iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Naiman

Robert Naiman

Posted: June 3, 2010 08:59 AM

Denis Halliday Urges Irish-Americans to Defend the Rachel Corrie

What's Your Reaction:

Former UN Assistant Secretary General Denis Halliday said it was imperative that the Obama administration support Ireland's call on the Israeli authorities to ensure safe passage for the Irish-flagged Rachel Corrie to carry humanitarian aid to Gaza, the Irish Times reports. Speaking by satellite phone from on board the Rachel Corrie, Halliday called on Irish-Americans to lobby the Obama administration: "We also feel there is a role for the Irish diaspora here, in the U.S. and elsewhere to lobby politicians over this continued illegal blockade of Gaza, which is causing such hardship to the Palestinian people."

Halliday has some experience with this issue, having resigned from his position as UN Humanitarian Coordinator in Iraq in 1998 over the impact of UN/U.S. sanctions on Iraqi civilians.

The issue of the Gaza blockade has tremendous resonance in Ireland, partly because of Ireland's high degree of engagement in international humanitarian causes -- John Ging, head of the UN Relief and Works Agency in Gaza, who had called on the international community to break the siege by sending ships loaded with aid, is also Irish -- but also, of course, because the Irish people have some experience with the consequences for civilians of a colonial blockade.

Between 1845 and 1850, more than a million Irish people starved to death under British rule while, as Sinead O'Connor famously noted, food was shipped out of Ireland under armed guard. A million more fled Ireland to escape starvation, many to America, including Falmouth Kearney, President Obama's great-great-great grandfather.

Many Irish people -- and Irish-Americans -- take the responsibilities of this legacy very seriously.

Mary Robinson, former President of Ireland and former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, has said:

The best possible commemoration of the men and women who died in that Famine, who were cast up on other shores because of it, is to take their dispossession into the present with us, to help others who now suffer in a similar way.

That's what Halliday is trying to do. Doesn't he deserve all our support?

UPDATE:: Francis Boyle, Professor of International Law at the University of Illinois [also Irish-American] writes:

We could act to deter an Israeli attack upon MV Rachel Corrie by invoking International Criminal Court Prosecution. According to the ICC Rome Statute, Article 12 (2) provides "2. In the case of article 13, paragraph (a) or (c), the Court may exercise its jurisdiction if one or more of the following States are Parties to this Statute or have accepted the jurisdiction of the Court in accordance with paragraph 3: (a) The State on the territory of which the conduct in question occurred or, if the crime was committed on board a vessel or aircraft, the State of registration of that vessel or aircraft; ... " If one of the vessel is Irish vessel and the attack was committed against the vessel, the ICC may exercise its jurisdiction over this situation since the Ireland is a State Party to the ICC Statute. Israel's attack may constitute a crime against humanity of murder, imprisonment, torture and other inhumane acts under Article 7 of the ICC Statute.

Ireland is a party to the Rome Statute. Hence if Israel were to attack the MV Rachel Corrie, the highest level Israeli officials could be prosecuted for the attack. If we got this word out internationally, it might do some good.


 

Follow Robert Naiman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/naiman

Former UN Assistant Secretary General Denis Halliday said it was imperative that the Obama administration support Ireland's call on the Israeli authorities to ensure safe passage for the Irish-flagged...
Former UN Assistant Secretary General Denis Halliday said it was imperative that the Obama administration support Ireland's call on the Israeli authorities to ensure safe passage for the Irish-flagged...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 119
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
tnkeating
Dyslexic agnostic insomniac
11:13 AM on 06/15/2010
AS long as you guys are not shipping weapons or material that can be used as weapons, you shopuld have no problem getting your supplies to Gaza. Just pull over for inspection when you get the call. I suppose you would think that when Kennedy (another great Irishmen) blockaded Cuba in the sixties, that that was illegal too.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
slogward
10:24 AM on 06/04/2010
Over here in the UK, we remember the last time Irish Americans were 'called upon to support freedom fighters'. They were called the IRA, and they used precisely the same tactics of maudlin propaganda, half-truth and demonisation of Britain as Hamas fellow-travellers are now using against Israel.

Funny how after 9/11, contributions to IRA terrorism from the US dried up overnight.

Listen up Irish Americans: the UK is by far your best ally in Europe, and Israel is by far your best ally in the Middle East.

