iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Scott Morgan

GET UPDATES FROM Scott Morgan
 

Fixing Our Drug Policy Will Require A Hatchet, Not A Scalpel

Posted: 12/08/11 10:58 AM ET

Two different staffers at the Drug Czar's office have both used the same word recently to describe Obama's approach to drug policy. That word, if you can believe it, is reform. It's a term I use an awful lot myself, and I must admit I'm more than a little intrigued to find Obama's top anti-drug officials co-opting the catchphrases of their critics.

Here's Rafael Lemaitre, a spokesman for the Drug Czar, making the case here in the Huffington Post that Obama's approach to drug policy is something new and dramatically different than what we've seen in the past:

The complexity and scale of our drug problem requires a nationwide effort to support smart drug policies that reduce drug use and its consequences. Since day one, the Obama Administration has been engaged in an unprecedented government-wide effort to reform our nation's drug policies and restore balance to the way we deal with the drug problem. We have pursued a variety of alternatives that abandon an unproductive enforcement-only "War on Drugs" approach to drug control and acknowledge we cannot arrest our way out of the drug problem and, further, that drug addiction is a disease of the brain, not some "moral failing."

It sounds pretty exciting, doesn't it? If you'd never followed the issue until now, you might come away with the impression that fundamental changes are taking place. But many of us in the drug policy reform movement have been following this issue for a long time, and memory serves us quite a bit more faithfully than you might infer based on our constant insistence that the law not prohibit us from consuming certain substances.

A decade ago, the Bush Administration was making the same claims we hear from Obama today:

"The president has a balanced approach to the problem of drug abuse in America that emphasizes both treatment and prevention," White House spokeswoman Anne Womack said. "We're confident that John Walters will do an excellent job of implementing the president's vision." [USA Today]

Examples of the Bush administration's self-proclaimed commitment to a "balanced approach to drug control" are abundant, but I chose this one because of its shudderingly ironic same-breath endorsement of John "Unbalanced Approach" Walters to serve as the nation's Drug Czar. Walters went on to badly shatter the credibility of that office, all the while insisting that he was restoring balance to our anti-drug programs and perfecting a formula for success that was vindicated repeatedly according to numerous press releases from and studies commissioned by... John Walters.

Under Obama, we're still spending more on enforcement and interdiction than prevention and treatment, and we're still being told that we ought to be proud of the balanced approach that the President's anti-drug officials have prepared. Obama's budget is a bit more balanced than Bush's, and corrects some serious accounting shell games, but it still spends its bulk on busting and burning our way to a future free of violence, destruction, and people smoking marijuana in their basements. It appears not to be working.

Nevertheless, Lemaitre's remarks do reflect a rather remarkable phenomenon in the drug policy debate: the president and his top anti-drug officials are trying to soften their image when it comes to drugs. That much is pretty clear, and pretty interesting to see when you consider the history of the issue. Despite our disappointment with the substance of Obama's policy on controlled substances, we can and should applaud the President for at least understanding that the thoughtless tough-on-drugs pandering of the 80s and 90s has no place in modern American politics.

We want change, and it's obvious from the rhetoric we're hearing lately that our message hasn't fallen entirely on deaf ears. The Obama Administration's efforts to acknowledge the problems with our drug policy, however disingenuous and insufficient as they may be, are still a welcome departure from the days when politicians spoke only of packing more muscle onto the long arm of the law. If there's any hope of replacing decades of kneejerk drug war idiocy with an actual adult conversation, I suppose that process would begin more or less like this.

 

Follow Scott Morgan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/drugblogger

 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:38 AM on 12/11/2011
Obama says one thing and does another.He is a drug war advocate by deed if not by speech.Every time he makes a conciliatory speech it is followed by a series of drug raids in states with medical cannabis.If he came out tomorrow and said he was looking at legalisation I would expect a huge crackdown on possession charges to follow.
09:47 AM on 12/10/2011
Cannabis prohibition is the Atlas which holds up our entire economy, from Big Pharma to Big Oil and the prison-industrial complex. To end it would be corporate suicide.
Hatchet? This is a job for a bulldozer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
yasunari
Video meliora, proboque, deteriora sequor
08:30 AM on 12/14/2011
TNT...
08:16 AM on 12/10/2011
It's so encouraging to see a lot of people behind this. The "War On Drugs" has done not much more then support the corporate private prison system with easy income. 60% of all prisoners in the US police state are non violent drug offenders. Think about all of the money that a private prison gets.. Each prisoner fetches a nice $50,000 per year! Now remember, who is paying for that? The American Tax Payers of course. Not to mention that the state run prisons are costing a fortune as well. They are overcrowded and are doing nothing to "help" the non violent offenders.
11:28 PM on 12/09/2011
The administration’s tone reflects the tone of the country. Draconian on drugs is a recognized extremist position. The pummeling given the drug war by writers and activists such as Scott Morgan and others has produced a legalistic foundation filled with cracks. Growing within these cracks is a happy little weed known to millions as marijuana, sending out its invincible roots in every possible direction and causing prohibition to crumble into dust.

