iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Suzanne Braun Levine

GET UPDATES FROM Suzanne Braun Levine
 

What We Left Behind: Girdles, Silence and Illegal Abortion

Posted: 01/14/12 09:11 AM ET

When I went to work at Ms. in 1972, I wore a matching pink skirt and blouse -- and a girdle. I had just gotten married and was, therefore, not able to get a bank loan without my husband's approval. I had given up playing basketball (half-court for girls) in college because no coach or court could be found. And I had had an illegal abortion.

Actually it was having had that abortion that was my first tie to Ms. and the women's movement. The Preview Issue of the magazine, which was excerpted in New York magazine, included among such classics as "Click! The Housewife's Moment of Truth" by Jane O'Reilly and "I Want a Wife" by Judy Syfers, a list of celebrity names under the headline "We Have Had Abortions." It took a lot of courage back then to admit to what was a crime. In the corner was a coupon which readers could fill out to add their name to the list. I filled it out with pride and relief (I hadn't admitted to my crime before), and by the time those coupons were being counted and processed several months later, I was managing editor of Ms.

Many of the social, economic, and political restrictions that held women back were overthrown during the 17 years I was there, and Ms. was a prime mover in that wave of change. Every day at work I was learning a lot about women and about myself. I know for sure that I would not be the person I am today had I not been part of the Ms. experience, and I certainly would not have had the expertise to draw on when I started writing about Second Adulthood (Inventing the Rest of Our Lives, Fifty Is the New Fifty, and out this month How We Love Now). Without the women's movement, I wouldn't have had the courage or the confidence to even draw on that expertise and go public with my ideas.

This year Ms. celebrates its fortieth anniversary. It's hard to believe that it has been so long, and when I look at photographs I am amazed at how young we were! My daughter is 25, the age of most of the staff back then. She wears whatever she pleases -- but never a girdle (do they still exist?); she has several credit cards in her name; she has maintained a commitment to volleyball throughout her school years and now plays on a (co-ed) New York City team; and if she needed an abortion, she could get one (though women, especially rural women, in other states, would have a much harder time).

The battles we fought are won, but not over. Women still earn less for the same job than men; the fashion and beauty industry still makes us feel we should look a certain way and if we don't -- especially if we are over forty -- we should be ashamed. Title IX, which made women's sports viable, is under siege from those institutions that think their athletic budgets are better spent on football. And as every election and legislative session reminds us, the right to choose abortion is under siege. Her generation will undoubtedly be called upon to hold onto these gains.

As she moves through her life, my daughter will also come up against still unresolved inequities. If she marries and has children, she will quickly learn that no matter how much of the work and family responsibilities her partner shares, the workplace is inhospitable to the needs of working parents. Sure, we now have family leave policies, but since frequently they are unpaid, time off is a luxury most can't afford. And although work hours have eased up somewhat, there is a price for that flexibility too -- a gentle shove off the fast track. That will have to change.

Care-giving in general, she will learn, is still women's work. Studies show that when a family is called upon to take care of an aging or ailing relative, it is almost always a female (an unmarried female is usually the first choice -- as if she didn't have pressures and responsibilities of her own, including being her own sole financial support) who gets nominated. I see care-getting as a new frontier that I hope my daughter's generation will cross; it is time for our society to step in where individual (unpaid) care-givers are toiling, and it is essential for all those care-givers to be encouraged to give the same degree of care that they are expending on others to their own well-being.

Her generation will also have issues of their own. But thanks to the strength and confidence they have absorbed from the changing world Ms. has been celebrating -- and chastising --for 40 years, I have no doubt that they will prevail.

2012-01-13-Abortions320x240.jpg

Stanford University will mark the 40th anniversary of Ms. magazine with a winter quarter of more than 25 events titled: "Ms. at 40 and the Future of Feminism." The symposium, which will run from January through March, will feature lectures, panel discussions. performances, exhibits and an international, multigenerational essay contest.

