I remember the first time a lady mag let me down. I was fourteen. Seventeen Magazine featured a small DIY segment before DIY was chic or marketable. "Turn the cuff of an old sweatshirt into a stylish headband!" chirped the copy. I did not let the fact that I had no sewing machine or any real knowledge of stitching stop me from wanting to look like the apple-cheeked brunette model in the feature, who seemed positively thrilled to be sporting her new, very stylish, sweet, sweet sweatshirt headband. I found a white sweatshirt I was willing to sacrifice, fished out my craft scissors, and got to work.
"Is that, like, a piece of a sweatshirt in your hair?" asked Matt, the cutest boy in my grade who I liked, loved, liked totally. My poor, over-stimulated pubescent brain started firing on all cylinders: "DENY!" screamed one part; "RUN AWAY!" screamed another; "OWN IT NO MATTER HOW TERRIBLE OR EMBARRASSING BECAUSE OMG MATT IS TALKING TO YOU!" I chose to listen to the third hormonal banshee because this is the fate of the hopelessly unhip: deluded into thinking that this one time, taking the path of cool might just pay off. It did not. "Yeah! I made it and everything!" I said a little too enthusiastically. "I can tell," said Matt with a smirk that turned into a giggle. Burn. I shrugged, pretending I could care less, which we both knew was a blazing lie. The "sweatshirt headband" situation dogged me for the rest of the year. Maybe it would have helped if I had not continued to wear it. Minor detail.
This was the first inkling I had that 'zine life and my life were never going to intersect. Like so many other young girls, I regularly picked up copies of magazines like Cosmo, Marie Claire, Seventeen, and SELF to follow style and make-up trends that I would never be able to pull off and to read sex tips I could barely pronounce let alone use. I read these magazines because some part of me wanted to look like the thin, pretty, fashion fabulous girls in the pages even as I knew I was a lost cause. But more than that, I read them because I thought that's what you did as a girl; I thought that the rules of doing girl culture the "right way," meaning the way of flawless skin and shiny hair and bathing suits that didn't ride up over your non-breasts were secreted in the pages somewhere between the perfume ads and the stuff about celebrities' dogs.
How wrong I was. I mean, duh.
I was in college leafing through an issue of SELF -- I had yet to discover BUST and BITCH and felt SELF was less tailored to the sex and style model of print media -- when I found myself becoming increasingly annoyed with the magazine's perky, peppy tone assuring me that healthiness starts with the right work-out gear and a good night's sleep is just the thing to jump start your sex life, believe it or not! (the over-use of exclamation points alone was enough to make my teeth start to ache). It was in that instant that I realized this mag was no different than its sister publications -- it definitely did not speak for or represent me in any way other than its whiteness -- it had just found a slicker approach to sell the lie of feminine perfection. I decided that day I was done with lady mags.
I refused to spend any more time or energy investing in someone else's ideas of girl culture or womanhood, not to mention the serious, serious doubts I had about all those sex tips. I decided I no longer wanted to be a part of supporting a culture that capitalizes on girls' self-doubts and insecurities. I stopped giving my money to media that consistently skews girls' images and promotes unhealthy attitudes towards style and the bodies warped to fit fashion. I made a promise to do my version of girl the same way I did my version of that damn sweatshirt headband: mostly imperfect, but all me.
How will Donald Trump’s first 100 days impact YOU? Subscribe, choose the community that you most identify with or want to learn more about and we’ll send you the news that matters most once a week throughout Trump’s first 100 days in office. Learn more