iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Russell Bishop

GET UPDATES FROM Russell Bishop
 

How You Frame The Problem Is The Problem

Posted: 06/07/10 09:27 AM ET

Is there something in your life that you would like to see improve in some way? That could be anywhere from fixing something that is negative over to simply going from good to even better; from digging out of debt, getting a job, finding a more loving and caring relationship, becoming a more loving and caring person yourself, getting rid of the job you do have in favor of something better, to simply learning how to enjoy what you already have.

Clearly, there is any number of conditions in which you may find yourself ranging from fantastic to horrific. The question simply comes down to how satisfied you are with your current experience of life and what can you do about it.

Notice the question isn't about how much you have of anything in particular, but one of your level of satisfaction with what you have. And what can you do about it?

From time to time, people ask me what I do for a living. Depending on the circumstance and context of the question, I can answer in a variety of ways. Sometimes the answer is that I am an author, an educational psychologist, a management consultant, or a coach.

My favorite answer: I help people get what they think they want as fast as possible so I can ask, "Was that it?"

I'll bet you've been there; in fact, some of you may be there right this very minute. Did you ever want something, really long for it, work your butt off to get it and then wind up wondering why you ever wanted it in the first place? Again, most of us know what this is like first hand.

What makes this so interesting in my work is that people seem to want and need a combination of both. Surely physical circumstances make a difference and yet people can have "everything" and still find themselves wanting at several levels.

You Can Never Get Enough of What You Don't Truly Want

Eric Hoffer, the longshoreman philosopher is often quoted as having said: "You can never get enough of what you don't need to make you happy. Sometimes, he is quoted as saying, "You can never get enough of what you don't really want." Same thing, really.

If I am after the experience of being secure, free and at peace, is there any amount of money (or house, or car, or perfect relationship) that will produce the experiences I seek?

The obvious implication here is "NO!" People have been happy with next to nothing, miserable with all there is, and everywhere in between.

So, what is it that you want out of life and what's in the way? If your answer is on the material side of things (money, house, car, etc) and what's in the way is someone else (Bush, bankers, greedy capitalists), then we have a real dilemma. Especially if you have lost your job, house, car and most everything on the material levels of life.

Surely, there are many of us in trouble, having lost everything due to circumstances ranging from hurricanes and oil spills to manipulated financial systems. I know a bit of what it means to have lost everything having come through a period earlier in my life when I wound up living in my second hand car after my father died and our family went through our third bankruptcy in 10 years.

However, I was quite fortunate that in the midst of my turmoil while literally living on a dollar a day, I got some great coaching from some equally great people who encouraged me to take responsibility for my circumstances, figure out what I wanted to do about them, get off my poor-me mindset and get busy.

Of the many profound lessons I learned at the time, one stands out right now: how you frame the issue is the issue. This can also be stated as, how you frame the problem is the problem.

If you're out of work right now, and your mindset is that some dirty, greedy SOB is to blame, you may be right. The only problem with this framing is that as long as you stay focused on those dirty SOB's , you will continue to be at the mercy of SOB's who may not care all that much about your circumstances.

If your life circumstances and how you experience them are going to change for the better, how will they get better? Who is going to be at the helm, guiding the change? There's no question that improved external factors can help; however, what are you going to do regardless of what happens out there?

Sooner or later, it's going to come down to you and what you choose to do.

If you read these HuffPost pages enough, you may slide into that group that has become so very good at blaming everyone else. Surely, we have no shortage of culprits to blame, ranging from oil companies to bankers to misguided politicians.

However, we have always had culprits to blame. The real question comes down to what are you going to do about it? And, in particular, what are you going to do about it as it pertains to your circumstances.

If you frame the problem as something that somebody else created, then as surely as you are a victim of what somebody else did to screw things up, you will remain a victim to the next set of screw-up's.

What would happen if you reframed the problem as something that not only impacts you, but as something about which you can exercise some choice? I hope you have noticed that even as the job situation continues to be "bleak," some folks have managed to find their way through all of this, finding jobs, opportunities, and ways to make things better, even if only marginally.

How would you have to frame the situation in order to make things even marginally better? What could you do that might take even the smallest of steps forward? Is there anything at all that you could do that might help, even in the slightest?

