More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robert Redford

Robert Redford

GET UPDATES FROM Robert Redford
 

As Companies Gather for Shareholder Meetings, Opposition to Bristol Bay Mine Mounts

Posted: 04/21/11 09:24 AM ET

I'm not against mining. I am against putting mega-mines where they don't belong. Near my home in Utah, Rio Tinto's massive Bingham Canyon Mine is one of the biggest man-made excavations on Earth and has rendered a large area of local groundwater too polluted for human consumption.

2011-04-21-binghamMine_color_500px.jpg


Now, the Rio Tinto and Anglo American companies want to put a mine even bigger than Bingham at the headwaters of our planet's greatest wild salmon river systems in Bristol Bay, Alaska. It's an environmental tragedy waiting to happen.

Their Pebble Mine would be gouged out of an American paradise -- filled with salmon, bears, moose, caribou, wolves and whales -- that has sustained Native communities for thousands of years.

2011-04-21-bristolBAY_color_500px.jpg


Imagine a pit two miles wide by 2,000 feet deep, and an underground mine a mile deep. This gargantuan gold and copper operation would produce an estimated 10 billion tons of contaminated waste -- 3,000 pounds for every man, woman and child on Earth.

Massive earthen dams -- some taller than the Three Gorges Dam in China -- would be constructed to hold back that waste forever. Now imagine all this in an active earthquake zone at the headwaters of the largest sockeye salmon runs in the world. The threat to Bristol Bay just below is unimaginable.

No wonder the Pebble Mine is opposed by nearly 80 percent of Bristol Bay residents. The growing coalition to stop this disaster-in-the-making is led by Native village corporations, associations and tribes from around Bristol Bay. They've partnered with commercial and recreational fishermen, sportsmen and conservation groups to protect the thousands of jobs and hundreds of millions of dollars that come from Bristol Bay's renewable economic engine: wild salmon.

Anglo American's history is littered with one pollution disaster after another: from Zimbabwe to Ireland to Nevada. Rio Tinto has left a trail of toxic contamination that spans the globe: from Indonesia to Bolivia to Utah. Do you trust these companies to take a catastrophic risk with one of our last and greatest wild places?

In February, the Mitsubishi Corporation did the right thing by ending its participation in this misguided venture.

Now it's time for Rio Tinto and Anglo American to do the same. Both companies are holding their annual shareholder meetings this month in London. In honor of Earth Day, click here to tell these companies that you oppose their plans to industrialize Bristol Bay.


Photo of Bingham Mine by Allen Macbean, UtahbyAir. Photo of Bristol Bay, courtesy of Robert Glenn Ketchum.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 100
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
05:43 PM on 05/04/2011
I do wonder if the Pebble Mine is really a smokescreen to detract from other mine projects that are being permitted. Kensington Mine near Juneau, Alaska is trying hard to get out of fisheries monitoring requirements even though it just began mining last year. Its new draft permit is currently out for public review with some substantial reductions in salmon and resident fish monitoring. The permit and fact sheet may be viewed on the State of Alaska Dept of Natural Resources website. Rationale for changes is given in the fact sheet including statements such as "low level of development near this stream" - true if you ignore the fact that all underground mine drainage flows into a stream and a three-storey processing mill and 200-person camp sit on the stream bank. Let's hope someone continues to monitor the salmon downstream in the three rivers nearby.
photo
librainstars
even the smallest things in life make a difference
10:02 AM on 04/24/2011
A person once said to me " This is like rape to the earth"
out of your story
quoted "Do you trust these companies to take a catastrophic risk with one of our last and greatest wild places?"
No i dont trust them not one bit.
Thank you for writing this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Diablo Canyon
Painted by Donna Polansky
06:17 PM on 04/22/2011
Robert, I'll trade you our reactor for your mine, with another mine to be named later.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RockyMissouri
'You must be carefully taught to hate'...
10:02 AM on 04/25/2011
I kind of think we are disgusting... It is the citizens who have to live with these choices.. Let's ask the people near those reactors (not affiliated with the industry!)....
zenbamboo
U.S. Marine Corps veteran
04:15 PM on 04/22/2011
When the mine has been completely exhausted and it is just left to rot, who cleans it up? Who pays for the clean up? The tax payers do. That's who. The mining companies shuffle off to their next project with a fist full of dollars and don't care about the clean up -- or the fallout.

