More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tom Alderman

Tom Alderman

GET UPDATES FROM Tom Alderman
 

Elizabeth Taylor -- Not Quite the Last One

Posted: 03/31/11 03:26 PM ET

"The last of Hollywood's golden era" is the way so many broadcast and cable obituaries described the legendary Elizabeth Taylor. If they're right we might have some respect for their fact-checking skills. But alas, there are at least five stars from that era who are probably saying to themselves," What am I, chopped liver?"

Olivia De Havilland, 95, and her sister, Joan Fontain, 94, probably saw the Taylor obit and yelped, although not to each other because they haven't talked in more than three decades.

How about Maureen Ohara, 91, the red-haired star of The Quiet Man, and The Miracle on 34th Street among many others. In addition to being the desk-top icon for Irish beauty, this lady's working buddies included Hollywood's big Johns: Wayne and Ford.

You think Mickey Rooney, 91, or Kirk Douglas, 95, are happy being overlooked? How could you miss Douglas' cringe-worthy, ego-busting showing at the recent Oscars when they couldn't get him off stage? As for Rooney, you can see him most any day at a Hollywood race track. Oh yeah, and he worked with Taylor.

Celeste Holm, 94, Oscar winner for Gentlemen's Agreement and nominated for Come to the Stable and All About Eve couldn't be too tickled over being ignored.

Louise Rainer, 101 (!) the first women to win two Oscars, consecutively, and the oldest living Oscar winner -- how do you miss that star?

Finally, there's Doris Kappelhoff, 89, the highest grossing actress of all time! Also known as Doris Day.

In all fairness, it was TV news and mostly the uber-hyberbolic showbiz shows like Entertainment Tonight, and Extra, that billed Taylor as the 'last star.' The Los Angeles Times, the New Tork Times and the Chicago Tribune did not get caught with their sloppy facts showing.

How do you explain this with TV? While these shows are entertainment, they deliver entertainment news. How hard is it to fact-check with a 24/7 Internet at your finger tips? Is this a deliberate screw-up that so many of them just re-screwed? Probably not. Producers along the TV news chain simply did not check their facts. It's lazy journalism and lazy journalism is bad journalism -- whether reporting critical issues of the day or movie star obituaries.

Oh, well, as Doris Kappelhoff use to sing, Que Sera Sera -- whatever will be, will be.

So sad.

 
"The last of Hollywood's golden era" is the way so many broadcast and cable obituaries described the legendary Elizabeth Taylor. If they're right we might have some respect for their fact-checking ski...
"The last of Hollywood's golden era" is the way so many broadcast and cable obituaries described the legendary Elizabeth Taylor. If they're right we might have some respect for their fact-checking ski...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 164
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
05:13 AM on 05/08/2011
Well Mr. Alderman you forgot Lauren Bacall. Lauren Bacall!!!?!!!?!!!!
11:31 PM on 04/05/2011
Thanks for naming all those people. I knew there were many of them still around. Joy Behar or Piers Morgan interviewed Angela Lansbury, Liz's sister in "Velvet" and was quite a star herself, pre-TV.

But, REALLY, Liz was unique. Nothing said about her was hyperbole. I was about 10 when she and Burton were making "Cleopatra". No "People" in those days, monthly movie magazines like "Photoplay" and "Silver Screen" and there they were, in layout after layout for 10+ years. And, then they started up space in "People".
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bruisersmom
03:23 PM on 04/04/2011
The hyperbole over Liz Taylor's obits didn't get past me, but I did mourn a little bit at her passing, and I felt like someone special had just passed out of the world. The last time I felt that way was when Audrey Hepburn died. I don't see myself feeling that way for any of the big stars of today, not George Clooney, or Tom Cruise, or Brangelina.

BTW, the woman who played Scarlett's littlest sister in Gone with the Wind also is still alive. She and De Havilland are the only two left.
09:18 PM on 04/09/2011
It was like when Audrey Hepburn died.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vaf112675
Read my comments. You'll know me by them.
02:02 PM on 04/04/2011
Doris Day is the highest grossing actress of all time???

