More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Shirin Sadeghi

Shirin Sadeghi

Posted: September 9, 2010 06:10 PM

This week, as flood waters ravage Pakistan's land and 20 million of its people, and after Pakistan's own president, Asif Ali Zardari, managed to muster only $58,000 of his own vast wealth to the flood relief (a donation nearly doubled by Angelina Jolie), yet another devastating blow has hit Pakistan: news that the government has now approved an $11-million statue of the President's assassinated wife, Benazir Bhutto.

And yes, this is Pakistani taxpayer money.

The statue itself will cost 4.7 million dollars, and it will be built on land that is worth another 5.9 million dollars. Apparently, Mr. Zardari, whose personal wealth is estimated to be more than 1 billion dollars, just couldn't afford to donate the land or the statue in honor of the mother of his children.

His government decided the people of Pakistan could afford it, though. People who, according to the World Bank, have an average per capita income of $870 annually.

Admirably, the people of Pakistan have taken it upon themselves to try and stop this misguided use of funds in the midst of a national disaster. A legal action failed, but now a petition is available online.

Another day, another battle in the Pakistani people's war for a representative government.

 

Follow Shirin Sadeghi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ShirinSadeghi

 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nicole Wisen
03:25 PM on 09/20/2010
well, seeing that the most likely person who had her killed is zardari himself, building a statue out of tax payer's money is like having other people pay for his remorse.
even if the basturd was paying for it himself, the woman does not deserve a memorial. i know its ill to speak of the dead, but this is the same woman who helped zardari swindle pakistan's poor and used the money to buy surrey palace in england and chateaus in france. zardari had her own brother killed in cold blood and she helped him cover it up. even her neice speaks openly about that fact.


$58,000 go towards feeding the poor and 11 million towards the monument of a con artist.
i wish the terrorists would get zardari instead of random innocent people. pakistan is literally ruled by the biggest don in the country. even corleone had rules. zardari is just a greedy basturd with a bad veneer job.

and meanwhile yousaf raza gillani continues to shop while the minor politicians kissing his butt pick up the tab. in pakistan, you have minor politicians buying million dollar designer furniture (in a store located across the slums).
this is why when the french revolution came, they killed anyone with soft hands.
02:36 AM on 09/17/2010
i wont say i m taken aback by this!!! knowing the President who has been ripping the country apart for so many years, this isn't a shocker! but then HELLO PAKISTAN! HOW ARE YOU FEELING TREMENDOUSLY HELPLESS AND SHATTERED?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Firas Al-Atraqchi
Journalist, assoc professor, musician; sci-fi geek
04:44 PM on 09/16/2010
Absolutely disgusting. Callous beyond remorse. I cannot believe this. I just wrote an article about the Muslim World befuddling its priorities http://www.huffingtonpost.com/firas-alatraqchi/why-i-oppose-the-new-york_b_713693.html partially saying funds are being misappropriated.

And now to read this? On a statue? An insult to every Pakistani and everyone wanting to help Pakistan.
09:12 PM on 09/15/2010
This pathetic excuse of a man is making Pakistan look bad. The image and reputation of Pakistan is disintegrating. 11 freaking million dollars on a bloody monument of his dead wife? That also from Pakistani tax payers is humiliating! This won't do! 1 Billion Rupees can be used to change lots of people's lives! The flood affectees who need this money more than our PRESIDENT. Somehow this construction has to be stopped! I am so ashamed. He is abusing his power.
09:27 AM on 09/15/2010
shameless Zardari and corrupt govt only care about dead devils, got nothing to do with effected ppls...
01:38 AM on 09/15/2010
cool
01:38 AM on 09/15/2010
Its a great article!
01:36 AM on 09/15/2010
We see a mute revolution soon in Pakistan! www.khabrain.net
12:47 PM on 09/14/2010
One wonders if Pakistan is really a country or just a piece land which these dynasties take turns to plunder!
06:02 PM on 09/14/2010
You pretty much nailed it on the head. Its not a country anymore, only a area where the people are to illiterate to do anything, and the "government" is all to happy about keeping it that way.
07:58 AM on 09/14/2010
Statutes are harmless. They don't kill.
12:45 PM on 09/14/2010
They certainly do when that much money can fund a sustainable project even in the area around where Benazir originally is (in Sindh) or perhaps in the neighbouring province of Balochistan.

If someone is so concerned about honouring memory of a PM why not her uber-rich family set a precedent by paying from their own pockets for once?
03:10 AM on 09/15/2010
Paperclips are harmless. They don't kill either.

See how pointless my post was?
03:01 AM on 09/14/2010
This is not it, they (the Zardari and company, which calls itself Pakistani government) broke a barrage near her grave, flooding and endangering the lives and property of another 80,000 Pakistani, just to save that site.
07:25 AM on 09/14/2010
You speak with great authority. We would love it if you show the world your evidence so the guilty can be brought to court.
03:39 AM on 09/15/2010
court?? guilty?? dude this is Pakistan - no law for the common man... u have to survive or u have to be too damn powerful to take advantage of the "might is right" rule in Pakistan.

