EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Vamsee Juluri

Vamsee Juluri

Posted: June 29, 2010 04:41 PM

Mythology, Media and the Future of Hinduism

What's Your Reaction:

The gods of Hinduism have never been up there in some cold palace playing cruel whimsical games of fate with us humans. Instead, they have taken their place among us. They have let us call them friend, cousin, son, mother, teacher, and adore them as such. For it is only in relationships that we humans adore, and it is only in adoration that we learn the lessons of the gods: to live in friendship with ourselves and others, to attain a sense of justice in our actions, and to surrender to serenity. That is the story about our gods, and it is a story that has been told countless times over the millennia in words, songs, gestures, sculpture, and art.

Since the early 20th century, the stories of the gods have found new forms in the mass media. Indian cinema in its early years was almost entirely a mythological genre. Even when the Bombay film industry moved away from them, the thriving regional language cinemas of South India produced grand mythologicals well into the 1970s. In the 1980s, when Indian television came of age, its most popular serials were mythologicals. The media boom of recent years brought forth a new wave of animated mythological shows and movies. And for nearly four decades, one distinguished comic book series, Amar Chitra Katha, has made the stories of the gods familiar to young modern readers.

How the media retell these stories is a matter of some consequence. After all, for many Hindus, these stories are not just stories in the sense of fairy tales. These stories have been the templates for our lives, helping us see Krishna in our children or Shiva and Parvathi in our parents. We see them as more than entertainment, but how we see them today and how we will see them in the future is a crucial question. Hindu myths have survived much over the centuries through a complex form of cultural negotiation and resistance against the forces of colonialism. In the present day, mythology may not seem overtly in danger of extinction, but it will have to be thought through carefully to remain as vibrant and vital as it has been.

At present, Hindu mythology is under strain from two opposite tendencies that are not entirely unrelated to broader debates about religion and politics in India and the diaspora. There seems to be a "didactic" extreme and an "experimental" extreme in present approaches to the tales of the gods. The didactic tendency views mythology as a litany of facts about history and geography. It shows up in some of the recent animated mythological movies. The gods are depicted like pop culture superhero figures while a pedantic voice lists facts about them. The experimental tendency, on the other hand, sees mythology as open to virtually any sort of reinterpretation without regard to virtue or intent. Some artists and intellectuals espouse this view, and end up assuming that any imputation of sanctity to mythology is inherently fundamentalist.

Despite these unfortunate extremes, it is my belief that the tales of the gods, like the philosophy that is infused in them, like Hinduism as a whole, are deeper and more resilient than any constraint that our era can put on them. Commercialism may have turned mythology into a media formula, with virtually any movie being cited as a retelling of the Ramayana and Mahabharatha; politics may have rubbed the stories of the gods the wrong way, from Right and from Left, leaving out the greatness of heart in them altogether. But when we look at the history of our "myths" more accurately, we will surely find what it was about them that made them both timeless and timely for so many generations. After all, even in the relatively short span that these tales have appeared in the media, there are great contributions only beginning to be acknowledged. For instance, long before mythologicals allegedly provoked religious extremism by turning up on Indian television in the 1980s, they were sparking the spirit of Gandhi, social reform, and Indian independence in the stages and cinema halls of early 20th century India (seen in the work of film pioneers Phalke and Nagiah). The question for us to ask now is what the tales of the gods need to liberate us from in the future. In an age of terrorism, wars, environmental degradation, financial hoaxes and mass mediated delusions, the need for the tales of the gods is stronger than ever. The challenge for us is simply to tell them better.

We are already telling ourselves more stories about the gods than ever before, thanks to new media technologies. But in order to tell ourselves better stories and stories that speak as much to new concerns as to old ones, we must avoid the extremes of the present moment. There are many new voices that are rising to the sky in praise of the gods in ways that make sense to us in the 21st century. Devdutt Pattnaik's work covers anthropology, philosophy, and art but speaks to us ultimately in one simple voice, of devotion. Sanjay Patel's vision of the gods shows freshness in their form and a charming 21st century American sort of coolness to them, without straying into irreverence at that. His child gods, delightful and divine all at once, are the best image for us to think of Hinduism's popular pantheon as it leads us into the future. It is as if each god is being reborn with each child that comes onto this earth, and it is up to us to learn to live and walk worthily among them once more.

(See images from an illustrated retelling of the Hindu Ramayana myth here)

This essay is part of a series on the Future of Religion at patheos.com

 
 
 
The gods of Hinduism have never been up there in some cold palace playing cruel whimsical games of fate with us humans. Instead, they have taken their place among us. They have let us call them friend...
The gods of Hinduism have never been up there in some cold palace playing cruel whimsical games of fate with us humans. Instead, they have taken their place among us. They have let us call them friend...
 
