As Benjamin Bratt gets physically older are his character choices on TV regressing?
By most standards, Bratt has had a fantastic career; he's a serious, thoughtful actor whose fine work has earned him ALMA Awards, a SGA Award, and an Emmy nomination. So, how did this actor, whose credits include playing Che Guevera and Detective Ray Curtis (Law and Order) come to his current role of Javier Delgado (Sofia Vergara's ex husband) on Modern Family? And more importantly, does it signify a step backward for Hispanics on TV?
Modern Family is a great show for lots of reasons. It skillfully captures contemporary non-traditional family structures and then layers on traditional family dysfunctions. It deserves its popularity and critical acclaim but for one thing... why are all first generation Hispanics on the show (basically Vergara and Bratt) hypersexual, overly superstitious, heavily-accented Hispanic stereotypes? The writers seem to have one model and one model only, Ricky Ricardo.
Some of it hits home with Hispanics in a positive way. They recognize the superstitions and have first hand experience with mispronunciations. It can be really funny. But to see Ben Bratt, who in the 1990s was repeatedly Emmy nominated for his portrayal of a determined and moral detective, adopt the Ricky Ricardo accent and portray his character as someone who can "see the soul of the horse in his eyes," feels, well, regressive. It would be quite in character if he were to put his hand on his head and say "LUUUUCIEEEEEE!!!!" The show's homosexual characters are similarly stereotyped (along with the many other characters), but the writers seem to give them more depth of character. From a sociological point of view:
"Television programming is primarily produced by commercial industries with capitalist interests. The symbolic products of these systems generally represent the ideas and values of mainstream corporate society or the views of dominant groups in U.S. culture" (Fiske 1987, Lembo 1992).
Does this mean that dominant groups in the United States see first-generation Hispanics as hypersexual, overly-superstitious rubes with heavy accents? Sure, its parody. It's well done.
It's fun to watch. But watching a well-known Hispanic actor, whose previous portrayals have added depth to the Hispanic image in American popular culture, play this role begs a question -- is this progress?
If anything, something needs to be said more for the characters on other sitcoms which lean so heavily on teh Mexican immigrant, gardener, possible illegal, et al. THAT gets so tiresome to see.
2. Probably most of "Modern Family"'s audience don't know who Ricky Ricardo is.
I would instead suggest that this inept article is a setback for Hispanic writers everywhere.
I'll admit it; I had big problems with Vergara's character in the beginning (in fact, I deplored her "chuchifrito accent"). But she's grown on me, probably because she reminds me of my first generation relatives, who also adhere to old-country superstitions and cultural "traditions." So when Bratt appeared I was predisposed to like him, especially when he rolled out what I took to be a flawless impersonation of the late Ricardo Montalban (a Mexican expat who had a heavy accent until he died). It was all there: the beautiful casual clothes, the ramrod posture, the insanely suave demeanor (Cam couldn't take his eyes off him!), the convoluted worldview. Heh. I thought he was great, and as a Latina, I thought the character wasn't a stereotype or insulting at all. I guess it's all in the perception.