That's calculating for inflation right?
07:34 PM on 04/04/2011
Yes, that is calculating for inflation. In addition, she is the only actress to be voted number one at the box-office in the annual Quigley Poll, four times. She appeared on the poll a total of ten times, the same number of times that Betty Grable did but Miss Grable only placed first on one occasion. Shirley Temple also placed first four times but only appeared on the top ten list 6 times. In addition, Miss Day also placed in the top ten of the prestigious Box office Magazine Poll on 18 occasions between 1951 and 1969, pacing 1st or 2nd on 9 of those occasions as well as winning three Golden Globes as World Film Favorite. Of her 39 films released, only 1 failed to make a profit.
07:43 PM on 04/04/2011
Some additional data about Miss Day - The Motion Picture Exhibitor Magazine in their annual poll of theatre owners, named Doris the top ranked female star at the box-office an unheard of 8 consecutive times from 1957-1964, inclusive. She also received their coveted Laurel Award as best Actress on four occasions. This was in the era of Miss Monroe, Taylor, Audrey Hepburn, Kim Novak and others and yet it was Miss Day that film exhibitors, the folks who owned the theatres, felt brought in the most consistent business to their theatres. Miss Day is too often dismissed by pundits and historians as "the virgin" which does a disservice to the magnitude of the success she enjoyed for decades. Actually viewing many of her films is an eye-opening experience in discovering a very skilled comic actress and extremely fine dramatic actress when given a chance. Filmgoers of the 50's and 60's eagerly awaited each "Doris Day film", which became a brand. You had to say nothing more than "There's a new Doris Day film coming" and your listener instantly understood.
01:59 PM on 04/04/2011
Everyone mentioned in the article and comments are stars, however, Liz was an icon. Icon's have a lasting effect on cluture and styles. Examples of icons, would be Jackie O., Marilyn Monroe, John Wayne, etc. They are recognized by multible generations. I would also consider Doris Day and Shirley Temple as icons because there influence on pop cluture and style is still felt today.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paris55
Think for yourself & reach your own conclusions.
01:45 AM on 04/04/2011
Question - has Mickey Rooney ever received the Kennedy Center Honor. I don' t think he has. It could be related to a few roles he has done that many people to this day, do not care for. One role - blackface in Babes in Arms. Although Judy Garland did it too, it was not necessary for the picture. Second role - the stereotypical Japanese landlord in Breakfast at Tiffany's. Many people asked him why he did the role as he did and he thought there was nothing wrong with the portrayal. He also stated that no one has ever brought it up until recently. He was pretty good in his day. He deserves a Kennedy Center Honor now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edgraham
There is no magic
11:20 AM on 04/04/2011
Interesting that many white stars played asians in movies just to name a few: all the Charlie Chans, Boris Karlof, Jenifer Jones, Marlon Brando, and Peter Lorie. Re: the black face in Babes in Arms - - I don't think Mickie or Judy had any pull at the studio. It was a different era. And as George Carlin once said, "F#%K Al Jolson." Unlike the movie people following directions, Jolson created that act.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paris55
Think for yourself & reach your own conclusions.
01:10 PM on 04/04/2011
Re the white actors that played Asian, of course at that time, it was a taboo for races to mix on screen re relationships in larger productions. Re Babes in Arms - there was an outcry re this scene at the time. Remember this was the same period, 1939, when David O. Selznick had the decency to consult with the NAACP on various topics and portrayals on Margaret Mitchell's Gone with the Wind and how to transfer them to the screen. I know that Jolson started the act in Vaudeville, later transferring that to the screen. That was at that time but it did make certain people very uncomfortable. You should check out Turner Classic Movies documentaries esp Asians and their portrayal on the silver screen. They had documentaries on Asians, Native Americans and Blacks in film.

I was just curious on why the Kennedy Ctr Honors did not recognize Mickey Rooney, a child star that had very good adult roles for a time. He may not be around too much longer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nycagnes
12:30 AM on 04/04/2011
How about Debbie Reynolds, Jane Powell and Kim Novak. They're not chopped liver either.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
BannedFromCommenting
♼ ♼ PLEASE RECYCLE TROLLS ♼ ♼
11:59 PM on 04/03/2011
"Louise Rainer, 101 (!) the first women to win two Oscars, consecutively, and the oldest living Oscar winner -- how do you miss that star?"

Typo, woman, not women.. just FYI.

I thought ah how about Debbie Reynolds too?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paris55
Think for yourself & reach your own conclusions.
01:48 AM on 04/04/2011
Rainer was very good. The first Oscar she won, The Great Ziegfeld, she was only on the screen for about 10-15 minutes. She poured so much emotion into that telephone call when she found out that Ziegfeld married Billie Burke.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MIvoter1231
I rarely answer replies, too many are just hateful
09:59 PM on 04/03/2011
I agree that there are many still living who were (depending on who you like) better actresses from that era. But there was one major difference between her and the others.

She was a "Movie Star". She never said she was anything else. De Haviland, Fontaine, O'Hara were her equals, in fact superiors, in acting chops and are Legends, but they aren't movie stars.

ET couldn't hold a candle to the range and complexity of De Haviland and her exceptional body of work. She earned her two Oscars honestly and was so wonderful in those films. But she still could not reach the kinds of depths that Olivia plumbed in "The Snake Pit."

So while there are other, much more accomplished (perhaps even more talented), yet quieter Legends, ET was indeed the last of an era. Much like Monroe, there is/was no one like her and no one who thrilled their public in the same way or for as long. ET even managed to keep making news right up until the end of her long life and long past her acting days were done. That's what made her a Movie Star, beyond being an actress and legend. There were very few that could lay claim to that title with a capital "M". ET did.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aranxa
10:58 PM on 04/03/2011
Olivia De Haviland wasn't a movie star? What planet are you on? She wasn't tabloid fodder, but that doesn't make her not a movie star.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chad Wheeler
12:23 PM on 04/04/2011
I think we would all agree DeHaviland was a movie star but ET was somehow different. To many people, she was larger than life. Her personal life, her health issues, her multiple marriages, the iconic roles. To me she was a Movie Star not an actress or a film star or even a movie star.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MIvoter1231
I rarely answer replies, too many are just hateful
06:35 AM on 04/05/2011
She is a legendary actress. And if you read, you will find that I find her a superior actress to ET, despite ET's talent and beauty.

