Last summer, when mass protests broke out in Iran following what was seen as a rigged election, Americans cried out in support of the uprising through all possible channels. Some commentators here went so far as to claim credit for the "revolution," as if it never could have happened without American political movements having already set the example. But despite the arrogance of that claim, the Iranian Green movement is indeed an exertion of democratic will that resonates closely with many Americans -- and for good reason.
America's rich history of successful social and political movements, from its genesis onward, lends profound familiarity to the Iranian uprising, most of which has remained nonviolent. The enduring American symbolic identity -- as a bastion of freedom and opportunity -- is mostly justified when one considers the relative success of the Civil Rights or Feminist movements of the 20th Century, or of the ongoing LGBT rights movement, which continues to make incremental gains today. American democracy, fueled by an active populace -- despite its numerous imperfections -- remains the gold standard around the world.
It is against this venerable historical backdrop that one must concede that the most well known, highly publicized American social/political movement today -- the Tea Party movement -- is a national embarrassment.
At its core, the Tea Party movement is rife with contradiction, incoherence and a willful contempt for facts or reason. It is but a parody of the legitimate movements for which American democracy has historically been held in such high regard. It is, in fact, the latest installment in quite another American tradition: the exploitation of frustrated, desperate, and susceptible people by monied interests and profiteers.
The impetus for the Civil Rights movement was centuries of racially based oppression at all levels of American government and society. The logic behind its call for equality was overwhelming. Now consider the Tea Party movement, whose foremost demand of a president who in his first month passed one of the biggest tax cuts ever...is for tax cuts. The movement's incoherence is only illuminated further when this demand is uttered in the same sentence as its call for deficit reduction.
Though the movement claims to have no defined leadership, there are public figures and entities who nevertheless carry that mantle, which has led to perhaps its greatest irony: a portion of the American populace who carries a populist banner against the coddling of greedy bankers is led by some of the country's most cynical and base profiteers.
When the movement was christened last April for a large tax day protest, it was derived wholesale from the efforts of a registered corporate lobbyist and a right-leaning cable news network, whose president recently pointed out that it's all about ratings. At the Tea Party's national convention last weekend, its keynote speaker was a former governor who quit midterm in order to peddle a book that she didn't write, but for which she collects most of the royalties. If this were Iran's Green Movement, these would be the people slinging marked-up green headbands on the street corner.
Of course, the Tea Party is not without its whistleblowers. The $500 per plate entry fee to last week's convention almost led to it being canceled altogether. But the exodus of reasonable elements will only homogenize the movement further towards a particularly polarizing worldview that opens itself to continued profit-driven exploitation.
In Authoritarianism & Polarization in American Politics, a revealing work of political science published last year that unfortunately went somewhat unnoticed, Marc J. Hetherington and Jonathan D. Weiler describe a specific worldview -- authoritarianism -- which they argue lies at the heart of political polarization in modern American politics. (It should be noted: their use of the term "authoritarian" is not related to the more quotidian and overly negative connotation associated with despotic regimes; rather, it describes a particular lens through which certain people view the world, based on a wide range of scholarly work spanning the fields of psychology, sociology, political science, and other cognitive sciences.)
According to Hetherington and Weiler, authoritarians tend to rely more on emotion and instinct in decision-making, view politics in black and white, resent confusion or ambiguity in the social order, and are suspicious of specific groups who they believe could alter that order (typically gays and immigrants). The difference between authoritarians and nonauthoritarians, according to the authors, becomes far more pronounced during tumultuous economic or social periods when there are more perceived "threats." During such times, authoritarians in particular lose accuracy motivation and, "become much less interested than nonauthoritarians in seeking information that [is] balanced in its approach, and much more interested in pursuing one-sided information that reinforc[es] existing beliefs." Or in other words, they are highly susceptible to misinformation campaigns, the likes of which pervaded the health care reform debate last summer.
Most every characteristic of an authoritarian worldview lends itself well to the impassioned rhetoric of the Tea Party movement and to the shrewd players operating behind the scenes and atop the soap box. The movement's overly simplified, often-confused solutions to complex problems align with authoritarians' Manichean worldview. That Tom Tancredo's anti-immigrant laced speech at last weekend's convention was well received comes as no surprise. And that this is the group who so often embraces proven falsehoods and spin-narratives to defend its anti-administration agenda should speak for itself with regards to accuracy motivation.
