iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tim Giago

GET UPDATES FROM Tim Giago
 

Chris Rock Was Only Telling the Truth About Independence Day

Posted: 07/06/2012 1:26 pm

Comedian Chris Rock sent out a tweet that went, "Happy white peoples independence day the slaves weren't free but I'm sure they enjoyed the fireworks."

Was he not telling the truth? Of course he was, but some people took it as offensive and unpatriotic. Those are the same people who bury their heads in the sand whenever anyone speaks about the not so happy history of America.

Native Sun News, a weekly newspaper based in Rapid City, S. D., recently ran a cartoon that showed an Indian and an African American standing side-by-side with the caption, "Which country was built on genocide and slavery?" There have probably been several, but the first country that came to the minds of most Native Americans was America.

When America celebrated its 200th anniversary in 1976, Indian activist Russell Means made an announcement that he and the American Indian Movement would "blow out the candles on America's birthday cake."

Means, like most Native Americans, knew their own history. He knew that America had built this Nation on genocide of the Native population and on the backs of Black slaves. He didn't sugarcoat this dark history of the birth of this Nation.

Comedian and activist Elon James White who hosts a show called, This Week in Blackness, defended Rock. "I just want to ask everyone who's mad at Chris Rock: Is he wrong?"

He went on to say:

I find this Chris Rock backlash ridiculous. Really? Someone tells the truth and you mad? I'm American. I never claim otherwise. I never give the 'We didn't land on Plymouth Rock' speech unless it's in a really funny way. But part of being American, to me, is that I have to acknowledge all the bullshit that comes with it. Basically some folks came over, stole other people's land, killed them, then started a country on the backs of my people while killing them, and then at some point, freed the slaves, but then oppressed them and killed them some more. Do I have the ability to do things here that I wouldn't in some parts of the world? Yes. But my family paid the price for that in actual blood, sweat and tears. If more people were like Rock and acknowledged the truth maybe we'd be in a better place as a Nation.

As White pointed out, there are some things in the history of America that are ridiculous and some that have never been addressed or corrected. For example, at Wounded Knee on December 29, 1890, 300 Lakota men, women and children were slaughtered. Women and children were chased down in the hills and valleys and shot down like animals. When the Lakota people speak of this massacre they always say, "Wokiksuye Cankpe Opi" or Remember Wounded Knee. To them it is like when Americans said, "Remember Pearl Harbor." The United States of America awarded 20 Medals of Honor to troopers of the 7th Cavalry for the killing and maiming of these innocent Lakota men, women and children.

Was that wrong? Of course it was wrong, but the honorable government of the United States has never apologized for this massacre, and what is worse, has refused to rescind these inglorious Medals of Honor.

Most Native Americans look back at the Declaration of Independence as a time in their history when the inevitable destruction of their homes, lives and territory was about to begin. On April 30, 1803 the United States purchased 828,000 square miles of land from France in what became known as the Louisiana Purchase. How did France come to own this land? They simply planted a flag on it and said this is now ours. Never mind that thousands of indigenous people had been living on this land for thousands of years. The land the United States bought from France was stolen land.

There are so many things in America's history books that do sugarcoat the truth. Ojibwe activist Vernon Bellecourt, now deceased, often said that the story of America is "His-Story" because it was written from one point of view. Seldom, if ever, was the indigenous other side of the story written about.

I attended school at the Holy Rosary Indian Mission on the Pine Ridge Reservation. In our history classes we were never told that just 15 miles down the road from the school was the place where the worst massacre in the history of America happened. Most of us Native Americans had to learn our own history after we left school. In fact, there were a lot of terrible things that happened to the indigenous people after the signing of the Declaration of Independence, but much of it is not taught in America's classrooms.

Twenty-five years ago I wrote about America, from an indigenous perspective, that your heroes are not necessarily our heroes. The same can be said from the perspective of the Black community.

From a historical point of view, Chris Rock spoke the truth and if he is to be chastised for that then those offering the criticism should ask themselves whether what he said was the truth.

If he is lying then our history books are wrong on more than one count.


Tim Giago, an Oglala Lakota, was born and educated on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation. He was founder of the Native American Journalists Association and of Indian Country Today newspaper. He was a Nieman Fellow at Harvard with the Class of 1991.