 
 
 
When I went to work at Ms. in 1972, I wore a matching pink skirt and blouse -- and a girdle. I had just gotten married and was, therefore, not able to get a bank loan without my husband's approval. I ...
When I went to work at Ms. in 1972, I wore a matching pink skirt and blouse -- and a girdle. I had just gotten married and was, therefore, not able to get a bank loan without my husband's approval. I ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 281
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
03:26 PM on 02/01/2012
What do you think of Susan G. Komen cutting off funding to women's health group Planned Parenthood under political pressure. Yes we have came a long way, but when an organization like Susan G. Komen can be bullied into this kind of behavior it just shows how much more needs to be done. Planned Parenthood will be struggling with out this funding. so before you give to Komen consider giving to Planned Parenthood. And no I do not work for Planned Parenthood or affiliated ith them in any way, I have just seen some of the good they have done for women!
06:04 PM on 01/20/2012
A fantastic article, Suzanne, I admire your courageous honesty. I would have filled out that same ballot had I seen one. Still would today. My legal abortion at sixteen in the early 70's had my family physician shouting at me in front of my silent parents for being promiscuous.

Some twenty years later I 'smuggled' my best friend into an abortion clinic, she was terrified her boyfriend would find our and force her to keep the baby. The glass wall in front of the receptionist was bulletproof.

It it still a mystery to me what the heck the abortion issue has to do with politics, other than a cheap shot at garnering more votes. What we do with our bodies is our strictly our business, our choice. Not some desperate politician's.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigWillyG
03:08 PM on 01/17/2012
So how is a girdle related to women's rights? Abortion I get, getting your own loan when married I get but a girdle is just a piece of clothing not some massive social statement, especially since it's worn under clothes so nobody knows if you're wearing one to begin with.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frank1946
Tell the Truth
07:46 AM on 01/17/2012
America is Insolvent and the Divorce Rate is over 50 %..................Marriage is now a failing
state of Union between partners and the battle of the Sexes seems to be frozen in time.

Progress ? I wonder ? Single Parent Households seem to be a Disaster.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bergerqueen
07:14 PM on 01/16/2012
Back in the day, my mom - a mother of 4 - needed permission from my father, from whom she was separated but not yet divorced, to get her tubes tied. The doctor had known her for years and knew that she was separated from my dad, but he still required written permission.
02:44 PM on 01/16/2012
Below this article is a picture of a pregnant woman holding a sonogram. It's not 1972 anymore. Back then, out of wedlock pregnancy was stigmatized, adoption was usually hidden, and almost nothing was known about fetal development. True feminism is pro-life. Abortion feminism hurt women. Abortion does not make it possible for women to become doctors, governors, or lawyers; it tells them that they reconcile maternity with life goals by having unborn children killed. As many have noted, it sets the standard for equality as the non-pregnant, unemcumbered male. Claiming that legalized abortion helped women is like claiming that amputating the leg helps the sprained ankle. And let's not forget the millions and millions of babies aborted.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jen Celli
Done sitting and watching quietly.
04:06 PM on 01/16/2012
Illegal abortion - generally the solution of last resort - was responsible for killing many women and maiming others. You can pontificate all day long of the deaths of unborn fetus', but no woman should be forced to continue a pregnancy that she does not want. She should be able to get a safe and legal abortion if that is her choice and make no mistake, it is her choice and between her, her doctor and her "God". Being pro-abortion is about life; it's being for the life of the woman and against knitting needles and coat hangars in back alley clinics. No woman should ever bleed to death because she does not wish to carry to term.
photo
sindurrella
now where did I put my bootstraps?
06:44 PM on 01/16/2012
well said. thank you.
Pro life people need to remember that if a "back alley" abortions didn't kill you, it could render you sterile. Making it legal and safe is the only way we can protect the life of the woman and insure that when she is ready for motherhood, she will be able to conceive..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jacqueline Homan
author and freelance investigative journalist
04:24 AM on 01/17/2012
Medical ethics, human rights and the geography of pregnancy are lost on the pro-sexual torture/pro-forced birth/Rapists' Rights political bowel movement. They're nothing but anti-woman bullies who seek to legitimize sexual sadism and gender-specific torture.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jacqueline Homan
author and freelance investigative journalist
04:21 AM on 01/17/2012
Logic FAIL. No children. No baby. Zygotes, blastocysts, and non-viable fetuses are NOT "babies" or "persons." It doesn't matter what you "believe"; the cold, hard facts of science, the universal declaration on human rights, and the geography of pregnancy are the issues. The human right to have control over what happens to one's own body is paramount. Forcing women to endure pregnancy and childbirth against our will for the sake of "morality" and the "sanctity of life" is no different than forcing men to undergo permanent life-altering organ donation surgery. No man is forced under penalty of law to donate his blood, bone marrow or kidneys to save the life of another human being, even if that other person is his own child and needs it in order to live. Because NO ONE can be forced to relinquish their body (in whole or in part) for use as a life support system for the exclusive benefit of another.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Frano
‘Plausible Deniability’: NOT A FAMILY_VALUE!!
01:33 PM on 01/16/2012
Re: “And I had had an illegal abortion. Actually it was having had that abortion that was my first tie to Ms. and the women's movement.” {Author}
There are many-grains-O’-truth in the old saying: “If men could get pregnant, abortion would be a sacrament!”…

