WASHINGTON -– Marco Rubio's speech Tuesday night elevated him to the national stage, but also presented him with his first real test on the long and winding road to the 2016 presidential election.
Rubio, who has enjoyed reams of positive attention since the November night that Mitt Romney's electoral loss exposed the GOP's terrible relationship with Hispanic voters, came under some of the harshest attacks he has experienced on the national level in the hours leading up to, and following, his remarks.
And, thanks to a case of dry mouth, he also had the first truly embarrassing gaffe of his national political career.
In addition, the 41-year old Florida senator, chosen by Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell after the election last fall to give the Republican response to President Barack Obama's State of the Union address, invited an extra layer of critiques by voting against a bill named the Violence Against Women Act earlier on Tuesday. Rubio said he wanted to see a different version of VAWA pass, but on a day when he was under a magnifying lens, the vote gave Democrats another arrow to shoot at the man Time magazine called "The Republican Savior."
In his remarks, Rubio hit two things hard: stereotypes of conservatives, and the president. He came out against the former stronger than the latter, devoting an entire passage to rebutting the charge that Republicans want to protect the rich from higher taxes, and another to making clear his devotion to Medicare, in an attempt to stake out a politically viable position on entitlement reform.
"Mr. President, I still live in the same working-class neighborhood I grew up in. My neighbors aren’t millionaires. They’re retirees who depend on Social Security and Medicare," Rubio said, arguing that Obama's "tax increases and deficit spending" will hurt the middle class.
"Mr. President, I don’t oppose your plans because I want to protect the rich. I oppose your plans because I want to protect my neighbors," Rubio said. Rubio also spoke of how his parents, both immigrants from Cuba, have depended on government entitlement programs.
"One of these programs, Medicare, is especially important to me. It provided my father the care he needed to battle cancer and ultimately die with dignity. And it pays for the care my mother receives now," Rubio said. "I would never support any changes to Medicare that would hurt seniors like my mother. But anyone who is in favor of leaving Medicare exactly the way it is right now, is in favor of bankrupting it."
Rubio called for a balanced budget amendment, and criticized Obama for having an "obsession with raising taxes."
Rubio also delivered his remarks in Spanish, pre-taping them so that Spanish-language TV channels could carry his remarks at the same time he delivered them live in English.
The media-savvy Republican got favorable reviews, but his night was almost derailed by a bottle of water. When Rubio came to the 10-minute mark in his 14-minute speech, he paused, looked down and to his left, and then looked back at the camera as he bent and reached for a small Poland Spring bottle. For a few brief, excruciating seconds, Rubio took a sip of the water as he looked directly into the camera, and then put it quickly down and resumed speaking.
Twitter exploded. Video of the moment was quickly posted, Democratic operatives cackled, and journalists complained about the volume of chatter about Rubio's thirst.
Rubio laughed it off, posting a picture of an almost empty bottle -– apparently the one he drank from on-camera -– to Twitter a few minutes after he finished speaking. He'll have to laugh the moment off again, but his willingness to chuckle at himself has already set him apart from most other Republicans.
The starkest contrast between the Rubio and Obama speeches was in tone and emphasis. Rubio's message was oriented toward a vision of economic growth as the engine that lifts middle class and lower-income Americans. He critiqued the president's vision of a government-formatted private sector.
"This opportunity -– to make it to the middle class or beyond no matter where you start out in life -– it isn’t bestowed on us from Washington," Rubio said. "It comes from a vibrant free economy where people can risk their own money to open a business."
Obama delivered his standard lines about the need for more efficient government: "It’s not a bigger government we need, but a smarter government."
The president's point of view originated in government action. He tried, as he often has for years, to strike a balance between talking about goals that Republicans share and often consider their turf, but through the means of government action.
"It is our unfinished task to make sure that this government works on behalf of the many, and not just the few; that it encourages free enterprise, rewards individual initiative, and opens the doors of opportunity to every child across this great nation of ours," Obama said.
Rubio came under attack from the Democrats well ahead of his speech. On Monday, Democratic National Committee chairman Debbie Wasserman Schultz hosted a conference call to begin the counteroffensive to Rubio's rebuttal. Wasserman-Schultz went after Rubio on Medicare. But even here, Rubio's political fortunes seemed charmed. Most of the headlines from the call focused on Wasserman-Schultz's attempt to pass off a Democratic operative as a "Medicare recipient from Florida."
