iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Tracy Baim

GET UPDATES FROM Tracy Baim
 

Title IX and the Women's World Cup

Posted: 07/11/11 01:23 PM ET

In the nearly 40 years since its passage in 1972, Title IX has been consistently under fire from a wide range of critics.

Like the Equal Rights Amendment, it uses simple language to level the playing field for women and girls:

"No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance ... "

This meant that schools receiving federal money had to treat female sports the same as male sports. Some schools used this as an excuse to get rid of under-performing men's sports rather than provide more for women. But that's not the fault of women, it is the fault of short-sighted and sometimes sexist school administrators.

Watching the Women's World Cup, and the incredible U.S. quarterfinal win Sunday against Brazil, I am reminded just how important Title IX has been to the women's movement, and for me personally as a woman.

I played Little League with the boys in 1975, just three years after Title IX began, and I didn't have to fight my coach for the right (even though Title IX did not apply to the league). I played softball in high school, and even though we had fewer resources than the boy's sports, we still had the right to play.

I also started playing soccer around 1978, not in high school, but on a private club team through the network of German soccer clubs in Chicago. (As a Jewish girl, that presented its own issues for me.) The "girl's" teams were always junior to the men's and boy's teams, no matter how good we were.

I eventually transferred to the Schwaben club, and it changed by life. Our coach was Julius Roth, who had escaped from East Germany decades earlier as a youth, and now was raising four girls, all who played soccer just as their father had. Mr. Roth and his family (his wife Elsie, daughters Karen, Marion, Lori and Diane) dreamed of going to Germany, and our team set out on two years of fundraising to be able to travel with the Roths and play some serious soccer in West Germany.

We were among the top women's soccer clubs in the Midwest, and had traveled around the region to play, so it was not unusual to think we could travel further. Sports had given us the confidence to think big.

Eight years after Title IX, in 1980, I was 17 years old and playing right half-back for Schwaben as we lived with and played against women's teams in West Germany. (Germany was not reunited as one country until a decade later, in 1990.) It was an amazing journey for our team, and living with the other teams added another dimension to our trip. And it happened 11 years before the Women's World Cup was first played in 1991.

2011-07-11-schwabenGermaninChicagoearly80s.jpg
Soon after the Schwaben team went to Germany in 1980, a German team came to Chicago to play. Pictured are the Schwaben and German team members and coaches posing together after a match in the Chicago area, early 1980s.


We played eight games in the West German cities of Hamburg and Hanover, and the German media covered the matches extensively. As we won match after match, the media attention, and focus of German coaches, grew more intense. But even an all-star team Germany put together for the last match was not enough to defeat us; we won all eight of our games that summer of 1980.

My life, and the lives of my teammates (even those who couldn't make the trip) were forever changed by playing women's sports. Our winning in Germany was a highlight of my life, but it was not because we played soccer and just happened to win. It was because sports has a way of building skills you need in life.

Among those skills that Title IX has directly changed in the lives of millions women and girls:

  • A confidence in your body and your mind.

  • The ability to come back after losing.

  • Working hard for a result.

  • Living a healthy lifestyle through athletics.

  • And most important, especially in team sports, you are working together as a group, depending on others, helping others, and succeeding in achieving a combined dream.

We may have failed as a country to pass the ERA, but Title IX had its own critical role in the women's movement. This is true even for those women who did not play sports, but saw brave women such as Billie Jean King fight for equality on the tennis courts, among sponsors, and in the media.

Four years ago, as the Women's World Cup was being held, our Schwaben team held a reunion. Looking at some of the players, I knew several of them would have played on the World Cup, if it had just happened a few years earlier.

But I also realized that our games in Germany were played on the historical backs of generations of women who never were allowed to play sports. That we were lucky to be able to play soccer at all, and even more fortunate to travel to another country to play our own mini World Cup.

Title IX is under constant threat by politicians and some men's sports advocates. Sports programs as a whole are increasingly seen as an expense schools can't afford. Except for sports such as football and basketball, some men's sports are also at risk.

If most school sports go away, and if Title IX is gutted, it would have a negative impact on the next generation of girls and women, and on our country as a whole. Women's sports are not just sports, they build skills we need as a culture. It's not about winning, it's about being able to play the game.

See http://www.fifa.com/ for details on the Women's World Cup. The U.S. Women had an incredible come-from-behind win Sunday over Brazil to advance to the semi-finals vs. France Wednesday morning, while Japan plays Sweden later that same day. Unfortunately, host country Germany lost and will not be advancing.

Tracy Baim is publisher and executive editor of Windy City Times newspaper.

 

Follow Tracy Baim on Twitter: www.twitter.com/windycitytimes1

 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:48 PM on 07/12/2011
Title IX is a great piece of legislation IMO. While I feel bad for talented women who never had the opportunity to compete, I am happy that today's women do have that opportunity.

The ancient Greeks considered athletic achievement to be the equal of artistic achievement. Sport is a celebration of the human body. Celebrate.
04:00 PM on 07/11/2011
Some may not want to hear this, but other factors are just as important as Title IX, especially elite youth club teams and national team residency camps in female soccer. Mia Hamm made the U.S. team at 15, before she played high school or college soccer.

Title IX applies only to scholastic competition that in a numer of sports, including soccer, does not provide the best competitive and player development environment for high-level players because of limits on games and practice time.

I'm amazed to see the same oversights being made about this subject now in the wake of the U.S. win over Brazil as there were in 1999.
photo
Tracy Baim
Publisher/exec editor Windy City Times
02:41 PM on 07/11/2011
Let me also add my gratitude for Karen Roth, my coach's daughter, for her pioneering work as founder and president of the Illinois Women's Soccer League (IWSL) in the 1970s. The league is going strong today. She also coordinated and presided over the first women's soccer tournaments in the US. She said: "Our annual tournaments began in Oak Brook on the polo fields in 1975. In 1976 or 77 we had a team from Canada and a team from Germany playing in the tournament. This was the beginning of the interchange of women's teaks from Chicago to Germany."
12:37 PM on 07/11/2011
Unfortunately, Title IX has also killed men's soccer programs at some schools as it's the program some choose to drop to achieve equity.
05:23 AM on 07/13/2011
Title IX has NEVER caused any school to drop a men's program. You have been misled. LACK OF FUNDING is what causes programs to be dropped, not Title IX. Title IX only ensures that when a school must face the unfortunate reality of having to drop a program, they do so in a non-discriminatory way. If this results in a men's team being dropped over a women's team, it is likely because women were being underrepresented already and thus dropping a women's team would be discriminatory. There are three ways to satisfy Title IX: 1) provide participation opportunities proportional to total student enrollment for each sex; 2) show a history of continual expansion of opportunities for the underrepresented sex; or 3) fully accomodate the interests and abilities of the underrepresented sex. Nowhere does it say that there has to be an equal number of women's teams as men's teams or that there be equal participation.