iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Sen. Patrick Leahy

Sen. Patrick Leahy

Posted: May 21, 2009 03:05 PM

Time to Support the President and Close the Facility at Guantanamo Bay


President Obama said in his campaign and he has repeated since the first days of his presidency that we must keep our nation safe and secure, but we must do it in ways consistent with our values. Now that is a sentiment I share, and one that I voiced in hearings and statements for years as well. And to President Obama's credit and to the benefit of the Nation, he has worked since his first day in office to turn these words into action and to make our national security policy and our detainee policy consistent with American laws and American values. And that, in turn, makes us more secure.

I have supported President Obama in these steps, and I will continue to do so. That is why I have voted against amendments to withhold funding to close the Guantanamo detention facility and to prohibit any Guantanamo detainees from being brought to the United States. These amendments undermine the good work the president is doing, and they make us less safe, not safer.

I believe strongly, as all Americans do, that we must take every step we can to prevent terrorism, and we must ensure severe punishments for those who do us harm. As a former prosecutor, I have never shied away from harsh sentences for those who commit atrocious acts. I point out that at times, I've requested -- and gotten -- for people I prosecuted, life sentences where they served without parole.

I believe strongly that we can ensure our safety and security, and bring terrorists to justice, in ways that are consistent with our laws and values. When we have strayed from that approach -- when we have tortured people in our custody, or sent people to other countries to be tortured, or held people for years without even giving them the chance to go to court to argue that they were being held in error -- we have hurt our national security immeasurably. Our allies have been less willing to help our counter-terrorism efforts. That's made our military men and women more vulnerable and our country less safe. Terrorists have used our actions as a tool to recruit new members, which means we must fend off more enemies. Worse still, we have lost our ability to respond with moral authority if other countries should mistreat American soldiers or civilians.

Guantanamo has become the symbol of the severe missteps that our country took in recent years. Changing our interrogation policies to ban torture was an essential first step. But only by shutting the Guantanamo facility down and restoring tough but fair procedures can we repair our image in the world. We have to do that if we hope to have a truly strong national security policy. To close Guantanamo, we need our national security and legal experts working hard to come up with a comprehensive plan for its closure, and we should be funding those efforts. By cutting off that funding, we have hamstrung the president's initiative, no matter what we intended to do. I believe we have made our nation less safe.

Much debate has focused on keeping Guantanamo detainees out of the United States. In this debate, political rhetoric has entirely drowned out reason and reality. Our criminal justice system handles extremely dangerous criminals, and more than a few terrorists, and it does so safely and effectively. We try very dangerous people in our courts and hold very dangerous people in our jails in Vermont and throughout the country. We have the best justice system in the world. We spend billions of dollars on our detention facilities, on our law enforcement, and our justice system. Are we going to say to the world that we're not good enough to be able to handle criminal cases of this nature? I don't believe so. We try these dangers people and we hold these dangerous people, in Vermont and throughout our country. We are showing we can do it. And I know; I put some of them there. We do it every day in ways that keep the American people safe and secure, and I have absolute confidence that we can do it for even the most dangerous terrorism suspects.

The Judiciary Committee has held several hearings on the issue of how to best handle detainees, and experts and judges from across the political spectrum have agreed that our courts and our criminal justice system can handle this challenge and indeed has handled it many times already. If after all these billions of dollars, after all the superb men and women we have working in our justice system, an all we spend on our maximum security facilities, are we going to say to the world, America is not strong enough to try the worst of these criminals? When we were hit with one of the worst terrorist attacks in this country, Oklahoma City, did we say we can't try these people we have no captured? We can't have them in a courtroom where it isn't secure? We cannot punish them? Of course not. We went ahead. We followed a system of justice. Having been horribly damaged in Oklahoma City, we followed our system of justice and the rest of the world looked at it and learned from us. Let's not step back from that. Republican luminaries like General Colin Powell have agreed with this idea. Republican member of the Judiciary Committee, Senator Graham, has said, "The idea that we cannot find a place to securely house 250-plus detainees within the United States is not rational."

Let's let reality come in and overwhelm rhetoric. It is time to act on our principles and our constitutional system. Those who we believe to be guilty of heinous crimes should be tried and punished severely. The courts and our prisons are more than up to the task. Those who are innocent should be released. There will be tough cases, and we should give the administration the resources it needs to find ways to dispose of those cases responsibly.

Let us put aside heated and distorted rhetoric and support the president in his efforts to truly make our country safe and strong and a republic worthy of the history and values that have always made America great. I believed that when I was a young lawyer in private practice. And I believed that when I was a prosecutor. I believe that even more today as a United States Senator.

