iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ross Szabo

GET UPDATES FROM Ross Szabo
 

Debunking 5 Common Wine Myths

Posted: 08/29/2012 6:11 pm

It seems just about everyone I meet has a variety of opinions about wine. I never know what to believe. Should I stick to Paul Giamatti's advice and not drink Merlot? When I tilt my wine glass and it appears to cling to the side like Spider-Man is that because of the tannins? Are blended wines just a mix of what's left over?

There are a lot of myths and urban legends floating around. I talked to Mariana Onofri, the Sommelier and Wine Director for The Vines of Mendoza, to learn what is true and what is an urban legend. Here are some of the most common myths I have heard -- and the real facts.

Myth #1: I Don't Want Any F#@!ing Merlot
Truth:
Some lines from certain movies really stick. The Merlot myth stuck so much that it caused sales to plummet. This is not the first time movies had this unintended impact. Check out the 75 percent of the shark population that was killed after Jaws. While we can't defend the honor of sharks, the truth is that Merlots are quality wines. Petrus is one of the most expensive and prestigious wines in the world. The composition is mainly Merlot and comes from Pomerol, France. Sometimes people drink blends such as a Bordeaux and don't even realize it is largely comprised of Merlot. Of course, as with any wine, you should be sure it is a quality wine before purchasing a bottle, but you shouldn't misjudge the entire varietal.

Myth #2: ABC-Anything But Chardonnay
Truth:
This catchy statement came about, because people have a belief that Chardonnays are typically oak tasting and not crispy or fresh. Don't give up on Chardonnay. Depending on the style of winemaking you can find Chardonnays that don't have any oak and offer a refreshing flavor. If you enjoy a crisp white wine, you can certainly find a Chardonnay to suit your tastes.

Myth #3: The Legs of the Wine Mean _________________________
Truth: It's so common to see someone get a glass of wine tilt it, look at what's left on the glass and come up with some theory. It's the tannins. It's the alcohol. It's the quality of the wine. It's a secret plan to help digestion.

The reality is seeing the legs can be affected by the thickness of the glass, the type of glass and how it was washed. They are not a sign of quality. In some cases, glycerol, a type of alcohol found in wine, can be a part of identifying the legs. However, this is not always the case.

Myth #4: Blended Wines Are Not As Good As Non-Blended Wines
Truth:
When given the choice between a Malbec, Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah etc. or a blend, a lot of people will choose the single grape wines. Blends can often be the best mix of all of your favorites or what I like to call the ice cream sundae of wines. I love cookies and cream ice cream, but mix that with some brownie and coconut ice cream and it's amazing. When winemakers take a Malbec and mix it with a Cabernet Sauvignon or any other grape it can be so much better than one of them on their own. Blends are definitely worth exploring.

Myth #5: Don't Drink Wines With High Alcohol
Truth:
A wine with high alcohol content doesn't mean it will be like taking a shot of vodka. There is a belief that a higher alcohol percentage will cause the wine to burn the throat or nose, but that isn't necessarily true. Argentine wines are high in alcohol, because the grapes are grown in a warm, dry climate. It is not uncommon for a wine to be as much as 16 percent alcohol. However, when winemakers deal with high alcohol, they make the other elements of wine (acidity, tannins and fruit flavor) high as well to give the wines a balance and hide the alcohol. Don't be afraid of high alcohol contents, but rather pay attention to the balance of the wine.

 
 
 
FOLLOW FOOD
It seems just about everyone I meet has a variety of opinions about wine. I never know what to believe. Should I stick to Paul Giamatti's advice and not drink Merlot? When I tilt my wine glass and it ...
It seems just about everyone I meet has a variety of opinions about wine. I never know what to believe. Should I stick to Paul Giamatti's advice and not drink Merlot? When I tilt my wine glass and it ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:04 AM on 09/05/2012
I have moved to a small village in the Austrian wine growing area, and have now realized how much hard work, dedication and love, that goes into making a bottle of wine.
With that in mind, I say, just enjoy and drink it....
Biggi
http://www.simplyburgenland.blogspot.com
photo
Gnomish
ego doctus ignarus
08:44 AM on 09/03/2012
Myth #22 the Color of the box matters.
09:19 PM on 09/02/2012
Another couple of Myths:

Organic wines are made without pesticides are are healthier for you:

truth: all wines are made with some types of pesticides - whether organically approved or not. And no evidence has ever been done to show organic wines are more healthier or better.