Nonetheless, in the hours before Rubio's address, the DNC hammered away at Rubio, sending out a release headlined, "Rubio knows nothing about the middle or class."
The DNC accused Rubio of "siding with the Tea Party over Florida's families," sending along what was essentially an opposition research dump on Rubio from the Florida Democratic party.
Rubio's speech was weakest when it came to specifics, particularly on the gun debate.
"We must effectively deal with the rise of violence in our country. But unconstitutionally undermining the Second Amendment rights of law-abiding Americans is not the way to do it," Rubio said. He offered no details of how the nation should respond to tragedies like the school shooting in Newtown, Conn., on Dec. 14.
Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) gave the third speech of the night, labeled the Tea Party response. Paul, considered likely to run for president as well in 2016, blasted both Democrats and Republicans for perpetuating the growth of government.
"Both parties have been guilty of spending too much, of protecting their sacred cows, of backroom deals in which everyone up here wins, but every taxpayer loses," Paul said. "It is time Democrats admit that not every dollar spent on domestic programs is sacred. And it is time Republicans realize that military spending is not immune to waste and fraud."
But Paul's most visceral criticism was of the president, who he obliquely accused of acting "as if he were a king" and who he took to task for approving drone strikes overseas of suspected terrorists who are American citizens, such as Anwar al-Awlaki.
"We will not tolerate secret lists of American citizens who can be killed without trial," Paul said.
Paul, whose father Ron Paul is a former Texas congressman who ran for president in 2008 and 2012, included lines in his speech aimed at softening the GOP's harsh image among Hispanics.
"We must be the party that embraces the immigrant who wants to come to America for a better future. We must be the party who sees immigrants as assets, not liabilities," Paul said.
But it's Rubio who has the upper hand in making that argument, and who also possesses vastly superior communications skills. Comparisons between Rubio and Paul are, at this point, not based in political reality. Yet the conservative wing of the party will watch Rubio for signs of going wobbly. At this early point, there's no indications that they see any.
BEFORE YOU GO
02/13/2013 1:22 AM EST
Paul Ryan: Obama Immigration Remarks 'Productive'
Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) had rare words of praise on Tuesday for President Barack Obama's message on immigration.
"I thought on comprehensive immigration reform, I thought his words were measured," Ryan said in an interview with CNN after the State of the Union address. "I think the tone and the words he took were productive on that front."
Obama urged Congress to act quickly -- "in the next few months" -- and praised the work of bipartisan groups in the House and Senate. Ryan said he appreciated that nod to Congress, adding that he thinks immigration is "an area where we have a good chance of getting something done."
"I think, you know, when you have -- when you are in the legislative arena and we're trying to get a comprehensive bipartisan agreement here, the words he uses matters," Ryan told CNN. "And he used what I thought was a measured tone, which gives me a sense that he is trying to get something done."
-- Elise Foley
02/13/2013 1:20 AM EST
Immigrant Workers Surprised, Disappointed By Obama Immigration Remarks
WASHINGTON -- For many of the 300 immigrant day laborers, cooks and manual laborers watching the State of the Union address at a Hilton Hotel in Washington on Tuesday, President Barack Obama's remarks on immigration were underwhelming.
When Obama called for swift action on immigration reform, the crowd in the Hilton conference room roared with cheers. But as the president laid out his policy ideas, including enhanced border security, taxes and penalties, the immigrant workers quickly turned to boos, hisses and indignation.
"I was surprised that he dedicated so little time of his speech to immigration," said Guillermina Castellanos, 52, a community organizer from San Francisco. "We know it's our labor that makes this country function."
The group was gathered for grassroots organizing trainings hosted by the United Workers Congress and the National Guestworker Alliance, and later this week will attend a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing and a press conference with Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.).
The organizers and workers are staunch supporters of comprehensive immigration reform that includes a pathway to citizenship, and one of their top priorities is to urge Obama to halt deportations -- which currently stand at record levels -- until immigration reform discussions are complete. About one-fifth of the crowd was undocumented, National Day Laborer Organizing Network spokesman B. Loewe estimated.