Don't be duped again. Your actions are suppporting those who danced in the streets at the sight of people jumping off the twin towers.

http://nbyslog.blogspot.com/2010/06/geopolitics-of-religion-time-for-eu-to.html
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
RobertNaiman
Policy Director at Just Foreign Policy
12:42 PM on 06/04/2010
Can I hire you to follow me around, insulting, on behalf of my adversaries, people whom I'm trying to recruit to my side? How much would you charge for this service?
06:18 AM on 06/04/2010
I am with Denis Halliday . . I do hope the Irish will send an escort ship . . . and America should follow Professor Boyle's advice . . . the one thing I fear Robert is that our politicians are too craven to defend the Rachel Corrie . . .

if they are too craven . . hopefully the UN will finally stand up to the US and say we are dealing with israel . . .deal with your oil spill . . . we've had enough of your hypocrisy
photo
tnkeating
Dyslexic agnostic insomniac
11:21 AM on 06/15/2010
lets hope they do just that. Then we can pull our finacial support and they can get the hell out of our country.
06:08 AM on 06/04/2010
"The State on the territory of which the conduct in question occurred or, if the crime was committed on board a vessel or aircraft, the State of registration of that vessel or aircraft; ... " If one of the vessel is Irish vessel and the attack was committed against the vessel, the ICC may exercise its jurisdiction over this situation since the Ireland is a State Party to the ICC Statute. Israel's attack may constitute a crime against humanity of murder, imprisonment, torture and other inhumane acts under Article 7 of the ICC Statute."

Ehhh, the Rachel Corrie is Cambodian-registered.
http://bit.ly/bl0qU2
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
RobertNaiman
Policy Director at Just Foreign Policy
09:03 AM on 06/04/2010
The Rachel-Corrie is Cambodian-registered. But 1) It's Irish-owned and 2) It's Irish-flagged and 3) Cambodia is also a State Party to the ICC Statute. (Turkey is not.)

So, I don't think the registration undermines Professor Boyle's underlying point: Israel would be exposed to ICC prosecution if it attacks the Rachel Corrie.
12:57 AM on 06/04/2010
How many ships from around the world, filled with nothing but food, supplies, and good intentions, will Israel massacre before the world acts decisively against them? They are already flagrantly violating the Geneva Convention with the horror that is the settlements, and the suffering, poverty, and terror that they inspire. When will the US have the guts to stop vetoing the resolutions against Israel that virtually the rest of the world supports. We could finally FORCE them to behave through sanctions, embargoes, and diplomatic censure.
06:21 AM on 06/04/2010
well said Justtellthetruth . . . sanctions, trade embargoes, et al must be put in place against israel and our government must pull the plug no more money no more arms .... even the fence sitters now know what israel is . . .
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:19 PM on 06/03/2010
If the US could ensure safe passage that would be amazing
08:37 PM on 06/03/2010
Try reading up on the San Remo Manual on blockades. It makes for enlightening reading and blows your cited arguments clean out of the water (pun intended).

In addition, as the direct descendant of Irish immigrants, I resent your associating the Famine with Gaza. There were no international aid organization in Ireland and massive starvation was the result. The citizens in Gaza are poor, but millions are not starving. Show me a single UN report that indicates mass starvation is occurring in Gaza

Finally, the Irish showed a good deal more practicality than the Gazans. They took the counties they could, when they could. The did not wait for the Northern Counties to be obtained.

Your comparisons, are pathetic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:18 PM on 06/03/2010
and the Irish prosecuted a relentless resistance. A good inspiration for the Palestinians
10:20 PM on 06/03/2010
I agree. Provided they pay attention to that Northern Ireland part.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MSGH
12:09 AM on 06/04/2010
As the direct descendant of Irish immigrants & and Irish/US dual citizen, I think the comparisons are well-founded.
07:45 PM on 06/03/2010
This vision of the barbarous Irish by the English, was largely born out of a form of imperialist condescension, made its way into Laudabiliter, one of the most infamous documents in all of Irish history, by which Adrian IV, the only English Pope, granted Ireland to Henry II, "...to the end that the foul customs of that country may be abolished and the barbarous nation, Christian in name only, may through your care assume the beauty of good morals."

