winkeled butts still sitting in Government chairs ,professing to be for the people! We are like beggers, instead of the elet that we are ,take away the people and they are nothing! hey make decisions without our permission, when caca-dodoo hits the fan ,both parties fight to have us fight with them,,What was Vietnam about,the watts riot,?Cuba?And who really shot Kennedy! I have to be honest, I think it was masterminded by his own brother,forget the name ,he was a republi-cain! HUMMM! funny how the past is to be forgotten and forgave ,but, sits in our future,We the People pay for awhole lot more then our," Nowfather's" are willing to give up! Picture, Paul Revere riding thur our towns,Yelling, "You've been sold out"so your government can party!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BobHiggins
Living on the brink of was.
01:01 PM on 11/16/2010
Long unemployment lines are a sight that warms hearts in the breasts of republicans and capitalists everywhere. The longer the lines the cheaper they can buy labor and the more profit goes in their pockets.

There will be no jobs program legislated in the next congress. There will be major, well financed moves against health care, against Medicare and against the minimum wage. Taxes will be cut on the top two percent of the pigs in the front of the line at the public trough and social security will come under withering fire.

The next congress will attempt to put the final stake in the heart of the new deal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rick Scheuer
Techincal writer, architectural specifier
04:46 PM on 11/16/2010
And now they'll push to disassemble even more of the hard-fought safety nets, social security, unemployment zero job creation (people don't understand that the middle class is an ahboration in a capitalist society, carved from the guilded rich back in the 20 century, they've been clawing it back one 'deregulation' givaway at a time ever since) - this time in the guise of 'deficit hawking.'
No we as a country cannot affort its citizens anymore.