Despite the criticism it receives, the Tea Party continues to be praised as a political force. It is loud, passionate, and generally unconcerned with pesky things like facts or reasoned, practical solutions to the country's problems. This bodes ill for 2010's political environment, and it is a shameful representation of what constitutes an American political or social movement. While the Tea Party may alienate some who see it for the profit-machine that it is, others who share the fearful, intolerant authoritarian worldview that it is increasingly coalescing around will be lured in and pitted against the very people in power who could actually help them. That this movement has grown political legs is too bad, and by Hetherington and Weiler's account, it means even more polarization is yet to come.
Tax Day Tea Party | Online HQ for the April 15th Nationwide Tax ...
Tea Party Patriots - Official Home of the American Tea Party Movement
Tea Party protests, 2009 - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
MATTHEWS: 'Tea party' movement a flash in the pan?
Meghan McCain Blasts Tea Party Movement, Palin on 'The View'
Gibbs mocks Sarah Palin's palm-writing at briefing
Misunderstanding the Tea Party
Anti-Tea Party Web Site Part of Scheme to Funnel Funds
Lowry: Democrats underestimate potent tea party
Slight of hand: White House spokesman Robert Gibbs writes in jab at Sarah ...
Anti-Tea Party Web Site Part of Scheme to Funnel Funds
Brit Hume on Media Reaction to Tea Party Convention
"Dear John": A Movie the Tea Party May Love
Ron Paul Warns Of Neo-Con Takeover Of Tea Party Movement
Tea Party Jab to Be Zapped From Captain America Comic, Writer Says
Tea Party Movement Produces New Political Organization
How Popular is the Tea Party Movement? - Feb 10
Reagan Brothers Feud Over Father's Response to Tea Party Movement
Stars and Gripes: Tea Party Protests Captain America Comic
Tea Party Movement Produces New Political Organization
What I Saw at the Tea Party Convention
Captain America's Tea Party Dig Prompts Apology From Marvel Editor Joe Quesada
Richard Brookhiser: Tea Parties and the American Political Tradition
Sarah Palin & Tea Party Movement Stand Alone As “Voice Of Reason”
Reagan Brothers Feud Over Father's Response to Tea Party Movement
Tea Party movement full of racists and conspiracists according to FOX poll
Tea Party Patriots | Find Your Local Tea Party
Tea Party movement - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Democrats to GOP: You're Either With Tea Party or Against It
Colorado Tea Party candidate calls bike-sharing a UN plot
The line is now clearly drawn and the American people know what the 2 choices are. Will they allow the liberals to lead our Federal Government to become a bigger, quasi-soci
The same anger that the liberal media sold to the American people about Bush "lying" to get us into the Iraq war has turned into a double edged sword. Simply put, many Americans in the center are angry from being misled and lied to from the liberal media and are bringing this government back to the center and back into the hands of the people.
The big cooperatio
Looking blindly as GNP and feel that you are the richest country in the world does not fill your stomach or pay for the rent and fill up your gas tank.
Cooperatio
Third world countries like Iran have better living standard. Anybody can afford to send their kid to universiti
A full body cat-scan costs $80 in Iran without health insurance and with health insurance it is free. I do not have so much informatio
It is about economy and where our huge wealth is worth if we cannot spend it for well being of ourselves and our children.
Technology is rendering these political activists disquised as news reporters irrelevant
The cat is out of the bag and the moderate American people in the center who trusted the media for their informatio
Hope, change, transparen
The moderate American people in the center are not happy.
I am AMAZED at the number of respondent
The federal government has saddled every U.S. citizen with unfunded obligation
Did you get that? $400,000 per person, $1.6M per family of 4.
How many of you believe that there is anything moral or compassion
Will somebody with a rational thought process please 1) acknowledg
Do the H/P clientele REALLY believe that tripling or quadruplin
You, sir, are a perfect example of the spend-at-a
Believe me, I may be many things, but DUPED is not one of them.
1) $560 Billion - DON"T SPEND THE REST OF THE STIMULUS BILL FUNDS
2) $50 Billion in savings from Obama-iden
3) $250 Billion from bank TARP pay-backs rather than illegally "re-used" for other government projects.
4) $1.2 Trillion - All of the $1.2 trillion that Obama added is DISCRETION
So, Mr. Morbius, you have $1.96 Trillion in INSTANT DEFICIT REDUCTION - yielding a surplus for FY 2010.
That's not even including across-the
Regarding the "bill presented to your children" comment, do you think that these unbelievab
Proactivel
These are the facts and figures - no propaganda except yours.