Of course, the cynics out there will decry these questions with all their usual pablumesque rejoinders about drivel, etc. However, if you are going to experience any improvement whatsoever, sooner or later it is going to come down to you to get off your assets and do something about your current condition.

It's going to be pretty difficult to find that job if you don't go looking; it's going to be pretty difficult to improve that strife-filled relationship if you don't look at your own role in it; it's going to be pretty difficult to improve damn near anything if you don't start with the assumption that it can improve and that you do something about it.

Sure, small improvements are only small improvements. However, how does anyone ever get better without taking those first micro steps? And if things only improve marginally for the time better, are you better off doing nothing or doing what you can?

If you don't like this advice, then don't take it and see just how much things change for you as you sit there blaming everybody else out there for your situation.

Once again, there's no question in my mind that you will be right. There are many to blame; the only problem seems to be that blaming somehow isn't sufficient to change anything.

What can you do to help your own situation? What will you do?

More to come next week. In the meantime, please do leave a comment here or drop me an email and let me know how this strikes you.

***

Russell Bishop is an Educational Psychologist, author, professional life coach and management consultant, based in Santa Barbara California. You can find out more about Russell at http://www.lessonsinthekeyoflife.com. Contact Russell by email at: Russell (at) lessonsinthekeyoflife.com


 
 
 

Follow Russell Bishop on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Russell_Bishop

Is there something in your life that you would like to see improve in some way? That could be anywhere from fixing something that is negative over to simply going from good to even better; from diggi...
Is there something in your life that you would like to see improve in some way? That could be anywhere from fixing something that is negative over to simply going from good to even better; from diggi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 79
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
11:50 PM on 06/08/2010
I just happened on to this posting and decided to share some things with everyone. I am a woman in my 60's whose husband is now in Nursing Home and find myself alone after 32 years of caring for some one else. I put everything on hold for my family. My children are adults with their own families and even though they are constantly sharing their lives with mine I feel the need for something else.

I have a job interview tomorrow with the local Chamber of Commerce in my town and am frightened, excited and nervous. can I do a 40 hour work week, am I taking a job from a younger person with a family to raise? These are the things that make me nervous.

Then I realize I am still a very capable, intelligent woman with years of experience behind me of managing the entire lives of 3 other people and getting them through some tough times.

I see this as another step on the ladder of life and hope I can continue to grow in mind and spirit and maybe make some one's day a little brighter.
05:05 PM on 06/08/2010
I have recently become aware that I've been complaining about my job to close friends for literally years now and not REALLY doing anything to change my situation. You have re-affirmed that it's time to get off my assets and make a real change for the better.
photo
Marcus01
It all just seems like it's real
12:29 PM on 06/08/2010
I've had a lot of powerful lessons in my life. One in particular happened in the early nineties when I was managing a very busy car dealer service department, servicing a line of import vehicles with a high degree of reliability issues. My employer had numerous franchises operating out of multiple locations and I worked under a very knowledgeable and talented service director.

For some time I had allowed the job to run me - rather than my running it - and I was feeling pretty ragged. In fact I was downright depressed, waking up each morning grimacing as I wondered what fires I'd have to put out that day. In contrast the service director was always very positive, even though he definitely had a plate full of problems too.

One day I asked him, "How do you manage to stay so upbeat in the midst of all this adversity?"

His response was, "Each day brings a new and unique set of problems, but in those problems lie opportunities, even if they're opportunities to simply learn something."

I was struck by the power in this simple mantra and decided to make it my own, repeating it every morning upon waking. Within two weeks everything changed. I was having fun addressing the challenges and learning a great deal also. My attitude affected the people around me and they were having fun too.

Life can be a bowl of cherries or a bag of s**t. It all depends on your attitude.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:00 AM on 06/08/2010
I see two subjects here. The first is the title, and the second is the actual subject of the article.

Regarding the title, I love it. So much of what we do, try to do, or don't do is related not to problems for which we do not have the answers, but to problems that we do not know enough about so as to even be able to ask intelligent questions. Before the advent of the invention of electricity less than 200 years ago, for instance, nearly all of the questions related to that field were beyond our ability to even frame. Likewise, in the field of "paranormal" experiences, we do not yet know enough to be able to frame intelligent questions for further study.

