More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sherman Yellen

Sherman Yellen

Posted: March 27, 2010 02:00 PM

That Acrid Smell in the Air? Timothy McVeigh-ism

What's Your Reaction:

Oh how I hate an ism. Born in the first half of the twentieth century I've lived through them all. That century was cursed with fascism, communism, and McCarthyism. In the twenty first we have Islamic terrorism. I must apologize if I am adding to the already overcrowded list of isms -- but with the threats from Republican Congressmen, the bulls-eye targeting of Sarah Palin of the Democrats she disagrees with, and the racist and homophobic curses from the Tea Party ringing in our ears after the passage of the health care bill, I suggest that we take a look backwards at the sad story of Timothy James McVeigh and see the McVeighism that is festering. Here was a man so filled with rage and resentment against the government for its Waco and Ruby Ridge raids, and a generalized hatred for American foreign policy, that he used explosives to blow up the Alfred P. Murrah Federal building in April of 1995 killing 168 people, injuring 450 others, nineteen of them small children in a day care center. I won't use the word fascism if I can help it -- it belongs to another era -- and often degrades clear thinking, but it requires more self control than I may have to keep it from sneaking into this piece.

McVeigh was the child of a divorced Irish Catholic family from upstate New York, the target of bullying in school, claiming that he found relief in fantasies of retaliation against the bullies. Withdrawn, a loner, he became interested in computer systems and showed a talent for technology. Fascinated by firearms, obsessed with gun rights, he served in the Gulf War, claiming that the army taught him how to switch off his emotions. Discharged from the army in '91, he became a wanderer, an anti-taxation advocate, writing "Do we have to shed blood to reform the current system? I hope it doesn't come to that. But it might." He wrote angry letters to the government, mostly because it was growing larger and he seemed to feel smaller, except for his possession of a gun. He worked at gun shows and handed out cards with the name and address of the sharpshooter who had worked for the government during the Waco siege "in the hope that somebody in the Patriot Movement would assassinate the sharpshooter." His paranoia had an almost humorous cast to it if it did not lead to such tragedy. He claimed that the government had planted a chip in his buttocks to keep track of him. If they had the chip in his behind it did not work because he was able to execute a tragic act of terrorism -- American style.

Of course no two madmen or assassins with a grudge against the world are ever quite the same. But the common thread that runs through them is a deep sense of victimhood. McVeigh had it, Hitler had it, Oswald had it, Booth had it, and I can see and hear reflections of that dangerous victimhood in the far right today. The anti-government, in this case anti-Obama rhetoric is hate filled, some of it race based, and contains within it an unappeasable grudge -- the us against them kind that sets off explosions, kills the innocent, and destroys the security of the country it claims to protect. If we sniff we can smell the burning fuse. There is no constitutional right to inflame sociopaths to commit murderous acts. Cool it Sarah, and all you Republican leaders who are playing to your base, using code words that are well understood by many who feel victimized because of the recession (just as Germans became targets for Hitler's rhetoric because of the Great Depression). Sorry, reader, I've done it, slipped it in but I am truly worried by the parallels and hope against hope that I am wrong.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 116
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Debra Lewis
Retired: Armed Forces
07:07 PM on 04/24/2010
I am watching MSNBC about Mc Veigh. I am also thinking about that crazy woman Sarah Palin putting gun sights on certain members of congress and their respective states. I wonder does Palin think that McVeigh is some kind of domestic hero. She tends to be skirting the law and freedom of expression rights. I personally believe that Palin is just a wackjob away from being a domestic terrorist herself. She should be a concern to the US Gov't and also us, as a peaceful people.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:10 PM on 03/29/2010
The fortunate thing is that 95% of these people are all talk no action. The unfortunate thing is that the other 5% are certifiable and armed. It does sound like at least of few of the second group were corralled by the FBI in the last few days.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JohnBryansFontaine
Liberal Democrat
01:09 PM on 03/29/2010
9 militia members charged in police-killing plot
By COREY WILLIAMS and DEVLIN BARRETT (AP) – 43 minutes ago

DETROIT — Nine suspects tied to a Midwest Christian militia that was preparing for the Antichrist were charged with conspiring to kill police officers, then attack a funeral using homemade bombs in the hopes of killing more law enforcement personnel, federal prosecutors said Monday.

