More

Virginia M. Moncrieff

Virginia M. Moncrieff

Posted March 4, 2009 | 02:01 PM (EST)

Despair In Pakistan Over Cricket Attack, Government's Incompetence


Notwithstanding the fact that the perpetrators have yet to be caught, what we can say for sure is that the real target of yesterday's attacks were not the Sri Lankan cricket team, nor was it Sri Lanka, or indeed cricket, but Pakistan itself. If ever there was a way to throw two fingers up at the Pakistani government and say we don't care, we don't play by your rules, this was it.

And everyone knows it. My Facebook page has been nearly jumping out of my laptop, with Pakistani friends despairing, truly despairing at their government's inability and ineptitude at holding fundamentalists at bay and getting to the root of the problem - to be a proper, responsible, strong, in control, legitimate government.

"It's adding to the atmosphere of insecurity already present," wrote one friend, "further tarnishing the country's image as a lawless state, more like adding to the atmosphere of insecurity already present, discouraging foreigners from visiting the troubled land, discouraging foreign investment in any form."

The government in Islamabad seems criminally preoccupied with power struggles and accusations (court proceedings drag on and disrupt the important business of government while President Zadari and former PM Nawaz Sharif go the verbal stoush). Ahem gentleman, can we pay attention to the pressing matters at hand? Like the future of your country.

But the West helps no one with its constant carping about Pakistan the Basket Case, Pakistan the Write Off, Pakistan the Islamist Haven. Yes, we recognize in that country the world has a problem, but let's get a grip, take a powder and dial down the pointless drama.

"Today Fareed Zakaria and Afghan Foreign Minister Mr. Spanta audaciously declared Pakistan 'the single most dangerous country in the world' without a thought to the fact that this menace was planted during the Cold War," wrote my good friend Maria Ahmad, a foreign affairs correspondent at Geo TV in Karachi. "Yes, we are a country plagued with this 'cancer' but none of us - not the elected government nor a dictatorship and never the civilians, have even remotely supported this. Pakistan stands to lose the most, our citizens, friends, repute and most of all, our economic opportunities. To isolate us is not the answer. We need dialogue and development, we need friends to stand by us because in this war we have inherited, we too are struggling for survival."

Within Pakistan, there is a deep struggle for some kind of political integrity, some sense that the truth must be told and that the government is genuinely working to and capable of repairing what have been identified, in the West as irreparable fissures. I worried to my friend Farrukh - always a good sounding board - that this attack would give the West yet another opportunity to accuse and blame and dismiss Pakistan based on perceptions that all Pakistanis are Muslim nut jobs living in a lawless land.

Farrukh wrote back some of the most sane words I have heard this week. "We have to fight reality not images. We must fight anyone who does this. No mercy for the terrorist either local or foreign!" was his succinct cri de coeur.

The last word goes to my friend Hasan. "Most people like me are crying in real, with tears in eyes. Today while posting my condolence to the Sri Lankan cricket board, I said them, sorry, as we feel ashamed that despite giving seven lives we could not save our precious guests from bullets of terrorists."


Notwithstanding the fact that the perpetrators have yet to be caught, what we can say for sure is that the real target of yesterday's attacks were not the Sri Lankan cricket team, nor was it Sri Lanka...
Notwithstanding the fact that the perpetrators have yet to be caught, what we can say for sure is that the real target of yesterday's attacks were not the Sri Lankan cricket team, nor was it Sri Lanka...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 60
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:00 PM on 03/07/2009
There is no one left in pakistan to talk to. It's only a matter of time before the army will have to take over AGAIN! But this time I think the civil war cannot be stopped. Once Taliban get close to acquiring the nuclear sites India or America will HAVE to invade.
06:59 PM on 03/07/2009
These pakistanis keep whining about cia/mossad/raw. why don't they fix their country? india and pakistan were both created at the same time on 1947. why did they take 2 such different paths? it's because of the inherent flaw on basing a country on a religious ideology. They have based Pakistan on Desert Islam which means it is against democracy and freedom and progress. The point of this Islam is to return to the time of muhammad which was the perfect age for Islam.

The only thing holding pakistan together is the kashmir which involves the hatred of India. The people are so brainwashed from birth that they are easily swayed and accept ridiculous explanations from their politicians about their failures. Anything bad that happens in Pakistan is automatically India's doing. This easy escape from responsibility keeps the population pacified and docile. It's the reason the army has been able to maintain its iron grip on the people without them fighting back.