President Obama said in his campaign and he has repeated since the first days of his presidency that we must keep our nation safe and secure, but we must do it in ways consistent with our values. Now...
President Obama said in his campaign and he has repeated since the first days of his presidency that we must keep our nation safe and secure, but we must do it in ways consistent with our values. Now...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 160
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
1088
07:47 PM on 05/24/2009
We have it made right now! Unfortunately, the Democrats is going blow it, for they do not know how to support our President, for their issues are more important than all American issues. They blew it in the 90's and they don't use history to learn. Our President uses history to succeed!!
06:44 PM on 05/24/2009
It is regretable but Pres Obama may no longer get support from the radical progressive or barely liberal sector. Pres Obama has become a clone of W by using W's policies & practices constantly. Military Commissions for Gitmo's inmates, contracting out torture of America's captives to foreign nations, escalating the war in Afghanistan by an infusion of US troops, continuing to use US troops to Iraq make Obama a clone of W. Obama is now W, Mark II. The USA can expect Pres Obama to become more like W as the days pass.
Pres Obama as W, Mark II, doesn't compute. It's a matter of GIGO. Who will the Democrats run in 2012 to replace the failed, war president, Obama? This is the time to induce Gen Powell to become a Democrat. He wouldn't be America's 1st black president; he'd have to settle for becoming America's best president, bar none. Gen Powell is well qualified to become POTUS.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
underoath
Crank up the crazy and rip off the knob !!
06:17 PM on 05/24/2009
I agree mr.leahy but it was your fellow senators that spit in the presidents face with there irrational vote on this this week. I hope that rational people can come together and close down the torture museum at guantanamo bay but when the vote went 90-6 it showed how scared the dems are of losing political ground rather then doing what is right.
03:49 PM on 05/24/2009
I recommend Senator Leahy to invite Dick Cheany and George Bush to the closing ceremony of the facility in the Guantanamo Bay, and publicly appreciate their leading role in eradicating one of embarrasing causes of the U.S. human rights abuses!!
03:29 PM on 05/24/2009
Thank you Senator Leahy for taking a principled clear stand on closing Guantanamo. I wonder if you could have a talk with your colleague Senator Harry Reid. Instead of standing with the President, he was one of the first to side with the Republicans. With friends like this, who needs enemies? My advice is to get a new Senate majority leader.
02:48 PM on 05/24/2009
I agree Mr. Leahy, It would have been nice if the Dems would have voted for the funding this week instead of against it. It just gave the Repubs & the MSM more ammo against the President. Harry Reid did not help either with his paranoia. If only they would have stood up to Bush the way they are standing up to a fellow dem things would be a lot different. The fear mongering must stop that will be the only way these matters will be dealt with rationally.
02:14 PM on 05/24/2009
A little bit of paint will hide a multitude of sin, why not just take the money they wanted to close it and build them a luxury prison at Guantanamo Bay.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rolf618
They call me Mr. Fahrenheit.
01:16 PM on 05/24/2009
Thank you Senator Leahy! Why aren't you the Senate Majority leader?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
brandnewstuff
01:04 PM on 05/24/2009
Gitmo is the worse development American War Criminals ever designed for their propaganda
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TJCole
01:04 PM on 05/24/2009
What worries me Senator is that 90% of our United States Senate showed, "Cowardice in the Face of the Enemy at a Time of War...!"

Combine that with Dick Cheney's fearful paranoia and abject cowardice, and any enemy would only be further encouraged to attack us, seeing our leaders are cowards...!

See what I mean...?

Happy Memorial Day Senator..!
11:53 AM on 05/24/2009
I am behind the president. YES close it. When the rightwing starts whining, ask them WHERE was THERE plan to end the war in Iraq. They didn't have one but they sent our troops and country there anyway.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mama4obama
11:51 AM on 05/24/2009
Wow! Some of the comments on here are ridiculous. These terrorists are not"guest". We can keep these people in the supermax prisons and no jury in the US would ever give them the possibility of parole. Also, to be so dismissive of the law enforcement officers that already guard over the 347 terrorists that are already in these jail is just insulting. This can be done. When in the world did the people serving us save 6 become so weak kneed and spineless. these are the same folks that criticized our President as not being tough enough to make hard decisions and they are the ones quaking in their 500.00 dollar shoes. Fear-mongering is what got us in this mess and I for one will not fall for this crap again. Democrats and Republicans need to grow a pair or I can lend them mine.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Pupadup4oBama
11:31 AM on 05/24/2009
Are we going to say to the world that we're not good enough to be able to handle criminal cases of this nature?

EXACTLY!!!
This is the way to get to that good old American ego!
09:29 AM on 05/24/2009
Yes yes, CLOSE IT ALREADY.....keep them in the middle of a mountain in Alaska where they don't dare try to escape, because if they do, the RAT-TA-TAT-TAT from the planes and helicopters will seal their fate. It may also spare the lives of some innocent wolves massacred yearly by Palin and the Aerial predators of innocent wildlife.
06:49 AM on 05/24/2009
yeah

lets close gitmo
lets close gitmo
lets close gitmo

D'oh what to do with our guests
D'oh what to do with our guests
D'oh what to do with our guests