07/22/2013 11:43 am ET Updated Dec 06, 2017

Amanda Seyfried Vs. Ashley Roberts: Who Wore This 'Three Floor' Dress Better? (PHOTOS)

When you find that perfect dress for a summer occasion -- neither too heavy or too light, too formal or too casual, and above all, not too sheer -- you really hope that someone else didn't have the same thought. Especially if said dress has very distinctive details. Unfortunately, both Amanda Seyfried and Ashley Roberts experienced just that when they were photographed in the exact same Three Four minidress.

Both stars wore the the nude dress with interesting blue lace and black leather appliqués to separate events -- styling it only slightly differently. Roberts wore the dress this past Sunday to the London premiere of "The Lone Ranger" with nude pumps. Back in May, Seyfried wore the frock to the MTV Movie Awards with black pumps. Both stars wore their hair long and straight.

Who do you think wore it better?


ashley roberts


amanda seyfried

More style showdowns:

Who Wore It Better?

Want more? Be sure to check out HuffPost Style on Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr, Pinterest and Instagram at @HuffPostStyle.