More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rory O'Connor

GET UPDATES FROM Rory O'Connor
 

Jose Antonio Vargas Is an American Hero

Posted: 06/22/11 07:15 PM ET

I first met Jose Antonio Vargas in the fall of 2008, in the midst of the historic Obama campaign for the presidency. At the time, I was a fellow at the Joan Shorenstein Center on the Press, Politics and Public Policy at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government, where I was researching the impact of the then-emerging social media on older legacy forms of journalism, such as newspapers.

A woman named Maralee Schwartz was also at the Kennedy School when I was there. Beginning in 1979, Maralee had spent her entire professional career at the Washington Post, largely as a political reporter and political editor. As national political editor, she led the Post's award-winning teams of reporters in coverage including three presidential elections, the last term of the Clinton White House, and the first term of the Bush White House.

As a "lifer" at the Post, and like many of her peers at the time in the so-called "mainstream, media," Maralee was, shall we say, extremely wary of the new media. When she heard upon our first meeting that I was researching how social networks were affecting journalism, for example, she promptly fired back, "Social networks? You mean those places online people go to get dates?"

Despite her pronounced skepticism, Maralee was still open enough to at least consider the possibility that there might be something to my seemingly wild contention that social media would have a major impact on the way journalism would be practiced in the near future. A few weeks after we met, she knocked loudly on my office door, and when I opened it, literally shoved a young man in. "This is Jose Antonio Vargas," she announced. "He gets what you're doing!" And then she marched off, leaving Vargas in her considerable wake.

We spent the next hour talking, and I quickly ascertained that Maralee was right -- this guy really did get it! Quick, articulate, savvy and full of energy, the 27-year old immigrant from the Philippines had already been part of a Pulitzer Prize-winning team at the Post -- and he certainly seemed poised to attain even greater honor and success in the near future, pursuing a career that had already taken him at a still tender age (to me at least!) near the pinnacle of establishment journalism...

Vargas then surprised me by proceeding to castigate his employer as completely behind the curve and mired in a rapidly fading past glory. "These guys don't understand," Vargas complained. "They should fire most of the editors and hire a bunch of graphic designers and online journalists," he announced with the impatience and brashness of youth.

I realized immediately that Vargas, whose Pulitzer participation came about when he cleverly used social media like Facebook to break news about the Virginia Tech campus massacre, was exactly the sort of young, hip and connected reporter places like the Post desperately needed in order to make the transition to a new digital form of journalism. I also realized that Vargas probably was not long for that world.

In short order he did walk away -- from what, in an earlier era, would have been seen as the opportunity of a lifetime -- in order to join the online upstart Huffington Post. He was among the first, in what soon became a wave, and then a tsunami of journalists, who were abandoning major media platforms like the Post, the New York Times and national television networks to work in a new form of journalism online.

In the years that followed, Jose enjoyed great success at HuffPost, and also began freelancing for major national magazines, including writing a landmark piece for the New Yorker about Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg. A series of articles he had written about H.I.V./AIDS became a documentary film called "The Other City," which opened at the Tribeca Film Festival last year and was broadcast on Showtime -- and along the way, Jose also came out as gay and wrote movingly about how he could and would no longer keep secrets about who he was and how he felt.

But despite his many amazing successes, Vargas still felt incomplete. Now we know why.

In an incredibly moving and important piece in the New York Times Sunday Magazine, "My Life as an Undocumented Immigrant," he has just "come out" again -- this time bravely and dangerously revealing that he is an undocumented immigrant, who has lived in the shadows since arriving in the USA in 1993 as a 12-year-old. Yes, this young man, on the fast track to attaining the putative American Dream. has now exposed himself not as "American" -- but as "other."

Jose Antonio Vargas is incredibly brave to risk everything he has accomplished in this country in order to tell the truth and to shine, yet another but still much-needed, light on the pressing need for comprehensive immigration reform in this country. He, and millions like him, have much to contribute to America -- and without people like them, our country will be far poorer.

If there isn't room in the United States for people like Jose Antonio -- the precise type of people who made this country great -- I despair for our collective future. I urge you to read his inspiring story, and then to take action to ensure that Jose Antonio -- and the many others like him -- aren't forced to choose between hiding in the shadows or risking it all by telling the truth.

