EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Sammy Perlmutter

Sammy Perlmutter

Posted: September 3, 2010 05:20 AM

This month, the Library of America will publish a stunning box set containing six of Lynd Ward's wordless "novels-in-woodcut." Over 1,600 pages thick and packaged in a deep red, the box set feels and looks like a brick -- a desperate effort, perhaps, to reassert the durability of the printed page in the era of the eBook. Anachronistic as it is, however, Ward's box set can actually serve as a useful example of how authors should innovate into the future.

Award-wining comics artist Art Spiegelman writes in the introduction to the edition: "Lynd Ward made books. He had an abiding reverence for the book as an object. He understood its anatomy, respected every aspect of its production, intimately knew its history, and loved its potential to engage an audience. This is one of the reasons he commands our attention now, when the book as an object seems under siege."

"Under siege," indeed, especially as eBooks begin to outsell hardcover books and authors and publishers vow to stop printing on paper.

So, with this in mind, how exactly can a printed book teach authors to evolve?

Widely recognized as the "founder of the graphic novel," Ward introduced the form to America with his 1929 novel "Gods' Man," a narrative told entirely in pictures. Radical as a formal practice, the wordless novel was also a political art form in its ability to communicate a message through the universal language of pictures. Perhaps the form's most provocative aspect -- in regard to both storytelling and political innovation -- can be witnessed in its application to books for children.

Having illustrated books for children himself, including the Caldecott Medal winning "The Biggest Bear," Ward's influence on picture books has stretched widely. Some highlights of the genre include: David Wiesner's "Flotsam," Shaun Tan's "The Arrival," Jerry Pinkey's "The Lion and the Mouse," and Brian Selznick's "The Invention of Hugo Cabret." In terms of innovation, however, none seems to surpass Barbara Lehman's "Red Book," a book about, well, a book.

Lehman's "Red Book" follows a day in the life of a little girl who reads her own "red book" and discovers that inside her "red book" another child reads his own "red book" ... and so on. When a child reads Lehman's "The Red Book," she must perceive and interpret the images and then piece the pictures together to form a cohesive narrative. This process empowers the reader by requiring her to construct a storyline and by enabling her to interact with the book.

Put differently: a novel without words can elevate its reader to a level of authority equal to -- or beyond -- that of the author. One message of wordless books, then, is that the reader is simultaneously an author ... or, at the very least, an active participant who can think critically about, question and critique the story in front of her. As a result, when a child reads a wordless book, she inherently learns how to be a critic, not just a passive observer, of a text.

Books lacking this interactivity are not only boring, but can also be dangerous, especially in our digital age when messages and media spew at us from a million directions at a mile a minute.

Unfortunately, technological efforts to innovate have fallen short. Sure, there has been some creative progress with content for the iPad. Textbooks, for example, now feature 3D graphics and videos, and there's an App that makes picture books accessible to deaf and blind children. And companies such as Vook have also started to merge text and video into a cohesive unit.

Nevertheless, all these so-called interactive forms of media remain systems wherein one voice dictates a narrative. The author -- or editor or producer or programmer -- will impose not only a narrative, but a manufactured message, of his own sole design. As media proliferates in the digital age, we need ways to teach children how to decipher what they see, hear and read and ultimately separate the good from the bad, the legitimate from the phony, the right from the wrong.

Despite the technological marvels of various eReaders, none of them approach the level of invention or edification that the wordless book does. In the end, I wonder: Are eBooks changing the way we read stories, or are they merely changing the way we receive them?

I believe that wordless novels present a fresh and unique way to understand and interpret a narrative. That's why I urge authors, editors, programmers, etcetera, to go and read books like Ward's to gain new ideas of how to truly break ground.

"Two years after meeting Lynd Ward, when I was beginning to seriously explore the limits and possibilities of comics, I drew a four-page comics story about my mother's suicide," Spiegelman writes in the collection's introduction. The panels to which he refers were eventually included in the revolutionary comic book "Maus." Let's follow Spiegelman's example and look to Ward for how to create revolutionary content -- printed, digital or otherwise -- into the future.

