iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Yoani Sanchez

Yoani Sanchez

Posted: June 2, 2010 09:52 PM

Silvio Rodriguez: Nostalgia Merchant

What's Your Reaction:

2010-06-03-silviorodriguez1.jpg
Exclusive to Huffington Post.

While young people around the world enjoyed the music of the sixties, for Cubans it was forbidden to hear anything that had imperialist echoes, including the Beatles. Just at that time there appeared in our island what ended up being called the Nueva Trova -- New Minstrel -- Movement. Silvio Rodriguez has been its signature performer with songs full of poetic lyrics and music that mixes the tonalities of our traditional minstrel songs with the chords of Bob Dylan.

Silvio's generation, touched by the euphoric effects of the Revolution, was considered anti-establishment, based on between-the-line meanings one could read into his lyrics. He was banned on some television programs and many of his songs were never broadcast. Little by little, before the eyes of followers and detractors, the Movement was absorbed by the ruling ideological apparatus to the point where there came a time when no political event lacked the accompaniment of his songs. He won admirers and spawned imitators, girls swooned over him, and requests for concerts came from all over Latin America.

Silvio Rodriguez, who always worked and reworked his lyrics, "dwelling in time as befits a man awake" - as he says in one of his songs - founded a record company, became a member of parliament, and started making statements of support for the government while repudiating its critics. His detractors say he also became a millionaire, but that doesn't sound like such a bad thing to be, compared to his fellow citizens who are forbidden by law to prosper economically.

He recently engaged in an epistolary debate with the intellectual Carlos Albert Montaner, who lives in Spain and has been the target of virulent accusations by the Cuban government. Silvio had a rough time in the debate - which occurred on the Internet - and even the Cuban Communist Party's official daily paper, Granma, rebuked him for daring to talk with "the enemy." The brief responses of the troubador lacked the agility he brings to his song lyrics, and his absence of arguments to rebut his "adversary" left some of his followers, still harboring their illusions of yesteryear, gnashing their teeth.

The singer has now begun a tour with a first stop in Puerto Rico, where striking university students have already received support from the former young rebel. His tour will also include New York and other North American cities, where he serves as his country's cultural ambassador, repeating that Cuba holds no political prisoners. Curiously, the author of "Hopefully" can stroll across the stages of our neighbor to the North, despite his profoundly anti-imperialistic message. Meanwhile, emblematic figures of our music - such as Willy Chorino, Gloria Estefan, Paquito D'Rivera and the late Celia Cruz - for political reasons have been denied permission to visit their own country.

The 1980s, when at any hour of the day or night, you could turn the radio dial and hear Silvio's songs, are long gone. In those days he won every popularity contest and seemed like a star whose light would never fade. But the demands of tourism and Cubans' own weariness with protest songs, set the stage for the creation and spread of danceable music which, in all its rawness, is the anthem of these times: reggaeton. While Nueva Trova still has its adherents, it has been relegated to niche audiences.

Today, Silvio Rodriguez is the living representative of nostalgia for a utopia that never materialized. Some of his fans come to his concerts decked out in their Che Guevara T-shirts and sing the choruses as if they could roll back history; it's as if they are saying, "This is not dead." Increasingly rare are those who can reconcile his musical expression with his civic behavior, as few can forgive the many years he has been sitting in parliament without raising his hand to ask for an end to the immigration restrictions, the elimination of the dual currency system, or the decriminalization of political dissent.

Fortunately, for what will one day be his memory, he composed beautiful songs of love and betrayal, and many others with a universal ambiguity that make you think about the times we have lived in. I have all his disks at home, but I rarely listen to them. Every time I'm tempted to put one on, I'm struck by the fear that this time I will see all the cracks, and the old illusions will lose their magic. I don't want to imagine myself exorcising the ghost of a poet. So I prefer to let it rest, until the urge passes, or until the day when Cuba becomes a garden that can shelter, in peace, all the unicorns, whatever their color.

Yoani's blog, Generation Y, can be read here in English translation.