 

Follow Rory O'Connor on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rocglobal

 
 
  • Comments
  • 66
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Lancer 101
Ripe and ready to rebel.
03:34 PM on 06/28/2011
Vargas did what most Americans and immigrants aspire to: being successful and contributing to our society. The problem is, he broke the law, as did his employers. Will he and them get arrested and charged for breaking the law? Doubtful.
photo
jazgr8
Ok, I give up, you win.
05:13 PM on 06/26/2011
You have an interesting definition for "hero" Mr. O'Connor.
09:50 AM on 06/28/2011
Is not standing up to shed light on those who suffer at the risk of losing all that uve accomplished in the pursuit of equality an act of bravery? I believe such actions and those to the like very much define or if need be redefine what it means to be brave, to stare adversity in the face and call it out for the liar that it is. I think in this country the word "hero" gets thrown out there far too often so why not this man, and his actions is what im asking.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frankg3400
11:17 AM on 06/26/2011
I wonder is voter fraud is also among his long list of broken laws that would put an ordinary American in jail for decades?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
amd02148
10:01 PM on 06/25/2011
First off, he's not American. That's total joke. And because he finally let the world know that he is in the country illegally and that he has been using falisified documents for years all of a sudeden he's a hero? What is your definition of hero?
09:53 AM on 06/28/2011
Whats ur definition of a Hero? its so typical of this countries ill informed americans wanting to weigh in with their partisan perspectives. I think that he very much embodies the average "joe" of today. It is only a secret to those who choose to close their eyes and ears that undocumented immigrants have been working or taking work away for many many years. It is to those whom have employed them and not a legal citizen that are to be looked to first. this issue has gone on for so long and was a system deemed not broken hence not in need of repair. Now people are shedding light on the matters and everyone wants to point the blame elsewhere. Its not the illegal immigrants that are at fault for ceasing the opportunites presented to them but yet those offering them.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
amd02148
09:17 PM on 06/28/2011
My definition of hero is not someone who uses falsified documents for years. Him having a career doesn't give him extra points. I'm not a person that says illegal citizens take jobs from Americans nothing could be further from the truth. I never said anything about him working he's supposed to be gainfully employed. He's a good man obviously very smart, he has an excellent career. But he has done nothing that would qualify him as a hero.
04:55 PM on 06/24/2011
Jose Antonio Vargas is an illegal immigrant that has lied to everyone pretending to be something he wasn't. He should spend time in jail, but would be happy with his immediate deportation to the Philippines.
10:01 AM on 06/28/2011
So should the people and agencies that poorly or haphazardly checked his documentation.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:10 PM on 06/24/2011
"Vargas then surprised me by proceeding to castigate his employer as completely behind the curve and mired in a rapidly fading past glory. "These guys don't understand," Vargas complained. "They should fire most of the editors and hire a bunch of graphic designers and online journalists," he announced with the impatience and brashness of youth."

Author Rory O'Connor isn't doing Vargas any favors here.

There's been nothing but layoffs in thew newspaper business for ten years. When you think of all the help Vargas got from older established journalists, both professionally and personally, as described in his own words in the New York Times, it kind of makes you sick to realize how cold blooded this guy can be.

He asks for our compassion for himself but in the meantime, he's eager to see his older print journalist colleagues out on the street. Out with the old, in with the new -- which is him, who isn't even supposed to be here.

Isn't that nice?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
EndRacismNow
Vielfalt Uber Alles
04:49 PM on 06/24/2011
Not to mention...

'The Times featured full-color photos of Vargas' fake document trove—including a fake passport with a fake name, a fake green card and a Social Security card his grandfather doctored for him at a Kinko's. He committed perjury repeatedly on federal I-9 employment eligibility forms. Following the rules would have meant a 10-year bar to re-entry into America. Making false claims of citizenship is a felony offense. Document fraud is a felony offense.

Vargas, who frames himself as a helpless victim, freely chose instead to secure yet more dummy documents. He used a friend's address to obtain an Oregon driver's license under false pretenses. It gave him an eight-year golden ticket to travel by car, board trains and airplanes, work at prestigious newspapers, and even gain access to the White House—where crack Secret Service agents allowed him to attend a state dinner using his bogus Social Security number.'