I can guarantee that most pakistanis see an indian hand behind these attacks. Also how can you have open dialouge with pakistani politicians? zardari is a liar who plays a double game with america, taliban and moderate pakistanis. gilani sacks darbari for admitting the lone surviving mumbai gunman was a pakistani. Watching these political games in pakistan is disconcerting to say the least.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:56 PM on 03/07/2009
This is just plainly not at all constructive. Have you been to Pakistan Vishix? Have you spoken to every single Pakistani? How can you guarentee anything? I think we should start concentrating on the postive - what we can all do, not blaming and being utterly negative.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ajita
06:42 AM on 03/08/2009
Im Indian, as a disclaimer, but I have some problems here:

"The only thing holding pakistan together is the kashmir which involves the hatred of India."

Absurd statement. Both India and Pakistn have ideological governments that curtain freedom of spech and promote religious oppression.

Say what you will about Kashmir (and I agree about the economic and historical reasons for Kashmiris to side with India) but

remember human rights. democracy is worth it. If Kashmiris choose to be part of Pakistan, who are you and I to deny them that right?

The facts about the ineffective and mosty disliked new administration in Pakistan.

Do you think you are helping with your diatribe? Do you think that our liberal brothers and sisters in Pakistan don't see through these political decisions? Let's find ways of working with them instead of finding points of contention.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
09:40 PM on 03/06/2009
Wander around many parts of South America in a yankee t-shirt and some will be polite, and some, not. Like people everywhere.
10:56 PM on 03/06/2009
Yes, thats what Pak.istanis told poor Sri Lankans. Come on in. We are just another city like south America. Seven people lost their lives

Your comment might be funny but for thefact that Journalists have d.ied in this god forsaken country:

Daniel Pearl
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Pearl

This other journalist wasn't even American. Just a Journalist
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2009/02/19/2495583.htm
03:34 PM on 03/06/2009
This article sounds good.

I challenge the writer to visit Pakistan and roam openly on city street with a T-shirt with American flag.
That will show what she really thinks about Pakistan and what Pakistan really thinks about Others!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Virginia M. Moncrieff
11:34 PM on 03/06/2009
Hi gsc99. I recently lived in Pakistan for quite a long stretch of time; in both Islamabad and in the NWFP.

It would have been a bit odd for me to wander around the streets in a T shirt with an American flag on the front, given that I am not an American! Not much point in wearing someone else's flag, I am sure you will agree.

Thanks for reading the post and taking the time to comment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ajita
06:22 AM on 03/08/2009
Can't imagine life in the NWFPes but am ROTF(W)eeping at the surreal discontinuity I gather from the above exchange.
08:28 AM on 03/05/2009
Who so ever was behind these attacks, whether Indian RAW or CIA's Taliban. Does not matter.. What matters is 7 people, 2 cricket careers, 1 country's cricket dies.

God bless all..
08:57 AM on 03/05/2009
Everyone is reposnisble except Pakistanis....you forgot the Mossad (they really ahte cricket).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mono
12:32 PM on 03/05/2009
Horst, Hassan Shabbir doesn't know Mossad. Because in Pakistan's world map Israel is not shown. I am not joking. It's the fact. So, how do you expect him to know the name of the intelligence service of Israel.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
10:09 AM on 03/06/2009
Finally. One person who speaks of compassion.
06:18 AM on 03/05/2009
There is a real problem with modern Pakistani culture to say the least. Obviously Pakistan is a failed state. Someone was kind enough to post pictures of the Bhutto palace in Dubai...no better symbol of corruption can be found. In the UK Pakistanis blow up public transport...and attack airports (doctors no less!). The AQ Khan network sold nuclear technology to the highest bidder. Support for the acid wielding Taliban...it goes on and on. Of course for the Pakistanis it is always someone else's fault.. the Indians, Americans, British and of course the evil Mossad.
08:27 PM on 03/05/2009
I think you are missing the entire point of the article - maybe should go back and read again?
03:14 AM on 03/05/2009
Two countries were founded after World War 2 on the false presumption of religious nationality: Israel and Pakistan. Unstable products of Empire, today the first explodes, the second implodes. The British used Hindu & Muslim fanaticism to sabotage Indian nationalism. Partition was an undemocratic imperial arrangement: there was no adult suffrage before 1950. Today few Indians remember that the Pathan leader, Abdul Ghaffar Khan resolutely opposed the Two Nation Theory, and that Muslims were victims rather than beneficiaries of that sordid event. After 1947 the US used Pakistan as an anti-Soviet outpost, no matter that it overthrew all democratic practices early in its history. The progenitors of the Taliban were created by the US and Saudis, while the only function of the Pakistani Army has been as cats-paw for Empire. This is why Gandhi opposed religion-based nationalism in principle, whether in Palestine or in South Asia. South Asians should long ago have told the imperialists to stop using our ethnicity for their strategic purposes, but we still define ourselves by a western standard. As usual, the consequences will be harshest for us, while ignorant and arrogant Western leaders decide our fate. Give up the self-righteousness, friends, whether you're Hindu or Muslim. Its too late already..
06:07 AM on 03/05/2009
How about all the countries founded between the world wars...i.e. most of the middle east with its phony kingdoms, etc.?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
10:25 PM on 03/04/2009
Sorry, Bhutto palce in Dubai http://www.epathram.com/webtrivia/2008_05_01_archive.shtml
06:05 AM on 03/05/2009
That speaks volumes.
09:49 PM on 03/05/2009
Ergon - I have seen those pictures before, but then they were passed off as Robert Mugabe's palace in Dubai. It seems that palace belongs to every corrupt leader in the world!

