More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Shelley Ross

GET UPDATES FROM Shelley Ross
 

Time for a Real Game Change: Is Halperin's Name Calling Arrogance, Immaturity or Something Else?

Posted: 06/30/11 06:48 PM ET

He Called the President WHAT!?

I heard it myself. Today, MSNBC's senior political analyst, Mark Halperin said President Barack Obama "acted like kind of a dick yesterday" while discussing politics on Morning Joe.

Joe Scarborough seemed genuinely in a panic over Halperin's language, as he scrunched his face and barked instructions to his control room, "Delay that. Delay that. What are you doing? I can't believe ... I was joking. Don't do that. Did we delay that? Did that work?"

(Scarborough earned his seven-second delay button, along with a knuckle rap from his bosses, back on November 10, 2008 when he dropped an F-bomb, live on the show. )

Mika Didn't Like the "D" Word, Either

As soon as this morning's "d" word was uttered, Mika Brzezinski recoiled in a full body cringe: her left arm went over her stomach, she turned her head away from Halperin and buried her face in her right hand, all within a split second moment of embarrassment and revulsion.

After assessing the comment had not been bleeped, Halperin, apologized, as did MSNBC, who for their part suspended their senior analyst "indefinitely" and released this statement:

Mark Halperin's comments this morning were completely inappropriate and unacceptable. We apologize to the President, The White House and all of our viewers. We strive for a high level of discourse and comments like these have no place on our air.

Halperin, who is also editor-at-large and senior political analyst for Time Magazine, posted an apology on "The Page," a political blog he created for Time.com:

I want to offer a heartfelt and profound apology to the President, to my TIME and MSNBC colleagues, and to the viewers. My remark was unacceptable, and I deeply regret it.

Halperin's "indefinite" suspension follows that of Keith Olbermann's for not disclosing financial contributions to the congressional campaign of Gabrielle Giffords. Back then, "indefinite" meant two days. (Joe Scarborough was also suspended for two days after his campaign contributions were discovered. )

Ed Schultz was suspended by MSNBC for a week after calling Laura Ingraham a "right-wing slut" on his radio show.

Ironically, Halperin was passing judgment on the President for his demeanor in yesterday's press conference as he addressed the republican position in the debt ceiling debate.

Halperin's suspension is definitely turning into a juicy summer sidebar with a steady stream of commentary running across the internet on the latest political pundit to put his foot in his mouth.

The cable news network's stated goal of "striving for a high level of discourse" has not gone unnoticed, or unanswered.

Perhaps the Comcast, er, MSNBC brass does want to elevate the dialog. I certainly hope so. I've just gotta ask, "Who calls the President a 'kind of a dick,' even in a candid moment?"

I'm certainly not shocked by the language; I've spent too many years in too many newsrooms. I'm more disappointed how crass it is, not to mention how arrogant and immature.

You call the kid in high school who accidentally-on-purpose knocks your chemistry book off your desk "a kind of dick." And maybe, just maybe if you hold a political office and engage in one on one political combat, I might get why you call the President rude names behind his back -- in private, that is, certainly not on the air, even if the offending language is expected to be bleeped.

Halperin already has some defenders. Greg Sargent, for one, has blogged on WashingtonPost.com that the MSNBC suspension is "crazy," and "way over the top," calling for more focus on fair politics.

Sargent also happened to be interviewing top Obama advisor David Axelrod today and got this reaction to Halperin-gate:

What he said was obviously stupid and tasteless, and he exercised poor judgment," Axelrod said. "I think he'd be the first to acknowledge that. I strongly disagree with his analysis. But I've known him for decades. he's a decent person and a good journalist. I'm sure that no one regrets this more than he does.

Axelrod went on to say while Halperin clearly made a mistake today, he doesn't think it characterizes the sweep of his career.

Now that's a game change we can all embrace: a mistake that's allowed to be a mistake and not the blood sport of the day.

I hope Halperin, other journalists, political pundits, fellow bloggers -- all of us in the business of exploring the mistakes of others -- will follow that standard of fairness.

It's fair to analyze those mistakes, research any history of like mistakes, then state one's conclusion. Let us now leave behind the name-calling, whether bleep-worthy or not, and more reasonably measure the full merit, and sweep of one's position, words and deeds.

This blog was posted earlier on Shelley Ross' daily Xpress.

 

Follow Shelley Ross on Twitter: www.twitter.com/shelleyzross

He Called the President WHAT!? I heard it myself. Today, MSNBC's senior political analyst, Mark Halperin said President Barack Obama "acted like kind of a dick yesterday" while discussing politics on...
He Called the President WHAT!? I heard it myself. Today, MSNBC's senior political analyst, Mark Halperin said President Barack Obama "acted like kind of a dick yesterday" while discussing politics on...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
O Really
What say You
12:01 AM on 07/02/2011
If the politicians are getting obtuse with derisive statements playing to the audience what can one expect from the media that covers them?