It's very odd that people are celebrating a multiple felon who probably won't be prosecuted for his identity fraud.
10:00 AM on 06/28/2011
Well though I appreciate your perspective it is flawed in itself and so insists upon the very nature of what Vargas is attempting to do. While you very well pointed out all the many laws he broke what you failed to do was shift the mind towards or showcase the flawed systems that allowed him to progress as much as he has. He was even able to get into the White House and you think he is entirely at fault? Thats just absurd and only half of a perspective. There is a lost notion in this nation and it is the notion and that is accountability. People will be looking for Vargas to be held accountable for his actions, well thats good and well but just as an illegal immigrant would be subject to a legal system that doesnt recognize him as a citizen so should this legal system recognize those who are citizen and the justice system should hold them and these agenices accountable as well.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hjo4
you can go with this or you can go with that
10:20 PM on 06/23/2011
Once Mr Vargas became of age it was his responsibility to make his immigration status legal. He chose not to instead he lied, used false documents and remained here illegally and unlawfully. He should face the consequences of his actions just as all others who commit criminal acts in America. There is no excuse to violate our laws and if you chose to, you must face the consequences of your actions.You cannot justify not processing Mr,Vargas for his crimes and not object to American citizens not being arrested for crimes they commit for a "better life". There is no difference.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KCDurling
01:36 PM on 06/23/2011
How can someone say a 12 year old broke the law when he was sent here. As far as I know, 12 year olds are not treated as adults. My mother came over on the boat from Yugoslavia to Ellis Island when she was 9 years old . She is deceased now, but as far as I know, she wasn't a U.S. citizen. Does that make her a criminal!?! Does that make me illegal ever though I was born in Detroit!?! Oh wait, maybe I need to prove that Detroit, Michigan was a state then... just sayin'
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rory Canfield
Rwy'n ysbaddu fy cath, nawr mae'n ryddfrydol
02:22 PM on 06/23/2011
So your mother came to the US and went through Ellis Island which was the legal way to do things back in the day. Notice I said legal way. As far as treating 12 year olds, we aren't talking about a 12 year old now are we. We are talking about a fully functioning adult who is according to the laws of this country, breaking immigration laws by not being in this country as an adult legally. Now, is that clear to you or do I need to explain it further.
04:33 PM on 06/23/2011
"At New York's Ellis Island, immigrants were required to pass a medical inspection and legal exam."

http://www.history.com/videos/ellis-island-registering-as-an-american-citizen#ellis-island-registering-as-an-american-citizen
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
amd02148
10:07 PM on 06/25/2011
Rory I think you're going to explain it further, there are a lot of people not getting it.
12:39 PM on 06/23/2011
He is more American than many of the people who's family has been here for generations. Being American is not about having a piece of paper. Being American is about being a fighter, making the best out of the circumstances that life has handed you, about being a dreamer. Mr. Vargas is a true American, at least in spirit. If he is deported it will be America's lost.
02:43 AM on 06/24/2011
You OBVIOUSLY have not traveled the world. Americans are fat and lazy.

If you want to see fight, go to a third world country. Take Ukraine for example. The legal definition of poverty is an income of $50 or less PER MONTH. 25% of the population is in poverty.

According to the United Nations, one half of the globe lives on less than $2 per day.
12:04 PM on 06/24/2011
How arrogant can you be? Sure, all Americans are fat and lazy. I'm sure it took a lot of work for you to come up with that.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
EndRacismNow
Vielfalt Uber Alles
04:59 PM on 06/24/2011
American citizenship means absolutely nothing then. By your definition 90% of the world is American.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anonani
A woman of substance
07:18 AM on 06/23/2011
I am so sorry that your friend lied to you and to the Nation that we call home. I am so sorry that because he is your friend, it doesn't matter to you that he lied, over and over again. He broke laws in the Nation that he professes to love and to want to stay. Does he wish to start a cottage industry of fellow liars and allow all comers to, like he did, reap the potential rewards of being a citizen of the United States? The fact that he earned a Pulitzer Prize put him in rarefied circles....but he lied to get it.