The Michigan-based group, called Hutaree, planned to use the attack on police as a catalyst for a larger uprising against the government, according to newly unsealed court papers. U.S. Attorney Barbara McQuade said agents moved on the group because its members were planning a violent reconnaissance mission sometime in April.

Members of the group, including its leader, David Brian Stone, also known as "Captain Hutaree," were charged following FBI raids over the weekend on locations in Michigan, Ohio and Indiana.

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5hGc00FR9o4OUr36gm80mOpG00ccwD9EOD0600
08:59 PM on 03/28/2010
The GOP needs to realize that YOU CAN'T CONTROL CRAZY PEOPLE!!! The Dems might be there targets but, everybody else is collateral damage. As Malcolm X would say, the chickens will come home to roost.
02:21 PM on 03/28/2010
"the racist and homophobic curses from the Tea Party ringing in our ears after the passage of the health care bill"

can anyone post a youtube video of the CBC beening insulted? there were cameras and cell phones all over and I have yet to actually hear a sound bite of a racial slur or anything.

I imagine if there were, it would be plastered all over the net, like Biden and his f-bomb.

I will assume democrats are playing the race card until I hear the slurs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JohnBryansFontaine
Liberal Democrat
02:44 PM on 03/28/2010
TEA PARTY RACISM: What The Media Won't Show You About Teabagger Racism

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S38VioxnBaI
09:25 PM on 03/28/2010
So very true.

These people did not think of this by themselves.

Look up:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedition
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ramblin jack
05:32 PM on 03/28/2010
Where have you been there are literally dozens of photos of racist and demeaning signs at all tea bagger events. not all tea baggers are racist but in general I think you are in denial about this so called movement is all about.
01:20 PM on 03/28/2010
.see..........
photo
tnkeating
Dyslexic agnostic insomniac
12:19 PM on 03/28/2010
Great artical, but the Tea Party is threatening with their votes, not violence. Every group has its fringe and no one can say whos doing the threats. There are desparate special interest groups out there (if I name them, no doubt this won't get printed) that would do anything to discredit and minimalize the Tea Party, time and time again they have tried at events accross the nation, and they will continue to try.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:36 PM on 03/28/2010
tnkeating,Well, the violence is brewing or at the very least, the threat of it.