All and every method was to be used in this 'civilizing mission' over time. In 1305 when Piers Bermingham cut off the heads of thirty members of the O'Connor clan and sent them to Dublin he was awarded with a financial bonus. His action was also celebrated in verse. In 1317 one Irish chronicler was of the view that it was just as easy for an Englishman to kill an Irishman as he would a dog
06:52 PM on 06/03/2010
the international law professor should learn that only countries who accept the ICC are subject to prosecutions and not country would actually arrest anyone
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lozange
Aiming around wondrously
06:28 PM on 06/03/2010
Many of those Irish from the 1800s famine landed with us in Quebec. I'm sure our part of North America would support the Irish initiative. There's no call for deliberately starving any people, race, denomination in the 21 st century. Israel wants to barbarize the world.
10:29 PM on 06/03/2010
well that's good, because nobody is starving in gaza.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
11:16 PM on 06/03/2010
That's just ignorant. You need to stop drinking the Hasbara Kool-Aid immediately. Just put it DOWN.
05:47 AM on 06/04/2010
Right. And the feckless Irish just didn't work hard enough.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KriTiKiT
Says"play nice"
05:50 PM on 06/03/2010
I think Israel is about to meet it's match, DON"T MESS WITH IRISH SAILORS... Americans like the Irish better anyway
06:18 PM on 06/03/2010
I agree. If something bad happens on the Rachel Corrie, expect the dual citizenship thing in the USA and the "zero distance between USA and Israel policies" mantra to evaporate. We have a LOT of Isish Americans in the USA. And as for Ireland, these folks can hold a grudge longer than an Israeli.
06:46 PM on 06/03/2010
Sorry for the typo. I meant Irish Americans (but you knew that, right?).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
11:17 PM on 06/03/2010
HAHA. So true about the grudge part! I've got a hard time with that, half Irish, half Italian... its' big trouble!
06:21 AM on 06/04/2010
fingers crossed KriTiKit . . fingers crossed . . we love love the Irish more
photo
Vlady
Better Late
02:12 PM on 06/03/2010
U.S. Vice President Joe Biden defended Israel's handling of the raid on a Gaza aid flotilla, departing from the Obama administration's approach. Biden said Israel has an "absolute right" to defend its security interests
03:09 PM on 06/03/2010
...unlike the passengers of the flotilla, apparently.
10:29 PM on 06/03/2010
sorry pal, but under international law, breaking a blockade (or having the intent to do so) is an act of aggression
06:19 PM on 06/03/2010
Biden is deluded.
01:24 PM on 06/03/2010
I don't think that there's a fair analogy between the Israeli blockade of Gaza and the British control of Irish ports during the '40's famine. While parliament's failure to close the ports of Ireland exacerbated the problem, this was not a blockade nor a forced exportation of goods. Irish tenant farmers were forced to sell all of their goods and live on the potato to pay rents to their landlords. This state of affairs was the result of centuries of bad land policy and disenfranchisement of the vast majority of the population due to the penal laws. Britain was Ireland's main trading partner, and this is why the goods wound up leaving Ireland for Britain.

Nevertheless, there are many similarities between the Irish and Palestinian plights, so many that the Irish indeed make a natural champion for the Palestinians. Both people have been subjected to terrible land policy, disenfranchisement, generational poverty, lack of access to education, partitioning of their country and manipulation by clerics and political figures with their own agendas. Both have been led by groups deemed terrorist organizations. The ethnic Irish in the North were the victims of gerrymandering, disenfranchisement, discriminatory housing and labor practices, road blocks and harassment by police and military.

Look at the Irish now. They are a testament to the doctrine that if given the opportunity to live as humans, to be employed and have a house and food and not be harassed on a daily basis, they will choose to live in peace.
11:08 AM on 06/03/2010
To "ConstitutionCrusader" who said "let's see if that gets by the censors!"...

Umm, *what* censors?! Israel is a democracy with free press and so forth -- from the free dialogue we have about the incident you can see Israel and this site is not censoring ANYTHING. You know where people do not have the freedom to speak their mind, where women are forcibly kept in the home, under lock/key/veil? That's right places like Hamas-controlled Gaza... If you look at the West Bank under more liberal Fatah, you'll see people have more freedoms. Part of the reason Gaza is under war-like conditions is because Hamas rules with an iron fist... THEY are the ones you should be worrying about being "censored" by... not Huffington Post or Israel.

Keep patting yourself on the back for your brave run at the "censors"! You should get a bravery medal like the knife wielding "Peace Activists" are getting in the Arab World.
03:17 PM on 06/03/2010
It's an open secret that HuffPo moderators have a tendency overall to junk comments critical of certain sacred cows - Israel being one of them. Not saying all moderators, nor all the time, but there is that tendency.

And... so, this Gaza place, nasty and brutish is it? Well - obviously that makes it alright to blockade it and make it even nastier, doesn't it?