 
This month, the Library of America will publish a stunning box set containing six of Lynd Ward's wordless "novels-in-woodcut." Over 1,600 pages thick and packaged in a deep red, the box set feels and ...
This month, the Library of America will publish a stunning box set containing six of Lynd Ward's wordless "novels-in-woodcut." Over 1,600 pages thick and packaged in a deep red, the box set feels and ...
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Plissken
It tastes like... chicken.
12:18 PM on 09/06/2010
The printing press...
olddognewtrick
Half full or half empty...It's the same
07:10 PM on 09/05/2010
eBabes?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Mahi Joe
Think critically...not blindly conform
08:16 AM on 09/05/2010
I find the concept of a wordless novel intriquing because when looking at the images do you not form words in your head which describe what you are viewing so in essence you become a co-author by providing your own words.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Keith
Dogs are the best people.
07:25 AM on 09/05/2010
'Widely recognized as the "founder of the graphic novel"...?­?? What are you talking about? That's completely untrue.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Keith
Dogs are the best people.
07:29 AM on 09/05/2010
Thought that was Will Eisner's "A Contract with God".
05:52 PM on 09/04/2010
What is a printing press?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lolyla
Now what?
11:55 AM on 09/04/2010
Nothing mentioned in this article is an innovation bigger than the ebook - especially a "wordless novel."
photo
TheBaffler
a long the riverrun
10:53 PM on 09/04/2010
What silliness. Without printing and all its attendant innovation­s, the lowly ebook wouldn't even exist.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:21 AM on 09/04/2010
The next big thing will be shrinking the words down, and displaying them one word at a time, in rapid succession­, onto an eye sized screen housed in a frame worn on the head like eyeglasses­.

When words are flashed one at a time, to a stationary eye...the reader's words per minute count bursts through the roof. Assimilati­on of informatio­n is vastly more efficient.

After that, we'll do away with analog interfaces altogether with direct digital uploads via either plugging into a module brain implant or wireless transmissi­on. Sometime after that...we'­ll graduate past digital with quantum level transmissi­ons into the brain's visual cortex.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deweydecimal
@DeweyMai on Twitter
09:04 PM on 09/06/2010
Sorry don't buy it, analog signals are also denser than the equivalent digital signal. Considerin­g the parallelis­m of the human brain and the complex interactio­ns within it to produce cognition, there will always be room for the written language. I would predict more multiplexi­ng in our language, layers and layers of meaning using multidimen­sional glyphs rather than a digital stream of data. Our brains thrive on it.
06:45 AM on 09/04/2010
This is really great. I think all books should be wordless.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lev Raphael
Author,Blogger,Reviewer
07:43 AM on 09/04/2010
from the novel The Enchanted April: "I hate authors I wouldn't mind them so much if they didn't write books."
olddognewtrick
Half full or half empty...It's the same
07:12 PM on 09/05/2010
sorry to disappoint you but the ink probably makes them burn faster...
12:38 PM on 09/03/2010
I don’t know whether wordless storytelli­ng can be considered much of an innovation since Cro-Magnon man was drawing something very similar on cave walls fifty thousand years ago. It seems that only the medium is changing. I am at present working on a wordless novel based on recent history called The American Bestiary that will be published by www.nonsto­p-press.co­m in 2012 solely as an eBook edition. The finished book will utilized animation in some sections, and I’m still trying to decide if is ok to use music and sound effects in a wordless book.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
proggirl
college teacher, artist, writer
04:23 PM on 09/04/2010
Now THAT'S problemati­c. How many mediums can be added before it stops being a book? Animation, music, sound effects- starts to seem like a Flash animation at that point. It's a great concept, but don't add so much that you lose sight of your goal.
02:19 PM on 09/05/2010
Yes, it is a big problem – I want to have something at the end that relates more to a book than a flash or a Powerpoint presentati­on. Images alone in the work of Lynd Ward and Frans Masereel are able to tell a powerful story. But it may possible that a true wordless novel in eBook form may become something like a mule – a sterile hybrid offspring – and what's really needed for this type of storytelli­ng is a paper book.
olddognewtrick
Half full or half empty...It's the same
07:13 PM on 09/05/2010
Right...yo­u probably thought all of those calls from Marcel Marceau were prank calls...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KalNJ
09:22 AM on 09/03/2010
lBooks (Legacy Books) aren't dead, far from it and eBooks are doing more for the book industry than any other gimmick people will come out with. eBooks are just starting to get popular and I'm willing to bet that the format of the eBooks, whether it would be enhanced eBooks or ads in eBooks, will change within a few short years.

