iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Thrity Umrigar

GET UPDATES FROM Thrity Umrigar
 

We Built It

Posted: 09/14/2012 6:22 pm

So I wrote a column on my admiration for Obama's message of hope and change.

Some people liked it; some people didn't. Some agreed with my sentiments. Others didn't. Some were respectful in their disagreements, others not so much. It was the genius of America at work.

But one reader's comments on my Facebook fan page caught my eye. He introduced himself as the relative of my landlady from a lifetime ago. He went on to say that he was a Republican but he'd enjoyed the column. And he congratulated me for having built a good life and career for myself in America. This is how he put it: "Congrats on all your success as it is obvious that you have 'built that.'"

It was a humorous dig at Obama's infamous "you didn't build that," comment which the GOP has had so much fun gleefully distorting. But my reader was obviously being tongue-in-cheek and in the same spirit of playfulness, I replied, "John, thank you for your kind words but I can't resist pointing out that I didn't 'build that' column alone. It was the education my parents gave me, the schools I went to, the folks who built the Internet etc... you get where I'm going with this. The same point that Obama was trying to make, yes?

To his credit, John wrote back: "Thrity, fair enough. We all are molded by our environment. Family, friends, teachers, co-workers, employees and mentors all play a strong part of helping 'build' our businesses & success."

So why am I rehashing this exchange? Well, for a couple of reasons. One, it felt so great to have a civil, rational, exchange of ideas with someone from the "opposing" side. It made me feel hopeful -- yes, there's that Obamaesque word again -- about the possibility of entering into dialogue with those worldviews are different from mine. Why has the Internet given us permission to act in crude, offensive ways that we'd never act in real life? Yes, yes, it's the anonymity, of course, but really, is this who we are when no one is watching? Is this who we want to be in our secret, private selves? How can we claim to be patriots if we unthinkingly trash the views of half of our citizens?

But two, the exchange really made me reflect on my life and what percentage of my successes I can claim for myself. Yes, I've worked hard but dear God, so do millions of people around the world who perform backbreaking, humiliating, mind-numbing labor, for not a fraction of the rewards that I have earned. No, sorry, if I am to be honest, my life was made possible by the labor and love and sacrifice of family and the hard work, brilliance and kindness of strangers. My mother stayed up nights teaching me grammar and spelling, laying the foundation for my writing career. My aunt got me my first library card and introduced me to books and that's why I became a writer. My dad worked in his business seven days a week and that's what made it possible for me to come to America. This country gave me a million gifts -- a free press, great universities, free libraries, an inclusive, tolerant culture, technological inventions -- that made my life and career possible.

Above all, it gave me friends who fed my stomach and my soul and my brain. Every one of those people is in my books and in my writing. They have all helped "build" them, a thousand invisible hands guiding mine as I click away at my computer.

You know the landlady, John's relative, who I mentioned earlier? Here's how I met her: My first newspaper job out of grad school was in a small mill town in Ohio. I had graduated a week earlier and had very little money. A friend from college drove me to my new hometown to search for an apartment. We saw an ad, called the number, and Dorothy, the landlady said she'd meet us there in half hour.

I liked her immediately. To my eternal gratitude, she apparently liked me, too. The ad had stated that I'd have to pay the first month's rent as security deposit, along with the rent. I said I'd take the apartment and pulled out my check book. And that's when Dorothy said, "How about you only pay the rent? I don't need the deposit. I trust you."

I looked at her confused. So she continued, "My daughter recently got her first job, also. I know how hard it is when you're first starting out."

This was in 1985. I hear these words in my ears all the time. Everything I know and love and cherish about America is in those words.

Dorothy, my landlady, helped build this column. She helped build my literary career and my teaching career. She helped build my life.

John the reader said he'd like to get together the next time he's in Ohio. If we do, we will take a toast to his aunt Dorothy and to the millions like her. These are the ordinary, anonymous people who paid the taxes that built our roads, space shuttles, bridges, schools, airports, stadiums, freeways, and the Internet. The government that Obama was extolling is not some foreign, super-imposed force. It is people like Dorothy. They are the government.

And yes, they helped build this one single life.

Thrity Umrigar is the author of a memoir and five novels, including the bestselling 'The Space Between Us' and 'The World We Found.'

 
 
 
FOLLOW POLITICS
So I wrote a column on my admiration for Obama's message of hope and change. Some people liked it; some people didn't. Some agreed with my sentiments. Others didn't. Some were respectful in their ...
So I wrote a column on my admiration for Obama's message of hope and change. Some people liked it; some people didn't. Some agreed with my sentiments. Others didn't. Some were respectful in their ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wayne Caswell
Consumer Advocate & Founder of Modern Health Talk
12:25 PM on 09/16/2012
I miss those days when corporate execs saw good employees as their most valuable assets, knowing that this army of workers made them look good every day. Good execs rewarded their staff on down the line with shared success, good pay, personal development education opportunities, sound retirement programs, and respect. They knew how important the administrative assistant was in managing the calendar and correspondence and a host of more trivial tasks, many of which the execs could not do on their own. This gave them more time to focus on higher-level taks. They knew that the Market Research department was critical to sound decision making. They knew the graphic artists and speech writers, and the PowerPoint charts they created, helped propel them up the corporate ladder with more powerful presentations and speeches. And they knew that sometimes, often in fact, good workers were more valuable to the company than the managers and execs themselves. They just had different rolls. But now workers are treated as disposable expenses while executives seem to have forgotten that they didn't "build it" themselves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jdshuttleworth
07:00 PM on 09/15/2012
I too have tried to make this point with everyone I communicate with. I also try to make the point that for 31 years I worked for the same company to help make them successful. They did not do it alone. I and my team worked hard everyday not just for our oun benefit but for the interest of the company. We knew that if they were successful we would be successful. We helped build the business from a few to many. We were so successful that the owner was able to sell the business for BIG BUCKS. The new owners lacked the committment and responsibility to the employees that the original owners had. The layoffs started. The wheels fell off and within a few years the business collapsed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zanzig
10:32 AM on 09/15/2012
Thrity, I love your books and am so thrilled you are sharing more insights with this audience. Look forward to more.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allene Stucki
09:24 AM on 09/15/2012
The obvious problem with those folks who are trying to spin Obama's comment to mean the public roads, public schools, etc., is that the people who never amount to anything, who are basically unproductive, and who live from the sweat of other people's brows, they ALSO drive on the public roads and send their kids to the public schools, do they not? So that begs the question, Why are they entitled to share the fruits of others' labors?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okradingle
12:42 PM on 09/15/2012
Who do you consider unproductive? Me? I think bankers moving fake money around and getting paid enormous sums costs us billions. I think freepers in their parents' basements are unproductive. But they still use the Internet and have freedoms protected or destroyed by our elected officials and military by extension.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Allene Stucki
07:00 PM on 09/15/2012
Those who produce little or nothing - kind by definition, right?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fearthebetenoire
Lying's like 95% of what I do. In your job? Sure.
07:33 PM on 09/14/2012
What an insightful personal spin on this whole concept of who is responsible for our success -- are we "on our own" or are we "in it together" is the fundamental question that the president's awkward syntax really highlights. As this post argues, and I absolutely agree, we built this country together, we succeed through our own efforts and with help from others (even the government) and we will best survive this economic crisis, regain our bearings and rebuild prosperity in America if we work together.
07:10 PM on 09/14/2012
I loved this column! Thank you for sharing your story and reminding us all that we are all connected by our shared vision of the American dream and...... yes....hope!!!