That entire watershed will be ruined. People underestimate how fragile a fishery is, or the ecosystem built up around it. The bears around there are far larger than they are elsewhere in Alaska because the rivers are so rich with fish that are born in that lake and then go out to sea only to swim back up Bristol Bay and complete the cycle of life. San Francisco Bay was the same way 150 years ago before the gold rush. It was one of the most prolific salmon runs in the world. Strip mining did a number on the watershed that is still felt today.
01:08 AM on 04/25/2011
You have to post reclamation bonds in order to receive permitting. In the past this wasn't the case and the taxpayers ended up cleaning up old mine sites.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kye154
07:40 AM on 04/22/2011
With all the surplus metal setting around along the roadsides, in abandoned areas, and in our mountainous junkyards, why are we still mining for more metals? The Chinese and Indians recycle their metals, why don't we? It would do much to save the environment, and defray the costs of mining. It is really nuts to be mining these days.
01:10 AM on 04/25/2011
We do recycle our metals. The Chinese and Indians also are involved in mega mines with very poor environmental standards. Recycling will not meet all our demands.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RockyMissouri
'You must be carefully taught to hate'...
09:52 AM on 04/25/2011
We are essentially lazy...
07:09 AM on 04/22/2011
Thank you for having made ​​known to us, this environmental disaster.
03:33 AM on 04/22/2011
This is a tough one. I hate to see the environment ravaged. I have lived in Alaska and it is almost boundless. We do need these precious minerals for several applications. If we don't use our own resources China will. Should we feed the Dragon? By the way, China is building up its military ,for what?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RockyMissouri
'You must be carefully taught to hate'...
10:23 AM on 04/25/2011
Time to reboot...Why is your username 'nuclear war' ? In light of the recent events in Japan showing the downside..you'd think we would move past that industry- except for medical purposes, why wouldn't we develop a safer alternative.? Fracking for natural gas is out... Coal poisons the air and more.. We can do better...can't we ?... If we are truly exceptional...
12:21 AM on 04/22/2011
God Bless You, Mr. Redford for helping shed light on this issue. This area is ecologically sensitive and pristine. These are the streams that feed into Bristol Bay one of the largest salmon fisheries in the world. with all the ecological degradation and ocean pollution that is occurring when do we say somethings are worth saving???? A pile of trash larger than Texas in the Pacific, Radiation in Japan, The gulf oil spill, When will we be good stewards to OUR EARTH??
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RockyMissouri
'You must be carefully taught to hate'...
12:20 AM on 04/22/2011
Nobody needs a damned mine..What we need is our water, our soil, our air, our animals, our food, our lives..!
10:02 AM on 04/22/2011
I have forwarded this to a family member who has a fishing business in Bristol Bay which processes some absolutely awesome Salmon. She is an attorney - and a good one who protects the lives of the vulnerable. Cannot wait to hear what her take on it is and what is being done to protect the ecosystem and the Salmon.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RockyMissouri
'You must be carefully taught to hate'...
10:33 AM on 04/22/2011
Great maab! Let me know how that progresses.. These atrocities done to our land will affect us...the people who do this, have no souls. I still believe in the power of many voices, becoming one-- very powerful voice..reminds me of: E Pluribus Unum !
01:10 AM on 04/25/2011
...and live in the stone age.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RockyMissouri
'You must be carefully taught to hate'...
09:26 AM on 04/25/2011
What exactly are you talking about..?? Do you even know??
photo
bridgeman
Jesus was a Jazz fan
12:18 AM on 04/22/2011
Excellent! We need to SPEAK OUT!

