iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Shelley Ross

GET UPDATES FROM Shelley Ross
 

Why Does Gov. Tom Corbett Get a Free Pass in the Penn State Scandal?

Posted: 11/16/11 02:47 PM ET

Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett has launched one of the most fascinating CYA campaigns in memory, in public everywhere serving as a moral compass on everything from the firing of Joe Paterno ("It was the right thing to do") to the question of whether or not to fire the graduate assistant coach who reported seeing Jerry Sandusky rape a 10-year-old, but did nothing to intervene

On Sunday's Meet The Press, Gov. Corbett explained to David Gregory how Pennsylvania's current attorney general made the decision that Coach Mike McQueary, currently on administrative leave, was more important to the case as an eyewitness, despite he failing to meet the higher moral obligation to intervene on the child's behalf.

Sadly, Gov. Tom Corbett, who was Pennsylvania's Attorney General until last January failed to meet that higher moral obligation as well. For at least six of the 15 years Jerry Sandusky is alleged to have molested children, Corbett was the top law enforcer in his state. The case began, then stalled on his watch.

Corbett's priorities towards the end of his AG tenure now seem curious: he used the grand jury not to finally close in on Sandusky, but to launch a criminal investigation against two of his political critics and to subpoena Twitter(click here to view document) to reveal their identities.

Gov. Corbett has spent much of his time since the Penn State scandal exploded getting out in front of it, all the while deflecting all personal questions in advance, saying that he isn't allowed to talk about the case because of grand jury restrictions.

Corbett's first national interview on the subject was with Jo Becker of the New York Times published November 10th. There he talks about the frustration of not being able to talk about it "or prepare for it."

"Prepare for it" relates to his dual role as Governor and member of Penn State University's board of trustees, a seat which comes with the job. Perhaps he really needed to prepare to deflect questions about his own failure to bring an indictment.

Although various Sandusky molestation reports had been kicking around for years, the case officially landed on Corbett's desk in 2009. According to the Times, officials at Clinton County high school had reported charges to the local district attorney that Mr. Sandusky had molested a boy there, but, citing a conflict of interest, the prosecutor passed it on to the attorney general's office to investigate.

Corbett did convene and grand jury in 2009. So why didn't he bring an indictment?

It's hard to say. No one has asked Tom Corbett.

Instead, surrogates have been used. The New York Times, for example, quoted Kevin Harley, who worked with Corbett during his years as Attorney General is now the Governor's press secretary .

"He knew what witnesses were going to the grand jury even though he was running for governor. So then he became governor, and he knew at some point that this day would be coming. He just didn't know when it would be."

Was running for governor too much of a distraction to bring even the most difficult of grand jury cases forward after more than a year?

On Sunday, David Gregory began his interview with Gov. Corbett with an extraordinary puppy pass.

MR. DAVID GREGORY: Governor Corbett, welcome to MEET THE PRESS.


GOV. TOM CORBETT (R-PA): Thank you, David.

MR. GREGORY: I know you're limited, because you were attorney general, in speaking about the criminal investigation, but I have to ask you more broadly, are there more victims that we don't know about?

GOV. CORBETT: I don't know the answer to that, David. When you conduct investigations like this-and in my career, I have conducted investigations like this-the more that you can get public about what has happened, the more that you can demonstrate that law enforcement and authorities are going to assist the victims of these types of crimes, it is not uncommon to see more victims come forward.

Like there rest of the country, Gregory probed to find out how Jerry Sandusky slipped through the cracks of the system for so many years?

MR. GREGORY: I just have to ask you as a trustee, as the governor of the state, as the former attorney general of the state, how did this happen? I mean, was this, was this a culture of indifference? A culture of cover-up? Did it extend throughout the university? Go beyond the university to the police, to the D.A.? Where?


Unfortunately, Gregory failed to press him about the culture of Corbett's attorney general's office and why the case stalled under his watch. This, of course, allowed the Governor a chance to filibuster and end on this:

GOV. CORBETT: I always wait for the results of investigation before I issue any opinions.
So why give the governor such softballs when there are so many pointed questions that skirt any legal restrictions in the case.

Here are just a few:

  • Did you assign a special task force for the Sandusky case?

  • Did you have to recuse any one in your office for conflict of interest?

  • The current attorney general has done additional investigating, so you should be able to say what was missing in your case for an indictment?

  • How much of the resources of your office did you dedicate to the Sandusky investigation?

  • When did the grand jury looking into Sandusky begin and end?

  • How many grand juries did you convene in your last two years as attorney general?

  • How many resulted in criminal indictments?

  • Did your criminal investigation that involved the Twitter subpoena result in an indictment?

  • Once you began your campaign for governor, how often did you meet with your prosecutors to discuss the road to an indictment of Jerry Sandusky?

  • When was your last official conversation about the Sandusky case and what was discussed?