It’s truly time to reflect on the substance of one’s own government when a simple plant can thwart a $50-billion per year judicial-industrial-military complex; and not only that, do it in style.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rational Voice
A voice of reason in a world gone insane
08:03 PM on 12/09/2011
American drug "reform" is quite simple:

1) Remove cannabis from the list of scheduled substances completely -- just like alcohol and tobacco. It must be legalized, and actually regulated to be "controlled".

2) Decriminalize ALL other illicit drugs

Anything short of that is just more madness.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
No death panels
There's no man with a trumpet. Only me.
12:17 AM on 12/14/2011
Wanna legalize crack?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rational Voice
A voice of reason in a world gone insane
11:27 AM on 12/14/2011
"Decriminalize", at least ... "legalize"? I don't see why not, but more debate is needed. What we know for sure is that prohibition absolutely does not work. Alcohol is a deadly, dangerous, and addictive drug -- it directly causes violence, sexual assaults, and death. I don't think the link to violence and sexual assault is as strong with crack -- it's biggest problem is that it's too easy to overdose on it ... but that's just natural selection. No reason we should be stopping that -- interfering with natural selection is NOT good for the gene pool. :-)
10:34 PM on 12/29/2011
Freedom ! The government has no right to tell me what I can do with my body. Free the WEED! (old republican i am)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Gudzikowski
free,natural,harmless,individual
01:54 AM on 12/09/2011
"I say lets bury the hatchet" america let your people go! Being wrong for 40yrs is enugh.
06:09 PM on 12/08/2011
The tragedy for drug producing and distributing countries in general, and Latin American countries in particular, is that US policy on drugs is entirely consistent with, and an expression of, “America’s grand-strategic tradition”. The whole point of Prohibition & the War on Drugs policies has always been to try to isolate the US from the highest costs it would have to pay in case it wanted, as it should, pursue those policies domestically. Instead, the US imposes them on drug producing and distributing countries.

That is the crux of the matter: Prohibition & the War on Drugs policies are inextricably intertwined with US foreign policy and when it comes to foreign policy it is irrelevant who is elected president of the US.Thererefore, there is no reason to expect Obama to be the exception — it cannot get more ironic that he even received the Nobel Prize for Peace, for goodness sake, for PEACE. Honestly, he should apologise to the world and return it, interests included, immediately!

It explains why a country that swaggers about lecturing everybody about the rule of law, democracy and human rights, ignores international law, practices extraordinary rendition, tortures, wages illegal wars, finances mercenaries, uses unmanned drones to carry out extra-judicial killings, and is the largest beneficiary of the war on drugs proceeds.
03:58 PM on 12/08/2011
Everyone knows it is wrong to imprison people for Marijuana but without the incarceration side effect, the value of Weed would dwindle to almost nothing. And with no value there is no drug money to sieze, no cross border smuggling operations to inderdict, and the drug warriors would lose there livelyhoods. It doesn't make good sense for the American Government to put all these beneficiaries of the War on Weed out of work. WE NEED JOBS!
02:20 PM on 12/08/2011
Legalize already! Prohibition does not work.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Oldchef
Former Executive Chef, tr0ll watcher
01:48 PM on 12/08/2011
There have been a number of studies showing marijuana's effectiveness against different tumors, in controlling nausea from chemotherapy, in alleviating muscle pain, help with asthma, etc., etc. With proper medical studies, there are probably more benefits available from this herb which grows all over the world, not to mention the many industrial uses of hemp and hemp seed oil. Despite all that, all requests for studies are being refused by our government, and the Justice Dept. is hassling state officials where medical marijuana has been legalized.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
blackraisin
Life, Liberty, Property.
03:51 PM on 12/08/2011
Not to mention potential tax revenue.
03:49 PM on 12/09/2011
cures cancer. why deal with chemo when you can just ingest it?
hx4354x0r
Computing geek, Hackysacker.
12:07 PM on 12/08/2011
The Drug War kills people. The drug itself does not. Cannabis is completely non-toxic. This, alone, should be reason enough to completely stand down from cannabis prohibition.

