01/06/2012 05:20 am ET Updated Mar 07, 2012

'Project Runway: All Stars' Premiere: It's A Whole New Panel For The All Star Contestants (VIDEO)

The contestants's faces may have been familiar, but everything else looked all new on "Project Runwa: All Stars" (Thu., 9 p.m. EST on Lifetime). In its 10th season, "Project Runway" brought back 13 designers who came close, but didn't win their respective seasons. But the challenge proved even greater since they have to get to know a whole new judging panel.

And the designers have to impress with the always surprising and unconventional challenge. In the premiere episode, they went thrift-store shopping to try and find a look that would wow designers Isaac Mizrahi and Georgina Chapman. Also judging, and serving as new host, is model Angela Lindvall, who brought a whole new accent to the phrase, "You're out."

One design stood out in particular for the judges: Season 4 runner-up Rami Kashou made a bold statement using laundry bags, umbrella lining and even Christmas tinsel, to create his look. "I think you have an edge over the other designers in terms of execution," Mizrahi told him. "You mastered all of these elements. You kind of made them your b---h."

Elisa Jiminez didn't do so well with her colorful look that featured writing throughout the outfit. "If you read the story on this sleeve, you read it on that sleeve. It's a good story," she said. "If you read it all together, you know the whole story."

Apparently, no one was interested in reading their fashion and she was "out."

Keep up with all the new looks, good and bad, as "Project Runway: All Stars" continues every Thursday night at 9 p.m. EST on Lifetime.

TV Replay scours the vast television landscape to find the most interesting, amusing, and, on a good day, amazing moments, and delivers them right to your browser.