  • Had you decided not to bring an indictment against Jerry Sandusky?

  • What, if any, was your "pass down" advice (on the Sandusky case) to the attorney general who succeeded you.
  • As attorney general, Tom Corbett did create a team to go after pedophiles and other assorted child abusers, although not much is publicly known about the prosecution record during his tenure. He has spoken frequently about a disturbing case he prosecuted as a young district attorney where a pedophile used a Christian charity to recruit his victims.

    In the scheme of things, Corbett is not any more of the devil than the Penn State gang who did what they knew was just barely enough under legal obligations. He's also not any less of an ostrich in his failure to now say publicly what he could have done, what he should have done and what laws must be changed tomorrow.


    This column was first posted on Shelley Ross' daily Xpress.

     

    Follow Shelley Ross on Twitter: www.twitter.com/shelleyzross

    Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett has launched one of the most fascinating CYA campaigns in memory, in public everywhere serving as a moral compass on everything from the firing of Joe Paterno ("It wa...
    Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett has launched one of the most fascinating CYA campaigns in memory, in public everywhere serving as a moral compass on everything from the firing of Joe Paterno ("It wa...
     
     
    • Comments
    • 30
    • Pending Comments
    • 0
    • View FAQ
    Comments are closed for this entry
    View All
    Favorites
    Bloggers
    Recency  | 
    Popularity
    Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
    11:23 AM on 12/10/2011
    Please see this latest post at Penn Live..He is so corrupt and the feds need to come in an clean the PA government..Please spread this around..As a PA citizen I fear for the future of my state with Corbett as a Leader..Such a mess we have

    http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2011/12/gov_tom_corbetts_team_defends/3032/comments-newest.html
    04:08 PM on 12/09/2011
    This guy is so mixed up in this mess and when the truth comes out we will learn he stalled the case so it would not negatively tarnish his run for governor...he's so busy talking about other people failing on moral obligations, this is done so the attention can be diverted away from him and how poorly he handled the case when he was AG for 6 years!
    12:09 AM on 12/03/2011
    It been over 2 weeks since this article and I must say I think our PA Governor is next on the chopping block in this scandal. The public needs to open there eyes and put 2 and 2 together and not let him come out of this clean. He's just as responsible for not doing anything as JoePA and the rest of the Penn State. When you have a sexual child predator on the streets and you know about it, you get him off the streets as soon as possible. For almost 3 years, 3 years, Must I say it again 3 years he left this predator free under his watch. Oh that's Right he didn't have time to do his job as AG because he was running for PA Governor at the time. Shelley Ross I commend you on this article. Good job and keep pushing this with other articles.
    11:54 AM on 11/20/2011
    Gov. Corbett is up to his eyeballs in the cover up. Please don't let him keep evading questions on the subject, as he has been up till now.
    10:20 PM on 11/18/2011
    Very good point about the governor. Thank you for some real reporting--doesn't seem like real reporting is much of a priority with many of the big media outlets these days.
    To answer your question about why Governor Corbett gets a "free pass," is because his name is not Joe Paterno.
    The big media outlets keep the spotlight on the big name person because that's the way big media works these days unfortunately. It's what sells. A very similar story about child abuse (5 kids) broke out this week at The Citadel (in S. Carolina) yet it received very little attention from the media.
    Attorney General Corbett only had to look at this one incident from 2008 (he didn't need to go back 10 years or so). It only takes one incident/allegation to do an investigation, bring up charges, grand jury, etc.--yet in over 2.5 years his efforts produced 0/nada/nothing to bring up charges.
    This guy needs to be investigated by the feds.
    Thanks for your time.
    07:01 PM on 11/18/2011
    Shelley

    Excellent work....but there is not enough pressure on Corbett to provide real answers. There is speculation and rumor of a video floating around about the DA. Follow the money and see where it leads you and hope you don't end up in the Susquehanna river too!
    12:50 PM on 11/18/2011
    The whole situation regarding the Penn State scandal seems murky to say the least.......My feeling is that many people were working at different levels and with different agendas regarding seeking the truth and keeping Jerry Sandusky from abusing more children.....This tragedy reflects badly, in my opinion, on the people of Pennsylvania and the US as a whole......Who can really find the truth and seek out and hold to account and prosecute those who should be held to account and prosecuted???????
    photo
    golfvue3
    It's all ball bearings these days.
    11:54 AM on 11/18/2011
    Missing the point on this article. There is no evidence of wrong-doing - just a bunch of unanswered questions - that you could ask about any investigation.

    Corbett started investigation - and it went too slow for the author's liking...