If there were functional courts in Pakistan, corrupt people like Zardari would never have been the president.
08:06 PM on 09/16/2010
Don't know about 80,000 people but they did manipulate the natural flow of the flood towards a nearby village in order to prevent it from flowing through that site.
11:56 AM on 09/13/2010
It amazes me that the United States government doesn't step in and demand that the Government of Pakistan use these funds for flood relief rather than building monuments. If they chose to continue with the building of the monument, the entire Kerry-Lugar Bill should be re-voted upon in the US Congress to decide if Pakistan's government deserves this assistance when they spend taxpayer money on their own lavish desires while 75% of the country has been destroyed by the floods. Until America stands up for Pakistanis, the government will continue to do whatever they choose. All of this, in the end, creates more hatred for America because its US taxpayer dollars that support these corrupt governments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atif Ahmed Choudhury
03:49 AM on 09/14/2010
Agreed the US should apply pressure to the Pakistani government, but ultimately it is the Pakistani people themselves who can change this reality and control their destiny. After all such outrageous abuses of power are merely symptoms of a much more over-arching problem. If the people collectively rise up and resist both military dictatorship and civilian despotism in order to establish for themselves a fair, competent and just government, then Pakistan cannot and will not continue to fail her people.
05:51 AM on 09/14/2010
Atif, that is a wonderful thought and I agree that it is a symptom of a much more over-arching problem, but for over 60 years, the Pakistani people have suffered at the hands of dictators, both military and civilian, that believe that feudal landlords have more rights than the average working Pakistani. These same feudals occupy the corridors of power in politics, bureaucracy and law enforcement assuring that they are able to enjoy the greatest wealth without any chance of being brought to justice. The sugar, flour and other crises that Pakistan sees every year and is unable to solve is due to their influence in the parliaments and government offices. Until feudalism is ended in Pakistan and true land reform is brought, Pakistanis will continue to suffer. For example, what country of the world doesn't charge a tax on agricultural lands, especially when the entire nation's economy is based on agriculture? Additionally, it was at the insistence of the US government that the black law of the National Reconciliation Order was imposed on Pakistanis giving those who had stolen billions from the national exchequer a free pass and another run at the government. Pakistan needs the US to stand by its words of a new relationship with Pakistanis and demand that all the funds stolen from Pakistan be returned, while withholding the Kerry Lugar money until it is done so. We Pakistanis need that money to rebuild a nation destroyed by terrorism and flooding.
05:02 PM on 09/14/2010
Dude, no matter what the US does Pakistanis are not happy with it. If the US was telling the Pak government what to do, then it would be 'why are you telling us what to do, now they are tying strings to aid, they always want something in return' etc. etc.
How about the Pakistanis do something for themselves, and stand up to the government that they voted in. Choose leaders more wisely in the future. US taxpayer dollars are being given through goodwill, if the people hate the US for failings of their own governement, the people are stupid. How about this; how about the US gives no money, would that make them love the US more? Don't blame others for the faults of your own government, nobody can be blamed but them.
03:32 AM on 09/15/2010
I wholeheartedly agree with you - the US should stop giving money to Pakistan completely. At the same time, the US should stop demanding that inept leaders they like should be elevated the the highest offices of government. Pakistanis, as you claim, are not happy with anything the US does. Sadly, you have probably forgotten that the US used Pakistan as a staging ground for the war against the Soviets and then turned their back on Pakistan once the war was over. You probably don't know that Pakistan has had more casualties in the War on Terror than the US because our soldiers are again fighting a war that we should have never been involved with. But because the US threatened to bomb Pakistan if we didn't help them, innocent Pakistanis and our military suffers casualty upon casualty each and every day. It is easy to sit in the US and blame other countries for "not doing enough," it's much more difficult to live in Pakistan and suffer from the stupid decision making of educated Americans. Take your own advice - don't blame others for the faults of your own government, nobody can be blamed but them.

I am not stupid enough to blame others for the faults of my own government, but I am definitely going to point out the enablers that fund, prop up and then provide political asylum to the people that have robbed my country blind.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gomorrah
10:50 AM on 09/10/2010
Its equally viIe to note that the Pakistan Army has approved to procure 14 new F-16s and two n00clear plant from China costing close to $5 Billion
02:00 AM on 09/14/2010
Agree with Gomorrah here. The news of wasting money on a statue during these times is as despicable as 63 years worth of continuing expenditure on F-16s, WMDs, new HQs and other unaccounted for military luxuries, and should be equally condemned, if not more, since the military has ruled the country for a larger portion of it's existence.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atif Ahmed Choudhury
03:22 AM on 09/16/2010
like boys with shiny billion dollar toys...if it wasn't so disgusting it would be funny
09:55 PM on 09/09/2010
Thanks Shirin. This is a shocking reality. It is unbelievable how these politicians can be so insensitive. All Pakistanis should sign this petition by clicking on the link http://www.petitiononline.com/flood786/petition.html
photo
TheMediaRanger
Pull over, buddy, let's see your poetic license
09:17 PM on 09/09/2010
I can never figure out this strange country of Pakistan. The history of corruption, the lingering hatred and paranoia of neighboring India, the hundreds of tribal arrangements and how they comprise a national socio-political quilt.

At the same time, it's demographically a very young country, with more than 50% of the population under 25 years old. Like any young people, they want to have hope and a shot at shaping their own destiny. There probably has never been a better time to show international support for Pakistan's recovery and continued progress toward democracy.
12:13 PM on 09/15/2010
What are we supposed to do with her useless monument?..Such a waste,subhanAllah
photo
TheMediaRanger
Pull over, buddy, let's see your poetic license
02:01 PM on 09/15/2010
No doubt, many Pakistanis and others around the world share your view.

I wonder how much attention would be paid to the monument without the current natural disasters and geo-political conflicts.