As a retired paramedic, I have seen/treated placenta previa, (1), abruptio placenta, (1), delivered children, managed P.I.D. patients, treated pregnant woman w/ G.S.W.’s, (that’s ‘Gun Shot Wound(s)) & other abdominal trauma, survived 1 shift with a prolifer praising E. Rudolph, (who left I.E.D.'s for rescuers as well as uppity woman, maimed nurses & dead cops), and generally have about 3.9 'femptoseconds’ to waste, listenin’ to the prolife pope as he waddles, in between (potential) FBI/Interpol Red-Sheet conspiracy-indictments for ‘fugitive-from-justice’ & ‘child-rape’ R.I.C.O.'s!

Placenta Previa, & Abruptio Placenta, (placenta first delivery & premature placental detachment, (respectively), are the ‘ob.gyn’ analogy to the late, (fictional) Capt. John Miller’s ‘storming Omaha beach’ experience. (Tom Hanks, “Saving Pvt. Ryan”).

There ain’t much that nauseates/causes this 22-year-career urban Paramedic Field Internship Instructor to hurl…

...Excluding the 2012-Republican-Also-Rans, as they prepare to lose the election, (...while parading their 'Stepford' wives & daughters, Maggie Gallagher, etc.!
12:05 PM on 01/16/2012
Yes Suzanne girdles do exist they call them Spanx now. But what I really want to say is Thank You because of what you and other women did I was able to get a legal abortion. Our right to choice is under attack on a daily basis may I suggest Ms. magazine once again run it's I have had an abortion form so young women can continue to have safe legal abortions.
04:12 PM on 01/17/2012
You are right that there are spanx but as far as I can tell there is no comparison to a serious girdle - or, worse, to a "merry widow."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syds180turn
Independent and Proud of It!
05:25 PM on 01/15/2012
It is up to us women to tell these wingnuts to butt out of our lives and demand equality. They may not hear a few voices but they will hear millions. Cohesively, women have the strongest weapon available...economic power. We should start at the top and work our way down. Stop supporting candidates that don't support us. Stop putting money in industries that want us all to be 19 forever, anorexic and emotionally insecure and weak. March on Washington as our mothers, grandmothers and others did when they demanded...not ask, but demanded that their voices were heard and changes in the workforce. As long as we stay silent and allow these religious fanatics to gain traction and support by omission and inaction, images that paint us as nothing more than things not people, we will continue to have this conversation and this fight for equality. I'm not anti-male I'm just pro-women's rights and equality. The few weak ones among us are the ones who's dragging us down. Every single time you sit there and watch the Kardashians, buy these magazines that perpetuate these beauty myths, spend money on movies that use women as nothing more than a sex toy and co-sign on TV shows, music and any and every medium that degrades and humiliates us, you're giving the so-called powers-that-be the right to infringe upon our personal freedoms and negate our voices.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
momoluvsu
We live in a parallel universe
06:02 PM on 01/15/2012
Fanned. You brought up excellent points. Another point is in 2008 presidential election women out voted men 51% to 49%. There is a lot that can be done with numbers like that, and women are not fully recognizing their potential for positive influence.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
canadagirl76
A mind is like a parachute, they work best open.
11:32 AM on 01/16/2012
Fanned!
photo
saint bernard mom
and Newfie Gram ♥spay♥neuter♥adopt♥
03:19 PM on 01/15/2012
No matter how anyone feels about abortions, it is imperative that people teach their sons AND daughters that they are equally responsible for conception. It takes a sperm AND an egg to reproduce. Both sexes should be aware that they need to be 100% responsible for their OWN actions.  
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mater
mater
02:39 PM on 01/15/2012
I'm prochoice and i STILL think that's unnecessary sensationalism for your blog. Write about winter or spring or getting older. No one's life is enriched knowing that about you, and the fact that after many years it's right there in the front of your mind and somehow tied to working for a feminist magazine seems like this was more therapeutic for you than it is for us, as readers.