Myth:
Sulfites are bad for you

truth; while wine contains on average 10-30mg/l - our own bodies can produce as much as 1000mg/l per day. Guess what is far more dangerous in wines - alcohol.
01:17 PM on 09/02/2012
I really enjoy merlot, pinot noire and chardonnay. I've had some really good inexpensive brands of these too. By inexpensive I'm referring to those in the twenty to thirty dollar range. I don't think I've ever had a glass of REALLY expensive wine so I don't have much to compare my tastes in wine to I guess.
photo
Johnsteed
Mrs Peel, we're needed
05:14 PM on 09/01/2012
Vino The Nectar Of The Gods
photo
lokitheviking
new triple bottom line ; profit, people, planet
10:59 AM on 09/01/2012
Another myth. That the wine will taste like the blurb on the label or the ads for it say it does. Even at wine tastings the servers exaggerations rarely match whats in the glass. Only sommeliers and good bartenders seem to be able to share real advance notice. At one winery after being told to expect the usual silliness of herbs and fruits and berries and whatever I responded that all I tasted was grape juice and dishwasher detergent. In France they were much more real about the wine than here in Cal. where sales hype is more important than word of mouth (pun intended).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stevie Hallandale
Aware
11:15 PM on 08/31/2012
I heard winemakers add sulfites, a dangerous poison, to stop the fermentation process. Wish this would have been addressed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ClevelandLib
Unless
10:45 PM on 09/01/2012
Lots of good organic wines these days and they don't contain sulfites.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stevie Hallandale
Aware
06:54 AM on 09/02/2012
Yes thanks for the tip I have been meaning to look into this. But still wish it were addressed in the article instead of what I found to be silly topics.
02:19 PM on 09/02/2012
It's important to read the label when shopping for organic wine. Some wine is made from organically grown grapes and fermented by traditional methods. True organic wine is made from organically grown grapes and fermented using oraganic methods.
12:44 PM on 09/02/2012
SO2 is commonly used in most wineries. It has 3 major purposes: antimicrobial, antioxidant, and it binds to acetaldehyde. SO2 can be used in white wine making to help prevent oxidative browning. It can be added at the end of fermentation or malolactic fermentation as a preservative. Acetaldehyde can make an off flavor in the wine. SO2 binds to it and you can't taste it. Most wineries typically don't neeed to add SO2 to stop fermentation. Equipment can be rinsed with an SO2 solution as a final cleaning step. Barrels can be gassed with SO2 to keep them clean between use. The amount of SO2 that can be present in wine is federally regulated.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
peppertrekker
To have some fun and maybe share a pun
07:20 PM on 08/31/2012
I prefer unfiltered, not a fan of fish bladders or egg whites threw my wine.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Christina Loccke
10:49 AM on 08/30/2012
More on Myth #@/Chardonnay: This grape is a chameleon and adapts to the vintner's style and the ground it grows on. Go for a colder/northern growing region. From France, try a Chablis--famously crisp and steely with minerality. It's also the grape of Champagne, and other Burgundy whites. Or, try Chardonnay from southern Australia's Mornington Peninsula.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WesStrikesBack
A winegrowing secular humanist
10:45 AM on 08/31/2012
Don't forget Margaret River and unoaked wines from the Santa Rita Hills!
06:23 PM on 09/01/2012
but do I become more attractive the more I drink
09:20 AM on 08/30/2012
Myth #6: Don't Drink Wine With LOW Alcohol.

Low alcohol wines are thin and tasteless. They lack the body of higher-alcohol wines, and cling to a misleading "healthier" label to sell their weedy product.

Oh, sorry, that's not a myth.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WesStrikesBack
A winegrowing secular humanist
10:47 AM on 08/31/2012
So the greatest Champagnes and German rieslings are thin and tasteless? These generalized statements do not show any familiarity with a meaningful understanding of global wine styles.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WesStrikesBack
A winegrowing secular humanist
02:06 PM on 09/06/2012
No comment? Do you write a wine blog? I'd love to debate you in a public forum on this subject!
photo
joebobjones
Eat everything.
04:30 PM on 08/31/2012
I avoid low alcohol reds, because (generally) they tend toward a sweeter or flabbier wine. Not always, but more often than not in my experience. Whites, not so.
photo
lionstar
There is no 'try'.
11:07 PM on 08/29/2012
The balance of the wine is crucial in determining whether a wine high in alcohol is delicious or simply "hot".