iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tammy Nelson, Ph.D.

GET UPDATES FROM Tammy Nelson, Ph.D.
 

Nagging: Is It Killing Your Marriage?

Posted: 02/01/2012 11:29 am

Recently in the Wall Street Journal, Elizabeth Bernstein wrote an interesting piece about relationships. Her article talked about what really happens in the day-to-day life of a married typical couple and the frustrations that lead to what we commonly call "nagging. Titled, "Meet the Marriage Killer," her report suggested that both partners in a relationship get tired of the vicious cycle of asking for what they want, being ignored and getting angry and having to ask again. Nagging more doesn't help and withdrawing from each other makes the situation worse. Being told what to do makes both partners then feel like children. Funny, I just had a session today with a couple who were complaining about the same thing. I have been a couples therapist for many years, and I see many of them complain every day in my office about what they describe as nagging behaviors that are killing the love they once felt for each other.

Bernstein says that there are certain tips to change the way that couples talk to each other about what they want. I agree. But I look at it from a slightly different perspective. The real reason that nagging happens is twofold. The moment we commit to forever, after the initial "in love" phase of our romance ends, which it does for all of us, we decide we are finally safe with the one person who we can live with for the rest of our life. And yet almost the second that we make that commitment to forever, we regress. We regress to what we know of forever: our parents.

All we know of love and relationships and forever is Mom and Dad. Mom and Dad were supposed to love us unconditionally -- hey, they're our parents and they probably will. But marriage is not unconditional. There are conditions. I can't get away with everything in my marriage that I might have been able to back at home with Mom and Dad. With my husband, there are certain conditions. In fact, now as a Mom I would probably visit my son in prison every day if he, for instance, robbed a bank. But if my husband pulled an armed robbery? Not so much. Marriage is very conditional.

All of us begin at that moment that we commit to regress to the fantasy that our partner will love us unconditionally and yet, interestingly, we don't forgive them unconditionally for their behaviors that we find annoying. Very quickly after marriage our partners begin to show signs that they are not living up to our expectations. And we start to point out the many ways. We begin to parentify our partner: "pick up your socks," "stop driving so fast" or "you are so messy," are examples. Once we start acting like we are the grown up and our partner is the child who doesn't know how to manage their life, then we have gone from being equals to being in a parentified and, by the way a totally desexualized, relationship. I mean who wants to have sex with someone who is nagging them like their mother, right? Or bossing them around like Dad?

The answer might surprise you; it is not necessarily to compromise. No one wins with compromise -- everyone has to give up something. The answer is appreciation. Appreciation is the opposite of disappointment. We always get more of what we appreciate. If we are frustrated that our partner doesn't take the garbage out, but we like that they do the dishes, then tell them. Appreciating that they do the dishes means they are more likely to do the dishes and wipe down the counters as well. If you appreciate that they wipe down the counters and do the dishes they are more likely to sweep the floor too. And frankly, wouldn't you rather live in a relationship where you are each appreciating the other, than one in which you are constantly pointing out the other's faults?

Take a few moments when you are frustrated with your partner to recognize that stress comes from feeling that you have a long list of things "to do" and you may believe that if your partner would just help you get to the bottom of that list you would miraculously feel relaxed and joyful. But you probably will never get to the bottom of your list. There will always be things to do. In our busy lives and busy homes we can always find things we are stressed about. Focus on what works and makes you feel less stressed. Point out how your partner helps when they do, and focus on ways that each of you can bring less stress into each other's lives. Go with your strengths and remember you didn't get married to be great roommates. You got married because you loved each other. Being good roommates takes practice. And kindness.

The problem in marriages is not so much that we nag each other; the problem is that we forget to appreciate what we have. Taking one another for granted means we neglect to say out loud the positive things we notice, the things we love and the parts of our partner that we are grateful to have around. Remembering to mention these things is a habit. Just like getting into the habit of pointing out what's not working, reminding each other what is working takes practice. Remind each other every day what's positive in your relationship. Take the time to say at least three things you appreciate about your partner every day.
Especially on days when they forget to take out the garbage.