Great post, yes this is exactly the same victim-ism that Tim McVey felt and it is dangerous.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Skepticat
Supporting skeptical felines everywhere
02:07 PM on 03/28/2010
Actually some of the T party crowd are threatening or hoping or praying for violence, and they are discrediting themselves by not taking action on their more idiotic participants. T party supporters are carrying the obnoxious signs picked up by the media - and if it was all a big plot to discredit them - all they would have to do is make it clear that the more extreme signage doesn'yt reflect their views. So far this hasn't happened.
12:02 PM on 03/28/2010
Godwin's Law notwithstanding, there are some parallels here. The "Tea Partiers" are in a highly-agitated emotional state. As such, they are resistant to reason. As long as the "Big Lie" keeps their emotions high, they can be easily manipulated, particularly to support that which is against their own best interests. The task is to look for what it is in American political culture which is resistant to the lure of the mass movement and strengthen that.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ramblin jack
05:35 PM on 03/28/2010
screw Godwin's so called law as all it does is nullify the real use and need of the comparisons at times.
02:16 AM on 03/28/2010
I understand your reluctance to tar the opposition--re: Godwin's law. But it's time to say what must be said, and this Tea Party deal is starting to look very much like the early stages of a proto- fascist movement. With their violent imagery and language, it could only be a matter of time before violence erupts. But how do you reason with a movement that considers its opponents not just political rivals, but foreign/un-American?
photo
Sherman Yellen
playwright, memoirist
07:48 AM on 03/28/2010
Farside, it isn't so much my reluctance to tar the far right with the word "fascist" - it is rather to protect that word against cheap and easy usage - for fascism led to the destruction of six million Jews, gypsies, Catholics, and homosexuals, not to mention the death of so many civilians and soldiers in WW2. Sinclair Lewis, the great American novelist of the 30s said something to the effect that when fascism comes to American it will not be wearing jackboots and a swastika but come looking like a good ole boy with a down home accent. I think he was referring to Huey Long - who played the populist for political advantage - but watching Ms. Palin on TV yesterday it was clear that all her homespun speech and regular gal persona was being used to send a message of violence and hate to her disciples, and perhaps to others who are susceptible to her ploys. Fox News jumped for joy at her rally, and she has a powerful lobby behind her, but it's hard to believe that she will not eventually be exposed for the mendacious fake she is - one only hopes it isn't too late. The genial parody of Tina Fey made her seem harmless - and one thing she is not is harmless.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Skepticat
Supporting skeptical felines everywhere
02:29 PM on 03/28/2010
What I see are willful attempts by Ms Palin and others to stoke up cumulative frustration in the hope it will turn into instability and violence to discredit the current government. Barring mass amnesia the only viable chance for a strong republican resurgence is if the country develops the type of instability found in Italy in the early 1920's and Germany and Spain in the 1930's - and becomes the kind of place where people are willing to give up freedom for order. Once that happens there are always people willing to take power, impose order and remove those pesky freedoms - and of course people who can profit by supporting them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:22 AM on 03/28/2010
Dear RNC,
Glenn Beck's rhetoric, which has been mimicked incessantly by the GOP for the past year, has incited acts of violence and continues to fan the flames of discontent. It is only a matter of time before innocent people are hurt, considering that the GOP’s tea party has gone so far as to cut a gas line at the home of Rep. Perriello’s brother, thinking the address was his. When apprised of the fact that the individuals in the home had children who might have been harmed, the tea party instigator suggested that it would merely have been "collateral damage". Meanwhile, another Republican, Rep. King, suggested that tea party activists should “Beat the [health care] opposition to a pulp.†“Chase them down, said King, “There’s going to be a reckoning.†Are you willing to accept responsibility for such acts as supporters of an extremist faction that takes its marching orders from the likes of Glenn Beck, Sarah Plain, and Michelle Bachmann, among others, who are actively calling for sedition? Freedom of speech is one thing, but I do not believe that the First Amendment protects the incitement of violence against fellow citizens nor encouragement of violence against the government, as the GOP’s Becks, Palins, and Bachmanns suggest their tea party minions should do to “take back ‘their’ countryâ€. Should the violence escalate, peaceful citizens will hold the GOP accountable.

America is America, not the Tea Party Republic. There's no WE in Tea Party.
12:07 PM on 03/28/2010
If Glenn Beck's exposure of documented information and direct quotes of Obama and his administration "incites violence" then how is he repsonsible for that?. We are well aware that Obama's agenda relies heavily on ignorance and suppression of the truth but come on!

