iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Simon Rosenberg

GET UPDATES FROM Simon Rosenberg
 

Why Romney and Ryan's Lies Matter

Posted: 09/03/2012 2:44 pm

For weeks I've been a bit amazed at how brazenly the Romney campaign has lied about simple things: the welfare waivers, the raiding of Medicare, that he would balance the budget in ten years, that they released two years of tax returns, the now infamous GM Janesville plant, the assertion that Obama never passed a trade bill while in office, Romney's weird story about this departure from Bain; while also repeating things which the campaign had to know were not true -- the economy is worse today than when Obama took office, the Arab Spring has become an Arab Winter, the whole "he didn't build it" embarrassment. And, of course, there is the hiding the ball on his taxes, the offshore accounts, the high likelihood of massive tax evasion and the repeated mistakes/errors/lies on his public filings.

I've been in this business for twenty-five years now and, truly, I have never seen anything like this at this level of the game.

The big question is why? The New York Times speculates that it is because the current set of facts about the world and the U.S. economy are not sufficient to un-elect the President. To win they would have to make things up to make them seem worse than they are. I think there is an element of this. But to me it speaks to something much deeper and more disturbing in the ideological evolution of the center-right in the U.S. -- how their politics has placed protecting the privilege of elites over all other concerns and considerations.

At the core of this approach is something profoundly anti-democratic. In order to protect privilege estate taxes are eliminated; investments taxed at much lower rates than regular income; programs/investments critical for the middle class -- schools, infrastructure, retirement programs, health insurance reform -- are cut; programs for the poor are gutted; laws making it much harder for people are passed across the country; the campaign system now allows just a very wealthy few to have an extraordinary influence over political discourse; while all the while the right is fighting, fighting, fighting to lower taxes for the wealthiest among us.

If your politics revolves around protecting privilege, then lying to those without it is no big deal, for at the core of this new politics is a remarkable contempt for the well being of everyday people and the common good. This contempt for the truth is just an extension of their contempt for us and our interests. Which is why Mitt Romney is, in so many ways, a perfect candidate for this modern Republican Party, and Paul Ryan its perfect propagandist. They lie because at the end of the day their politics are not about us -- they are about them, and their small group of funders and political allies looking to do a leveraged buy-out of the most powerful government in human history. Which is why there has been almost no mention the first few nights of the GOP Convention about what they will do when in power. Other than protecting low taxes for the wealthy, it just isn't clear there is that much else they care about.

So yes, the extraordinary contempt for the truth demonstrated by team Romney is an issue in this campaign. But commentators and journalists need to dig a bit more and, I hope, connect it to a much deeper and more troubling corruption of the modern center-right.

 

Follow Simon Rosenberg on Twitter: www.twitter.com/simonwdc

FOLLOW POLITICS
For weeks I've been a bit amazed at how brazenly the Romney campaign has lied about simple things: the welfare waivers, the raiding of Medicare, that he would balance the budget in ten years, that the...
For weeks I've been a bit amazed at how brazenly the Romney campaign has lied about simple things: the welfare waivers, the raiding of Medicare, that he would balance the budget in ten years, that the...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 79
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
eps0609
07:49 AM on 09/05/2012
Wow! This was a great article/commentary.

Very interesting indeed. Funny how people who have little (compared to the 1%) will align themselves with those who have much with such disregard, as if the "have's" give a damn about them, as they ask everyone else to forget that the dialogue is untrue and factless. It's unbelievable. and deceptiove
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bradlinsky
Concept Other Than Self
09:27 AM on 09/04/2012
I remember the flack with Barkley, when he said he wasn't a role model. Well, here we have people in the highest positions of power, where all can see them - and not just in THIS country - and many times these are the people that 'represent' us to others, and should be looked up to as examples. Sadly, I wouldn't let most of these people babysit my kid. I couldn't trust anything they say, and I know should anything else come up they'd just leave my kid alone to fend for herself.

And these are the people we have RUNNING OUR COUNTRY?!
elogco
Borincua from Ohio the buckeye state
09:04 AM on 09/04/2012
It is incredible the power money plays in our politics. It is incredulous how almost half of the 99% have fallen under it's control.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alortiz
08:47 AM on 09/04/2012
This lying by the right has to be called out every day until it stops. They've had no shame.
photo
Skunkman
old & decrepit
08:33 AM on 09/04/2012
As Sinclair Lewis noted, "When fascism comes to America, it will be carrying a Bible and wrapped in the flag."

And the American Heritage Dictionary (1983) defined Fascism as, "a system of government that exercises a dictatorship of the extreme right, typically through the merging of state and business leadership, together with belligerent nationalism."

I don't see a lot of difference between that definition and what the Republican party has come to stand for.