Regarding blaming others for our problems, that is just part of human nature. Many times in discussions with young people who complained about not having jobs that paid what they wanted, I found that they would disparage good paying jobs because they involved too much labor and/or training. Man of us want the fruits of money, but do not want to come by it through honest hard work, intelligently applied.
05:59 AM on 06/08/2010
I build my home with my two hands. As a city boy I am proud of this accomplishment.
I learned that to build a house all you have to do is hammer one nail into one board at a time. When you have done enough boards and nails, you have a house. It is easy to do anything when you break it down into single small steps.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kate Emery
05:47 AM on 06/08/2010
Check out this article as well - it's interesting to ponder whether you're talking about things that get in the way of experiencing happiness, or things that will impede your memory of yourself as a happy person. It turns out they are two different things!

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/06/04/daniel-kahneman-nobel-pri_n_601236.html
05:29 AM on 06/08/2010
Four words: Solution-focused brief therapy.

Similarly: check out neuro-linguistic programming.

Here's a hint: avoid starting with asking "why?"

Better questions revolve around the solution-path:

"How can I improve this situation?"
"What would it take?"
"How have other people accomplished that in the past?"
"Who can I ask for help, ideas, or guidance?"
"Where should I go to make this happen?"
"How should I schedule the steps I need to take?"
"How can I raise the funds to make this happen?"

Etc.

Save "why?" for ruminating later. There is seldom a definitive answer to that one, only opinions.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:05 AM on 06/08/2010
I see a simple dichotomy, between those who ask questions, and those who are content to accept on faith what they are told to believe.
For someone who questions what are the common beliefs, it does not matter whether one starts a question with How, What, Where, When, or Why, only that one is willing to be inquisitive about the world around them.
photo
Marcus01
It all just seems like it's real
10:55 AM on 06/08/2010
It's true there are people who follow the leader and those of us who ask questions, often very important questions. But what about the leaders? What is it about them that others see them as worthy of being followed? Is it just charisma or is it something... more? Knowledge, experience, relevancy, vision? Some leaders are in service to self. Some are in service to others. Some are both.

Some of us are simply observing and trying to sort it all out. Others are offering opinions based upon observation and other factors. Some see themselves as being along for the ride, with everything happening "to" them and all of it caused by some external source. Some see life as a procession of choices. Some live in the past, some in the moment, some are focused on the future.

There are those who follow their own inner guidance. Often they're asking questions in seeking that guidance. Many of the responders to this article are sharing what they found and the actions they took as a result of listening to that inner voice.

We are all of these people at one time or another, and will react to our environment in a myriad of different ways depending on which person we choose to be in the moment we respond.

If we were to really sit down and think about it, we would find there are many, many shades of gray between the stark polarities of black and white.
12:43 AM on 06/08/2010
Habits in thinking are very hard to change. They are the best and most worthy things to change. I am still trying. This was a very encouraging article. I will forward to friends.
11:07 PM on 06/07/2010
I control my destiny, and am not at the mercy of others. If I want change I am not going to bide my time and wait for it. I am going to be the change I want to see.
photo
Marcus01
It all just seems like it's real
07:59 PM on 06/07/2010
We really are what we think and more important, how we think. Our society conditions us to see everything as being external to us and among other things that creates a whole group of self-proclaimed victims. Most of us have known - and many have stepped away from - people who constantly complain about how miserable they are, and through that complaining seem to create more for them to be miserable about.

It's a matter of perception. Once we begin to realize that whatever is happening is happening "in here" rather than "out there" we can choose to take responsibility and stop placing blame on things external to ourselves. Once you take responsibility for everything in your life the excuses cease entirely. You really start to understand that life is a series of opportunities for personal growth, and how you choose to handle the challenges that arise will determine how much you grow.

The meaning of life is how you handle the lessons.
07:34 PM on 06/07/2010
This is exactly right - you can blame someone else and do nothing to make an improvement, or you can take a look around you and try something, anything at all. It absolutely drives me crazy to hear people complaining about situations that they do have some control over, but they just don't do anything about them to improve their lives. I will help you solve your problems if you want me to but I absolutely REFUSE to enable you in your victimhood. It is a waste of time and energy.