Oh, and the "Tea Party" members who cut that "gas line" that was member #42882 and #51771 we'll call them into the office and talk to them.............
09:34 PM on 03/28/2010
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedition
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Beth Boyle
01:36 AM on 03/28/2010
Here is a call for all you sane Republicans to leave the sinking ship. The wacko right has taken over the GOP.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
BoyInBOYCOTT
12:11 AM on 03/28/2010
I've always resisted the Godwin law, the reasons hundreds of holocaust books, films, and oral histories of survivorsof the holocaust were collected, is because the statement NEVER AGAIN was a warning to watch for the early signs of fascism, when it still might be averted, before it gains control.
Especially in desperate economic strife, desperate people will believe simple answers to complex problems, and it can lead to scapegoating,
12:26 AM on 03/28/2010
I agree. I am a republican but for some reason I find myself agreeing with much of what democrats say on the weekends.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Gidster
Not so much Liberal as I am anti evil.
01:38 AM on 03/28/2010
Then sir, you are a moderate, and we need more like you to keep balance.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Libertarian09
Anti War Socialist with a taste for freedom
11:51 PM on 03/27/2010
While I cannot condone his methods, McVeigh's motivations are ones that should find great resonance in America today. The government is heavy handed with the citizenry and US foreign policy has been downright criminal in the last half century. It's too bad that his act of terrorism casts a shadow over non-violent people who may feel the same way, silencing them for fear of being seen as "terrorists".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tmose
01:09 AM on 03/28/2010
"non-violent people who may feel the same way, silencing them for fear of being seen as "terrorists".

Non violent people never "feel" the way he did...and he was in fact a terrorist.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Gidster
Not so much Liberal as I am anti evil.
01:42 AM on 03/28/2010
Another apologist.....

Non violent people who dissent have no fear of being seen as terrorists, because of the fact they are non violent.

The tea party, and the Republicans and corporate operatives that fuel their Obama h8, have been ratcheting up the rhetoric for months now.

Limbaugh is calling for Dems to be "Wiped out", Palin has them "In her sights", the level of violent hyperbole is increasing.

Textbook example of escalating....McVeigh showed the same behavioral pattern.
09:24 PM on 03/27/2010
A well-written wake up call written by an active duty Marine for those civilians who are considering taking up arms against our lawful government and her people:

http://christopher-calbat.newsvine.com/_news/2010/03/26/4073188-an-article-i-wish-i-would-never-have-to-write-to-those-calling-for-a-civil-war-this-marine-wants-you-to-stop-and-think
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Unitynow8
Liberal World Citizen
02:40 AM on 03/28/2010
this linked article was deleted
04:05 AM on 03/28/2010
You can also read it on DailyKos.
04:53 AM on 03/28/2010
Update: The Marine took his original post down from NewsVine after he and his family were threatened, and he felt that his message had been derailed:

"I never expected the response I got, and I must admit while some of the comments that I received were some of the greatest thoughts and words I've ever seen - some were words I'd hope no human being would never utter to another. My family and myself were threatened, if for no other reason than because my opinions differed from someone else's. Obviously, the intent of my message was convoluted and lost. "

http://christopher-calbat.newsvine.com/_news/2010/03/27/4080107-a-rewrite-of-a-marines-call-for-peace-and-pause-that-had-been-reduced-into-sheer-irrelevanceand-an-apology

His original post can still be read at the following link. Very eloquent and stark:

http://sealaskatimes.blogspot.com/2010/03/article-i-wish-i-would-never-have-to.html
09:21 PM on 03/27/2010
The Western Rifle Shooters Association is sponsoring the "Restore the Constitution Rally," inviting participants "to bring their sidearms to the banks of the Potomac" on April 19th, next month.

Any true Okie who went through the Murrah bombing would be sickened and disgusted with WRSA using the 15th year anniversary of McVeigh's murders with the above rally. I should know. I was a physician on call a few blocks away when the bomb brought down the Murrah building.

Here's what a poster said on the WRSA's site concerning this event:

"First, I'm not going to ask permission from a foreign government what can and cannot be done on a friendly state's land. I do not recognize US government possession of the land.

Second, if I were to attend, my rifle will be loaded and slung in front for ready use, I'll have a combat load of ammo, chemical protective mask, and likely a armored vest.

Somebody needs to get a grip on what this rally is all about, it ain't to ask permission."
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Now THAT, sparkandy, is throwing gas on a fire!!
09:06 PM on 03/27/2010
My aunt is from Bad Axe, MI and lived just a few farms down from the NIchols, and were interviewed after the bombing by the FBI.

She said the whole community thought they were a little off.

It pays to know your neighbors I guess.

And if they are loons send them a pie. Keep your friends close and your enemies closer.