iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert L. Cavnar

GET UPDATES FROM Robert L. Cavnar
 

Mitt Romney's Defense Simply Not Credible

Posted: 07/15/2012 7:56 pm

As I watched Mitt Romney bomb the networks on Friday, steadfastly sticking to his story that he had nothing whatsoever to do with Bain Capital after February 1999, even though he was listed as the firm's Chief Executive Officer, President, and Managing Director well into 2002, I was reminded of the lame defense put up by Jeff Skilling, the now imprisoned CEO of Enron, claiming he knew nothing of the activities of Andrew Fastow, his CFO, in dozens of off balance sheet transactions, asset shuffling, and mark-to-market scandals that drove the company off a cliff in 2001, at that time the largest bankruptcy in US history. What made Skilling's story unbelievable was that he was well known as a brilliant micro-manager. Ultimately, the jury didn't buy his excuses. The Enron collapse seems like ages ago, especially after it has been so totally overshadowed by the gargantuan financial failures of the last 5 years.

What makes Romney's story also so completely unbelievable is that he claims that when he was off running the Salt Lake City Olympics during those 3 years, he apparently was just signing whatever SEC disclosure document that was put in front of him, not exercising his fiduciary and managerial responsibilities as CEO of Bain. So, either Romney is not telling the truth, or, his actions were so reckless as to disqualify him from the office of President of the United States. I can tell you from my personal experience as a CEO who has run both private and public companies, you don't just sign whatever's put in front of you, especially with the additional scrutiny to which all CEOs are subject since the Enron collapse. Further evidence that Romney is not telling the truth or that he is unbelievably reckless is that during the very period he signed some of those documents without managerial review was the very time that the Enron scandal was unfolding. I can assure you that no executive during that period of time was signing anything that he/she wasn't absolutely sure was correct and accurate. Even today, responsible CEOs do everything they can do to assure that the documents they sign are true and accurate.

It's time for Romney to come clean about the entire Bain story, especially since he uses his experience at Bain as his primary qualification to be President of the United States. I remain unconvinced that the current story line is true, especially in the context of that particular time in US history when all executives' awareness of their actions was so acute. Until Romney tells the entire story, the American people are being denied the very information they need to exercise their most important right.

The right to vote.

 
 
 

Follow Robert L. Cavnar on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dailyhurricane

FOLLOW POLITICS
As I watched Mitt Romney bomb the networks on Friday, steadfastly sticking to his story that he had nothing whatsoever to do with Bain Capital after February 1999, even though he was listed as the fir...
As I watched Mitt Romney bomb the networks on Friday, steadfastly sticking to his story that he had nothing whatsoever to do with Bain Capital after February 1999, even though he was listed as the fir...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 96
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
winds7seas
08:59 AM on 07/17/2012
I believe it's all over now for Romney. That was a fast campaign.
12:21 AM on 07/17/2012
America needs Newt
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
martymartymarty
red gold and green, red gold and green
08:30 PM on 07/16/2012
"So, either Romney is not telling the truth, or, his actions were so reckless as to disqualify him from the office of President of the United States."

Exactly.

Like the Enron comparison, too -- quite appropriate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
openmissoula
Now Kiko's spirit will live in the happy frog!
03:49 PM on 07/16/2012
Whatever happened to the, "The buck stops here," motto? Is this how Gov. Romney shows personal responsibility? He keeps all the profit from wrecked jobs and pensions while appearing as the sole owner in the paperwork, but then he avoids the consequences of his actions for working families?

The GOP is supposed to the be the party of personal responsibility. Gov. Romney apparently doesn't believe in personal responsibility for entitled rich kids who can't bear to accept the bitter with the sweet.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
openmissoula
Now Kiko's spirit will live in the happy frog!
03:43 PM on 07/16/2012
Gov. Romney behaves like an entitled, self-centered, spoiled child who thinks rules should only apply to others.

He already released his tax returns to Sen. McCain during the last election cycle. Why shouldn't voters --- esp. those who work for a paycheck --- see what Sen. McCain has already seen? Gov. Romney is campaigning as a business man who can create (rather than just outsource) jobs. But he doesn't expect to release his business records to voters? That's unacceptable.