Lack of respect and decorum.
This train has been long coming.
10:40 AM on 07/01/2011
I dont agree with the president on much, i got mark's point he should have worded it different but he is the president and deserve the utmost respect
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lets Drink
10:20 AM on 07/01/2011
1088,

And what of the hatred showed by liberals towards Pres. Bush? Did that offend you as well?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Shelley Ross
07:19 PM on 07/01/2011
I didn't have a blog during the Bush Administration. But as a news executive at ABC, I produced many interviews with President Bush and Mrs. Bush, along with George Herbert Walker Bush and his wife, Barbara. I also reported widely on the Clinton administration. I think tough questions and healthy discourse always trumps hatred and name-calling.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
faithnj
07:44 PM on 07/01/2011
I couldn't stand Dubya. (You could almost say I hated him, if stereotyping liberals makes you feel like you have a handle on life.) But I never in a million years would have called him a d!ck. It's just low, uncalled for, and immature.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lets Drink
10:00 AM on 07/01/2011
Cyndie,

Im with you but feel that we all have to agree that these standards apply to all people. Anything that helps return a level of civility towards fellow Americans would be a welcome and positive trend.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lets Drink
09:54 AM on 07/01/2011
Where was the suspension for Chris Matthews when he called Palin "stupid"? Or for the journalists that disrespected Pres. George W. Bush? Why is the media allowed to be coarse with some people and not others?

Also,I will agree with anyone that says the office of the Presidency should be respected but that should go for all holders of that office, not just some.
10:47 AM on 07/01/2011
totally agree,these people are destroying their own credibility look at their ratings people know bias when they see it
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Shelley Ross
07:25 PM on 07/01/2011
Again, I think more fair to call a politician's remarks or position "stupid." That's a judgment call in a tangable debate, not a blanket insult of a person with political ambitions. Having said that, it's a time-honored American tradition to discern the aspiring leaders who aren't the brightest bulbs in the box.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
1088
09:46 AM on 07/01/2011
It's call hate, and you cannot suppress that feelings, it will come out or eat you up. The Republicans and some Progressive left wing hate his President, and because of that hate, they are going crazy.
05:18 AM on 07/01/2011
I was fired once for a less offensive comment in a much less public place. There is absolutely NO excuse for this type of juvenile, foul-mouthed, name-calling of the President of the United States no less. Whatever motivated this seemingly responsible 'journalist' to act so irresponsibly, only he knows for sure but I'd suggest suspension and demotion.
To think that his point was that the President didn't move the debate on the debt-ceiling forward w/ his remarks....where the hell was his rude, disrespect of the highest office in the US moving it? Infantile behavior like this is totally unacceptable and the punishment should reflect that of any employee who acted with such disregard for their position. Wow!
Cyndie Harper Williams
No longer a Republican.
08:17 PM on 06/30/2011
Just because someone is a public servant does not mean it is OK to use them as doormats. From President to Janitor, it is not OK to be "ugly" to people or about them publicly!
Cyndie Harper Williams
No longer a Republican.
08:11 PM on 06/30/2011
I personally prefer the old school idea that the President of the USA deserves to be treated with dignity and respect. Those old fashioned forms of civility are apparently eroding away. If it doesn't get better in the near future, I will be glad that I won't be around to see it get worse later.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:44 PM on 06/30/2011
Somebody should tell him harshly about the error of his way, then make sure he understands it,or has a good dental plan
fiorentina5
Strong Progressive
06:58 AM on 07/01/2011
I completely agree with you, respect seems to be a thing of the past. And that is very sad.
fiorentina5
Strong Progressive
07:51 PM on 06/30/2011
No matter someone's politics, Obama is the President of ALL of America, I don't like his politics but he is still the President of our country, and when someone speaks so terribly of him that is wrong. They are not speaking about the man Obama, they are speaking about the office of the President, the most important office in our country, and no one should be affiliated with that type of language. When we don't respect the most prestigious office in the country it's easy to see how the people of the country have lost respect for themselves and the nation as a whole.
photo
Cyn63
Every day I wake up is a great one
09:39 PM on 06/30/2011
Thanks fiorentina5. It's so nice to see someone be civil and positive. I respect your disagreement with his politics, everyone has the right to their own opinions. I also respect your ability to stand up and call out this kind of behavior.
fiorentina5
Strong Progressive
06:56 AM on 07/01/2011
Thank you, it is rare in this day and age to comment on someone's mean statements and not be attacked or called and evil liberal. So, thank you again I really appreciate that :)
photo
petey64
I fix computers free for those in need
07:46 PM on 06/30/2011
there is room for both debate and class and this is the language of the educated liberal in America? pretty sad.
07:14 PM on 06/30/2011
lol well he was right...hard to follow eh libs? Its ok when it was bush or palin being bashed tho eh?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:48 PM on 06/30/2011
We criticize do not bludgeon there is a difference ,eh??????????????
07:10 PM on 06/30/2011
There are far worse deeds being done in the world. I'm glad I live in a country where this can happen and the consequences aren't fatal. However, it does demonstrate how our political standards in conversation have changed. Not sure if it's for better or worse—the frankness and honesty is refreshing though brutal at times but freedom of speech is being tested more and more with each sound byte, blog post, live comment, and tweet.