Tammy Nelson, PhD is a sex and relationship expert and the author of Getting the Sex You Want and the upcoming The New Monogamy. Find out more at www.drtammynelson.com

 

Follow Tammy Nelson, Ph.D. on Twitter: www.twitter.com/drtammynelson

FOLLOW WEDDINGS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 666
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (12 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:34 PM on 02/05/2012
Our spouses do not really change... Only what we choose to think of them changes.
Early on, we ignore their faults as inconsequential in comparison to those wonderful traits for which we have long searched. Once we safely have those wonderful traits, every day, they become our expectation, our Due, just as we take each breath for granted... But spend 3 minutes at the bottom of a pool, and see how precious that next breath can suddenly become. Expectation breeds nagging, and leads us to downgrade our estimation of our mate. The idea that they should be, or do, as We want.
All I know is that when I see her look at me with admiration and desire in her eyes... It makes me strive to be the better man she imagines me to be. And when she sees me as a lesser man... I become that, as well.
We choose how we shall see our mate...and in so doing, we create the mate we choose to see.
08:37 AM on 02/05/2012
~~Continued~~-----> We've had our spats, but I think it really helped that we started with a trial of living with one another for two weeks (before marriage was even a consideration. We just wanted to be together, and the long distance thing was miserable), which turned into one month, then three... and has turned into five years. And one thing we're both certain of is that being honest, no sugar coating at all, even if we know it's not something the other wants to hear, has literally saved our relationship many times over. I know some people think that lying is the only way to get through some situations with their S.O., but I have to disagree strongly, and I admit I've never really understood that outlook. Rather than letting frustration build, and sitting down and 'talking it out' once a week or once a month, we're just blunt all the time, and that removes the need for having a set time to "communicate" with one another. Of course, because we're so blunt, friends and strangers who see us together have often gotten the wrong impression in a wide variety of ways, but it works for us, so a simple explanation of "This works for us. If it didn't, we wouldn't still be together." seems to do the job.

