More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robyn Carolyn Price

GET UPDATES FROM Robyn Carolyn Price
 

Coexistence in Israel: A Tale of Two Communities

Posted: 06/10/11 03:00 PM ET

The relationship between Arabs and Jews in Israel has been strained by failed peace agreements, suicide bombings, and the construction of a separation wall, which have fostered fear and anger on both sides.

Since Israel became a state in 1948, the road to peaceful coexistence has been, as most people in the region describe it, complicated. Somewhere in the midst of the conflict, however, are two communities -- one Arab and one Jewish -- that for years have shared a well, harvested crops together, and attended each others weddings and funerals.

Kibbutz Mezer, a collective Jewish community, and the Arab village Meiser, are located less than a half-mile from each other and from the "green line" border with the West Bank. Their relationship began in the early '50s when Kibbutz Mezer was established. Unable to find a viable water source of their own, the new kibbutz relied on the generosity of its Arab neighbors, who allowed them to share their own small well. In gratitude, Kibbutz Mezer shared with Meiser tips for navigating the new Israeli bureaucracy.

Both communities say that, in time, respect and even friendships grew. Not even the murder of a family at the kibbutz by a Palestinian extremist on November 10, 2002 could dismantle the peaceful relationship the two communities share.

This is the tale of Mezer and Meiser, communities that have lived side by side for over 55 years, offering a model of what peaceful coexistence in the region might look like.

Watch and listen to members of both communities describe how they got to know each other and how their relationship was tested.

WATCH:


Mezer-Meiser Coexistence from Rosalina Nieves on Vimeo.



This piece was originally published at onBeing, and was written, produced, and edited by Robyn Carolyn Price, Rosalina Nieves, and Bethany Firnhaber, in conjunction with USC Knight Media and Religion and USC Annenberg. Find out more information about the Mezer/Meiser Project.


 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
GohBokhor
www.ifamericansknew.org
02:41 PM on 06/13/2011
This is a tale of 100,000+ ultra-orthodox European Jews known as Haredim rioting throughout Israel because the high court ruled that their children would have to share schools with Sephardic Jews, those of Middle Eastern origin: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/06/17/israels-ultra-orthodox-je_n_616441.html

This is the real face of Israel, a so-called democracy.
photo
fairwayhill
1948 Palestine belongs to the Palestinians
11:55 AM on 06/12/2011
The only real solution is a one state solution where all the people have equal rights regardless of race and religion, and where the Palestinian refugees return to their homes in 1948 Palestine.
01:14 PM on 06/12/2011
fairwayhill , same old blha blha blha...
hfpf
Wake up World.
11:56 PM on 06/12/2011
You REALLY MISSED the point of this video. I feel pity for you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarcEdward
likes all cats more than most people
11:50 AM on 06/11/2011
Wish that spirit could spread across Israel. Most Israelis would simply call the IDF and seize the Arab's well.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GZLives
01:21 PM on 06/11/2011
Which only proves Marc that you know nothing about Israel. From the beginning of the State, the Jews called for co existence and the Arabs called for extermination and continue to call for extermination. Maybe it has something to do with what they are taught in their Mosques ?
chinchilla
They say I need to write something here.
03:11 PM on 06/11/2011
The Jews called for co-existence?

Is that why Palestinians were driven from their homes by the Israeli army? Why Arab villages were destroyed?

Yosef Weitz was a Polish Jew who settled in Palestine in 1908. Weitz was the prime mover behind the first and second Transfer Committees (1937-48), and between 1932 and 1948 he was the powerful director of the Jewish National Fund's Land Settlement Department. The UN GA proposed partition plan, and the coming hostilities, provided Weitz the opportunity to set in motion long-nurtured plans of "transferring" (Ethnic Cleaning) the Palestinian people out of their homes, farms, and businesses. His diary (contained in five volumes located in the Zionist Archives in Jerusalem was started from 1932 and continued until his death in 1970) is replete with injunctions not to "miss the opportunities" offered by the 1948 war. The diary documents a great deal of incriminating confessions and evidence of many WAR CRIMES, looting, and atrocities perpetrated by "Jewish state's" army.
http://www.palestineremembered.com/Acre/Famous-Zionist-Quotes/Story644.html

(I'm sure you will ridicule the site, but can you ridicule the diaries written by a leading Israeli?)
11:59 PM on 06/11/2011
You mean "some Jews" called for this and "some Arabs" called for that"; that's a world of difference from saying "the Jews" and "the Arabs". But you love your blanket statements, don't you?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cdncommentator
05:16 PM on 06/11/2011
Not only is your comment unfair, it's untrue. There's a thousand of these kinds of stories. In the 90s, when it looked like a peaceful settlement was on the horizon, it was these kinds of stories that were ascendant. They could be again. Instead of being such a cynic and knee-jerk critic of everything Israel or Israeli, why not open your mind and find the strengths and peaceful intentions and see if you can thread these together. Because if peace is to happen, that's what you do.

