More

Sally Kohn

Sally Kohn

Posted February 5, 2009 | 06:20 PM (EST)

The Unconscionable Idiot of the Week Award Goes To...


Sheriff Joe Arpaio of Maricopa County, Arizona! Congratulations!

This week, having already done everything imaginable to turn himself into a national right-wing celebrity by terrorizing undocumented immigrants, Sheriff Joe turned to the unimaginable. For a pre-arranged media circus, he paraded -- that's right, paraded -- undocumented immigrants wearing humiliating old-fashioned prison uniforms and shackles out of the county jail to a "tent city" where they are now being held and awaiting court. Just as Arpaio rounded up immigrants in the county through widespread racial profiling, he has carried that racism to detention by segregation -- and singling out -- Latino immigrants.

Arpaio claims the measure was a cost-saver, but it's worth noting that in 2005, he moved 700 prisoners from one prison to another wearing only pink underwear and flip-flops (the prisoners were, that is, not Arpaio). Outraged Maricopa County politicians say the cost-savings are negligible and merely a red herring. "He's trying to justify this as a 'budget savings,' and I'm just appalled," said County Supervisor Mary Rose Wilcox. "It's just another publicity stunt."

Of course the idea that gross violations of human rights might possibly be justified by cost-benefit analyses (see, e.g., the death penalty) or efficiency (see, e.g., torture) has been repeatedly repudiated mathematically. Let alone the moral calculus that apparently is beyond Arpaio's grade level.

The most noteworthy thing about the photos from the orchestrated show is that the antiquated prison costumes all say "UNSENTENCED." According to Stephen Lemmons, over 70% of people under Arpaio's control are all still awaiting trial. What better way to welcome immigrants to America, where everyone is supposedly innocent until proven guilty, than march them in chains to a temporary concentration camp encircled with a high-voltage fence. That will teach you to seek low-wage working picking our vegetables to feed your own family!!!

The "UNSENTENCED" labels in the midst of the "we're doing everything to portray you as dangerous and guilty" pageantry is the ultimate irony -- despite Arapaio's best attempts, the men he is trying to dehumanize remain human, fathers, brothers, sons trying to pursue the same dreams dangled in front of generations before.

Still, hats off to Sheriff Arpaio who, while he could be spending his time pursuing fraudulent mortgage brokers or mini Madoffs, is doing his part to whip up anti-immigrant furor among those who truly have bigger problems but find scapegoating immigrants much easier than imagining a new economic paradigm of justice for all. What better way to ignore your own shackles than to shackle others. Sheriff Arpaio is a real trailblazer in the right-wing shell game of denial.

Sheriff Joe Arpaio of Maricopa County, Arizona! Congratulations! This week, having already done everything imaginable to turn himself into a national right-wing celebrity by terrorizing undocument...
Sheriff Joe Arpaio of Maricopa County, Arizona! Congratulations! This week, having already done everything imaginable to turn himself into a national right-wing celebrity by terrorizing undocument...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:05 PM on 02/10/2009
You all need a reality check here. They are illegal aliens. You do not know their crime status and "assume" they are minor offenses against American citizens. Does this woman who wrote this article not know they are treated like every other inmate - same food, same clothing, same shakles?

How about Edward Chisman 88 years old took a day trip across the Mexican border with his grandson who was in need of dental work.

Mexican police arrested the pair Jan. 8 on pornography charges after Gary Chrisman took a photo of two fully clothed young women in a convenience store in Algodones, Mexico.

After Gary Chrisman's dental work, the pair stopped at a convenience store. Edward Chrisman waited in the car while his grandson went to buy a soda. Gary Chrisman said he asked a family in the convenience store if he could pay them $25 to take their photos. He'd been taking photos of Mexican culture all day with a new camera.

The mother granted permission and took his money. He snapped headshots of her two daughters, 17 and 18, and left the store.

The elder Chrisman never got out of the car.

Local police arrested both men a few minutes later. Their money, passports and other belongings were taken. The pair were placed in a holding cell in Morelos. The charge: "intent for pornography."
07:13 PM on 02/06/2009
The problem here in Maricopa County is not Arpaio as much as the local news media's willingness to serve as his loyal shills whenever he pulls publicity stunts like these, as he does on a regular basis. That the local TV stations eat everything out of this man's hand is a greater shame than his actions, appalling as they are.