We are taking back Olympic medals from liars....we should take his Pulitzer Prize back too...he lied. We are erasing the existence of these medalists from the history books....because they lied. This is no different and he deserves no better treatment that anyone of lies, cheats, and steals their way into the psyche of a nation that would make him a "hero".

Sir, you standards are very low for "hero-dom".
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rory O'Connor
Author, Friends, Followers and the Future
09:58 AM on 06/23/2011
I'm sure Jose Antonio would voluntarily give back his Pulitzer in exchange for meaningful comprehensive immigration reform!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mokachyna
Ready for the zombie apocalypse...if it comes.
12:38 PM on 06/23/2011
In the days after Osama bin Laden was killed, we found out that the Pakistani government was paying millions of dollars to lobbyists to make sure that US aid to Pakistan continued. I don't believe that it's right for foreign governments to be able to pay to get what they want from our elected leaders and I don't believe it's right for an illegal immigrant to be here illegally lobbying for our US policies to be changed. But I guess now that he's got the media (that he duped) on his side, he's untouchable.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rory Canfield
Rwy'n ysbaddu fy cath, nawr mae'n ryddfrydol
02:05 PM on 06/23/2011
He should give it up just to prove he is serious about immigration reform, he obviously is quite happy being a liar and criminal. As an immigrant who came here the LEGAL way, his blantant disrespect of this countries laws and its immigration process is a slap in the face to the millions who do it the right way. He won't voluntarily give back his Pulitzer any more likely than he would move back to his home country. I hope he and his family get fined, deported and banned from ever coming to the US ever again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rory Canfield
Rwy'n ysbaddu fy cath, nawr mae'n ryddfrydol
02:10 PM on 06/23/2011
Excellent posting Anonani .. excellent.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlueRevolution
Doing my part to help keep Colorado blue.
01:22 AM on 06/23/2011
Giving Vargas an amnesty is a slap in the face to all the people who followed the rules to come here. What he may not understand is that "comprehensive immigration reform" is not and should not simply be a validation of his illegal status, but a fairer recognition who gets to be a citizen and how. Even in the best of circumstances, he has to get to the back of the line, pay a hefty fine, and show federal authorities that he has never used a US citizen's ID to gain employment, find housing, get a loan, buy a car, etc. And THEN he gets to be a citizen. People who follow the rules have to wait 5 to 10 years. Who does he think he is, bitching about a law that if passed, would bump him up to the head of the line? Go back home, Mr. Vargas, and apply the right way.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rory O'Connor
Author, Friends, Followers and the Future
09:56 AM on 06/23/2011
Of course Jose Antonio -- and many of the rest of us -- understand that "comprehen­sive immigratio­n reform" is not and should not simply be a validation of his illegal status! And we agree that we need "a fairer recognitio­n who gets to be a citizen and how."

Now what?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlueRevolution
Doing my part to help keep Colorado blue.
12:33 PM on 06/23/2011
The DREAM Act, if passed, would treat him better than a 27-year-old legal resident alien who never broke the law. In many states he would be charged a higher tuition rate for college and university despite having lived in the USA for all but one of those years. I know, because, my home state of Colorado does this to legal resident aliens who begin their college career while still waiting for citizenship status to be finalized. How, then, is it fair to legal immigrants to hold them up for the higher rate? Until disparities like these are addressed, the DREAM Act should not pass.

His behavior patterns are indicative of someone waiting for another blanket amnesty (like what Reagan signed in 1986) instead of someone aware of the implications of the bigger issues. My apologies, but in the current political climate, that is not likely to happen. Even a Republican president inaugurated in 2013 would not get a bill out of the Tea Party-controlled House. The climate for passage would be much harder than now.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:04 PM on 06/24/2011
I don't think that's in any of the "comprehensive immigration reform" bills.