Mike:
08:24 AM on 09/04/2012
America elect Mitt and Ryan at your own pearl.
photo
JudgeCCrater
From under a NJ boardwalk thanks to free Wi-Fi!
07:51 AM on 09/04/2012
I've no more faith in the MSM, Mr. Rosenberg, than I do in Tea Partiers waking up and realizing how thoroughly they've been used BEFORE November 6th.
05:29 AM on 09/04/2012
If the truth isn't good enough and you have to lie to win, then we all loose!
05:27 AM on 09/04/2012
The authoritarian-follower fringe has become the core of the Republican Party's base... and they so expect to be lied to -- audaciously -- that they will not support anyone without that particular moral depravity. These are the Bush-worshiping torture-lovers... and everything worse.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:00 AM on 09/04/2012
What is even sadder is that the liberal media is able to convince everyone that the Democrat's spin on so much is "the truth" while the Republican's view is "lies". There are so many gullible people out there that allow themselves to be told what to believe by Obama and his media puppets.

Even many of the so called fact checker analyses are just more of the same propaganda...twisting words and numbers to fit an agenda.

I've fact-checked several fact-checker articles and found as many if not more misrepresentations and falsehoods in the fact-check analysis as in the claim they are supposed to be checking.
05:19 AM on 09/04/2012
You imagine yourself a more competent fact-checker than the fact-checking professionals themselves... yet you still believe the laughable, long ago debunked fiction of a "liberal media."

Have you ever learned how to judge what an authoritative source even is... or how to distinguish pseudo-fact garbage from reliable research or real evidence?

No. Of course not.

The entirety of your fact-check analysis -- so called -- comes down to whether the item in question agrees with your preconceived notions or not.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:27 PM on 09/04/2012
I actually took the data from the same source as the fact checker. They just added up the numbers in a different way that made it appear as if the statement was incorrect when, as originally stated, there was nothing incorrect.

Basically, the original statement was A + B = C and the fact checker said that since X + Y = Z, then the claim on A + B can't equal C.

The conclusion they made did not logically follow from the statements they made. Regardless of the point trying to be made, it just didn't add up.
05:27 AM on 09/04/2012
Funny thing is Romney is lying to the republican voters as much as anyone else.

He actually considers himself a progressive.

He is actually pro-choice.

He actually loves Obamacare so much, he enacted it in his home state.

He actually is no more republican than Obama himself.

But, he lies to the republican voters because its the only way he can get elected! He doesn't want them to know he's not one of them. If fact, he's as much like Obama as...well...Obama himself.

So, republicans, be careful what you wish for. Because the joke just may be on you!
08:09 AM on 09/04/2012
you won't mind too much if he's elected then?
04:52 AM on 09/04/2012
Maybe, one day, a poor man or woman will run for president.
They will have no millions. They will have no holiday house at Martha's Vineyard...
They will not have family connections in politics. They will simply want to make a difference. When that person comes, watch the rich tremble, there will be no religion. Everyone will vote because they will have had enough of the lies you talk about above. One day...
TRoy, NZ
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rsstone74
My real name because I have nothing to hide
03:31 AM on 09/04/2012
Has anyone else out there stopped to think about what turning the clock back to the Reagan era will mean, in terms of interest rates? I am 100% convinced that the first thing that will change when Romney/Ryan take office is the Federal Reserve and the interest rate. Just watch: 3% will become 10% in a matter of months, and it won't stop until the cost of borrowing money is back in the 13-15% range.

For decades, the oil companies wanted the price of gas to be comparable to what they pay in Europe ($5 per gallon). We're almost there. Just watch. The next thing to go up is the interest rate.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rimser
08:03 AM on 09/04/2012
Actually, it's over $8.00/gal in the UK.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rsstone74
My real name because I have nothing to hide
04:41 PM on 09/04/2012
Correct...I meant to say, since it was $5 per gallon back in 1982 or 83 : ) Thank you for th correction.
02:17 AM on 09/04/2012
Read: "The Republican Brain" by Chris Mooney for an understanding of conservatives vs non-conservatives. You will understand why lies and no compromise play an important roll in conservative politics.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigMitch
An awesome Alaskan dude.
02:11 AM on 09/04/2012
by the way, this lying has the effect of making people sick of politics, and therefore, they pay less attention, making lying easier, and they don't vote, making winning easier for the people who don't mind being in the gutter.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigMitch
An awesome Alaskan dude.
02:08 AM on 09/04/2012
Stretching the truth, and spinning facts are not new. However, you are correct that this is very different. This is lying on a scale that is unprecedented. Why now? The answer isn't as deep as you may think. The truth stretchers and spinners of the past would have been full blown liars if they thought they could get away with it. But in the past there were three networks and they competed for your attention by promoting their fairness and trustworthiness. So, if someone went too far with his exaggerations, he would pay the price. Now, the media is so fragmented that you can find an outlet that is perfectly tailored to your outlook and perspective. And people like watching and listening to people they agree with. So if you are a pro-life, anti-gay, Paul Rand supporter, you can spend all day getting your views validated by the media. If you are a Romney guy, there's an outlet for you! And that outlet is interested in keeping your attention. So why would it call out Pinochio Romney? And thus, lying becomes the norm, for their is no price to pay.
elogco
Borincua from Ohio the buckeye state
01:14 PM on 09/04/2012
That's mighty insightful there, Mitch. Good job.
photo
MayaAtlantis
We are all connected.
03:23 PM on 09/04/2012
I wish I could fan you again. Thank you for your insight!