More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
HuffPost Social Reading
Therese Borchard

GET UPDATES FROM Therese Borchard
 

Is Your Job Making You Depressed?

Posted: 07/12/2011 8:22 am

The other day I wrote a post for Blisstree.com on how to stay productive when you are clinically depressed. I mentioned that, at my rock bottom, I had to take a break altogether from writing, as every time I sat down in front of my computer, all I could do was cry. Moreover, because my concentration was so totally shot, composing a sentence -- much less an article -- wasn't going to happen.

I took a year off. To heal.

Because my husband was gainfully employed at that time, I was able to swing it.

Eventually I tiptoed back to the working world. Very slowly. Very carefully. Very deliberately. Because a sudden plunge might have rendered me disabled for another year or so.

And I didn't start with writing, ironically.

My therapist advised me to do something in which I interacted with people, as the process of writing is not all that conducive to recovery from depression. The time alone and the cerebral exercise can often aggravate depression and anxiety, inviting more invitations to obsess and ruminate. When your job requires that you be among people, some of whom you have to listen to, you have a better shot of concentration.

So I became a tutor at a local college. For two hours a week. I read the words of my students since I couldn't compose my own.

One of the more complex quandaries of depression is knowing when your job is making you depressed, or if you are just clinically depressed and your job has nothing to do with it.

While most mental health professionals assert that gainful employment improves mood and promotes resiliency, a new study by the Australian National University (ANU) maintains that the wrong job can do more harm than good. Psych Central's Selena Chavis covered the study last October.

According to lead researcher Dr. Liana Leach, "The research showed that people who moved from being unemployed into poor-quality jobs were significantly more likely to be depressed at follow-up than those people who remained unemployed ... This research suggests getting people into any job may not necessarily lead to mental health improvements. Instead, people need good quality work to gain and maintain better well-being."

I can think of two jobs that definitely made me more depressed: My first year out of college, when my personality was a horrible match to my co-workers', and the six months of this past year, when I became a government contractor with a conservative consulting firm and was doing PowerPoint presentations on change management and other things that I knew absolutely nothing about.

Both times, the last day of these jobs felt like I had transcended into the air -- you know, like the transfiguration of Jesus. The lightness I experienced seemed metaphysical. In fact, this last time, I was so glad to be done with that job that I got manic. I couldn't contain my excitement that I would no longer have to type my employment ID number forty times a day into my computer and wear a dark gray, navy or black suit with my badge faced out.

Not to say that my days are perfect now. I do hit rough patches, and during those times, I put down the writing for awhile and focus on tasks that get me out of my head because, while writing is enormously rewarding, the isolation and cerebral exercise is hard, I think, for a person prone to depression and anxiety. The challenge is staying resilient enough that you can stay productive, which, in turn, promotes more resiliency.

Unless you're working a job that only fostering more insecurity.

For six tips on how to stay productive when you are depressed, click here.

Originally published on Psych Central.

 

Follow Therese Borchard on Twitter: www.twitter.com/thereseborchard

The other day I wrote a post for Blisstree.com on how to stay productive when you are clinically depressed. I mentioned that, at my rock bottom, I had to take a break altogether from writing, as every...
The other day I wrote a post for Blisstree.com on how to stay productive when you are clinically depressed. I mentioned that, at my rock bottom, I had to take a break altogether from writing, as every...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 47
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gwhizz
01:11 PM on 07/19/2011
I can say with certainty that while my job is not making me depressed (I was diagnosed prior to taking this job) it is certainly exacerbating my depression and adding a whopping does of anxiety. Not a day goes by that I don't think, "My God I'm going to die in this filthy, depressing cubicle. Is it worth it? NO!" But I, like most people, am stuck here. I have kids to support, bills to pay.
02:16 PM on 07/14/2011
been depressed at my job for years, and have no options of taking time off, or retiring for that matter...
It must be nice to be a lady such as yourself, when you can rely on a husband to support you. Be very grateful.
11:00 AM on 07/13/2011
NOT having a job these days can make most folks even more depressed.
photo
dikedrummond
Struggle Free Midlife Crisis Expert
07:46 AM on 07/13/2011
Therese - of course your job can make you depressed and I wish that was the worst thing it can do. People die every day from on the job accidents and are emotionally and sexually abused by bosses and co-workers. AND in my experience, nearly 100% of the people who experience any of these job related effects in their lives hate their jobs.