There is Legendary Actress and movie star - DeHaviland, Fontaine, Davis, Hepburn
And then there is Movie Star, with a capital M - ET, Monroe

A Movie Star is known for far more than their acting chops.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aranxa
07:03 PM on 04/03/2011
Today is Doris Day 86th birthday day!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paris55
Think for yourself & reach your own conclusions.
12:53 AM on 04/04/2011
Doris Day is one woman that I asked the Oprah website to try to interview for Oprah's 25th finale. Ms. Day has not done an interview since the Manson killings - remember Manson and his followers were after Terry Melcher, Doris Day's late son. They thought he was in the house when Sharon Tate and the others were murdered. Manson has a problem with Melcher a record producer, because Melcher did not want to record Charlie Manson's songs. He either owned the house or rented it and told Tate she could use it because he would be out of town. When the FBI found this out, they provided security for Doris and Terr for a while.

I am sure if Oprah or anyone who has tried to get an interview with her would want to ask questions re this time of her life and she probably has or will refuse. Even if they do not bring it up, I wish she would finally give an intervew.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aranxa
07:01 PM on 04/03/2011
There's also Margaret O'Brien, "Toottie" in Meet Me in St. Louis who did so many films and had so much talent Lionel Barrymore said, "If she had been born 200 years ago she'd have been burned at the stake as a witch."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aranxa
07:15 PM on 04/03/2011
And Ester Williams, Lauren Bacall, Shirley Temple, Sophia Loren, Brigitte Bardot, Debbie Reynolds, Andy Griffith, Eve Marie Saint, Deanna Durbin, James Arness, Ann Blyth, Theodore Bikel, Ann Blyth.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paris55
Think for yourself & reach your own conclusions.
01:00 AM on 04/04/2011
Arness died some years ago, did he not? I would not place him in the same category with the other actors you named. Out of your list, Sophia Loren, Debbie Reynolds and Lauren Bacall had something going....so did Brigette Bardot.

You forgot Kim Novak. Although I never really liked her roles too much, she was well respected and had talent. I do not like comparing actors with each other. But we all have our favorites.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rutroGeorge
Silence is Golden, unless I have something to bark
02:36 PM on 04/03/2011
Yeah, but they weren't married (7) times, twice to the same volatile partner. C'mon folks, remember what's REALLY important to todays MSM: if it doesn't bleed (matrimony included) it doesn't lead.
photo
Ima Speakonit
The truth hurts because honesty is brutal!
01:09 PM on 04/03/2011
You really expected today's TV media to take the time and research, some simple facts? Surely, you jest?
photo
rsaillant1
He who argues facts wastes time, his & mine.
09:47 AM on 04/03/2011
Folks...relax, all those living, big name film stars lack
one thing that Liz attained....she died, they haven't. When
their time comes the accolades will fly. For their sake,
don't rush things.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
p c r
Compassionate and Conservative are polar opposites
01:57 AM on 04/03/2011
My husband and I have discussed the same topic. What about Shirley McClaine and Debbie Reynolds and Doris Day? Taylor was a star, and a great one, but she is not the last of the era. I want to take nothing away from Elizabeth and her legacy, but it is an insult to others to pretend she was the only star of her time, and that she is the last of her era. Thanks for pointing this out.
09:28 AM on 04/03/2011
Not to take anything away from Elizabeth, who was amazing, but Doris Day is, to this day, the number one female box-office star of all-time. The name Doris Day is still used today. When you mention her name people immediately think of a particular kind of film whether or not it's an accurate representation since Miss Day starred in suspense thrillers, westerns, musicals, dramas, frothy comedies, slapstick comedies. In an era of Taylor, Monroe, Novak, and Audrey Hepburn Miss Day dominated the popularity polls. While Miss Taylor's notoreity in the late 50's and early 60's insured front page headlines, Miss Day was the person filmgoers lined up to see in droves. Let's not pretend that Doris Day is not an icon either. After Katrina, Miss Day chartered a plane to save hundreds of stray animals that had lost their owners, flying them to California to be cared for and given new homes. Privately she has given millions to "People Charities" including AIDS. Miss Day's more than 700 recordings and tens of millions of records sold have given her lasting recognition. She was number one in films, number one recording star for many years (She is about far more than "Que Sera Sera"), and one of the few film stars to successfully transfer to television where she starred for 5 successful years. Let's remember Miss Taylor and so many others who are still with us, but let's not dismiss Miss Day's contribution and lasting popularity.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BJHenton
01:59 PM on 04/03/2011
Well said. Very informative. Thanks.