The ONLY thing that will stop this man's endless string of human rights abuses is federal intervention. The local media serves no other purpose than to serve Arpaio's need for self-aggrandizement at the expense of others.
04:22 PM on 02/06/2009
Jake, ironically illegal immigrants are the most law abiding people in the country. Study after study has shown they don't commit crimes because if they do, they get deported and can no longer send home money to feed their families. Another myth is that they use public services but don't pay taxes. The majority of them pay taxes they don't qualify for the bast majority of public services and the few they do get, they rarely use. They're helping propping up social security right now because they pay into it don't qualify for it.
http://www.truthinimmigration.org/Myths.aspx
04:20 PM on 02/06/2009
We should never deny anyone in our country due process and human rights. See a pregnant woman who was detained and shackled speak of the harmful impact of agreement 287(g) between local police and federal immigration authorities, which also enables people like Sheriff Arpaio to enforce unfair immigration policies.
http://www.breakthrough.tv/product_detail.asp?proid=130&id=7

Also check out www.homelandgitmo.com
photo
JakeMontero
Independent thinking
04:04 PM on 02/06/2009
I must admit I have mixed emotions about illegal aliens. Some of these folks are just looking for work to take care of their families BUT unfortunately the jails are filled in the southwest with undocumented worker/illegal aliens who are charges w/ horrific crimes. Mexico is cratering and it will only get worse.

We have enough problems in this country taking care of our own citizens.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cadsuch
A 70 retired construction worker/truck driver
06:26 PM on 02/06/2009
As long as we are fighting each other we are helpless with the Oligarchy. Aliens are here to make this happen!
12:52 PM on 02/07/2009
JakeM, I'd like some data on your assertion that "...the jails are filled in the southwest with undocumented worker/illegal aliens who are charge(d) w/horrific crimes." I'd like data showing the jailed population total and the exact number/per centage of the population that undocumented immigrants comprise of that total. Then, I'd like data showing the types of crimes that they are charged and/or convicted of. Thank you.
12:48 PM on 02/06/2009
These people broke the law. We are at war. Remember? The first rule of war is to allow alien residents to sneak into your country and then protect them?
photo
kathy001
Don't bogart that duck
01:19 PM on 02/06/2009
Yeah, all these migrant pickers have me shaking in my boots.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Gidster
Not so much Liberal as I am anti evil.
07:16 PM on 02/06/2009
No. We are not at war with Latin America Bronceye,
We are at war with an idea, an intangible concept that our court appointed President gleefully worked into a shooting war for profit!.

These immigrants are looking for a better life, not for violence and mayhem! Lumping them in with terrorist is just ignorant.

Be vigilant not fearful!
photo
kathy001
Don't bogart that duck
12:30 PM on 02/06/2009
Good for Joe! He's worked hard for this award. I can't think of anyone who is more deserving.....this week, at least.
12:15 PM on 02/06/2009
Arpaio is why the Framers put the Eighth Amendment into the Constitution.
photo
Aldyth
Advocating for those who cannot defend themselves.
09:32 AM on 02/06/2009
I don't have much sympathy for illegal aliens, but there isn't any sound reason to treat them in humiliating ways while they are in jail.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
mexamerican
professor
09:54 AM on 02/06/2009
wow, your humanity is overwhelming!
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Gidster
Not so much Liberal as I am anti evil.
09:22 PM on 02/06/2009
I understand where he is coming from. I don't think Aldyth meant to sound insensitive.
Illegals that get caught should not be subject to humiliation anymore than anyone else.

That is what Arpaio is, a sadist that found a whole class of helpless people to abuse for his own enjoyment.

I have seen his smug, ridiculous justifications of his outdoor jail and pink underwear and they fall very short of plausible. This is a county jail, not a supermax! He charges inmates for their food as well. They must work on chain gangs which contribute thousands of dollars of free labor to the community. The male chain gang, and the world’s first-ever female and juvenile chain gangs!

Inmates are not paid for work they do, but they are charged $2 for meals, (That cost less than a dollar) which are baloney sandwiches and only received twice a day. They are also forced to pay for their own medical care while in Arpaio's jail.

There is tough on criminals, then there is dehumanizing them for personal gain.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:00 AM on 02/06/2009
I challenge the sherriff to find Americans who will work for $2 an hour in 95 degree weather, picking vegetables. If we have no one to perform this strenuous and back breaking labor, WHERE will we get our food from BUT South America.... where pesticides are unregulated and used like they're going out of style.