 
 
 

Follow Yoani Sanchez on Twitter: www.twitter.com/yoanisanchez

 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:14 PM on 06/09/2010
I think Yoani's article and most comments I read here fail to consider two things. One is the significance for Silvio (and Cuba) for the rest of Latin America. After all, the alternative to what has happened in Cuba is not very appealing... Haiti, Mexico with 60 million in extreme poverty and the richest man in the world (not to mention...)... Also, Silvio has repeatedly and openly challenged the most absurd policies and restrictions in the island (if not all, and not as strongly as Yoani would like, of course) If you read Spanish, check: "Silvio Rodríguez, contra prohibiciones en Cuba" http://www.jornada.unam.mx/2008/02/07/index.php?section=sociedad&article=048n1soc. In the recent press conference he gave in NY, he repeated his believe that the Revolution needs to turn into Evolution, and that most of the political prisoners in Cuba should be freed, specially those with medical conditions.
09:02 AM on 06/10/2010
You are right, silvio and castrofascism has been well sold not only in latin america but the whole third world....... Lenin said "we get to have only a concern: Propaganda, propaganda, propaganda"..... castrofascism was not an exception and like all other stalinist countries invested in propaganda all money they could........even now that regime transformed in a fascist one propaganda continue in the top of its concerns.......... but you are not right about the alternatives of cubans........ first, why the worst alternatives??????..... why to forget Chile, Costa Rica, end most of Antillian countries that has elevated social and economical parameters?????......... any way we cubans had not to look outside to find our best alternative..... it is our self...... we was one of the most social and economical developed countries in the world befor castrofascism destroyed our country...... it is not my invention as most castro supporters likes to believe because precisely the huge propaganda of regime but UN and FAO records:

http://ctp.iccas.miami.edu/FACTS_Web/Cuba%20Facts%20Issue%2043%20December.htm

About...... he always has been ambiguous .... today says something senseful tomorrow sign a letter supporting the assesination of 3 young black men or makes a declaration supporting the incarceration of dissidents.
07:43 PM on 06/07/2010
In Cuba Rock n Roll was banned by Castro´s regime during the 1960s to the 1980s, as a corruptive influence from US. The Beatles were banned from their beginning in 1964 until few years ago. Cuba was the only country in the world that pay no attention to such fame deserved by these four young men admire all around the world.

John Lennon and the Beatles music are symbols of individual independence and freedom of thought. How many young people were abused and how many injustices were committed against those who listened to The Beatles? The Castros regime has established an iron censorship in, according to their saying, “the greater democracy in the world.” It is a symbol of all those who have died trying to escape the tyrannical regime that puts barriers to ideas, and is also a call to liberation.

History is an implacable judge who, to the slightest slip, raises its finger and reminds us of the past. With regard to Fidel Castro for sure history will raises its finger, and will never absolved him.
08:25 AM on 06/07/2010
I'm both surprised & appalled that every last comment on this page is so virulently anti-Cuba and so full of mistruths. I thought the hufpo readership was above that. Anyways, my comment is not political, but in reference to the statement that Silvio's music "mixes the tonalities of our traditional minstrel songs with the chords of Bob Dylan." The latter half of that statement couldn't be more incorrect, and is simply a lazy thing to write. The truth is that Silvio studied classical guitar with Leo Brouwer, the Cuban composer who is one of the most acclaimed guitarists of the 20th century. This allows Silvio to take music to musical heights & complexities that very few popular musicians, if any, have been capable of achieving.

Meanwhile, to call Silvio an opportunist while seizing the opportunity of this presence in the US after 30 years to protest against the Cuban Revolution, is a high act of opportunism in itself. For all those who can't appreciate the music of this genius composer because of their bitterness over the Revolution, it's truly your loss...
09:18 AM on 06/10/2010
Anti-Cuba....... Cuba is not castro mafia........ anti-castro???........ yes..... can't be in another way..... castrofascism has caused tens of thousand of death, hundreds of thousand incarcerated and millions refugees..... I exhort you to prove those mistruths you writes about.......... by the way......... Alina Brouwer, dotter of Leo Brouwer, is one of the organizers of the bigest signatures collection organized in the world to condemn castrofascism crimes........ this event has been a great success because the huge amount of international known personalities of arts, politics and science that has signed the document........... I invite you not to stay behind........ most of signers are ideological left leaned people......... becau
se thank sites like this one the world has been aware of regime's trully ugly face and bloody history...... here is the Brouwar site....... do you want to sign???

http://firmasjamaylibertad.com/ozt/index.php
11:29 PM on 06/05/2010
Silvio, with his concerts and sale of his music outside Cuba, has become a rich man. He own properties outside and inside Cuba and own a recording company in the island. But these privileges are only granted to him and a few others like him. The rest of the Cubans aren’t allowed those privileges. Many talented Cubans, because they don’t kowtow to the Castro brothers military regime, aren’t allow to travel abroad, nor are they allow to profit from their talents.