Some books are meant to be read on paper and not on screen, comics and graphic heavy books are a prime example. Until, that is, we'll get a colored eReader which is affordable and displays crisp graphics.

Once publishers will realize what a gold mine eBooks are and the informatio­n that can be extracted from them (reading habits, download vs. read vs. read and not finished, immediate feedback, demographi­cs, etc.) you'll see the business change in leaps and bounds.

Book Reviews: http://www­.ManOfLaBo­ok.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
proggirl
college teacher, artist, writer
06:18 PM on 09/04/2010
True, but then you're going to have issues with color shifts on different monitors. The best way to get consistent output remains a printing press. And with POD, your quality control increases.
The other issue is that publishers are going to do the same thing many music distributo­rs have done and charge the same price for a download they do for hard copy, thereby k1ll1ng the market yet again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frank day
More Liberals Equals More Liberty
09:46 PM on 09/06/2010
Who needs publishers­? Seriously. The good thing about ebooks is that anyone can get 'published­'. The bad thing about ebooks is that anyone can get 'published­'.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
deweydecimal
@DeweyMai on Twitter
09:07 PM on 09/06/2010
Books are heavy. I'd rather have a great colour ebook reader.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lev Raphael
Author,Blogger,Reviewer
08:42 AM on 09/03/2010
I'm curious to know how writers who live with and in the word can do this:

"I believe that wordless novels present a fresh and unique way to understand and interpret a narrative. That's why I urge authors, editors, programmer­s, etcetera, to go and read books like Ward's to gain new ideas of how to truly break ground. "

The advice seems almost parodic.
03:59 PM on 09/03/2010
Well, to be fair, let me offer a perspectiv­e. For many years I ran a design firm in Silicon Valley. One of the services we provided was helping technical writers communicat­e more clearly to their audience. If the readers were technicall­y savvy, they often lacked time to read through an entire manual. If they were innocents in the technical jungle, it wasn't in the scope of the documents to educate them; all we could do was tell them how to work a specific thingie.

First rule of thumb I used to tell writers: if you've spent three sentences describing something, consider an illustrati­on. If you have a process to explain, consider an illustrati­on. If you have a marketing narrative that you need to get across to your audience, and you'll only have a few seconds to reach them, consider an illustrati­on. Reason? A complicate­d message can be encoded into an illustrati­on that can be comprehend­ed by the viewer in an instant. Writers got this instantly the minute I handed them a comic book.

This doesn't mean words and writers are going the way of the dodo; exactly the opposite. It's that the craft of writing does not solely reside in the little symbols we call letters. Writers are more essential than ever. They won't be replaced by illustrato­rs, it will be more like how directors work with cinematogr­aphers.

Hope this helps.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Schiavo
Poet
06:29 PM on 09/03/2010
"The Instructio­n Manual" by John Ashbery

http://www­.poetryfou­ndation.or­g/archive/­poem.html?­id=177261
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lev Raphael
Author,Blogger,Reviewer
07:20 AM on 09/04/2010
Got it.

You're not talking about poets and writers of fiction or even creative nonfiction­.