Also, if indeed "knifes were wielded" against an armed trained combat soldier illegally boarding your ship and shooting your fellow passengers, and this is somehow cowardly, what does that make the politicians who sent the helicopters full of armed soldiers? Brave, no?
06:40 PM on 06/03/2010
Exactly. Well put.

In a similar vein, the idea that Rahm Emmanuel (the person that was THERE while this raid was planned who is Obama's mouth piece) urged restraint is laughable. Rahm doesn't do "restraint".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConstitutionCrusader
10:49 AM on 06/03/2010
Irish-Americans have a tradition of engagement with our history and our cultural narrative. Who better to help the world learn from the mistakes of the past than a people who has "lived through it" so to speak. As Halliday said, how would the world react if they cordoned off 1.5 million people in Northern Ireland? The fact is, the only reason this is tolerated and in some cases, condoned, is because of Anti- Arab sentiment. There is no question in my mind that much of what underpins the acceptance of this illegal blockade and its horrific effects upon the citizens of Gaza is the desire to exterminate and punish an arab population. Let's see if THAT gets by the censors!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:08 PM on 06/03/2010
I have frequently thought the same. When Israel decimates Gaza in retaliation for rocket fire I ask what if the British had reacted the same way when the IRA bombed Warrington or Canary Wharf? Would the world have stood by while Britain did to Dublin children what the Israelis did to Gazan children. We all know the answer to that one.
http://www.google.ie/images?q=gaza%20dead%20children&um=1&ie=UTF-8&source=og&sa=N&hl=en&tab=wi
06:30 PM on 06/03/2010
During the "Troubles" of 1969-1990 most members of the IRA and related militants were, like their Unionist counterparts, British citizens so Britain attacking Dublin was not an issue. What did happen – somewhat like Israel - was walling off sections of Belfast along sectarian lines to keep the factions apart. Due to government policy of years of benign neglect, some areas were ghetto-like, but this applied to both sides.
10:34 PM on 06/03/2010
Yea, but at the same time if the British had withdrawn from Northern Ireland, the PIRA wouldn't have responded by escalating their terrorist attacks, which is exactly what hamas did.

And if the PIRA had taken control of the government of the Republic of Ireland, the British government would have declared full scale war.
02:52 AM on 06/04/2010
Apologies for interrupting the self-congratulations society, but when trumpeting Ireland's contributions to freedom over the centuries, some perspective is in order. Pre-1860 famine Irish immigrants proved to be not exactly abolitionists when it came to slavery. They may be forgiven, given their own circumstances (i.e. free blacks would have been job competition in their land of refuge).

And when presented with the most clear-cut moral issue of the 2oth century, independent Ireland went dark. It chose to sit out all of WWII. That "neutrality" continued even after U.S. entry and the war against the worst tyranny western Europe had ever seen had long-ceased to be arguably some "English war" patriotic Irish could not bring themselves to back.

No one would have expected 50 divisions from Ireland; but even Latin American countries broke diplomatic ties. Yet Dublin, following diplomatic convention to the point of absurd, as a "neutral" offered Nazi Germany condolences upon the reported death of its head of state - with the end of the war days away and when contriving an excuse not to do so would not have been difficult. What a slap in the face to all the Irishmen who CHOSE to go abroad and join the fight against Nazism.

Also, despite the ongoing tensions, no one in Northern Ireland has been firing (London-supplied) missiles towards Dublin whenever it suits, or dispatching suicide bombers into County Louth to try blow up people in pubs.
03:25 AM on 06/04/2010
Lessons Learned! Should we in the 21st century allow this kind of shiit to happen again to other people because it happen before?
06:04 AM on 06/04/2010
So: starving immigrants arriving on coffin ships were not full of the milk of human kindness when it came to competitors for jobs? So what? I don't blame the Jews for wanting to found Israel after the holocaust, even though there was an injustice to the other people who were living there.

Participation in WWII was not "clear cut": Britain had been burning down city centres, and unleashing irregulars to in terrorise civilians in Ireland 20 years prior to that - i.e. well within living memory. I'm more than a little bit fed up with that canard being thrown in our faces - Britain's participation in WWII didn't stop the early _Israeli's_ treating them as the enemy in '48, did it?

I had Irish-American relatives fight in WWII, there was no "slap in the face" given or perceived. The problem with this line in Ireland, is that it is usually used by people who basically want to harangue us about not being pro-British enough.

BTW, there actually were two German bombing raids on Ireland - as a warning because it was selling the British food supplies. There were also a couple of "British Loyalist" bombings, that the the dogs in the street know were carried out with British Military Intelligence connivance.