12/03/2012 06:23 pm ET

Who Is 'A' On 'Pretty Little Liars'? Lucy Hale Says Who She'd Like It To Be

Who is A? "Pretty Little Liars" fans have been trying to figure out the whole truth for two and a half seasons now. Even the stars of the show don't know the full story and some are casting their votes.

Lucy Hale, who plays Aria on the ABC Family series, told "Nylon" magazine that she is hoping A turns out to be "a Bonnie and Clyde thing. Where Aria and Ezra are in it together. Or Spencer and Toby. But something romantic, [where] you root for them [even though] they're the bad guys."

"Pretty Little Liars" fans already know that Mona (Janel Parish) and Toby (Keegan Allen) are part of the A Team, but there is certainly at least one other person donning the black hoodie.

Meanwhile, Ashley Benson, "Pretty Little Liars'" Hanna, has something else in mind. "I always want Hanna to be A. It would be such a weird twist," she told "Teen Vogue." "She's acting like she's scared of everyone trying to torture her, but maybe she was in on the whole thing?"

Benson has be gunning for her character to turn evil for a while. "It's a team and I'm really hoping that I'm in that team," Benson says in a "Pretty Little Liars" Season 3 promo. "I'm still crossing my fingers."

Season 3 of "Pretty Little Liars" continues on Tuesday, January 8, 2013 at 8 p.m. EST on ABC Family.

TV Shows Celebrate Halloween