They know they don't like what they do for money. They have talked to friends and family about their discomfort. And for any number of reasons, they take no action to quit. Many times it is the money - or, more specifically, the fear of having no money if they quit this job.

The important realization is you can have what you want in this life IF AND WHEN you actually take different actions. You don't have to quit this ob cold turkey ...you can transition out. Here are the key questions.

What do you want to do for a living?
What skills and activities do you want to participate in?
What jobs might allow you to do that?
How can you get a taste of these jobs/professions (?Volunteer)?
What is one 'baby step" you can take today to investigate this alternative career?
When will you do that?

If it aint workin' get out and start your transition today,

My two cents in this early morning,

Dike
Dike Drummond MD
http://www.threehourmidlifecrisis.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Erewhon7
Join atheists, our non-prophet organization
11:18 PM on 07/12/2011
Path through depression:
Take enormous quantities of vitamins.
Begin practicing meditation, hatha yoga or Tai Chi or walking meditation. Even if it's a few blocks or a few asanas at a time.
Volunteer helping those more misfortunes than you are.
Find one pleasurable thing each day. No matter how small..
Do not narrow your social circle.
Cognitive therapy-- most depressions start in your mind. this is the place to begin the healing while supporting it with above steps and limited medication (as a temporary remedy, not the measure of first resort).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
boxerbuddy4
I am a proud American
11:46 PM on 07/12/2011
Currently on LOA for depression, anxiety and stress. I am going through divorce from someone who enjoyed my benefits and salary without contributing much of his own funds for 27 yrs. My boss treats us like a he's a drill sgt. He's made one person cry, refused to allow another out of an office because he wanted to discuss an issue with them and nitpicked our work every day. I was so nervous that I couldn't concentrate, made a decision or even read with comprehension. Terrible situation. On meds and looking for a therapist.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Erewhon7
Join atheists, our non-prophet organization
01:09 AM on 07/13/2011
Look for a therapist who will really listen to you and not just prescribe more meds. Try a short-term cognitive therapist who will help you adjust your thinking.
Learn meditation. Transcendental meditation is an accessible option.
Good luck.
photo
James Stordahl
Pursuing an acting career. Ready to go anywhere to
09:59 PM on 07/12/2011
Clinical depression jsut about killed me in 2006. It has taken me five years, lots of therapy and medication, and a very supportive wife to realize that it was my job that drove me over the cliff. I had the misfortune of being sucked into the great void called the U.S. Postal Service. I had the education and training to rise quickly in the uncivilized Pargon of Mediocrity. Nespoitsm was 'officially' frowned on, but overt discrimination and sexual harrassment was rampant. I experience racial bigotry as open as can be. Friends hiring friends. Grudges being played out with foot-dragging and administrative threats. Letter of Warning used as threats for 'perceived' attitudes and possible non-team-member actions. The USPS (Titanic) started sinking in the early 90's. The employee communications function was shut down and all employee newsletters were stopped. That allowed for much more secrecy in promotions and temporary assignments. Review Boards were selected at random with very little discussion of supporting documentation for promotions. Local candidates, known to the selecting official, were normally selected. This after much time and many funds were expended to bring in a qualifying number of candidates for interviews. The stories of poor people skills and lack of common sense have overtaken the USPS. It is no surprise, to any retirees, that the business is dying.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Erewhon7
Join atheists, our non-prophet organization
11:19 PM on 07/12/2011
Self pity and obsessive focus on the faults of others is extremely detrimental to recovery. Try meditation.
07:00 AM on 07/13/2011
i understand how you feel, when i started on one of my jobs many years ago, i was idealistic and excited. this was before i encountered all of those bad things you mentioned. there were unqualified suckups who got promoted, bias against women, favoritism. but when one complains you're seen as an antagonizing force or a dissident or a whiny person. when i told people of the deplorable state there, they just thought i was just a bitter person who got passed over for promotion.