Notes from Indian Country
By Tim Giago (Nanwica Kciji)
© Unitysodak1@knology.net

 

Follow Tim Giago on Twitter: www.twitter.com/N/A

FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:56 PM on 07/09/2012
I love the fact that Chirs told the truth and if FoxNews doesn't like it oh well you can't please everyone.
photo
LaFemmeNikitty
What Would Wyatt Earp Do
04:36 AM on 07/09/2012
The US has a shameful history that school textbooks are crafted artfully to instill patriotism in children. As Tim Giago has noted, most Americans don't learn the truth until long after K-12 has ended. We are instructed to believe in patriotism the way we believe in Santa Claus as children -- until we lose our innocence. Some never do.

We celebrate Independence Day the same way we celebrate St. Patrick's Day, Cinco De Mayo, and Super Bowl Sunday, now -- with lots of food and drink. Any race, creed or color can participate. You don't have to believe in Santa Claus to have a merry winter holiday, either. But putting someone down for telling the truth about what Independence Day does NOT mean to some is not cause for a backlash. Maybe if we acknowledged the truth, and taught that truth to our children instead of the lies in the history books, there could actually be strides toward equality here in the United States.
03:40 PM on 07/08/2012
Chris Rock is wrong. People were savage, and it is unforgivable. This behavior occurs throughout history in every corner of the planet, however, we should remember our history, as it is OUR HISTORY no matter how we wish to view it. Chris Rock, is correct, that slaves were not free at the time, and my mother's side of the family were still being slaughtered, but his is action was ignorant and racist and he does not seem to be suffering. I would say, if events did not occur exactly as they did, he would not exist. So in summation, yes horrible things happened in OUR past, and it has defined us to be who we are as a nation, and we are still not perfect, anyone. But believe me, I do not owe you anything for your ancestor's place in OUR history, the same as I do not owe half myself for what occurred in OUR past. Cris Rock's actions were only the self serving attention seeking rant of an ignorant person and nothing more. Many honorable people, of all skin tones and backgrounds, have made true sacrifices, for you to have the right to disrespect the country they were helping to build, so if you want to show your disdain for this country and insight hate and disrupt the coming together of all the people in this nation, we would rather you just find a country without a tainted past and live there. Good luck on that search.
08:08 PM on 07/07/2012
Read the full comments by Frederick Douglass - see how contemporary they are!
http://teachingamericanhistory.org/library/index.asp?document=162
12:57 PM on 07/07/2012
As an Irish American Chris Rock's "Tweet" was offensive, as I am "White" and your comment was offensive as well, as being offended, I do not "Bury my head in the sand whenever anyone speaks about the not so happy history of America". The term "White People" includes me in that generalization, another term would be greatly appreciated. There have been and are many "White People" who have stood w/Indians, African Americans, and every race for justice and equality, the generalization is ignorant and dishonorable. My ancestors endured the same treatment as the African slaves and Indians, in Ireland and America. When you educate yourselves on that history, you will have a better understanding as to why I was offended, and going forward people hopefully will use appropriate terms such as, slave owners, thieves, murderers, racists, etc., not "White People".
12:15 PM on 07/07/2012
This is all so ridiculous. I have a hard time thinking Chris Rock didn't know this was going to drudge up controversy. And now look at all of the hundreds of articles online with the thousands of comments below them of people arguing back and forth about racism and history. Regardless of where your stance is - His comment certainly didn't HELP things in those departments.
06:58 AM on 07/07/2012
I'm Black and a veteran. The Founding Fathers could not pass the indepence vote without the southern states which depended on slavery. While slavery was bad there was no way that the cotton and tobacco states would have voted for independence. The vote had to be unanimous. Slavery was bad, I agree. That was then and this is now. We must work together to continue to build a better nation.
photo
Keith Williams
Internet Community Management, Thoughtleader
07:35 PM on 07/06/2012
More denial from the ancestors of the people who gained wealth on the backs of the people of color who were forced to serve them. Nobody is saying - those of you in the offended majority -that you were personally responsible. Chris Rock and a lot other people of color are saying the holiday doesn't fully represent them. In that time in history, they were considered to be "created equal". My ancestors - and ancestors of many people of color - were considered property. Not even human in a lot of cases. They didn't have the equal opportunity to gain wealth at the same time your ancestors did. Various laws had to change to make that happen. That's a fact, it's not going away and it shouldn't go away. And speaking of majorities in the country, that's about to change soon enough. However, I highly doubt the new majorities will inflict the same inequality on the current majority. I. for one, wouldn't stand for it. And so would a lot of others.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mark One
06:55 AM on 07/07/2012
Did you know that 15 percent of the continental army was black americans at one time?
photo
Keith Williams
Internet Community Management, Thoughtleader
05:52 PM on 07/13/2012
So what does that mean? In a lot of those cases they were promised freedom if they served but did they really get their freedom? Were they able to fully participate in the business and government of America? In an overwhelming way, not even close.
06:19 PM on 07/06/2012
Chris has the Freedom of Speech that was brought on by Independence Day. He also has to realize that racial issues are not going to be resolved if the "slaves" (his words, not mine, and meaning "blacks" or African-Americans, you know what he meant by his words) I am a white man and I have been on this great planet called Earth for 54 years and my father was born in 1920 and my mother in 1917. In the almost 100 years since my mother was born we or my family did not own any “slaves”. They say that history repeats itself, if that were true we would not have any (and I mean ANY) African-Americans anywhere let alone President of the United States. Time for all people to understand that the only way to salvation is to understand where you came from, if you were dealt a bad hand do something to make it better for the others that follow, not blame people and then bring up old history that really isn’t a factor anymore, it is a factor only because those that bring it up, let it happen.
09:18 PM on 07/06/2012
And what makes you think the legacy of slavery is no longer a factor in this country? The very economy of the nation you were born into 54 years stands on a foundation of slave labor. That "bad hand" you referred to has been reshuffled a few times over the last 236 years, but it's never stopped being dealt. If you sat on our side of the table, perhaps you might understand that. But be all that as it may, Independence Day celebrates the Declaration of American independence on July 4, 1776, a date when slavery was still very much a fact of life in this country. That's what Chris was alluding to. I'm not sure which part of that you don't get, and I seriously doubt that Chris cares, something he has in common with me and many others.
04:56 PM on 07/10/2012
You are probably correct that Chris doesn't care. Please explain so use simple mided white folk can understand what you are saying? I was bon i 1958, President Lincoln abolished slavery when he was President. I will say you are correct when the Declaration of Indepence was written there was slavery. But I believe that mour foundng fathers meant their words when they said in the declaration that "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness".

