More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Stewart Nusbaumer

Stewart Nusbaumer

Posted: September 13, 2010 01:31 PM

Film Review: Beijing Punk

What's Your Reaction:

Atlantic City, New Jersey -- At the very beginning, Beijing Punk asks: "What happens when 1.3 billion Chinese discover punk?" Then it proceeds to answer the question -- well, not exactly. But that doesn't matter. This is a fascinating and insightful journey into China's punk culture, a world few people know about, including the 1.3 billion Chinese. We are taken into their underground clubs, hang with several bands that fuel the Beijing punk spirit, visit their crash pads as they unwind and get ripped and stoned. We witness their anger, their alienation, their hostility, their rebellion.

2010-09-10-Beijing_Punk2.jpg


This intimate and raw film screened at the Atlantic City International Film and Music Festival, which is the festival's inaugural year. With venues scattered among four boardwalk hotels -- Bally's, Caesars, Showboat, and Harrahs -- it makes for an unusual atmosphere for a film and music festival. The competition with the casinos is never easy in Atlantic City, but the festival's founder and director, John Paxton, is determined to turn Atlantic City into a major festival stop.

As for Beijing Punk, which is quickly achieving cult status among a growing number of independent film goers, the film was received enthusiastically in Atlantic City. At the Q&A after the screening it was clear that the film took a few American former-punkers down memory lane.

But are Chinese punks different from other punks? The Chinese variety have the same spiked hair and leather jackets and tattoos, engage in heavy if not constant drinking and drug taking -- codeine and hash seem to be their favorites -- and violence is more than tolerated. It appears there is nothing really different about Chinese punks, except they are punks in China.

Yet, didn't punkdom have a quick death back in the 1970s? And isn't China tightly controlled by a ruthless authoritarian government? And doesn't a famous Chinese saying go, "Any nail left standing up must be hammered down"? China may be embracing the capitalistic -- "getting rich is glorious," as they also say in China -- yet causing trouble certainly isn't. So how are punks in China possible? They tip-toe on a razor-sharp line.

The punk bands' lyrics do not directly challenge the government and it's closed political system. That would be one fast and brutal no-no and the end of punks in China. Instead, their words attack the amorphous "society" and "culture." The words are ambiguous and allow hidden meanings to be understood among the faithful punkers, yet allow the authorities to claim the punkers are not saying what they are actually saying. This vagueness allow punk bands in punk clubs with punk fans to exist in modern China.

Growing up in a society where the government is watchful and nervous about popular culture, about anything and anybody that could develop into a challenge to its authority, Chinese punkers are ballerinas on the line between the acceptable and the unacceptable. If they dance too close to the forbidden, the authorities clamp down; seldom is the line explicitly crossed, so they are allowed to exist as an underground entity. Their rage in public, even in their underground clubs, exists without specific targets. Diffused rage is seldom a political threat.

The visuals and audio of Beijing Punk reflect the rawness and roughness of the subject matter. Australian director Shaun Jefford has produced an intimate, at times hilarious, riveting portrait of a group of young Chinese struggling to survive in a society increasingly infatuated with materialism While most of the Western media, even some independent films, focus on the "economic machine" of the East, Jeffords slips us into the lives of those who hate this "getting rich is glorious" machine.

Beijing Punk, then, is not so much about a bygone subculture that today lives in Beijing, but about the arrival of what Chinese authorities will have to adjust to in the future: citizens refusing to follow the official program. This will mean rebellion from the mainstream -- nails that refuse to be hammered down! This will mean more Chinese individualism in all its strange and weird forms.

Beijing Punk gives us the Western punk of our past that lives today in in Beijing, and a glimpse into the future of China, a future its authorities would rather not see. And that is another reason to see this very good film.

 
Atlantic City, New Jersey -- At the very beginning, Beijing Punk asks: "What happens when 1.3 billion Chinese discover punk?" Then it proceeds to answer the question -- well, not exactly. But that do...
Atlantic City, New Jersey -- At the very beginning, Beijing Punk asks: "What happens when 1.3 billion Chinese discover punk?" Then it proceeds to answer the question -- well, not exactly. But that do...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joseph Smigelski
College English Instructor in Northern California
10:31 AM on 09/16/2010
"Chinese punkers are ballerinas ... " I wonder what the late Sid Vicious would have to say about that.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Stewart Nusbaumer
05:19 PM on 09/16/2010
Where are my leotards?
photo
SF TKF
Cthulhu thinks you'd make a nice sandwich.
03:04 PM on 09/14/2010
Punk died a quick death in the 70s? Don't tell that to all the punks down at the Gilman!
10:30 AM on 09/14/2010
"Diffused rage is seldom a political threat." --Great line, great city!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Stewart Nusbaumer
06:43 PM on 09/14/2010
Hey, thanks. I loved that too. Sometimes things just pop into your heard, and they're good. Wish it happened a little more often.
09:07 PM on 09/14/2010
Agreed! The review was a really good read all round, Stewart, but that line - thank the muse!:)
12:24 AM on 09/14/2010
And doesn't a famous Chinese saying go, "Any nail left standing up must be hammered down"?

Nope - that's Japanese.

for more alternative music from China and the rest of Asia check out world renowned distributor 'tenzenmen'
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Stewart Nusbaumer
09:44 AM on 09/14/2010
Don't tell the Chinese that. To them, the Japanese claim everything.
11:01 AM on 09/14/2010
that is what I thought as I heard that exact saying recently on either The Cove or the regular show Blood Dolphins, attributed to the Japanese and an explanation about why media and regular folk have not made an issue of the dolphin slaughters.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Stewart Nusbaumer
09:36 AM on 09/15/2010
Of course the origins of these sayings are murky. When I lived in China in the 1990s, it was being said then, and Chinese took ownership.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alice Radley
Post hoc ergo propter hoc
07:05 PM on 09/13/2010
Where there's punk, there's hope. This makes me incredibly happy.
08:11 PM on 09/13/2010
I used to frequent the violent yet exciing chinese punk world until i found recruitment. Both worlds in my opinion have their unique place. The Director Shaun Jefford should turn his sights to the real underground world of C++ programmers. It's only then his eyes will become trly open.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alice Radley
Post hoc ergo propter hoc
08:38 PM on 09/13/2010
You're just trying to perpetuate the idea that programmers are cool.