For immigrants, Obama's statements were particularly important. Raul de la Torre, 46, is a worker from Mexico who along with 89 of his colleagues was fired by his employer for allegedly being undocumented after the group tried to organize to bargain for fair wages. He is involved with Voces de la Frontera, an immigrant rights group, and was with Jennifer Martinez, a 33-year-old U.S. citizen also involved with Voces. She has four small children she is raising alone after her undocumented husband was deported to Mexico last year.
With Martinez acting as a translator, de la Torre said he "hoped and prayed with all his heart that Obama has a conscience."
-- Preston Maddock
CORRECTION: This post has been corrected to clarify details of Raul de la Torre's case.
02/13/2013 1:14 AM EST
Jobs Proposals Don't Go Far Enough, Economists Say
President Barack Obama argued Tuesday night that a growing economy with more middle-class jobs "must be the North Star that guides our efforts."
But some outside observers and economists said the president's State of the Union address reflected a less ambitious approach to job creation than in the past -- one that acknowledged the realities of dealing with a Congress focused mostly on deficit-reduction.
"I'm sure there are a lot of good things in there, but it's just going to be nickel-and-dime stuff," said Dean Baker, an economist with the Center for Economic and Policy Research. "He's starting his term, in my view, by asking for very, very little."
Obama's new proposals included a "Fix It First" program that calls for $50 billion to hire people to fix decaying infrastructure such as bridges, and new upgrades to roads and railroads financed by reduced war spending. He also proposed a program to put people to work revamping vacant homes in communities ravaged by foreclosures, estimated to cost $15 billion.
The president made a passing reference to a $447 billion jobs bill he proposed in 2011, but he stressed that "nothing I’m proposing tonight should increase our deficit by a single dime."
The language was a marked contrast from last year's speech, where Obama referenced the Hoover Dam, the Golden Gate Bridge and the interstate highway system as examples of past administrations investing in "great projects that benefited everybody."
"You need to fund these projects," he said in the 2012 address. "Take the money we're no longer spending at war, use half of it to pay down our debt, and use the rest to do some nation-building right here at home."
"Rhetorically, there were some bold visions in this speech, but I didn't see the level of specificity about the new projects this time as I have in the past," said Scott Paul, president of the Alliance for American Manufacturing. "Part of that may be an aspect of realism, but I'm of the school that if you don't ask for it, you're not going to get it."
Jared Bernstein, a senior fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, said some of the more modest initiatives on job creation in this speech reflect the country moving beyond the crisis mode of 2009 and 2010.
"As opposed to his agenda in his first years, where he was really putting out a huge fire, at this point he's talking about rebuilding the house," said Bernstein, a former Obama administration economist. "You're going to hear much less about large deficit spending on a big stimulus, and more about investments in kids, in infrastructure, in our manufacturing base."
-- Chris Kirkham
02/13/2013 12:46 AM EST
Howard Fineman: The Emotion Of The Night
I was playing the role of hard-boiled -- not to say cynical -- reporter on the Hill when I got into a conversation with Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz after the president's State of the Union address Tuesday night.
"So," I asked, "do YOU have your own personal victim of gun-violence with you tonight?"
The Florida Democrat, an important party leader, shot me a glance that was equal parts pity, surprise and annoyance. "Yes I do," she said, and turned to introduce me to 17-year-old from Miami named Megan Hobson. The young woman explained that she had been injured in a drive-by shooting last year.
"We needed to have people here such as Megan to underscore the point we want to make about gun violence," Wasserman Schultz said.
President Barack Obama laid out a detailed progressive agenda, a recitation that some pundits panned, but that early polls showed the public liked. Still, the emotional highlight -- and potentially most politically astute maneuver -- was when Obama and his fellow Democrats discussed the lives and losses of gun-violence victims.
In an effort organized by five Democrats from New York and New England -- the region of Newtown -- more than 30 members brought to the Capitol families that had experienced gun-related tragedies. It was powerful theater, especially when Obama himself paid homage to the parents of a victim from Chicago.
Using the call-and-response cadence of a church service, the president demanded that the Congress allow up-or-down votes on several gun measures. The idea was to put Republicans and wavering Democrats from Red States on the spot.
And it felt in the House Chamber Tuesday night that he had done so.
