Judicial Activism

No White, Republican, Heterosexual, Church-Going, Male Prosecutor is Qualified for a Judgeship in Virginia

Judge H. Lee Sarokin | Posted 05.17.2012

Judge H. Lee Sarokin

Virginia's Republican-controlled House rejected the judicial nomination of a gay Richmond prosecutor on the grounds that his past "indicated that he would press an activist agenda from the bench."

Will the Supreme Court Split the Difference on Health Care and Immigration?

Harvey Rosenfield | Posted 04.30.2012

Harvey Rosenfield

During three days of hearings last month, the notion that the Supreme Court would invalidate the federal health care law went from being a right wing fantasy to a possible, even likely, outcome based on the questions and comments of the Republican justices.

When Is Judicial Activism Appropriate?

Geoffrey R. Stone | Posted 04.13.2012

Geoffrey R. Stone

The Affordable Care Act case is a perfect case for judicial restraint. If the states that brought the suit want to change the law, they can do it through the political process. That is the point of democracy. They do not need the justices of the Supreme Court to do the job for them.

An Open Letter to the Supreme Court

Benjamin R. Barber | Posted 04.10.2012

Benjamin R. Barber

I prefer to think this does not translate simply as "liberal = favorable to Democrats" and "conservative = favorable to Republicans." Yet the radical inconsistency of the court in two recent cases suggests I am insufficiently cynical.

Why the Supreme Court Wants to Kill Universal Health Care

Harvey Rosenfield | Posted 04.05.2012

Harvey Rosenfield

Anti-government forces realize that once Americans begin to receive the benefits of universal health care -- no denials for pre-existing conditions, no medical underwriting, no caps on benefits -- they won't want to give them up.

Mike Sacks

President Obama Locks Horns With Chief Justice Roberts

HuffingtonPost.com | Mike Sacks | Posted 04.05.2012

WASHINGTON -- Looking to a Supreme Court decision in the health care case months away, President Barack Obama has locked horns with Chief Justice John...

Sam Stein

Conservative Judge Lashes Out At Obama After Remarks About Judicial Independence

HuffingtonPost.com | Sam Stein | Posted 04.04.2012

WASHINGTON -- The wrangling between the judicial and executive branches over President Barack Obama's health care law grew even more contentious on Tu...

The Activist Supreme Court

Washington Post | Posted 04.01.2012

Three days of Supreme Court arguments over the health-care law demonstrated for all to see that conservative justices are prepared to act as an altern...

Challengers Press for Radically Limited Government in Health Care Law Oral Arguments

Caroline Fredrickson | Posted 05.28.2012

Caroline Fredrickson

If the high court's conservative wing does indeed strike the minimum coverage provision, they will do so by actively ignoring or overriding precedent.

The Good Wife Does More Harm to the Judiciary Than Newt Gingrich

Judge H. Lee Sarokin | Posted 04.24.2012

Judge H. Lee Sarokin

With conservatives constantly railing that too many judges are getting it wrong, it does not help to have such a popular program declaring that they are jerks and creeps as well. They should call the show The Good Wife and the Bad Judge.

Are the Courts Fed Up With America's Badly Broken Immigration Laws?

David Leopold | Posted 04.14.2012

David Leopold

In courtrooms all across America, judges sit helplessly by, their hands legally tied, as the twisted immigration law wreaks havoc on American families,

How the Gingrinch Stole the Judiciary

Judge H. Lee Sarokin | Posted 02.20.2012

Judge H. Lee Sarokin

Gingrich apparently has this view that judicial independence and separation of powers are some quaint old relics that have seen better days.

Republican Candidates Want the Federal Judiciary to Be More Like American Idol

Judge H. Lee Sarokin | Posted 12.24.2011

Judge H. Lee Sarokin

The GOP keeps insisting that judges be held accountable; that somehow public opinion should influence outcomes. Nothing could be more inaccurate or contrary to constitutional principles.

Engaged Judges Needed to Protect Vital Freedoms

Jeff Rowes | Posted 07.19.2011

Jeff Rowes

To those locked in the power struggles between right and left, adverse court decisions are frequently lambasted as "judicial activism." When the Supre...

Conservatives Enraged Over Judicial Activism Displayed in Health Care Bill Ruling

Judge H. Lee Sarokin | Posted 05.25.2011

Judge H. Lee Sarokin

The absence of conservative criticism regarding the decisions declaring the Affordable Care Act unconstitutional demonstrates that judicial activism is in the eyes of the beholder.

Health Care Ruling Shows Judicial Activism Is Alive and Well -- and Living on the Right

Adam Winkler | Posted 05.25.2011

Adam Winkler

Monday's federal court decision striking down the landmark Affordable Care Act shows how much the political right has embraced judicial activism.

Unfinished Business: 19 Judicial Nominations Left Unconfirmed by 111th Congress

Nan Aron | Posted 05.25.2011

Nan Aron

As a result of unprecedented Republican political gamesmanship, President Obama ends the first half of his first term with a smaller percentage of his nominees confirmed than any previous president.

Right-Wing Hypocrisy on "Judicial Activism"

Carlos A. Ball | Posted 05.25.2011

Carlos A. Ball

The difference between liberals and conservatives on the role of the courts is that only right-wingers criticize their political opponents for doing so.

Iowa Voters AXE Judges Over Gay Marriage Ruling

TylerKingkade | Posted 05.25.2011

TylerKingkade

In an unprecedented move, and after a nearly three month long campaign by conservative activists, Iowa voters chose not to retain three state Supreme Court justices based on a unanimous ruling in April 2009 to overturn the state's ban on same-sex marriage.

Battle Over Judge Retention In Iowa

TylerKingkade | Posted 05.25.2011

TylerKingkade

DES MOINES, Iowa -- Conservative activist Bob Vander Plaats is hoping Iowans will vote today to sack three Iowa Supreme Court judges who took part in ...

Activist Judge Rules Against Wisconsin's CCW Ban, Cites Wikipedia, Ignores Facts

Josh Sugarmann | Posted 05.25.2011

Josh Sugarmann

This week Wisconsin Circuit Court Judge Jon M. Counsell ruled that the state's ban on carrying concealed handguns in public was overly broad and therefore unconstitutional.

Conservative Hypocrisy Is Alive and Well in Respect to Same-Sex Marriage Decision

Judge H. Lee Sarokin | Posted 05.25.2011

Judge H. Lee Sarokin

A reminder: Courts have the right and duty to declare a law invalid when it conflicts with the Constitution. There is no proviso stating "so long as the conservatives agree with the decision."

Poll Shows People Support Checks and Balances, But Want More Limits on Supreme Court Justices

Mark Penn | Posted 05.25.2011

Mark Penn

In our latest poll, voters send one clear message -- they want more direct power, not in the hands of the politicians, but in the hands of the people, giving them more control over the judiciary and election of the president.

Kagan Kabuki Theater Delivers More than Drama and Comedy

Brian Ross | Posted 05.25.2011

Brian Ross

OPINION - The senatorial process of vetting Supreme Court candidates is about as close to Kabuki theater as we get in America. Elena Kagan did the ri...

President Obama and Judicial Activism

Geoffrey R. Stone | Posted 05.25.2011

Geoffrey R. Stone

If the President meant to imply that judicial activism is invariably in "error," then he seems to have fallen for the line conservatives have been espousing ever since the days of Nixon: judicial restraint is good, judicial activism is bad.