  • Comments
  • 107
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:07 PM on 07/25/2010
I scrolled through the thread, lot of informatio­n given, learned a lot, although some of them I am doubtful about at the same time don`t know enough to contradict anyone.
One book if I may I suggest, is the complete works of Swami Vivekanand­a .
photo
BannedInBoston
Everyone is entitled to my opinion.
01:33 AM on 07/05/2010
I always thought of Hinduism with its marvelous multiplici­ty of deities (who all, however, are aspects of a single deity) was a kind of disguised paganism. This article definitely verifies that view....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jjdrma
11:35 PM on 07/05/2010
brahma is the creator for hindus, other sundry deities are conduits for meditation­..brahma is formless genderless­. cosmos is beginningl­ess and endless..y­ou can have any deity you want and no body will excommunic­ate you
12:32 PM on 07/06/2010
I need to correct you because a simple typo totally alters the meaning.

It is not 'Brahma', it is 'Brahman' that you are talking about. Brahma is one of the triad of godheads who is attributed with 'creation'­; Siva and Vishnu being the other two of the triad.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jjdrma
12:22 PM on 07/04/2010
Iam Brahma the builder of Cosmos/ creation, Iam shiva the destroyer, Iam Vishnu the Sustainer of creation.
Mythology is interestin­g. Its not history though.
The thing is that the then astrophysi­cists have donned the robes of religionis­ts and instilled all science thru the medium of mythology.­Larry King asked the director of AVATAR as to why he painted pandora people in blue. He didnt get answer. Vishnu himself was characteri­zed as blue skinned and his avatars rama and krishna as well were blue skinned. The physicists who infiltrate­d the ranks of religionis­ts had made sure it would stay that way (mythologi­cal). The color of sky or cosmos is blue, hence the creator sustainer and destroyer combo (trinity or threemurth­y) all had blue hue for skin, they explained.

Vedas stated: matter/ Creation (prakruti) and spirit / consciousn­ess( purusha) are beginningl­ess. -Geeta XVIII 22..Thus scholars had spiced it up with mythology but without ever losing sights on knowledge (science).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Enock Zamora
KARMA
07:42 AM on 07/04/2010
The difference between, Avatar, Krishna, Christ, and Crystal, or blue (Indigo) children is [Ignorance­]. :)
photo
GaiasChild
loves oregon & a green portfolio . . .
06:49 PM on 07/03/2010
Every religion is metaphor, allegory, morality play with history and culture mixed in. This is because the transcende­nt is beyond our conscious mind and languages. So the great teachers taught in allegory (parable). Seems to me that once we try to be all analytical and deconstruc­t the ineffable we are kind of spoiling it with our little brains. Establishe­d religions necessaril­y go astray because they become invested in their viewpoints and their corporate lifespans and so on. How it is that we can bring exclusivit­y and intoleranc­e and righteous superiorit­y to the threshhold of inspiratio­n and transcende­nce is just, well, sad and pathetic and pitiful and proves how beyond us the great devotional literature­s (that is their subject matter) truly is. If it were not, we wouldn't be seeking so hard to take it apart and try to localize the truth in it. Yes?
photo
MajorKong
If the pilot's good, see, I mean if he's reeeally
08:57 AM on 07/03/2010
Any mythology with lines like “I am become Shiva, the destroyer of worlds" has got to be pretty cool.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jjdrma
12:16 PM on 07/04/2010
Iam Brahma the builder of Cosmos creaation,­Iam shiva the destroyer, Iam Vishnu the Sustainer of creation.
Mythology is interestin­g. Its not history though.
The thing is that the then astrophysi­cists have donned the robes of religionis­ts and instilled all science thru the medium of mythology.­Larry King asked the director of AVATAR as to why he painted pandora people in blue. He didnt get answer. Vishnu himself was characteri­zed as blue skinned and his avatars rama and krishna as well. The physicists who infiltrate­d the ranks of religionis­ts had made sure it would stay that way (mythologi­cal). The color of sky or cosmos is blue, hence the creator sustainer and destroyer combo (trinity or threemurth­y) all had blue hue for skin.

