CRIME
12/31/2014 03:51 pm ET Updated Dec 31, 2014

Homicides Drop, But Shootings Rise As Chicago Still Struggles With Guns And Violence

A makeshift memorial is seen in Chicago, Tuesday, March 12, 2013, at the site where 6-month-old girl Jonylah Watkins, and her
A makeshift memorial is seen in Chicago, Tuesday, March 12, 2013, at the site where 6-month-old girl Jonylah Watkins, and her father, a known gang member, were shot Monday, March 11. The girl, who was shot five times, died Tuesday morning. She became the latest homicide victim of a bloody gang war in Chicago when a man approached a van in which her father was changing her diaper and opened fire. Her father, Jonathan Watkins, was in serious but stable condition. (AP Photo/M. Spencer Green)

Though Chicago is ending 2014 with its lowest number of homicides since 1965, a look at the broader picture of gun violence in the Windy City tells a more troubling story.

At a news conference on Monday, Chicago Police Superintendent Garry McCarthy touted the reduction in homicides and overall crime, while admitting that shootings have increased in 2014 compared to the previous year.

Through Dec. 20, the Chicago Police Department has counted 390 murders, down from 406 over the same period in 2013 and 488 in 2012, DNAinfo Chicago reports. There have been 2,500 shootings reported in Chicago this year through Dec. 20, a 13 percent increase from 2013 numbers and 14 percent decrease from 2012.

McCarthy blamed the increase in shootings on the continued impact of gang activity and illegal guns in “certain pockets” of the city, the Chicago Tribune reports. While some neighborhoods have seen drastically reduced instances of fatal gun violence, others, like Humboldt Park on the city's West Side, have seen an increase.

“The reason why shootings are up in those neighborhoods is because there's so many guns," McCarthy said Monday, according to the Tribune. "If these guys are throwing rocks at each other we wouldn't have this problem."

Chicago magazine and other media have suggested the department has strategically altered its crime statistics to appear more positive, but McCarthy said Monday such claims were “nonsense,” the Associated Press reports.

With Democratic Mayor Rahm Emanuel seeking re-election in 2015, gun violence in Chicago is a particularly hot-button issue.

Mayoral challenger and Cook County Commissioner Jesus “Chuy” Garcia, also a Democrat, said Monday that, regardless of Chicago police data, “fear of crime is at an all time high," according to Crain’s Chicago Business. Garcia credited better medical care for shooting victims as a “likely” key factor in the homicide reduction.

Garcia said that, if elected, he would hire 1,000 more police officers -- something Emanuel vowed to do during his 2011 campaign. However, Garcia offered an unclear explanation as to how the city would pay the $110 million-$120 million price tag to do so, Crain’s reports.

After Chicago posted a 16 percent increase in homicides in 2012, leading the nation in the number -- but not per-capita rate -- of fatal shootings, the city earned the misleading title of “murder capital” in the eyes of many, a reputation that continues to this day.

In response to the surge of violence, Chicago police instituted several initiatives in an attempt to reduce the bloodshed, including a “summer surge” of officers working overtime in high-crime areas and an expansion of its “custom notifications” program, in which officers knock on the doors of gang-affiliated individuals to put them on alert, connect them with social services and even set up meetings with family members of gun violence victims.

Chicago's decrease in homicides but uptick in shootings in 2014 is mirrored by crime statistics out of New York City, which also reported its lowest number of homicides since the 1960s this year.

CONVERSATIONS