04:23 PM on 01/15/2012
It's called "normallizing", and it's a journey that has to be taken by members in society because of the "demonizing" that is underway by the fundamentalists and right wingers. Others call it "Bear Witness" and "Testify". Both are required in the process of achieving social justice. "Keeping it in the Closet" is what happens to people who are made frightened by those who "demonize".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mater
mater
05:03 PM on 01/15/2012
I think she needs to do whatever is right for her, but to share that with readers who have a range of their own experiences, is taking alot for granted. I wish her no unkindness, but I am not a therapist and it apparently happened to her a very long time ago. If she still has things to work out, I wish her well, but am uncomfortable with not being asked if i wished to share this deeply personal experience.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:17 PM on 01/16/2012
You are wrong. My life was enriched, for one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mater
mater
01:22 PM on 01/16/2012
Good for you. My life is enriched by living it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
estercat
12:59 PM on 01/15/2012
I support choice, I support women being treated a equals. I also feel there should be more equity in the work place, women still make less, I support all of this and much more, But the girdle -- if you don't want to wear one you shouldn't, but don't make it a feminist thing, Girdles are great and no I don't wear one, but I would if it was not a censored item by many. go braless, and don't wear a girlde, but please let it be a choice that is not looked down on
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
shortguy54
Short, balding, brilliant... (well, maybe not so)
02:39 PM on 01/15/2012
I'm not saying you're right or wrong. But your priorities so seem a little wierd. Just saying...
12:19 PM on 01/15/2012
Well, even St. Thomas Aquinas thought that the human (rational) soul did not begin a the moment of conception. It appeared only when the "matter" was prepared by its development through the vegetative and animal (sentient) souls.

There is something deeply cruel in those who would not allow abortion in any case whatsoever -- and it becomes even more cruel that they would want to seize the political power to prevent all abortions without qualification. No moral code is to be treated without qualification (e.g. "Thou shalt not kill" --
tell that to McDonald's or the Marines) It is evident that women love children, and that they do not enjoy having an abortion, and it is a traumatic and painful step taken only under extreme duress. Perhaps the angry moral Nannies might help out by adoptions or financial help? Do they? By the by, a positive moral defense of abortion can be develped along the lines of taking the fetus as an unjust aggressor -- but this is not the place for it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:20 PM on 01/16/2012
Interesting, I did not know that. Usually Aquinas gets so much wrong. Thank you for enlightening me.

I carry around a flier in my car, for every time I see a "Choose Life" bumper sticker. It says quite simply, "put your money where your morals are" and then provides them with all the information they need to know to contact local adoption agencies and services.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
callie34677
In Florida, surrounded by crazies
12:48 AM on 01/17/2012
You'd have a field day down here, we have state issued license plates with that slogan, unfortunately.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dan Slander
06:20 AM on 01/15/2012
Your abortion was in a larger sense an act of nature much in the same way an eagle allows its young to kill each other to increase the stronger one's chances. Dropping the first would have put you behind the eight ball financially and professionally. Offing it allowed your 25 year to grow and prosper and be higher up the food chain. Sacrifice or selfishness? It's irrelevant, your daughter reaps the benefit of it, bottom line. Is there really anything more important?