Gov. Romney should release his tax returns to voters immediately!
photo
MED1025
Here to save the day
11:57 AM on 07/16/2012
Listen to what he said carefully. He said he "didn't recall" going to meetings or attending them via telephone etc. He's lying and he knows it. He just wants to create plausible deniability.
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
10:32 AM on 07/16/2012
Taking Robme on his words - he is extremely financially astute! He is a Harvard MBA (So was W! - so much for Harvard). Do you really believe someone like Mittens does not know where every penny of his money is at any given time? That just does not fit the obsessive compulsive personality. Further, it is hard to believe that someone of Mitts controlling personality would just sign off on anything! And if he did, he is reckelss and has breeched his fiduciarhy duty. Also, did he lie to be govenor of Mass? Or is is lying to be President? When he was interviewed on TV he wore a smirk the entire time - - like" I'm so smart and you're so stupid, how dare you question me!"The RNC needs to apoloize to Kerry!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
legitane
Mankind's biggest sin, Ignorance
09:11 AM on 07/16/2012
He has convinced as many people on his taxes as he did in 30 months in Paris...
Less than 25... ha ha
photo
demisfine
Often correct, NEVER right.
09:03 AM on 07/16/2012
"So, either Romney is not telling the truth, or, his actions were so reckless as to disqualify him from the office of President of the United States. I can tell you from my personal experience as a CEO who has run both private and public companies, you don't just sign whatever's put in front of you, especially with the additional scrutiny to which all CEOs are subject since the Enron collapse. Further evidence that Romney is not telling the truth or that he is unbelievably reckless is that during the very period he signed some of those documents without managerial review was the very time that the Enron scandal was unfolding. I can assure you that no executive during that period of time was signing anything that he/she wasn't absolutely sure was correct and accurate."
EXACTLY!!!!
photo
gochenaur8
who said that, I said that
09:02 AM on 07/16/2012
I for one, feel that this is the best story that has come out about the whole issue. Very well written and even without facts, had examples to compare to. Mr. Cavnar has since been deleated from Romney's Christmas card list.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CountingCoup
08:07 AM on 07/16/2012
Mittens constant lies prior to the Bain fiasco lost him credit long ago. Bain is simply sealing the deal ~
08:06 AM on 07/16/2012
"you don't just sign whatever's put in front of you"

No, I think that's *exactly* what the Republicans expect out of Romney if he's elected.
photo
demisfine
Often correct, NEVER right.
09:03 AM on 07/16/2012
Norquist is banking on just that.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rosalee Harris
07:54 AM on 07/16/2012
"What makes Romney's story also so completely unbelievable is that he claims that when he was off running the Salt Lake City Olympics during those 3 years, he apparently was just signing whatever SEC disclosure document that was put in front of him, not exercising his fiduciary and managerial responsibilities as CEO of Bain. So, either Romney is not telling the truth, or, his actions were so reckless as to disqualify him from the office of President of the United States"

Thank you for saying this. This is what I have been saying since this story came out but not half as eloquently as this. Either way its bad for Mitt. How can you allow yourself to be responsible for decisions others are making in your name without knowing what those decisions were or being involved. How can you even consider trusting someone like that in the office of the Presidency. Why would he think that saying he had nothing to do with Bain after 1999 while being listed as CEO was the smart move for someone running to be CEO of the country. This is a guy that keeps crticizing Obama as in over his head and not have the needed experience yet he does something like this.
photo
Inkosi
The gods themselves rage against stupidity
10:35 AM on 07/16/2012
His signature appears on a legal, official document - and SEC document. So he lied to the SEC? No matter how you spin this, it is a lie. I always thought that lying on an official document was a crime! (unless your Mit Robme, I guess)
07:26 AM on 07/16/2012
It really is funny to see liberals parrot this story even though liberal news sources find it to not be factual. The PBO campaign says it and you repeat it. You don't check it out. You don't ask questions. You just repeat with blind faith even though PBO and his campaign have lied to you over and over.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Scribe57
It would take too long to explain.
08:03 AM on 07/16/2012
Here's a question: How can someone be the CEO and sole stockholder of a company, and yet bear no responsibility for what the company does?
photo
adabar
The future is bright...
08:57 AM on 07/16/2012
Even in the face of hard evidence, you are still in denial... Not surprised that you are backing Mitt Romney as he is a bold face liar! The radioactive candidate! Never in my lifetime have I being aware of a public figure who lied about so many different things... Sad!
http://politicalgates.blogspot.co.uk/2012/07/read-sec-reports-which-could-be-mitt.html
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mjune
07:04 AM on 07/16/2012
I think some people believe that they can make up their own "truths," and if enough people believe them, it turns them into a solid base for the future. I doubt the former governor even knows the actual, fact-based real-life truth, himself.