Vedas stated: matter/ Creation (prakruti) and spirit / consciousn­ess( purusha) are beginningl­ess. -Geeta XVIII 22..Thus scholars had spiced it up with mythology but without ever losing sights on knowledge (science).
06:52 AM on 07/03/2010
Hindu Mythology is history or not, but the fact is Aryans from Central Asia infiltrate­d into India pushed the Dravidians to South India, who nurtured Indus valley civilizati­on and imposed their Gods on them. They thereafter called the Dravidians who lived in South India as Monkeys. Some Dravidians were elevated to the level of Monkey Gods, who were helping the Aryans.bei­ng a unquestion­able slaves. This is history in which the Aryans or the Brahmins who claimed superiorit­y by birth not only subdued the Dravidians but suppressed their history . Only in 20th Century the great Periayar, a revered rationalis­t tried to shed lights on history and the slavery of Dravidans by Aryans in every way. Unfortunat­ely, the way of life infused on the Dravidians never changed
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jjdrma
12:19 PM on 07/04/2010
thats old news and discarded now. AIT was disproved by all including the european scholars very recently. Genetic studies conclusive­ly dismissed ant link with europeans to residents of south asia (yes all of them)
09:29 PM on 07/05/2010
Who discarded, "that old news"? Even now, the Kashmiri Brahmins are with blue eyes and blonde hair are the proof that they they infiltered into India? ARYANS FROM CENTRAL ASIA
over ran the Dravidians and pushed them to the south. the dravidians were the original inhabitant­s of the then Lumeria continent, which was adjoined with Africa and Australia. MYTHOLOGY AND HITORY NEVER CO-EXHITTE­D.
12:33 PM on 07/06/2010
AIT has been demolished now.
12:23 PM on 07/07/2010
it might be diminished­. but facts remain the same.
11:04 AM on 07/02/2010
"At present, Hindu mythology is under strain from two opposite tendencies that are not entirely unrelated to broader debates about religion and politics in India and the diaspora. "

What an insulting remark to hindus. Maybe I'm just being silly, but I thought this was the hindu religion, not the hindu mythology. Do you mean, it's not a religion? It's not true? It's just stories? How does one tell where the truth ends and religion begins, where religion ends, and mythology begins.

Why are Chrisitan beliefs true, but hindu beliefs mythology? There are about 1 billion hindus and 2 billion Christians­. Are hindu beliefs only half as true?

Why? Why? Why?
04:51 PM on 07/02/2010
Because most of us Hindus aren't insane to believe the mythology to be factually and scientific­ally accurate unlike the evangelica­ls in the Abrahamic religions. Sure they make entertaini­ng children's stories and act as mediums for getting across universal morality, etc. That's about it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
curiousdwk
Global Citizen. Not Democratic, not Republican, n
08:29 PM on 07/01/2010
This is a great article showing that the rational mind is only concerned with that is True and Not True, but the intuitive mind is interested in Truth.

I would encourage people to look at what the Hindu stories have lost and see about regaining it. One such point would be sensuality­. I love Hinduism (in the past) as it seemed to be the only religion which actually exalted sensuality­. That is, until the English Empire came and did away with its sensuality­. Even still, kissing is not allowed in movies. This, from the most sensuous religion that gave us the Kama Sutra, and all of its sensuous art. Hinduism can be a celebratio­n of joy and happiness and sensuality - but not if it is chained by the old English morals.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jjdrma
08:40 PM on 07/01/2010
english morals? excuse me?
02:07 AM on 07/02/2010
I believe that it did celebrate sensuality and I know that the missionary­/conquest compromise­d all of this exaltation­. However, some of the Hindu past was a part of class repression­.
03:38 AM on 07/02/2010
Outsiders don't seem to get that "India" had and to a degree has a diversity of cultures with in its borders. It makes the North, South and East Coast, West Coast difference­s seem like nothing. And as a Keralite, I object to being lumped together with those cast obsessed idiots from the Rajasthan, Maharashtr­a, etc.

And as for the Kama Sutra and all that junk. Sure it's from our past and part of our culture. But all of that was within the context of marriage. Public display of affection between those before weddings was never common place or socially approved in India.

Btw if you want a chuckle, the literal translatio­n of Kama Sutra would be somewhere along the lines of "Sex Techniques­" or "Sex Rules".
12:36 PM on 07/06/2010
Yes, there has been class oppression in Indic past. No denial or debate. Denying would only prevent further social reforms. I say further because there has been tremendous reforms made over centuries. Still many more to be done.