I also elieve that Martin Luther King, Jr., said the same thing. So please stop hiding behind the race card and teaching your children that as well.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:24 PM on 07/06/2012
On the other hand, you have American Indians like Russell means who has lied and abused and brought so much shame to all American Indians, that we have to realize at what point the victim begins to perpetuate their own moral decline. Quoting means is rather ironic, in that Means has postured and posed and abused his way into American media consciousness without ever having done anything ever to help anyone but himself. He cannot point to a single result or accomplishment which has benefited a single American Indian anywhere. So we might say you have inadvertently shown us how both external and internal forces have really damaged and continue to damage the American Indian people. While your history lesson is accurate, it has omitted the long shadow which lay behind it. I am an American Indian and I have seen the same things you have seen, and I have seen other things. I know that all doors remain open and inside the accusations of history there is also a moment when the dreamer awakens from their long memory of torment and takes responsibility for moving themselves forward into anew ancient future.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
First NameAZ Rock
A prudent question is one-half of wisdom.
04:35 PM on 07/06/2012
"The evil that men do, lives after them,
The good is oft-interred with their bones."
"What have I, or those I represent, to do with your national independence?" - Frederick Douglass

I do not celebrate July 4th, hell July 4th is just one of the many reasons that I moved to Canada. America is number one when it comes to people not wanting to be bothered by facts (well North Korea is up there too). And with President Obama being a self-proclaimed man of color, we see thru blogs, websites hate-groups, congress, how America truly feels about non-white Americans. It's cool when we shine your shoes or dunk a basketball, but when it comes to true power, white people get scared as if we are going to attempt to do to them the same atrocities that assailed against up. America needs to open its eyes and grow up... I served this country, yet I am more and more ashamed of it every day. Chris Rock spoke the truth, swallow the pill.
05:55 PM on 07/06/2012
i agree 1000%. did u know that our holiday is actually Juneteenth
04:25 PM on 07/06/2012
I don't take offense to his comment for it is the truth. I think the article was extremely well written and impossible to argue with. The problem is the double standards. If a white person were to make a statement of equal caliber about blacks and whites, they are immediately a racist and the black community would have calls for their head. Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton would be on the phone with the ACLU and all hell would break loose. But its ok if a black man makes a joke about slavery.

This stuff happend a very long time ago. I'm very sorry it did; I think it is horrific and shameful. But neither I nor any living person in my family had anything to do with it. Will an official apology really make a difference? Unless we literally rewrite the history books an apology means nothing. Get the chips off your shoulders and move on. Stop identifying people as black and white. As long as blacks live by double standards we will never progress and will remain a divided country because we are damned if we do and damned if we don't.