Oh, and by the way, you don't call the IDF, any more than YOU call the American army. Just like everywhere else in the world you just call the local police.
12:21 AM on 06/12/2011
I think the question is which of the two or three realities, coexistence vs. suspicion vs. hatred has dominated in the relations between the two communities since 1948? You are probably right is pointing out that there are many happy stories like this one, but they are clearly drowned out by the daily tension and conflict, sometimes simmering under the surface and sometimes breaking out in violent outbursts. Israeli Arabs are a minority; they have suffered a lot; starting with the destruction of their homeland and the decimation of their national community; and given the rise of extreme nationalist and racist parties in Israel, they still face the danger of expulsion or ethnic cleansing.

Stories like Mezer and Meiser are inspiring and can serve as models for relations between Jews and Arabs; but it's just as important to publicize and confront the bigotry and injustice, and threats Arabs face and help them in their struggle for full rights and true equality in their homeland.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cynthia Rays
peace in the valley seeker
05:52 PM on 06/10/2011
I have been to this kibbutz. There is no equity in these separate and not equal villages as there is no equity anywhere in Israel and the occupied territories. Children go to separate, not equal schools. Employment opportunities are limited for Palestinians. Israel treats its Arab neighbors as a problem to be overcome.
photo
Greg Mirsky
Riga dimd, Riga dimd, Kas to Rigu dimdinaj?
06:37 PM on 06/10/2011
There's no equality or fairness in the nature either. The only thing that a state can and must provide - equal opportunities. Everything else is up to an individual or a group. You can reach as high as the sky or you can slide down into a ravine.
chinchilla
They say I need to write something here.
08:50 PM on 06/10/2011
And when equal opportunities are not offered, what then?

Try looking at land purchasing laws in Israel for Jews and for Arabs, and then try to tell me they are equal.

Try comparing the approval percentages for building permits between Jews and Arabs in Israel and try telling me they are equal.

Try looking at educational resources available for a Jewish school compared to an Arab school in Israel, and then try telling me about equality.

The lies Israel attempts to foist onto the world have been shown for what they are, lies.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cdncommentator
05:21 PM on 06/11/2011
Children go to separate schools because in order to offer Arabs the opportunity to continue their own culture and language, Israel allowed them to conduct their own schools in Arabic with a curriculum that is more Arab-centred. If an Arab wants to go to a Hebrew language public school, they can. And in large urban centres, some do.

Also, one is a village and one is a kibbutz. If an Arab from the village wants to apply to join the kibbutz, they can. And BTW, I lived in Tel Aviv, and there were many Arabs from villages who moved there to go to University and for work.

If there informal discrimination against Arabs in Israel. Sure. It will take peace and trust and the passage of time for that to disappear. Don't be so critical. Slavery ended 150 years ago, and there is still systemic discrimination against blacks in the US, and particularly in certain areas of the US.

Is there work to do? Yes. But no one is denying that there's still a way to go.
photo
califlefty
Fighting back against the lies
05:34 PM on 06/10/2011
Let's be clear about what happened at Kibbutz Metzer, because the video is a distortion.
This was not an attack by a lone "extremist" or even by what the saner elements of the Left have always been willing to condemn -- Hamas or Islamic Jihad, but rather an attack carried out by President Abbas' own movement, Fatah under orders by Arafat. Why is this glaring omission so important?

Remeber, Kibbutz Metzer is located within Israel proper west of the "green line" and is affiliated to the Kibbutz Artzi federation, part of the Israeli far political Left. They are people who routinely march and demonstrate on behalf of an independent Palestinian state. The kibbutz was very well known for it's position and was targeted simply because they were Jews. It raises questions that remains pertinent today - specifically will the Palestinians acknowledge Israel as a Jewish State?

Without such recognition it's a very small step on the part of some to legitimize future attacks against Israel and conversely erases the distinction Israelis make between 'bad' and 'good' Palestinian movements. While there is polarization in Israeli domestic politics, an acceptance of a negotiated two-State solution will be enforceable even upon the extremist in the settler movement. However, with the current unity pact between the PA and Hamas and without recognition of Israel as a Jewish State, the racist ideological basis held by some Palestinians remains making future attacks of this sort plausible.
Tony Andrews
Ὁ βίος βραχύς, ἡ δὲ τέχν
10:28 PM on 06/10/2011
The Palestinians are not the only people on the planet that Israel has some levels of difficulty with. She , for example, has some difficulties with most of the EU.

Please list those peoples of whom Israel demands that they "recognise Israel as a Jewish State" as a condition of talking to them.

I anxiously await your erudite response - or better yet, a simple list.