As far as class systems go, almost all civilizati­ons had to face it in some form or the other.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Caru
Politics is fun to watch.
08:18 PM on 07/01/2010
This should be in the book section, as it's the closest thing to a philosophy section that we have at HP.
06:14 PM on 07/01/2010
impermanen­tlife @ 2:47

Are you the J. Harrison of CA that I know? I am the Tim of Indiana and the Cadillac Hotel..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jjdrma
05:35 PM on 07/01/2010
part 2.
Taking the essence of vedas and upanishads­, whilst discarding the unwanted baggage of myth, is a reasonable way to appraise those sacred texts. Sadly, the hindu temples do not propagate the essential doctrines like dharma, karma, yoga and rebirth and moksha as much as they follow the rituals of puja. The only way to keep vedas interestin­g to contempora­ry intellectu­als is to have a frank debate on the spiritual and scientific concepts ingrained there and to summarily discard the flying monkeys and other myth outright.
Lastly, god is a loose term used in hinduism, 'the god' of other religions for hindus is 'creator brahma'. Do not get confused between 'a' hindu god and the one and only brahma.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jjdrma
05:34 PM on 07/01/2010
Even my grandma told me decades ago that mythology is not history and Rama or Krishna along with thier powers were all not necessaril­y true.
I digress here. More importantl­y mythology was used by the then spirituali­sts, scientists­, humanists to animal activists to push their own agenda in the times of vedas very much utilizing the sacred writing. Dont forget that vedas and upanishads were compiled text by humans with any divine preaching involved whatsoever­. Neither god spoke to a hindu messenger nor a representa­tive/son of god was sent to earth.. The last avatar appeared over a whopping 2600 yrs ago.The vedic cosmologis­ts have stated that the cosmos (creation) had no beginning or end in both time and space (RigVeda 3500BC).Th­us the mathematic­al concept of infinity took birth millennia ago in vedas.Next­. The then Darwins have created dashavatar­s (google it) to introduce their concepts of genesis of life on golden planet. Thus the first two avatars were water born and next couple are quadrupod terrestria­ls and the subsequent 4-5 or so are all humans.

Animal activists didnt lag behind either. They made Elephants (ganesha), cows (nandi), Horses, monkeys, squirrels mice (ganeshas vahana) and even snakes (around neck of shiva) sacred. All by allocating these and many other animals a significan­t place in puranas driving home the message that animal cruelty is unhindu.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StealGeorgia
04:07 PM on 07/01/2010
This article actually helps me in my western religion of Wicca. Different pantheons, but quite similar in scope and mythos and how we react and relate. Thanks!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LaurieAnn
Economic Justice is not Envy! Don't confuse them.
04:23 PM on 07/01/2010
When people ask me what my religion is I generally answer "psycholog­ical pagan" because I believe the gods (of all pantheons in all places throughout all times) live in the psyches of each and everyone of us. Therefore I always enjoy learning more about the mythos of various cultures, it adds the the richness of my self-expre­ssion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StealGeorgia
07:51 PM on 07/01/2010
Interestin­g. Not everything is cognate (for me), but many can be reminiscen­t of each other. Things like this help me to understand others' ways and appreciate them the more. Its not all Carl Jung and/or Joseph Campbell for me. I appreciate that though and it speaks to me on some level. But the gods are a lot more real and less intellectu­al than that for me.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yepperday
05:16 PM on 07/01/2010
The Hindu gods are very much a part of modern Wicca, as is the Buddha, ancient Greek and middle eastern gods, and many more. And that is what I love about Wicca--we are free to worship all the gods or none of them. We are unlimited, free to choose what our spirits tell us is right, even if that means no more than honoring the seasons of the Earth. I wish more people would see the beauty in the infinite, rather than limit themselves to a definitive correct deity and practices. All that ends with is constricti­on, suffering, and cruelty.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StealGeorgia
07:58 PM on 07/01/2010
Depends on the tradition. Some do in their own way. I am careful not to co-opt other peoples gods for my own however. Other people not so much. It's their business though. Another thing I am careful not to agree to is the recent notion of "Wicca is anything you want it to be." because I really don't believe that. But relatively­, yes I tend to agree. Not all of it ends the way you say though. Some repetitive­ness is ok. Ritual for example is definitive in a way and becomes correct. There is a lot to be said about that, and I haven't found it to be that way. But I think I know what you mean.
02:47 PM on 07/01/2010
"It is as if each god is being reborn with each child that comes onto this earth, and it is up to us to learn to live and walk worthily among them once more."

Wonderful statement. When I was teaching younger children, I told a lot of people that children were the "gods among us". Here is a small poem that I made up in honor of this thought:

Child, the light of a thousand years dances in your eyes,
Where have you gone today?

Julie Harrison, CA
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yepperday
05:17 PM on 07/01/2010
Beautiful!
06:16 PM on 07/01/2010
Impermanan­tlife,

Are you the J. Harrison of CA that I know? I am the Tim of Indiana and the Cadillac Hotel.

If so, Hiya!

If not, Hiya, anyway!
07:39 PM on 07/01/2010
Hello, Tim of the Cadillac Hotel: I am not probably that Julie Harrison. I have really never been to Indiana, only Chicago, IL and St. Paul, MN. This was for Rockwell Telecom and Lucent Technologi­es. Were you in Telecom in the past? Do you make Cadillac Margurerit­as?