As far as it is known, during Silvio many years as Deputy of the National Assembly of the Popular Power, never has raised his voice to condemn the despicable actions of the regime. Nor has him spoke in favor of those musicians and intellectuals that are not allow to freely travel outside Cuba or publish their work inside the island. Those who can speak against violations of human rights, and dare not to do so, are collaborators of a regime that denies those basic rights to their people. Silvio, if you really want change, you must pursuit it without fear of the consequences, like many of your compatriots have done it.
09:15 AM on 06/05/2010
Sylvio Rodríguez was always an opportunist. Although some people say he's a good poet, poetry, when written with an agenda, is not poetry, it's something else that I won't mention here because I respect Ariana Huffington and her publication. Readers should look into his son's (Sylvio el libre) lyrics. He calls himself "Sylvio, The Free One" and he's part of the new Cuban Hip Hop scene. He calls his father's actions for what they are and refuses to be a part of them. Like Yoany Sánchez, he's part of that new Cuban generation that is not afraid to say what they think and pays a high price for it. Anyone who thinks a revolution can last 50 years is as morally deteriorated as Cuba's geriatric leaders of today. In a country where the majority of the population don't have the basic needs or human rights and everyday people are dying in hunger strikes to achieve them, Sylvio Rodriguez cruises in his brand new Ford Explorer through the streets of Siboney, the Cuban Bel Air, where he lives. Now, he even sings at Carnegie Hall which is an insult to the intelligence of the American people. But as they say, once an opportunist, always an opportunist!
01:53 AM on 06/05/2010
After the Castro brothers are gone and the horrors committed by these monsters are revealed to the world Silvio and many of his ilk will suffer the same consequences that Leni Riefenstahl experienced due to her support for Adolf Hitler's regime.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:13 PM on 06/04/2010
Silvio Rodriguez is just another crafty hypocrite.
Its amusing how his fans find passages in his songs with 'hidden meanings' and 'cryptic codes' for this and that; but whenever he was required to show support for the regime he was never cryptical, he always was very straightforward, like when he happily signed a letter along with other 'intellectuals' condoning the execution of 3 young men for trying to commandeer a boat to leave Cuba, only because Castro wanted to set an example.
He always went to bat for the regime, and they in turn allowed him to go on tours and sell records to his fans in Spain and South America, where they have no idea what the real Cuba is, they sing along and cheer for the romantic pictures he puts in their minds, making lots of money and living the life that 99% of Cubans can only dream of.
02:30 AM on 06/04/2010
The Beatles weren´t the only ones back in the 1960s whose music was banned in Cuba. Other musical groups and artists like the Rolling Stones, Queen, Carlos Santana, Led Zeppelin, Black Sabbath, etc, or Cuban musicians who left Cuba like Cachao, Bebo Valdés, and Carlos "Patato" Valdes. Franciso Aguabella, René Tozuet, Chico O'Farrill, Mario Bauza, Alejandro Vivar, Meme Solís, Celia Cruz, La Lupe, Zenaida Manfugás, Olga Guillot, Willy Chirino, Maggie Carles, Albita, Paquito D'Rivera, Arturo Sandoval, Gloria Estefan, Jon Secada, Aurelio de la Vega, Odaline de la Martínez. Tania León, Marlene Urbey, Horacio Gutérrez,Marta Pérez, Manuel Barruecos, Nohema Fernández, etc, etc,etc, were officially banned by the regime, and aren’t welcome to perform in the island. In Cuba musicians like Silvio Rodriguez and Pablo Milanés and many others are required to support the regime in order to travel outside the island. But in their case, they are allowed to perform in the US.

The Cubans, after the martyrs and patriots, which have done most for Cuba, are the musicians. They are the flesh and soul of the homeland, which have gone around the world spreading the Cuban music into the four cardinal points. The Castros regimen, which wanted to create “the new man”, wanted to endow them with “the new music”, and failed miserably in both accounts.