Before anyone goes ballistic about meth and all that stuff, review the numbers first: more than half of all anti-drug expenditures, from law enforcement to incarceration and everything in between, are focused solely on cannabis. Not because it's a particularly harmful drug, mind you... it's just low hanging fruit. The fact that cannabis stands alone as a non-toxic drug that's never directly killed anyone means we can talk about legalization, without getting into the infinitive argument about then having to legalize *all* currently illegal drugs.

Furthermore, cannabis is knowns to produce over 70 unique cannabinoids. The endocannabinoid receptor system is the single largest such system in our body, being found in virtually every type of tissue. All those keys... all those locks... Cannabis has already been clinically proven, in placebo controlled, double-blind trials, to have real value as medicine. This is a call for more research, not the Leonhardt-inspired violent attacks on cannabis users.

Sure, cannabis use causes problems. I don't deny that. But the damage from prohibition is a million times worse. Legalize it, regulate it, tax it if you feel it's necessary. But for God's sake at least stop violently attacking and incarcerating people for using the stuff!
12:02 PM on 12/08/2011
Does this mean that our predatory "law enforcement" will stop praying on college kids? I understand, they are an easy target for an undercover sting operation. It's much more difficult to "deal" their crackhead, gun-toting counterpart. Shooting fish in a barrel, it works until you turn an entire culture against your failed policies. Shame on you Obama. Won't be voting for you again, I'll go with the candidate that I know will take a stand against this war.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
fumes
Midnight Toker
11:08 AM on 12/08/2011
''.. drug use and its consequences.''
------------------------------
Worth Repeating
​By Ron Marczyk, R.N.
Health Education Teacher (Retired)

Did you see the medicinal cannabis science report in The New York Times on February 16?

In summary, the report says the great sense of euphoria and calm that many people report experiencing after prolonged exercise ("the runner's high") is not so much governed by the endorphins as "now an emerging field of neuroscience indicates that an altogether different neurochemical system within the body and brain, the endocannabinoid system, may be responsible for that feeling" of "pure happiness, elation, a feeling of unity with one's self and/or nature, endless peacefulness," and "inner harmony."
Ongoing discoveries, which are starting to dominate research on the endocannabinoid system, are validating the ancient stories of healing mind and body with this non-toxic plant.
Only as recently as 1992 did medical researchers discover this previously unknown, body-wide neurocellular receptor system that controls or regulates almost every function in the body, by apparently bringing the mind and body back to a state of homeostasis after being stressed by the environment. This system is the "wisdom of the body" that we all experience as the body "just knowing how to fix itself" after illness. This system is the very definition of wellness!
http://www.tokeofthetown.com/2011/03/worth_repeating_bodys_own_cannabinoids_are_the_bli.php
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marijobama
Prohibition is NOT an enumerated power.
11:57 AM on 12/08/2011
Good post. This is the kind of great information that all of us can use to counter the reefer madness boilerplate that many still have imprinted in their brains. I'm gonna show it to my mom!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
fumes
Midnight Toker
01:58 PM on 12/08/2011
show mom this too:

Studies to Discover the Full Potential of Marijuana's Benefits

Already scientists, researchers and doctors have discovered a wide range of benefits unequaled by any other natural or chemical medication, ever. Period.

No other medication or herb offers relief from symptoms like these:
Relief of muscle spasms
Relief of chronic pain
Reduction in interlobular pressure inside the eye
Suppression of nausea
Weight loss - increase and restore metabolism

No other medication or herb offers treatment from a wide variety of diseases like these:
AIDS - Marijuana can reduce the nausea, loss of appetite, vomiting from the condition itself and the medications as well.
Glaucoma - Marijuana relieves the internal eye pressure of glaucoma, and therefore relieving the pain and slowing or even stopping the condition.
Cancer- Many side effects of the medication to stop cancer can be relieve with Marijuana, some studies suggest that Marijuana tends to slow down the progress of some types of cancer.
Multiple Sclerosis - Muscle pain, spasticity, tremors and unsteadiness are some of the effects caused by the disease that can be relieved by Marijuana.
Epilepsy - in some patients, epileptic seizures can be prevented with Marijuana use.
Chronic pain - Marijuana helps to alleviate the pain caused from many types of injuries and disorders.
Anxiety, Depression or Obsession - Even though mild anxiety is a common side effect in some users, cannabis can elevate your mood and expand the mind.
http://www.health-be.com/2011/05/is-marijuana-wonder-drug-that-could.html
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marijobama
Prohibition is NOT an enumerated power.
12:25 PM on 12/08/2011
Good post. Thanks for the info. I can't say anything else, or I'll get sensored (I might anyway) Is it my breath?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
fumes
Midnight Toker
12:49 PM on 12/08/2011
it's your breadth