fortunately i left that place and found out that not all work institutions are like that. there are of course all forms of red tape and other upsetting systems anywhere. to some degree. i try not to go with that, i try to maintain my individual principles, but i don't rock the boat either.

i can understand why a person who wants things to conform to a higher standard would be depressed over the state of our work ethics.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mr Sick Of Greed
06:44 PM on 07/12/2011
anything can be depressing, look around you, our country is falling apart, people are not doing well...it is sad, so who knows what caused your depression...it is tough to pinpoint.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
linmarco
06:39 PM on 07/12/2011
Good article but who can afford to take a year off-a sabbatical?-to heal?
10:29 PM on 07/12/2011
Anyone quitting a job isn't ever likely to get another one. That alone is very depressing.
photo
laaambchop
Cheerfulness is a sign of wisdom
10:24 PM on 07/13/2011
That's just not true.
07:03 AM on 07/13/2011
you're right! that's the depressing thing about it. some of us would like to quit our depressing jobs, but i think it's even more depressing not to earn anything to support the family. one just has to pick the kind of blues ya want.
06:21 PM on 07/12/2011
I think you are spot on with this column. In fact, isn't it ironic in an economy where the number of foreclosures is reaching 7 figures that going to work actually increases depression? Maybe this doesn't happen immediately, though. Self-realization is a lot farther up the psychological pyramid than self-preservation, but maybe initially the individual is grateful to be able to put food on his or her table, then as the mind becomes accustomed to the new standard of living, depression returns to attack what vulnerabilities remain in the person's mind.

Wow, that would be ascribing a motive to depression, as if it were a living entity, like a virus. I wonder what would happen if we treated it like that?

My humor blog: http://withbothhandsandaflashlight.blogspot.com/
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pete Mojica
05:00 PM on 07/12/2011
My mood goes south when I know I have to go to work, so perhaps.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
karen lyons kalmenson
i poem/paint, sometimes, i ain't
04:29 PM on 07/12/2011
Depressed by job, depressed before job
Depression is a most terrible and insidious malady that can attack even when the external world is going one's way

Been there, enough times to depress the non depressed
01:45 PM on 07/12/2011
If I really WANT to be depressed I need look no further than the "news".... if that doesn't do it, the comment threads certainly will!
01:38 PM on 07/12/2011
Clinical depression is an overlooked and growing issue in the workplace and causes individual suffering and a great loss to companies in productivity and profits.

As a former psychotherapist who is now coaching clients privately and for corporations, I see many employees who fail to recognize they are depressed or if they do, fail to get help. To make matter worse, supervisors and managers are not equipped to recognize depression and often deal with the situation ineffectively, escalating the problem.

Companies need to do more than they are doing because it's the right thing to do because the results will show up in their profit statements.
jefe
liberal at large
01:34 PM on 07/12/2011
Job? What job?
01:27 PM on 07/12/2011
This is like reading a southern plantations girls view of dealing with the heat. One out of ten people in my state are un-employed, not buy choice. De-pressed, heck they are losing their houses. 70% of the kids, in my kids schools, are getting govt' free lunch because they are low income, broke. Many adult's have lost their health insurance because they are now un-employed. So the medical fields are not hiring because patient loads are way down. So I can't find work any-where in Georgia with an engineering degree and medical degree-can't sell your houses either.. De-pressed, heck we are going to have a very high suicide rate this year, we don't have the money for health care. The military is already having record suicide rates!