I find it a bit sad that he and I aren't even married, yet we've been together longer than most marriages last these days....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cschieda
In God we trust
08:15 AM on 02/05/2012
Nice article. I ve been saying something similar for years. Your child can come home everyday and talk about her friend's Mom and how great she is and you will relate or try to relate her traits to yourself or commend her for her admirable qualities, but....let your husband spend more then 2 minutes complimenting another woman and you will either pick her apart or attack him, or suffer in silence and secretly harbor hurt feelings by his comments. But you will definately be affected differently by the two adorations. Love of a spouse is conditional and so many forget that. Even if they are not going to leave because of your bad treatment does not mean they have 'stayed' in the marriage. I know so many couples that stay together but are so distant and shut off from there spouse, they would be better off seperated. I am married 25 years and i treat my husband like I want him to treat me, with love, lust, respect, and consideration, . The only problem is the ratio for the receipe is different for every couple. So pick someone who shares the same portion size.
08:02 AM on 02/05/2012
Sorry you live in a world where falling out of love is inevitable or the fantasy world where parental love is always unconditional. No wonder you see appreciation of one's partner as a tool to achieve goals. I suspect that a marriage based on self-serving and manipulative behavior would not persevere either. How about loving people for who they are and not what you want them to be or do? Seems pretty simple to me and a strategy that does not require a book to explain how to be decent to one another. Married for over 15 years with no sign of the honeymoon ending.
09:13 AM on 02/05/2012
Which utopian planet is Lexastone from? Simple honeymoon planet. No one said not to love people for who they are, or to love them for what they can do or be. It has nothing to do with love! It has to do with sharing life's enormous amount of chores, and creating more of a balance, so that one person does not have a huge, heavy burden. (If you want to stay married, better to find a balance by employing self-serving and manipulative behavior which keeps us ALL happy!). It is a challenge for all of us! Maybe one day I will find your planet. But for now, appreciating my husband is a wonderful way of showing respect and decency for his efforts. I do not receive much appreciation from him, but his wanting to do more certainly improves our lives and relationship.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
peacebythesea
Promote peace not hate!
08:01 AM on 02/05/2012
I'm living proof nagging can ruin a marriage....along with a depressed person that is hateful, manipulative, egotistical, and has no clue how to love his own children or be close to them. I can't do anything right with my husband....so critical and nagging! Too bad he didn't have boys.. then he might be blissfully happy!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
evestar
Generation Jones
07:46 AM on 02/05/2012
Not what you say but how you say it
07:29 AM on 02/05/2012
Ok well when you are the project leader of your lives and not getting any real form ofsupport from your partner, taking the brunt of the responsibility and that person doesn't make an effort to pull their share of the load or recognizes they should, no ammount of appreciation will help. I am fed up with house training and teaching BASIC life skills to grown men. And I am sure there are men out there thinking the same thing. relationships are work and both need to pitch in even when they dont want to. That requires being honest about yourself. Most people can't do that.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gay Snyder
Brilliant. Gorgeous. Modest.
08:35 AM on 02/05/2012
Amen.
07:19 AM on 02/05/2012
I agree that I nag or say nothing at all more than I compliment on most days. However, ending this article with "even on days that he forgets to take out the trash" implies, at least to me, that you find nagging petty. I find that insulting. In many cases, nagging is the ONLY way to get him to do anything. We both work full time,however, I am left to raise the kids, run them everywhere, clean the house, cook, shop, do the laundry, cut the grass, care for our pets, pay the bills, etc. While he gets to come home and eat a nice meal and flop on the couch! This is what most women have to put up with. Where is our appreciation? In the picture it looks like the woman is nagging the man. Well, maybe it's out of frustration.
07:44 AM on 02/05/2012
Hey as the Man I get this ,,,, I don't want my wife to do everything but, she does do more around the house then I do for sure - making dinner, cleaning and such. I take command of other duties, mowing, snow removalm taking care of our auto's or home repairs. What if you share making dinner either do it together or tell hime the nights he is responsibile for gettting dinner ready. Maybe if you tried a different approach then nagging ( a note, taped to his beer that you bring him on the couch?) May I suggest that you sit down with your man and ask him which chores he would like to share with you (and don't dig - "since I seem to be doing everything")
You may try to write down your feelings and shre them rather than comfront him as well. Worked better for me I wasn't able to interup and if I got angry I still kept reading instead of just shutting down or walking away... Hope this helps... xoxox
08:00 AM on 02/05/2012
Thanks for the advice but we've been married 22 years. I have tried it all. I'm at the point of just shutting down all together. I'm tired.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gay Snyder
Brilliant. Gorgeous. Modest.
08:36 AM on 02/05/2012
Amen. Yes, many women deal with this . . . . . and IMO, many women file for divorce once the kids are grown.
scromolie
Live, laugh, love
06:55 AM on 02/05/2012
I hate to nag. I ask once and only once. If it is not done, I do it myself and never ask again. While it may seem better not to nag or be nagged, the resentment that builds is worse.
08:01 AM on 02/05/2012
I totally agree. I'm doing a lot myself now. But there are some things that I can't do. The resentment is definately growing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rforeverfree
06:33 AM on 02/05/2012
Nice article for "once upon a time". What was left out was GROW UP first.
06:32 AM on 02/05/2012
Nagging and "having to nag" (to get any task done) is surely a poison, but I found that the true killer in a marriage is when one person "breaks the trust" maybe just one time, but usually more than just one big event. It can be either mate - when they start relying on someone else (a father-figure, a mom, an anybody who is not in the marriage vows). It happened to me. Many times, my mate relying on an older man (father figure) and analyzing ME! And not in a nice way. Please don't repeatedly do this to your mate. It will surely kill the love, the trust, then it all just dies.

icari75
05:28 AM on 02/05/2012
While I TRY not to nag, (how many times do I need to ask you to do something anyway?) I know it comes across as such. Yeah around the 4th, 5th time I'm sure it SOUNDS like nagging, but truly just remember to buy the milk, or take the damn recyclables in!
I mean I'm pretty much trapped here 24/7 with your daughter (severe emotional issues) & your mother (alzheimers) so can you do me a solid once in a while? Thanks. :)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hedah
Live Better...Live Vegan.
04:16 AM on 02/05/2012
Hey Boys ! wanna stop the "nagging" ? just Keep Your Promises ! HA
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gay Snyder
Brilliant. Gorgeous. Modest.
08:38 AM on 02/05/2012
They often don't keep their promises.
02:36 AM on 02/05/2012
this goes the same for non-married couples, and even friends. Nagging would be a relationship no matter who the parties involved are.
02:02 AM on 02/05/2012
Women get more naggier over generations, and men get more.... do I really need to go there?
photo
artgrrl74
the big print giveth & the small print taketh away
06:46 AM on 02/05/2012
i wish you would