I also dislike hearing that someone is jealous of another person - for example, my brother is jealous of me that I have a Master's degree and some business certifications to my name. Well, if you want those things, then do what you can to start the process of getting them. If you don't want those things then why are you complaining that I have them and you don't? Why waste time and energy being jealous and a complainer?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
1southernbelle
agape to eros, love informs us
05:20 PM on 06/07/2010
I have been through this. There was a time when my life was so difficult for so long that I began to despair. Because somewhere in me some hope lived, I began to meet people who helped me by the way they led their lives. When they had problems, they took action; if the first didn't work, they tried again, and on and on. Most of these folks would be considered "poor", yet their lives were rich with music and friends and laughter and free cultural events.
The big take-away for me was that my life was my responsibility and that I could choose how to live. Talk about small steps! Nevertheless, over the years I have helped raise an amazing daughter, achieved many of my goals, and like myself more each year.
The people and situations that held me back are not important--the steps I took to move into a life I loved were.
07:36 PM on 06/07/2010
Good for you. You took steps, no matter how small. You took control. And you were helped by example by people doing the same thing. I hope life is less difficult for you now.
04:12 PM on 06/07/2010
Great post! What you focus on is a form of power. Taking action, however small, is a form of power. And power over yourself is the foundation of happiness.

'Sure, small improvements are only small improvements. However, how does anyone ever get better without taking those first micro steps? And if things only improve marginally for the time better, are you better off doing nothing or doing what you can?' How true.

How will you know when you have arrived?
In talking about a thoroughbred, you do not admire his strength, but admire his temper. - Confucius justonequestionaday.com
09:31 PM on 06/07/2010
You won't know when you have arrived. Every arrival is also a departure, and the only thing that seems like fun to me is the journey itself, not the arrival.
12:52 AM on 06/08/2010
Great response and so true. Sometimes in the past, I lived for the goal, the "arrival", only to find when I got "there" it was sort of empty and not at all what I expected. It really was the journey that made my life satisfying, fun and rewarding, even though they were definitely THE most challenging times in my life---financially, emotionally, and intellectually. Having positive people around to share the good times with really helped, too. And I agree with a previous poster, sometimes the least wealthy are the most rich!! And the most fun to be around.
08:13 AM on 06/08/2010
Very true! The journey IS the destination.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Angie Cordeiro
We do all things through Grace which empowers us.
03:33 PM on 06/07/2010
Another great read & thought provoking!

"...at rock bottom, simply a capacity for awareness."

Jean Shinoda Bolen--Penny Whistle Story
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtsMx_GvAaE
02:58 PM on 06/07/2010
I am reminded of an EST style seminar where the facilitator relentlessly pursued participants with "How did you set that up?" as they complained about various life events. The facilitator did not allow "can't" and did not allow blaming others.

To be sure, others always impact your life, but sometimes we "set things up" to permit that impact in the first place. His purpose was to persuade people to explore themselves for contributing factors, AS IF they each were solely responsible for the outcome. While that is not factually the case most of the time, "self" is the only person under your immediate control every day.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RButler
I've always wanted to have everything I wanted
06:47 PM on 06/07/2010
I recall the purpose of the est Training, which I did in '78. It was 'to rehabilitate our ability to experience living so that the problems and issues in life clear up in the process of life itself'. Quite a mouthful. An infant or small child cries one minute and when it's done, it laughs the next, and when it 's done it falls asleep and so on. But, as we grow up, we resist or suppress unwelcome experiences, such as rejection, embarrassment, fear etc. and get 'stuck' in so many ways as we age. You would think that we would be able to 'unstick' ourselves but we don't. The Training allowed us to experience whatever there was to experience and when we were done, it and we were complete for the moment. It was an ongoing process. Life opened up as a result of being 'unstuck'.

As an experiment, when I had tooth filled between the two 'est' weekends, I said "No Novocaine" and then just experienced the various sensations. It was so weird. The more I relaxed the less I felt it although it never did hurt. I still do that to this day, sometimes falling asleep in the dentist's chair.

Of course, there are still a lot of other areas where I haven't been willing or able to experience something fully but I work at it. It's a very useful tool.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Honora
09:06 AM on 06/08/2010
I did the est training way back when & it was invaluable. I have what I consider a major problem today & it's good to be reminded that I can do my best to resolve it & then live with what comes next. Life is a series of problems & for the most part I manage them graciously thanx to the old est training. I have a tape of Werner about the training & I watch it from time to time. A great reminder. This is a great way to express my thoughts & will always be interested in what other;s have to say.