BTW: "The Conspirator" was a phenomenal movie

HP'ers If you haven't seen it...go this weekend!
ecohawk
Ecohawk
11:39 PM on 04/21/2011
Robert Redford does not speak out publically unless it is for something REALLY important. This is one of those times. I joined the Natural Resources Defense Council at his request and I have seen what uncontrolled mining has done to Montana. (Visit the great city of Butte sometime. It is now a virtual ghost town). A Canadian Gold mining company is already polluting another great river, the Yellowstone. You might remembe from "A River Runs Through IT'. The run off contains arsenic and poisons the trout in the Yellowstone. Now more want to damage one of the "Last Best Places" in Alaska. This unfettered pursuit of the almighty dollar has to stop. We have to leave some small parts left for our children's children or be known as the "Greediest Generation. " Montana has an 1872 law that allows this and they pay MILLIONS to protect it. The companies are not even American and they are stealing our resources. Please do whatever your can,: write, call, email or visit your Congressman or Senators to stop this.

Joe Reichert
Ecohawk@aol.com .
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RockyMissouri
'You must be carefully taught to hate'...
09:37 AM on 04/25/2011
THIS is our inheritance from the GOPs ...... waste and ruin...and the ones who allowed it, will be
held just as responsible.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Smithn
Different strokes for different folks.
11:37 PM on 04/21/2011
Of course I sent my letter--anything for Jerimiah Johnson. 8-)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WordProcessor
I'm a Democrat living in Daryll Issa's district!
11:10 PM on 04/21/2011
I can easily live without anything that comes out of a mine. What I need to live comes out of farms.
01:11 AM on 04/25/2011
Really? If you can't grow it, you have to mine it and people use large amounts of mined material whether they realize it or not. Minerals come in varieties besides metals.
10:16 PM on 04/21/2011
Our world needs to extract raw materials to produce the goods that we all consume and make our lives better. The copper in the extension cords to your computer, the gold in the fillings in your teeth, the fuel that powers your transportation, the steel in your bicycle, etc. are all natural resources that you and I consume on a daily basis. How are we going to proceed if we do not extract these resources?

Yes, we should conserve, recycle, etc. Still natural resources must be extracted from the earth. Would you rather there be 100 mines each producing 1% of Bristol Bay? What if the mine was located in Siberia Russia, would you feel better?

Are you willing to forgo the benefits of these materials? I am not.
photo
snowballinhell
Humans have a 100% chance of extinction
10:27 PM on 04/21/2011
Are you willing to forego life for copper? Gold? Uranium? Coal? Oil? You think mining and oil extraction practices don't matter? I do.
10:43 PM on 04/21/2011
In my post point out where I say I am willing to forgo life for minerals or think extraction practices do not matter.

Are you living without copper, gold, uranium, coal, oil, etc?
01:12 AM on 04/25/2011
Since the mining practices won't kill anyone, no, I don't care about heavily regulated mining practices.
11:32 PM on 04/21/2011
Where are you "proceeding to"? There is no conservation, population, or viable national energy plan in sight. The system and agenda here is corporatism, which strictly defines itself through power and money. This is the kind of monomanical,colonizing system our forefathers had a revolution against. Whether you like it or not, you are imbedded and adorned in the natural world. We must make decsions concerning the radical extraction of heavy metals and other resource in a manner that (totally) protects the carrying capacity of our environment for our health and survival. We're not talking about extension cords. This is real life and death.
photo
snowballinhell
Humans have a 100% chance of extinction
02:15 AM on 04/25/2011
Fantastic. Thanks for posting. Agree 100 por ciento. ff
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
samtee
Shankapotomus.
09:57 PM on 04/21/2011
I saw something funny today, that Apple was the least friendly green TECH company and Al Gore was on the board of directors
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alvy5521
12:35 AM on 04/22/2011
Gee, that really has so much to do with Mr. Redford's article! You must really have a thing for Al Gore.
photo
snowballinhell
Humans have a 100% chance of extinction
02:28 AM on 04/25/2011
Would you call this misdirection? If not, what?