As long as we continue to allow people to sponsor extended family members -- parents, brothers and sisters, we'll continue to get swamped by millions of people participating in an endless chain migration. I don't blame the immigrants for wanting everybody to come here. It's up to us to change our laws and communicate by word and by deed that because we've lost so many jobs that aren't coming back and our population is rapidly growing, we are going to cut our annual immigration numbers.
11:54 AM on 06/23/2011
I came to the US legally, I'm finally eligible for citizenship and I'm excited for it. But I don't at all feel that Mr. Vargas' story is a "slap in the face" to me or any of my family who also came here legally. More than anything it makes me feel lucky to be here and makes me wonder why my family was considered "good enough" to make it while so many others are turned away.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlueRevolution
Doing my part to help keep Colorado blue.
12:19 PM on 06/23/2011
There are legal resident aliens like you who are never granted in-state tuition for colleges and universities, as is done in my home state of Colorado. These student's parents did EVERYTHING right---even start businesses that employ people---but the kids still get charged out-of-state tuition for all 4 years of college. The DREAM Act, as presently proposed, lets grown children who had been smugggled in across the border as babies and toddlers to get in-state rates. How is that fair to you, if you live in Colorado or any other state that does this to legal resident aliens?
10:07 PM on 06/22/2011
He's not an "American" until he is a naturalized citizen. Failing that he is a criminal alien resident no matter how admirable you think he is.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rory O'Connor
Author, Friends, Followers and the Future
11:26 PM on 06/22/2011
Define American...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlueRevolution
Doing my part to help keep Colorado blue.
01:12 AM on 06/23/2011
Google the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution. Some of your answers will be found there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jane Porto
01:16 AM on 06/23/2011
native american, descendant of the americas, all the rest of you are immigrants.
10:00 PM on 06/22/2011
He BROKE the laws in SOOO many ways. He IS a criminal and the Secret Service SHOULD be going after him. IF I were to get caught trying this even as a 20 yr U.S. Army vet and certified US citizen "I" would be charged with a crime for using false papers to get into White House. Hell, look at the White House crashers and the stink about that. WHY is this not getting the same "media" coverage?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Rory O'Connor
Author, Friends, Followers and the Future
11:27 PM on 06/22/2011
The law is an ass. We need comprehensive immigration reform now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rory Canfield
Rwy'n ysbaddu fy cath, nawr mae'n ryddfrydol
02:15 PM on 06/23/2011
Sure, start with those in line legally or does that offend your sensibilities?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jane Porto
01:09 AM on 06/23/2011
because really who cares, have google JP morgan fraud or Goldman Sachs fraud? This to companies alone defrauded the american people trillions of dollars, and not one of them has gone to jail. just slaps on the wrist. besides large corporations love cheap labor, legal or illegal, why do you think we have a flood of people coming to this country every year.
11:50 AM on 06/23/2011
Perhaps one reason is there are too many people who don't think all laws should be upheld. Why is it an either/or - prosecute billionaire fraud and illegal immigration...
08:57 AM on 06/25/2011
Well hell when we have people that are supposed to be WRITING the tax laws can break the law by not paying taxes and get away with it "What the hell" really then? You can't justify BAD behavior (or breaking the law) by pointing to another. You thought procees? The following are primary offenses investigated by the Secret Service:
Identity Crimes - Identity crimes are defined as the misuse of personal or financial identifiers in order to gain something of value and/or facilitate other criminal activity. The Secret Service records criminal complaints, assists victims in contacting other relevant investigative and consumer protection agencies and works with other federal, state and local law enforcement and reporting agencies to identify perpetrators.
Identity crimes investigated by the Secret Service include, but are not limited to, the following:
Bank Fraud (Opened account with false documents, Vargas?)
False Identification Fraud (Drivers permit, and SSN by Vargas)
Passport/Visa Fraud (Traveled about the world on false documents?
Counterfeit and Fraudulent Identification - The Secret Service enforces laws involving counterfeit and fraudulent identification which means, where someone knowingly and without lawful authority produces, transfers or possesses a false identification document to defraud the U.S. Government. (IF he obtained ANY education funds from government, Vargas) The use of desktop publishing software/hardware (USED a copier and "thin strip of white tape" by Vargas) to counterfeit and produce different forms of identification used to obtain funds illegally remains one of the Secret Service's core violations.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lindsay Dittman
07:47 PM on 06/22/2011
In complete agreement.