    End result is where we should have ended up with Sandusky arrested and indictments on purjery...
    09:00 AM on 11/17/2011
    Great column, Shelley. I'm editor of The Patriot-News of Harrisburg. Our reporter Sara Ganim did one of the only critical looks at how slow the investigation was initially. It got much less attention than some of our other reporting has, even tho I thought it was much more original and uncovered ground. http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2011/11/special_report_why_the_jerry_s.html
    photo
    HUFFPOST BLOGGER
    Shelley Ross
    01:01 AM on 11/18/2011
    Thanks for the feedback. And thanks for sharing Sara Ganim's story which I will repost. Is it true Corbett assigned one investigator? However many, it wasn't enough. Good luck with your team. National reporters will dip in and out, but the PN is ere for the long haul.
    Shelley
    02:33 PM on 11/26/2011
    Not only was there only one investigator assigned to the case. that investigator (Frank Noonan) is now the Commissioner of Pennsylvania State Police and was nominated by Corbett.
    01:56 AM on 11/17/2011
    An excellent article! Thank you for taking an interest in this situation.
    10:46 PM on 11/16/2011
    Thank you Shelley Ross. Good job connecting the dots. Another question for the list. "Governor, you claim to understand this case. What information beyond that disclosed in the grand jury presentment do you have; when did you learn this information; what actions did you take as a result of this information?"
    photo
    HUFFPOST BLOGGER
    Shelley Ross
    12:29 AM on 11/17/2011
    Thanks so much for the feedback.
    photo
    HUFFPOST BLOGGER
    Shelley Ross
    12:41 AM on 11/17/2011
    Thanks for the feedback!
    10:39 PM on 11/16/2011
    You're getting warmer Shelley. Do a Google search on the disappearance of 'Ray Gicar' Centre County DA....after the investigated Sandusky in 2005... clearing him of all charges. A DA goes missing under these circumstances and State DA Corbett doesn't reopen the case he most recently was working on before going missing. He calls in the FBI only to do phone record review. Read the details then tell me how he could act so cavalierly in 2009. Apparently, the victims didn't have enough cash for his campaign coffer or come from the right voting demographic. The he throws the elder diminished capacity Paterno under the bus because Joe's celebrity takes the focus off of Tom Corbett... where it belongs.

    If you took an issue with Sandusky to the police or DA, from 2005, they weren't doing anything about it.. even if a county DA ended up missing! Think a DA ends up missing in this manner in any other state and the State DA puts on blinders and goes to golf outings and fundraisers instead of doing his Job. Keep after the Corbett connnection and You are on to something newsworthy in this case.
    01:59 PM on 11/17/2011
    This is interesting... One might conjecture that Corbett was part of a conspiracy to get rid of the Centre County DA that you mention (not to suggest that he offed him himself), and that Penn State officials promised to support Corbett's political aspirations in exchange for him shelving the Sandusky charges. That would also account for State Police Commissioner Frank Noonan's move to distract the media by crucifying Joe Paterno at the press conference given by the new attorney general to announce the indictments. It all sort of fits.
    06:01 AM on 11/19/2011
    Corbett was an adversary of PSU. However, when he was Attorney General Cobett did receive enormous contributions for his campaign for Governor from leaders of the Second Mile,Jerry Sanduskys program for kids. This occurred just after then state attorney general did not reopen the Ray Gicar case from 1998 when DA Ray Gicar went missing. If you follow the money and look at the time line, Corbett should be very nervous and the FBI should get involved here. On the surface, It appears Corbett threw an elderly icon under the bus to divert attention away from his own incredible misconduct. At the very least, the surface needs scratched.
    08:04 PM on 11/16/2011
    Corbett should resign. David Gregory's failure to press Corbett is not surprising.
    04:55 PM on 11/16/2011
    corbett is an republican
    HUFFPOST SUPER USER
    Tim Berton
    04:32 PM on 11/16/2011
    I think Gov. Corbett has done a terrible job with the Sandusky case.

    He was on the Penn State Board of Trustees and knew this was coming. Even when it was in the newspapers months ago that Sandusky was under investigation, he apparently didn't urge Penn State to develop a plan of action. He let Penn State down.

    He had a conflict of interest as the instigator of the investigation and a member of the Board of Trustees. He should have abstained on board votes relating to the Sandusky scandal.

    He also plays up the scandal by going on all the political talk shows. He seems to be basking in the limelight to the detriment of his state and Penn State. It should be the current Attorney General versus the Penn State President on the talk shows.

    Reports indicate he pushed other board members to vote for the quick firing of Paterno, which the current Attorney General publicly questioned given that Paterno violated no laws and was a cooperating witness.

    He also steps on the current Attorney General's case when he publicly criticizes their star witness, Mike McQueary .

    His investigation was also way too slow. Sandusky should have been charged in 2009 when the first complainant came forward. Any abuse victims from 2009 to 2011 are Corbett's fault for moving too slow.
    06:07 PM on 11/16/2011
    he approved 3 Million dollars in Federal money to go to Second Mile, when asked about this, he said it had already been approved for them, and then when pushed, he admitted the givernment had gone back anf rescinded the money..yeah...Corbett, your days may be numbered