iOS app Android app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Roger Friedman

Roger Friedman

Posted: June 7, 2010 02:07 PM

Helen Thomas Story Hasn't Happened in Mainstream Press

What's Your Reaction:

The Helen Thomas story? According to the New York Times, it hasn't happened.

Maybe it didn't happen. Maybe the eldest member of the White House Press Corps didn't insist on video that the Jews in Israel "get the hell out of Palestine" and return to "Poland or Germany."

The Times has simply ignored the entire Thomas fiasco, even though: Thomas's lecture agent has dropped her, her co-author has disavowed her, and there's an open letter to her in today's Jerusalem Post. The Washington Post has equally avoided the Thomas story, making passing reference in a blog (written by someone from the Conservative right) and a short summary of it in Howard Kurtz's column today.

The Times -- and all the New York newspapers -- have completely ignored the fact that man who interviewed Thomas and posted the now infamous video on YouTube is a rabbi who lives right here on Long Island. Considering how much the papers want to increase their local coverage, you'd think they'd be camped out on Rabbi David Nesenoff's front yard. Nada.

See the video at www.rabbilive.com.

The last reference to Rabbi Nesenoff in the New York Times was in 1996.

On Saturday night, I spoke to Rabbi Nesenoff exclusively.

He's a journalist and filmmaker from Long Island who has his advanced degree from the Jewish Theological Seminar. He went to the White House on May 27th with his 17-year-old son and the son's 18-year-old friend on a press pass. Both boys as well as the Rabbi wore yarmulkes and tsi-zit. They were obviously religious Jews.

And that's what shocked Nesenoff when Helen Thomas told him -- as he filmed her on his Flip camera- the Jews should "get the hell out" of Israel and go "home" to Poland or Germany-places they'd been tortured and killed in, and escaped from during the Holocaust.

"There's anti-Semitism in the world," Nesenoff told me. "And it's sitting a foot from the president."

Nesenoff says he isn't aligned with any political party or ideology. He's basically pro-Israel and is happy to meet any politician who agrees with him. Thomas surprised him, he says, because she knew who she was talking to. "She must have felt comfortable to just tell us how she felt."

"It was shocking," he said. The reason it took a week or more to post the video interview on his site, www.RabbiLive.com, or YouTube? "My 17 year old son is my webmaster and this week was finals," he laughs. "So we had to wait."

Nesenoff tells there's a little more that he'll post, including a conversation with Thomas on the state of journalism. Once she made her "Poland" remarks, Nesenoff says there wasn't much time to respond. Thomas was whisked away by a helper or page.

The Rabbi, by the way, has credentials: one film he worked on went to Sundance a few years ago, another garnered several prizes. A few years ago Nesenoff worked for the U.S. Department of Justice as an intervention consultant on a famous racial hate crimes case with Denny's.

More recently he's consulted Mel Gibson on the aftermath of his DUI arrest and anti-Semitic crimes. The rabbi says, by the way, that Gibson still has not really apologized for what he did. "You can't just say you're sorry for what you've done. You have to become the Poster Boy for apology, and he hasn't done it," Nesenoff says.