I don't think there is any debate that Benzair Bhutto was corrupt. So what's your point exactly?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
10:15 PM on 03/04/2009
Read "Charlie Wilson's War" (the book, not the movie :) then ask, who armed and trained the jihadists?
Then sent them to Lebanon and Chechnya to get further training? It wasn't Pakistan.
06:21 AM on 03/05/2009
That explains it! America's world class incompetents and bunglers..the CIA have destroyed Pakistan (with help from the super-smart Mossad, of course).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
08:09 AM on 03/05/2009
Horst, my dad worked in the foreign service so I grew up in India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka, and since I know many people in all these countries, I think I can safely say that you're mistaken. Pakistan and India were relatively stable until China invaded India, and the Russians invaded Afghanistan. Since then, tne game plan is to destabilise the region, and I think all sides are playing a very dangerous game.
But my main focus is anti-war, and to get US troops out NOW.
10:07 PM on 03/04/2009
It is a sad day for many peace loving people of Pakistan. Lahore is a beautiful city full of life. Friendly people, great food and fun.

The current political situation in Pakistan is to blame for this type of attack.

Pakistanis need to get mad and take their country back and kick out the current politicians.
09:55 PM on 03/04/2009
'No mercy for the terrorist either local or foreign' - who are these Pakistanis kidding? Their own military and intelligence service were the ones who trained and equipped these terrorists. Training camps for terrorists are still operating in many parts of Pakistan.

Once you keep and feed snakes, you should not complain if they turn around and bite you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ajita
08:41 PM on 03/04/2009
As an Indian, my heart goes out to my Pakistani brothers and sisters who are caught in the middle of this thing. Such attacks during a cricket match in the subcontinent is a violation of everything that our countries have stood for. Both India and Pakistan have terrorists, and religious extremists are responsible in both cases. But it is reasonable to blame the vastly greater degree of terrorism in Pakistan on a particularly extreme form of Islam.

I'm aware that most Pakistani's are against these extremists, but the article does mislead in a way.

"none of us - not the elected government nor a dictatorship and never the civilians, have even remotely supported this."

It does seem like none of the above have any say in it either. What's the solution? Pakistan has become a terrorist haven, whether the people of Pakistan like it or not. There has to be a solution, and sympathy alone cannot solve anything.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ergon
Man From Atlan
09:54 PM on 03/04/2009
Yes, what is the solution? A fair question for the people of Pakistan to answer.
And while we're being honest, Indians, Israelis and Americans who fear the Islamic nuclear bomb and make no secret of their governments plans to dismember Pakistan, should ask themselves where their responsibilities lie as well.
I have friends in IAEA based in California, who tell me Pakistan has 200+ nukes. I'd be careful what one wishes for.
12:05 AM on 03/05/2009
Nu-k-iller blackmail!
06:28 PM on 03/06/2009
CLAIM! (I am going to mark all your claims from now on!!)..
08:15 PM on 03/04/2009
How far is Muridke from Lahore? Just wondering!!
And who donates money to Jamaat-ud-Dawa?
Who wants to keep T@liban (aka assets fro strategic depth) alive?
Who wants to establish caliphate in south asia?
Who wants to break India into "million" pieces?
I don't know the answer!!
08:11 PM on 03/04/2009
Most moderate Pakistanis have been trying to bring these people to the limelight, but the Musharaf's of Pakistan while getting billions in aid from the US and sympathy from the neighbor to the east played them both while harboring these terrorists/gunmen/fundamentalists/alqaedaists/talibans or what ever the world want to call them. It is not the fault of millions of Pakistanis who never had any say in this matter. It is definitely the fault of Musharaf and the nations he fooled into giving him aid and sympathy without any accountability. And if you are smart enough to figure out what nations I'm referring to you are smart enough to figure out that your nation has had just as much part in bringing up and harboring the extremists as the military (not nation) of Pakistan.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wasim ali
08:21 PM on 03/04/2009
Well said!
07:37 PM on 03/04/2009
anyone that travels to pakistan needs their head examined.