We might want to rethink the whole immigrant laborer issue. I'm sure there is some sort of a fair solution.
12:45 PM on 02/06/2009
These people don't pick veggies, anymore. Here in Las Vegas, there are no farms. Why are there so many here????? Do you know that you can sponsor these people? Put them up in your house and feed them? How many have you?
01:43 PM on 02/06/2009
There are only three solutions to this and they have to be applied all at once: First, the United States needs to stop outsourcing jobs to Mexico and instead help Mexico to build its own economy rather than depending on ours. Many of the companies outsourcing to Mexico (read the automakers) are in trouble. Second, the US needs to stop cracking down on the immigrants than themselves and start sanctioning employers who violate labor laws. Third, we need to open up our border to free immigration so that all the workers who cross the border are legally documented. Legal, easy immigration destroys the incentive to come illegally which eliminates the availability of under the table labor. Everyone is subject to employment laws, everyone pays their taxes, and some modicum of fairness is restored to the job market.

Know-nothings telling you the immigrants themselves are the problem are attempting to exploit your fears to get you to vote for them so they can keep subsidizing and shielding the corporations responsible for the real problem.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Gidster
Not so much Liberal as I am anti evil.
01:51 PM on 02/08/2009
Bronceye,

Who do you think washes the dishes, does the laundry cleans the rooms and runs the fryolater at the casinos?
12:08 AM on 02/06/2009
First of all “undocumented immigrants†are illegal aliens. That means they entered this country illegally. They probably snuck into this country through the desert, swam across the Rio Grande, or were hidden in a truck or car. So immediately they are law breakers. You make them out as just “Latino immigrants†and that is incorrect. Latino immigrants have been issued residency documents. The intention of illegal aliens is to obtain work without first obtaining a social security card that would define their legal rights.

When they these Latinos commited crimes they were arrested. When it was determined they were not in the United States legally they were segregated from the American population. Humiliation is the least of their problems. They deserve more than that. Although I feel sorry for their plight, the United States cannot be the destinaton for thes poor and uneducated people of Mexico. It is not our reponsibility to fix their problems. The Mexican government should be held responsible even if that means reduced relations with that country.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
mexamerican
professor
09:56 AM on 02/06/2009
hey, you benefit from undocumented workers, bub. there is never any reason to humiliate people, especially folks who come this country to work. and don't give me that "you feel sorry for their plight." the very last thing you feel is compassion. that's obvious.
12:07 PM on 02/06/2009
I don't see any benefits from undocumented workers, after you factor in the billions they cost us in the long run. Maybe the price of a piece of fruit is less, but is the savings worth throwing out the rule of law? I think not. Come in through the front door or don't come at all. If we stem the tide of illegals flooding in we can force the mexican govt. to change their crooked ways.
02:10 PM on 02/06/2009
"They probably snuck into this country through the desert, swam across the Rio Grande, or were hidden in a truck or car. So immediately they are law breakers. You make them out as just "Latino immigrants" and that is incorrect. Latino immigrants have been issued residency documents."

The reason they are 'illegal immigrants' is because, in the 1950s, the laws were changed to make them so. Prior to that, we had an open immigration policy in the Americas: citizens of countries in North and South America were free to immigrate to the US without restriction. This created the illegal immigration problem of today, because it created an illegal workforce exempt from labor laws and minimum wage because they did not officially exist. This has greatly benefited American business.

Undocumented immigrants work in agriculture, in restaurants, in hotels, in meat-packing, in domestic housekeeping. Corporations and wealthy Americans profit from them and know-nothing politicians attack the immigrants rather than the reasons for the problem. No one is locking hotel owners in concentration camps for employing undocumented maids, they are locking up the maids for taking the job.

Think about that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
baseballmom
Proud to be an Amercian.
08:10 PM on 02/05/2009
Joe the Sheriff should show a little compassion. Is there any one of us who would NOT sneak into another country and work illegally so that we could feed and clothe our children?
12:46 AM on 02/06/2009
I'd be willing to bet the word "compassion" is not in the job description of any law officer in this country. Most are hired because they're easily led thugs and bullies who have a deficiency that induces them to seek power, however meager.
10:25 AM on 02/06/2009
I am with you. We should fire all law officers.