More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Vivien Lesnik Weisman

Vivien Lesnik Weisman

Posted: January 19, 2010 01:09 PM

Haitians Die As International Relief Organizations Can't Deliver

What's Your Reaction:

As I watch CNN's Anderson Cooper discuss with Sanjay Gupta the lack of medical care and basic medical supplies, such as antibiotics, six days into the crisis in Haiti, I need to read between the lines to figure out what seems to be holding things up on the ground.

Cooper and Gupta gingerly skirt around the issue and are careful not to impute blame on any one organization or country. Still, Cooper did conclude that decisions being made in Geneva are perhaps costing lives here on the ground. He pointed the finger at large international organizations.

In my previous blog "International Rescue Workers Afraid of Poor Black Haitians," I explain the lack of rescuers and relief workers in the most devastated neighborhoods within Haiti as rooted in fear of the Haitian people because they are different, poor, or black.

Both Gupta and Cooper agreed that the doctors who are here in Haiti need to get on with their business of healing, however imperfect the facilities and supplies and that their supervisors and the UN need to put their security reservations aside because people are dying while they are assessing and strategizing. Moreover, if the basic services are not delivered very soon the violence that is so feared will become reality.

Missing from Cooper's excellent coverage and Gupta's expert medical assessment is any mention of the 350 to 400 Cuban doctors who were here before the crisis administering free medical care. While the Belgian doctors where being whisked away due to security considerations the Cubans were operating in full force.

The day after the earthquake struck the Cuban doctors reopened two hospitals. The very day of the quake the Cuban doctors started administering treatment directly from their livingrooms. Since the Cubans live in the poor neighborhoods amongst the poor Haitians they were actually the first responders. We hear about the international doctors who have arrived from Doctors Without Borders and the Israeli Operating Center but no mention of the Cubans. It is so disheartening that these doctors who are doing a great deal of the timely work in the most needed areas are given no mention or credit.

If you would like to support the Cuban trained Haitan doctors on the ground working right now with their own people and alongside the almost 400 Cuban doctors give here.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:55 AM on 01/20/2010
I have found two small articles that mentioned the Cuban involvement. However, this is a US mission and all other countries involved are secondary. We are the Superman for the planet and only our flag should fly. MSM is all over our assistance and all others are secondary or even lower on the PR chain. We want others to foot the bill, but we want the credit. Cubans were the first responders and as near as I can figure the Chinese were neck and neck with several other countries on arrival. We were not the first by a long shot. What is clear is we have invaded that country and taken it over with the military. Water, food, medical is on the list some place, but it is far down the list. Hooray for the red, white and blue.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mara Gibbs
03:50 AM on 01/20/2010
great blog! Nobody is talking about the fear factor in why aid is not arriving sooner to the Haitians....ahhh we liberals are too afraid to admit that we may not really want to venture deep into alien territory. What a tragic crime.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
vivienwe
filmmaker
02:47 AM on 01/20/2010
here is the only mention in the main strean us media i have found (democracy now always the exception) notice they use the word cuban only once. www.cnn.com/video/#/video/world/2010/01/17/kastenbaum.haiti.la.paz.hosp.cnn
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
laylahb
11:00 PM on 01/19/2010
They have mentioned the Cuban doctors on several occasions, both as an individual entity and as part of the Spanish- speaking teams (my term) of doctors from Argentina, Chile, Venezuela, etc. They also mentioned that Cuba has been allowing American planes over Cuban airspace to cut 90 minutes from the trip from Miami since last week.