Let me ask the final question that is critical: Are you saying that you are OK with you and each of your family members owing $400,000 from government debt and unfunded obligation
Please answer this $400,000 question.
America has always had a very high proportion of authoritar
My friends, that is about the scariest thing I have read in a long time. And the Utah State gov't is trying to show how right such an awful decision is!
THAT is an embarrassm
Add to it the high unemployme
The cherry on top? Our crooked, liar elected officials, who cheat on their wives at taxpayer expense all the while pounding their self-right
I have to stop now, making myself ill with it all.
John Edwards may have been wrong on just about everything else, but he was right about one thing: there are indeed two Americas! It's as if our elites--pa
Public education has become a real mess: and this is definitely the case in NYC where I grew up and now work. It's heartbreak
So long as our public education fails us, we will be in increasing danger of lagging behind 3rd world nations. Actually, we already are, given that more than a few developing Asian nations have outstrippe
Now as for the T-baggers, they could care less. Heck, they'd prefer to homeschool so their children won't have to be exposed to disturbing concepts like "evolution
Ultimately
I subsititue teach to help my school system. I want more than anything else for our school system to produce better educated students. In Oakland, California
Please, stop with the ignorant characteri
Mensch === a person of integrity and honor. ( maybe Gentile dictionary
It is not rocket science that jobs create wealth and a healthy economy. It is not a mystery that our economy is fueled and maintained by small businesses
The Washington crowd is elected or rejected by Main Street. Unfortunat
We thought that Obama promised change. Sadly he has been a very big disappoint
The GOP has done all they could to stand in the Democrats' way JUST to make sure Americans were disappoint
Don't be pathetic. Educate yourself about the problems. READ THE NEWS.
The national embarrassm
The large unemployme
Become a meintsch, a human being with decency, stop silly and superfluou
And to others stop blasting about subjects of no interest to the American people, like wasting time and effort on heath care reform. We need jobs, jobs, jobs. I this too difficult to understand
It is a shame and a tragedy. The only resource we have is to vote the incumbents out. Also blog to defend this right that has been taken away from us. The right to make a decent and honest living.
garelj@ver
The GOP's strategy by being obstructio
Congratula
http://www
if Libertaria
Their view of the Constituti
if the Libertaria
:ibertaria
Is simply
AHHHH WHAAAAN AHHH WHIIIDE PREZEEEDEN
They cannot use the "N" word, so they call Obama:
Socialist (like it's a BAD thing and the US Medicare is somehow not a socialist program)
Marxist
Communist
Nazi (at least it is close to the "N" word)
Meanwhile they have no idea what any of these words mean.
They lose their minds, led by Glen Beck, and claim that he is a racist and hates white people.
Or worst of all they believe in "death panels" and even republican members of congress claim these exist an shout about them on the house and senate floors.
These congress persons should be thrown out or at least heavily sanctioned for this FACTLESS fear-monge
Law makers should be required to work only with facts and not insane claims like this.
What if they were to just as falsely claim that an alien invasion were eminent, or that Iran and/or North Korea had actually launched nuclear missiles at the US??
Which predicts that people unthinking
translatio
Rock on teabaggers
A patriarcha
I think the tea baggers are as much victims as they are anything else. Victims of a really bad educationa
How much of it do we really have? We talk a lot about conformity in Eastern nations, and yet we are finding more of the same here: it's evident not only in our increasing
How do you think the CEOs were able to grab as much compensati
For the Bible thumpers, it's even worse: follow the pastor/min
BTW - fanned.
AHHH WHAAAN MAHHH CUNTREE BAAAACK
Is simply
AHHHH WHAAAAN AHHH WHIIIDE PREZEEEDEN
They cannot use the "N" word, so they cal Obama:
Socialist (like it's a BAD thing and the US Medicare is somehow not a socialist program)
Marxist
Communist
Nazi (at least it is close to the "N" word)
Meanwhile they have no idea what any of these words mean.
They lose their minds, led by Glen Beck, and claim that he is a racist and hates white people.
Or worst of all they believe in "death panels" and even republican members of congress claim these exist an shout about them on the house and senate floors.
These congress persons should be thrown out or at least heavily sanctioned for this FACTLESS fear-monge
Law makers should be required to work only with facts and not insane claims like this.
What if they were to just as falsely claim that an alien invasion were eminent, or that Iran and/or North Korea had actually launched nuclear missiles at the US??