"The president backed them into a corner and they sat there like they were trying out for stone faces on Mount Rushmore," said Rep. Steve Cohen, a Democrat from Tennessee. "I loved that. And maybe we'll get those voters."
Maybe the Democrats and Obama will. Whether they will win them is another matter. If they do, the beginning of the story of that victory will be this night in the U.S. House -- and with people such as Megan Hobson.
-- Howard Fineman
02/13/2013 12:35 AM EST
Obama Promises Climate Change Action
The Huffington Post's Ryan Grim reports:
President Barack Obama Tuesday night pledged that if Congress refuses to take action to stem climate change, his administration would act unilaterally.
"I urge this Congress to pursue a bipartisan, market-based solution to climate change, like the one John McCain and Joe Lieberman worked on together a few years ago," Obama said, as McCain offered a tight smile from a back row. "But if Congress won’t act soon to protect future generations, I will. I will direct my cabinet to come up with executive actions we can take, now and in the future, to reduce pollution, prepare our communities for the consequences of climate change, and speed the transition to more sustainable sources of energy."
There's about zero chance that the GOP-led House will pass climate change legislation this session, given that many of its members do not acknowledge that human activity has anything to do with it, if it's happening at all.
Click here to read more.
02/13/2013 12:34 AM EST
Sen. Joe Manchin, West Virginia Democrat, Miffed Obama Didn't Mention Coal
Sen. Joe Manchin, a Democrat from West Virginia, said he liked President Barack Obama's speech, but was miffed the energy portion left out his state's key resource -- coal.
Obama and his administration have talked about coal in the past, but Manchin noticed the president didn't bring it up when he was addressing energy efficiency and climate change.
"I was disappointed on energy," Manchin told reporters. "Not to say a word about coal -- and coal produces about 35 percent of the the nation's energy. When you look at it, you've got to talk about climate, and if you're talking about climate, the United States of America consumes close to one-eighth of the the coal that's burned in the world -- you should be finding the technology that helps use it cleanly, and uses it much better and more efficiently. So that was disappointing."
Many analysts have said there is no such thing as clean coal, although Obama and Vice President Joe Biden have talked up the idea in the past.
-- Michael McAuliff
02/13/2013 12:18 AM EST
Obama Short On Details For Climate Change And Green Energy
HuffPost's Lynne Peeples reports:
President Barack Obama's State of the Union remarks fell in line with what many energy experts, industry representatives and environmental advocates predicted to me earlier today -- lots of rhetoric yet little detail on how to tackle climate change and propel green energy.
Read more here.
02/13/2013 12:10 AM EST
What Stands In The Way Of A Minimum Wage Increase
The payroll tax increase that went into effect at the beginning of the year stands to offset significantly the president's proposal to raise the federal minimum wage to $9 an hour.
In his State of the Union address, Barack Obama called on lawmakers to increase the federal minimum wage from $7.25. For an employee working a 40-hour work week, the bump would translate to a 24 percent raise to $18,720 a year.
-- Caroline Fairchild
02/12/2013 11:50 PM EST
Obama Calls For Pre-K Expansion
HuffPost's Joy Resmovits reports:
During Tuesday night's State of the Union address, President Barack Obama proposed several major education initiatives, including a big push to expand pre-kindergarten and a potential revamp of the federal aid system for college students.
"Tonight, I propose working with states to make high-quality preschool available to every child in America," Obama said. "Every dollar we invest in high-quality early education can save more than seven dollars later on.”
Instead of focusing on the bulk of American public school students, the president's proposals zeroed in on the margins, targeting the oldest and youngest members of the country's education system.
Read more here.
02/12/2013 11:49 PM EST
Obama Calls For Immigration Reform To Attract Skilled Entrepreneurs, Engineers
President Barack Obama during his State of the Union address called for reforms to the nation's immigration system that would help highly-skilled immigrants remain in the country.
"Real reform means fixing the legal immigration system to cut waiting periods, reduce bureaucracy and attract the highly-skilled entrepreneurs and engineers that will help create jobs and grow our economy," Obama said.
The president said bipartisan groups in both chambers of Congress were working to draft an immigration reform bill. "Send me a comprehensive immigration reform bill in the next few months, and I will sign it right away," he said.
Advocates said a massive backlog of visas is preventing immigrants with advanced degrees in engineering from securing visas to remain in the country.
-- Gerry Smith