On CNN they've made a point of shining a light on the international nature of this effort, noting rescue and medical teams from places as diverse as Iceland, Poland, Greece, Qatar, China and well beyond. They even mentioned the many barrels of oil that Chavez was shipping from Venezuela to help alleviate the fuel problem.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
laylahb
12:36 AM on 01/20/2010
CNN.com also has a 2 1/2 minute clip on the Cuban doctors and their long-standing relationship with Haiti, and their quick response in the aftermath of the earthquake.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
vivienwe
filmmaker
09:49 PM on 01/19/2010
yes, there is a kind of journalistic pact not to mention the cuban doctors. they have opened la paz hospital and are treating with minimum supplies 600 patients a day three times what the israelis are treating. I am happy that the isrealis r there and with such modern equipment but it just seems so misleading to ommitt the cubans. this pact with the media and the white house is shameful. the pact is why we are in iraq and afghanistan.
11:17 PM on 01/19/2010
NBC tonight highlighted the Israeli efforts at length; Diane Sawyer on ABC last night ditto without mention of the efforts from any other nationalities. I am sure that the Haitians appreciate all help, & it's very good the Israelis & many nations are taking part in the rescue efforts. I do have to wonder, however, why the other nationalities are being ignored by the major broadcast networks with their focus not on including all the many other nations who are participating in the efforts?
07:50 PM on 01/19/2010
Juan Gonzalez today on "Democracy Now" did a great job of covering Haiti with Amy Goodman reporting from Haiti with personal descriptions & reactions; Danny Glover talking with Juan about his views & more. They credited the Cubans, Venezuelans, Turks, Chinese & others whose medical & relief work on the ground has been ignored by the American MSM. They also highlighted in full how the UN is failing to deliver the goods to the people in a timely fashion, while the US has militarized heavily, with soldiers & weapons where they go. It is tragic, but even is made more so by the opportunities that are being lost.
05:40 PM on 01/19/2010
Besides illustrating that politics is not black and white, and that we should start living with Cuba (would we have gone to their assistance if the Earthquake had hit that island?) like a real world leader, the hurricane in Haiti has made one other large and glaring statement about who we are as Americans: Jim Gulley (Frisco, Colorado missionary) who tramps all over the world to God forsaken places in order to help people raise cattle, ends up being nearly crushed to death in Haiti (Gods' will?) and is trapped for 55 hours, and gets zero dollars except maybe some expense money. Contrast that with his Excellency Mr. Rush Limbaugh who said to the effect that the Haitians don't deserve any help, and we pay him $30 million dollars a year for this wisdom.
05:18 PM on 01/19/2010
I have heard some about Cuba being there for a long while doing for the Haitians. They send people to collage in Cuba, cuba trains Drs. for Haiti, sends them food, and does more than i can remember right now.... Cuba has been real good to Haiti and will be in the Future..

All countries tv stations are reporting on what their own people are doing in Haiti.... some of the work others do get through to other countries....

we are not intentionally doing this to other countries just as they are not doing it to us....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
teknodum
04:36 PM on 01/19/2010
Don't expect to read anything good about Cuba in the Miami Herald.( Here in Dade County we censor Cuban travel books for children in school libraries because they make Cuba look too good.) .
01:45 PM on 01/19/2010
I think it might be more productive to emphasize what works and what does not work, rather than concentrating on giving credit and who is not getting credit (enough). What works, apparently, is the Cuban doctors are working from within the neighborhoods. They know the people and the circumstances. Theycan set up shop quickly in their own homes. Reminds me of the practices I used to know in The Netherlands, where doctors have (had?) their practices @ home. A doctor who lives in the neighborhood, visits sick people, gets to know the patient and the family, plus, and that is very important, the living conditions. What works very well also is cell phones (no landlines, shows pictures of missing persons, text in donations). What is lacking is organization, logistics, the ability to set up clinics fast, field hospitals, etc. Apparently, some were up and running quickly. Mentioned here is the Israeli field hospital. We need to find out, how and why, and then incorporate. Preparedness, as in war times, to be ready when disaster strikes, i.e. coordination of efforts, organization, must be in place BEFORE disasters occur. The world is overpopulated, disasters will increase. Aftercare is still overlooked.
11:14 AM on 01/20/2010
Excellent. I wish someone would listen to you.
01:21 PM on 01/19/2010
"We hear about the international doctors who have arrived from Doctors Without Borders and the Israeli Operating Center but no mention of the Cubans. It is so disheartening that these doctors who are doing a great deal of the timely work in the most needed areas are given no mention or credit."

Every major broadcast network has provided the coverage you refer to here, ignoring the contributions of the Cuban doctors as well as that of other nations like China & Venezuela. Diane Sawyer's extensive coverage on ABC is a good case to illustrate the point.
07:43 PM on 01/20/2010
Alexa -- I have noticed this too. The European media have a slightly different slant -- Cuba's important role is being widely reported, as is the swift response of Venezuela and China.
08:42 PM on 01/20/2010
I am glad that the European public is not being subjected to the politicized coverage we are getting here, especially favoring which nations are getting credited & which are not. I have been watching Euro News, Al Jazeera English as well as Link TV & "Democracy Now." Their coverage is so hugely different from that of the major networks that I have to suspect the majors are in collusion as they all seem to be highlighting the same focus & non-focuses.
I would be interested to know which European media channels or nwspps you prefer. Thanks for your comment!